Evan & Tiki

The Yankees general manager has spoken, and we have a lot of thoughts on his assessment of the offseason, from Craig Carton strongly defending Cashman to Tommy Lugauer ripping the Yanks for essentially running it back.

Craig Carton believes the Giants suffered a setback as Todd Monken accepted the Browns head coach job over Giants offensive coordinator. Plus, Boomer and Gio on who the best fit to help develop Jaxson Dart would be (25:43); Evan & Tiki react to a report that former Jets OC Tanner Engstrand is in play with the Giants (36:10); Tiki also gives his top five candidates for OC (53:56); Craig and C-Mac debate whether the Giants or Jets have the brighter future (1:14:05)

Boomer and Gio are intrigued by a report that the Jets reached out to Jon Gruden for a coordinator position. Plus, why Evan Roberts believes this is all a set up for Gruden to become head coach in 2027 (18:20); Evan & Tiki discuss the hopelessness of the Jets (35:23); Craig Carton calls out the Jets and the Gruden delusion (59:00); Boomer and Gio on the mess that the Jets find themselves in with their coordinators (1:13:28).

Matthew Schaefer called in to Boomer and Gio after his Islanders finished off a season sweep of Boomer's Rangers, while Team USA legend Mike Eruzione also joined the show. Plus, SNY's Connor Hughes gave Evan and Tiki the latest on the Jets quest to fill their coaching staff, and Ian Begley provided the Giannis trade intel.

Boomer and Gio react to the Giannis Antetokounmpo trade demand and the possibility of him becoming a Knick. Plus, SNY Knicks reporter Ian Begley joins Evan & Tiki to talk Giannis and more (12:13); Evan & Tiki give their thoughts of a potential Giannis trade (28:58); Craig Carton and C-Mac talk Giannis to the Knicks with ‘Basketball Jones’ (46:17), and Craig and C-Mac on the likelihood that the Knicks part ways with Karl-Anthony Towns for Giannis (57:39).

The Rangers get swept but dos it count? The Jets may have another QB option, the Knicks prep for Lebron, and much more

Evan wakes up furious at the two people he works with, and it starts with a simple point: the New York Islanders swept the New York Rangers and Evan wants full credit, no asterisks. Shaun tries to wave it off with “the Rangers quit,” which turns into an all-out fight about what “counts,” rivalry pride, and whether Ranger fans are ducking the embarrassment after the Garden got loud for Islanders fans at Madison Square Garden and UBS Arena.

Then Tiki Barber lights the fuse on a totally different argument: could Kirk Cousins actually make sense for the New York Jets, not just as a stopgap starter but as a future “player-coach” type who helps shape the offense? The crew debates the age factor, the directionless feel of the Jets, and whether this is a “bottom out” year or a “build something” year, with names flying everywhere from Atlanta Falcons money mechanics to Frank Reich, Aaron Glenn, Malik Willis, and J. J. McCarthy.

Plus, the phones go crazy: Islanders fans demand Shaun “own it,” Rangers fans double down on the apathy defense, and the hour ends with more fuel added to the fire, including Matthew Schaefer “king of New York” talk, Chris Drury trust issues, and a surprise moment where James Dolan somehow enters the chat.

Hour 2 opens with Jon Gruden finally addressing the rumor mill on Tampa sports radio, flatly saying there was “never anything” from the New York Jets. Evan and Tiki Barber dig into what that actually means, parsing the difference between an “offer” versus contact through agents, friends, or back channels, and why the wording can be technically true while still avoiding the full story.

They also push back hard on fans dismissing credible reporting, defending Diana Russini and Zack Rosenblatt and explaining how information can be real while still being shaped by the motivations of whoever leaked it. The conversation turns into a bigger question: who benefits from the Gruden chatter being out there, and could it make Aaron Glenn look better or worse depending on what gets pinned on him versus Woody Johnson?

Then the show takes a left turn into comedy when a caller, Ozzie from Woodridge, “bullies” both Evan and Shaun about their hair on YouTube, leading to on-air style changes, hat reveals, and plenty of roasting. On the phones, the Malik Willis conversation heats up with callers pitching him as a real Jets swing, plus trade ideas and fear that he ends up elsewhere.

The hour closes by pivoting to the NBA trade deadline drama: how a potential Giannis Antetokounmpo move could ripple into a New York Knicks decision on Karl-Anthony Towns, why Oklahoma City Thunder and Golden State Warriors keep getting mentioned, and the ultimate high-risk debate: is Anthony Davis worth the gamble if you are chasing a title?

Evan starts by waving the white flag on winter, then quickly pivots into a debate that takes over the segment: why are Los Angeles Lakers at New York Knicks tickets at Madison Square Garden suddenly the hottest regular-season get in years? Is it the “last chance” to see LeBron James in the Garden, is it actually about Luka Dončić, or is it just pure MSG hype?

The crew argues about whether LeBron even has a real Garden legacy, why Barclays does not command the same prices, and how much of this is New York chasing a moment they do not want to miss. Along the way, callers weigh in on the iconic player plus iconic venue theory, and Evan admits he once paid big to see LeBron and barely remembers the details now, making the whole “last chance” logic even funnier.

Then the segment takes a sharp turn into classic New York chaos when a caller tries to pitch a blockbuster New York Mets and New York Yankees trade involving Juan Soto, and Evan shuts it down fast, with plenty of jokes and disbelief before the show rolls on.

The 4th and final hour of Evan & Tiki is packed with Jets drama and classic WFAN chaos. Zack Rosenblatt of The Athletic joins to break down the reported Jon Gruden phone call with the Jets, who made the call, Aaron Glenn’s shaky footing, Woody Johnson’s involvement, and the uncertain plan at offensive coordinator and quarterback. Plus, calls on the Rangers vs Islanders rivalry, Knicks history debates, Mets vs Yankees lineup arguments, WWE Royal Rumble predictions, and a hilarious edition of Idiots With Idioms to close out the show.