Evan & Tiki

With the NBA back, the conversation turns into a “what counts as success?” checklist for every team in town, and the answers get blunt fast. For the Knicks, it’s simple: anything short of the NBA Finals is a massive disappointment, and the window is not staying open forever. For the Yankees, the standard is even harsher: win the World Series, period, no matter who’s on the other side. The Mets are trickier, with the floor rising from “make the playoffs” to “get to the Division Series,” because the quick exit versions of October do not count as progress anymore.

Then the focus shifts to football, and the Giants get put under the microscope. With the offseason still unfolding, the expectations are more complicated, but the baseline is clear: competence, a winning season, and being in the mix late. The division suddenly feels more open than it did a year ago, which raises the pressure even more. And looming in the background is the Jets wild card, because one aggressive move at quarterback could instantly change the entire expectation game.

A full-state-of-the-union debate on New York sports standards, pressure points, and what “successful” really means for 2026.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): We're days away from the Mets first Spring Training game of the season, but there has been plenty going on the first few days of camp. Evan gives you his top 10 storylines of Spring Training.

To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Tony Clark did what? Carlos Mendoza denies political locker room divide, and Jalen Brunson wants to get paid.

Tony Clark’s resignation went from “boring labor story” to absolute baseball soap opera when an internal MLBPA investigation revealed an inappropriate relationship with his sister-in-law. That sparks a hilarious, surprisingly intense debate over which version is worse, then the conversation flips fast to the real baseball fear: did this just put a work stoppage on the fast track?

Hour 1 breaks down why owners may smell leverage, why the interim MLBPA decision (including the Bruce Meyer factor) matters, and how a salary cap fight could turn into a long, ugly standoff. Plus calls on floors vs harsher luxury tax penalties, keeping homegrown stars, and the lingering paranoia from 1994: miss games… and still change nothing.

How many championships in a row would it take before baseball fans finally tune out… or would a superteam actually make the sport more compelling? The guys break down the Dodgers’ overwhelming dominance, why players and owners may secretly love it, and how a modern dynasty could reshape the league’s future, TV ratings, and even the next labor battle.

Then things get heated when a caller challenges Evan’s stance on Derek Jeter, sparking a fiery debate over legacy, defense, Gold Gloves, analytics, and the eternal clash between the eye test and the numbers. Can Jeter be the second-greatest shortstop ever and still be overrated in one part of his game? The phones go wild.

Plus: Mets talk ranging from the captain conversation to clubhouse narratives, how leadership actually works inside a locker room, and why fan sensitivity often depends on who delivers the criticism, not just what’s being said.

Evan unveils his 25-deep Jets QB Big Board, ranking every realistic option from free agency to “likely trade or release” candidates, and it instantly turns into a full-blown debate. Aaron Rodgers is dead last, the middle tier gets rapid-fired, and then the top 10 drops with a jaw-dropping Anthony Richardson at #1 and Malik Willis at #2, sparking the obvious question: are the Jets hunting “stability” or swinging for the fences on upside?

Calls pour in challenging the logic, the risk, and whether the Jets are even capable of fixing a reclamation project. Evan explains why he’d rather take a volatile shot that could hit big (or crater into a top pick) than sign a “bridge to nowhere.”

Then Hour 3 takes a hard left into Cinco De Luncho: Food Edition as the crew reacts to the final Long Island Hooters closing, drafts the chain restaurants we miss most, argues Friendly’s vs extinction, remembers Pizza Hut buffet glory, and gets sidetracked by a Wendy’s poll idea that turns into a mini crisis when Tiki nearly reveals his password on-air. Plus: quick teases on what’s coming next with Jalen Brunson and Giancarlo Stanton.

The 4th and final hour of the Evan and Tiki Show is PACKED with big New York sports debates, fiery opinions, and plenty of laughs. First, Jalen Brunson opens up in a revealing interview and his comments about the New York Knicks and his future contract raise serious questions. Did he sacrifice money for the team and will they pay him back? Could a massive supermax deal actually happen? Then the guys break down a heated media moment involving Giancarlo Stanton and a blunt question from a reporter. Was the line of questioning fair or totally out of line?

Jalen Brunson opened up in a revealing Vanity Fair interview and a few comments have Knicks fans buzzing for very different reasons. From the oddly specific details about his off-court life to a brutally honest assessment of the team’s current shortcomings, Brunson did not sugarcoat where things stand.

But the real headline is financial. Brunson acknowledged the massive discount he took to help the Knicks build a contender and hinted that he expects to be repaid in the future. By 2028, he could be eligible for a five-year deal worth well over $400 million, a staggering number for a 32-year-old point guard.

Is this simply the cost of doing business in today’s NBA, or a ticking time bomb for the franchise? Would the Knicks actually commit that kind of money long term? And if they hesitate, could another team swoop in and change the entire landscape of New York basketball?

This episode breaks down Brunson’s candid comments, the reality of the NBA salary structure, the risk of paying aging stars, and what it all means for the Knicks’ championship window.

The phones are ringing, Evan’s yelling, Tiki’s laughing, and nobody’s in control because it’s Cinco time. This one spirals fast when the “final Hooters on Long Island” goes down and Shaun Morash goes full food historian with a Top 5 list of chain restaurants we’ve lost (or are about to lose) locally. From Roy Rogers nostalgia and Bennigan’s smoke-stained memories, to TGI Fridays getting credit for potato skins, plus Friendly’s, Sizzler, Ground Round, and the Pizza Hut buffet glory days, this turns into a full-on Long Island food eulogy.

Then it gets even better: a caller fact-checks Roy Rogers locations, the crew debates the Mount Rushmore of Wendy’s items.

Chaos, nostalgia, and food takes that should probably be illegal.

If the Jets need a quarterback, who should they actually target? Evan unveils a painstakingly built 25-man QB Big Board featuring every realistic option, from aging veterans to boom-or-bust reclamation projects and potential trade targets. Aaron Rodgers lands dead last, surprise names crack the top 10, and one ultra-polarizing young quarterback takes the No. 1 spot purely on upside.

The debate quickly turns heated: Is it smarter to chase stability with a proven veteran or swing for the fences on raw talent? Can a new environment unlock former top prospects like Anthony Richardson or Malik Willis? What about injury risks, locker room concerns, and the Jets’ track record of developing quarterbacks?

This segment breaks down the brutal reality of New York’s QB situation, the risks attached to every available name, and why there may be no “safe” answer at all. If you’re a Jets fan hoping for a quick fix, brace yourself.