Evan & Tiki

The Jets finally make it official: Frank Reich is the new offensive coordinator. Tiki calls it a smart, stabilizing hire for Aaron Glenn, but Evan keeps it real, a “single to center field” that doesn’t fix the one thing that matters most: quarterback. They dig into Reich’s résumé (Philly success, Indy chaos, Carolina disaster), why some fans can talk themselves into it, and why the vibe around the franchise still feels inevitable.

Then it turns into a full-on Jets credibility brawl. Shaun Morash is in the crosshairs of Jets fans and Craig Carton after yesterday’s reporting, and Evan lays out why the public treats them like extremes. Morash pushes back, defends his sourcing, clarifies the Darren Muji comments, and explains why the Jets always seem to be playing defense. Plus, the show tackles the bigger point behind all of it: Woody Johnson’s involvement, the “toxic” perception around the league, and why Jets fans can’t get inspired until the organization proves it can simply win.

WFAN dives deep into the shockwaves following the New York Giants’ decision to hire former Chiefs OC and Bears Head Coach Matt Nagy as their next offensive coordinator.

As the "John Harbaugh era" officially takes shape in East Rutherford, the station debates whether Nagy’s experience under Andy Reid is the secret sauce needed to unlock Jaxson Dart’s superstar potential—or if this is a repeat of past offensive frustrations

Super Bowl Week continued with breaking Giants and Jets news, plus Evan proves Aaron Boone may be wrong.

The New York Giants finally lock in their offensive coordinator as Matt Nagy comes over from the Kansas City Chiefs to join John Harbaugh. The crew breaks down what Nagy’s offense could mean for Jaxson Dart, why Theo Johnson might be a sneaky winner, and how much credit should go to Andy Reid after Nagy’s mixed run with the Chicago Bears.

Then the mood flips to the New York Jets, as exclusive reporting paints a franchise with no real head coach autonomy, with Woody Johnson stepping in and Aaron Glenn getting undercut, including a wild twist involving Wink Martindale. Giants competence, Jets chaos, and a fan base bracing for impact.

Hour 2 keeps the spotlight on the growing divide between New York football franchises. The New York Giants officially bring in Matt Nagy, and the discussion centers on competence, development, and why this staff feels trustworthy under John Harbaugh, even if the hire is not flashy.

On the other side, the New York Jets remain mired in dysfunction. Woody Johnson is painted as increasingly hands on, confidence in Aaron Glenn continues to erode, and fans openly wonder if there is any path to credibility without a complete reset or a powerful buffer between ownership and football operations.

The hour also features a classic Posted & Toasted segment that dredges up old takes, cold tweets, and station personalities getting exposed, followed by a full blown showdown involving Aaron Boone. Boone fires back at criticism over how the New York Yankees handled Jasson Domínguez, prompting a deep dive into the actual numbers that turns anecdotal frustration into hard evidence.

Add in raw Jets fan calls, season ticket soul searching at MetLife Stadium, and the growing sense that one franchise is moving forward while the other is stuck arguing with itself.

Evan and Tiki turn a messy headline into a game: how many times would the media actually press Roger Goodell about Steve Tisch and the newly released Jeffrey Epstein email exchanges. The league drops a brief statement, then the room goes right at it, including questions from Judy Battista and Albert Breer. The guys react to Goodell’s careful wording, debate what an actual NFL “fact-finding” process even looks like, and whether “not illegal” can still be “bad enough” under the personal conduct policy. Plus: quick hits on the Rooney Rule, Goodell going out of his way to praise officiating, and the league’s thoughts on Bad Bunny and the halftime spotlight.

The final hour of Evan & Tiki dives deep into the reaction around the New York Giants hiring Matt Nagy as offensive coordinator and why fans are split between trust and skepticism under John Harbaugh. The guys also rank the top Jets offensive coordinator candidates, debate Greg Roman vs Frank Reich, and break down uninspired vs experienced hires. Plus, Evan reveals his prank call on Tommy Lugauer, Knicks trade deadline talk heats up with Giannis rumors, James Harden trade speculation, and plenty of classic Evan & Tiki banter to close the show.

The New York Giants officially land on Matt Nagy as their next offensive coordinator, and the reaction is exactly what you would expect. After Todd Monken heads to Cleveland, John Harbaugh pivots to Plan B, bypassing names like Kliff Kingsbury and Charlie Weis Jr. and choosing experience over mystery.

The crew breaks down why Giants fans are already uneasy, where the criticism of Nagy actually comes from, and why the surface-level stats do not tell the full story of his time in Kansas City or Chicago. Is this really a boring hire, or just a familiar one for a fanbase conditioned to expect disappointment?

The conversation then swings to Florham Park, where the New York Jets continue their own coordinator search. Frank Reich, Greg Roman, and Darrell Bevell are on the board, and the guys rank the candidates while unpacking what Aaron Glenn actually needs right now. Giants optimism, Jets uncertainty, and a reminder that sometimes the loudest reactions come from the least informed places.

Super Bowl 42 officially turns 18, and that means the Helmet Catch is now an adult. With Giants fans already feeling old, the crew takes a nostalgic turn on Cinco de Luncho by ranking the five MVPs of the historic upset over the Patriots who were just as vital as Eli Manning. From clutch catches and relentless pass rush to an unforgettable halftime moment that steadied an entire fan base, they break down the plays, performances, and forgotten heroes that made one of the greatest Super Bowls ever. A pure Giants throwback that still feels as good as it did in 2008.

After a quiet Friday news dump, the focus turns to the Steve Tisch connection to the Epstein emails and how the NFL chose to handle it. The crew plays a game predicting how many times Roger Goodell would actually be asked about the situation, then listens back as the commissioner faces three pointed questions at the podium. From the league’s vague preemptive statement to Goodell’s careful non answers, they break down what was said, what wasn’t, and what an NFL “investigation” even means in this context. The conversation expands to personal conduct standards, how far the league should go with owners, and whether this opens a much bigger can of worms. Along the way, they also react to other Goodell topics from the podium, including the Rooney Rule, officiating, tanking, and the Super Bowl halftime show.