Evan & Tiki

Dan Orlovsky dropped a scorching hot take after Texans vs Patriots, saying Houston wins that game with “31 other quarterbacks” instead of C.J. Stroud. The guys actually debate it, build the list, argue over what Orlovsky really meant, and land on the real truth: the number might be insane, but the point isn’t.

From there it turns into a full-on quarterback philosophy fight. Would Justin Fields win that game with a safer game plan? How much of it was Stroud’s turnovers vs the Patriots capitalizing in bad conditions? And if it “wasn’t going to take much,” why didn’t Houston consider going to Davis Mills at any point?

They also hit the bigger takeaway: apologizing for a sports take like that is ridiculous, especially when the core point is pretty close to true.

The conversation takes a dark turn for Jets fans: even if they drafted Josh Allen, would it have mattered, or would the Jets have broken him too? The guys dig into how much quarterback development is about the organization, coaching, and timing, using Darnold’s journey as the prime example.

Then the calls roll in. One caller argues the bigger joke might actually be on the Vikings for moving on from Darnold and tying their future to J.J. McCarthy. Another says Jets fans should stop living in regret because Darnold never becomes this player if he stays in New York. Plus: the “Ghostbuster” debate if Darnold faces the Patriots, a poll comparing Jets pain to Giants fans watching Saquon win with the Eagles, and a quick Nets tangent that somehow turns into a real conversation about player development.

A Jets fan dilemma: Sam Darnold is one win from the Super Bowl, and the fan base is split between rooting for a guy they still like and bracing for the avalanche of “LOL Jets” takes that would follow.

The guys revisit how the Jets handled Darnold, how the “seeing ghosts” moment became a career-defining label, and why moving on for Zach Wilson still feels like the franchise’s biggest sliding doors decision. They also debate how much credit Darnold deserves for Seattle’s success, why Jets fans fear two weeks of nonstop relitigating, and whether this would be more embarrassing than Giants fans watching Saquon win it all in Philly. Plus, the poll question that could start an all-out NY fan war.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Jett Williams and Brandon Sproat, we hardly knew you. But to get a top of the line starting pitcher in Freddy Peralta it's worth it. The Mets also get back Tobias Myers. Is this the final stamp Mets fans have been waiting for this offseason?

To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Evan isn't in love with the Mets big trade for Peralta, callers react, a look ahead to Championship Sunday, plus a Giant reshaping.

Evan isn’t screaming, he’s just being honest: he did not celebrate the Freddy Peralta trade. Yes, the Mets are better right now and the rotation finally looks legit, but Evan’s main fear is simple: this feels like a one-year rental, and they paid two top-100 prospects (Jett Williams and Brandon Sproat) to do it. That sparks the real debate for Mets fans: what result makes a rental worth it, World Series or bust?

Plus, Mets fans flood the phones to defend the move, rip the move, and argue whether Stearns and Cohen are building a sustainable plan or living year to year. And Evan delivers a classic story from MSG, including the rough night as a Nets dad and the even tougher conversation explaining to his son why “Jet” is suddenly no longer a Mets prospect.

Hour 2 starts with the crew wrapping up their MLB Free Agency Bingo board, with only one final name left on the list and plenty of laughs at who nailed predictions like Cody Bellinger and who completely whiffed. Then the conversation shifts into the big-picture question: what do Vegas win totals say about the Yankees and Mets right now, and do those numbers match reality?

Evan explains why he would have been far more comfortable paying a premium for an elite like Tarik Skubal than a “really good” Freddy Peralta, and why the “five-inning pitcher” label matters when you are giving up top prospects. Calls pour in debating whether the Mets should push Peralta deeper into games, whether an extension is actually possible, and whether this whole plan is a smart year-to-year build or just living on rentals.

Plus: a wild Jets caller tries to “grease the wheels” for a Josh Allen fantasy, the guys roast the sad state of Jets fandom, and a fan checks in with life updates that send the show down an unexpectedly funny path. And to close the hour, the crew dives into pronunciation chaos, including a pitcher clarifying how to actually say his name, and a Drury joke that deserved better timing.

Hour 3 opens with Evan owning his “Nets shocked the world” slip, plus a full recap of the quickest 6–4 hope in sports history as he takes his five-year-old to MSG and watches the Knicks turn it into a crime scene. Then the guys debate whether Tommy is officially a group chat squatter and if the crew should quietly boot him at the perfect time.

From there, it’s real Giants business: the organization starts clearing out long-time staffers as John Harbaugh puts his stamp on the building, with Tiki explaining how those behind-the-scenes changes actually work and why some “family” staples may not survive this new era.

Then the moment of the hour: Andrew Caplan’s audio package that proves John Harbaugh and Joe Biden are voice doppelgangers. Once you hear it back-to-back, you cannot unhear it.

Plus: Mets fans call in with the perfect word for this offseason, confusion, as the “hope mode” roster debate rages on. And the hour closes with pure Cinco de Lunch chaos as the crew fires off their top five New York starting pitchers lists and immediately starts a civil war over where Peralta, McClain, Rodon, Cole, and the new Yankees arms belong.

The final hour of Evan & Tiki is packed with baseball, football, and classic New York sports banter. Evan and Tiki react to a whirlwind MLB offseason, including the Mets’ aggressive moves for Freddy Peralta, Luis Robert Jr., and Bo Bichette, and debate whether Peralta is a risky rental or a long-term building block. The Yankees’ decision to retain Cody Bellinger sparks further discussion about roster construction and championship expectations in a Dodgers-dominated league.

The crew opens with a big-picture baseball thought experiment: MLB should invent “Fugazi deadlines” to turn the offseason into a fast, chaotic sprint, because the last week has felt like an NFL-style frenzy. The Mets’ entire winter gets compressed into a handful of headlines, from missing on Kyle Tucker to landing Luis Robert Jr. and adding Freddy Peralta, plus the value of getting a controllable arm like Tobias Myers as part of the bigger move.

Then the conversation shifts into the real Mets fan experience right now: confusion, nerves, and a growing divide. One side sees the Peralta trade as an obvious upgrade. The other sees a potential rental that cost two top prospects, and says if you do that, you better be serious about keeping him.

From there, it becomes a full debate about how “rentals” actually work, with a Mike Piazza comparison, plus the bigger question hanging over everything: can anyone realistically beat the Dodgers. The answer is complicated. The Dodgers might be the best team, but baseball still gives you a shot if you catch the right breaks and play clean, because you cannot afford a single slip against a team that deep.