Evan & Tiki

Evan opens a chilly Tuesday in NYC with Shaun Morash filling in for Tiki, and it immediately turns into a full-blown Giants coaching search argument. Is Kevin Stefanski the clear best option for Big Blue, or is he being overrated because the other candidates feel like bigger risks? Evan and Shaun go back and forth on Stefanski’s résumé, the red flags, and why fans are split between “safe hire” and “dream hire” as names like Mike McCarthy, Brian Flores, and other coordinators get dragged into the debate.

Then the conversation shifts to the New York Knicks after another ugly loss and a stretch of sloppy, low-effort basketball. Are the warning signs real, or is this just a January lull that good teams go through? Plus: a preview of what’s coming later in the show, including reaction to James Dolan’s appearance with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle, and hearing from Aaron Glenn and Darren Mougey.

Hour 2 starts loose and gets weird fast before settling back into serious Giants talk. Evan, Shaun, and Tiki explain why they were standing during the show, joke through an awkward cold weather discussion, and set the table for a packed hour.

The focus quickly turns to James Dolan’s in studio appearance, breaking down what stood out from his answers on the Knicks and Rangers. Dolan saying Leon Rose can overrule him sparks a real conversation about ownership, power, and trust, while his patience with Chris Drury frustrates Rangers fans and draws comparisons to the Giants sticking with Joe Schoen.

From there, the Giants coaching search takes over again. Callers debate Kevin Stefanski versus Mike McCarthy, defensive minded hires versus offensive development for Jaxson Dart, and whether keeping Schoen could cost the Giants their top coaching choice. The Knicks slump, Trae Young trade rumors, and draft pick implications also get mixed in before the hour takes another sharp turn with an unforgettable Boomer Esiason massage story that completely hijacks the show.

Hour 3 centers on the question Giants fans actually want answered: why Joe Schoen is still the general manager. Evan and Shaun react to Schoen’s press conference and replay his explanation for keeping the job, then rip apart the idea that the Giants have merely “stubbed their toe.” The discussion turns into a blunt breakdown of accountability, ownership patience, and whether Schoen is underselling just how bad things have gone.

The hour also dives into whether Jaxson Dart should have any input in the next head coaching hire. Schoen’s dismissive answer sparks frustration, with Evan arguing that listening to your young quarterback does not mean handing him the keys. The guys explain why ignoring Dart’s perspective sends the wrong message about development, leadership, and the future of the franchise.

From there, the Giants coaching search opens back up. Kevin Stefanski, Mike McCarthy, Rex Ryan, Bill Belichick, and surprise candidates all come up, with a focus on who the Giants are most likely to hire rather than who fans want. Callers weigh in on dynastic ownership, why bad owners only fix things by accidentally hiring the right person, and whether the Giants should slow the process in case a major name becomes available.

The hour ends with classic show chaos, including Jets misery comparisons, Olympic hockey arguments, media access stories, and a reminder of the hard truth of fandom: you scream, you argue, and then you hope you are wrong.

FULL SHOW: Evan and Shaun debate if Kevin Stefanski is the right hire as the new Giants Head Coach. Plus, reacting to Mougey and Glenn's press conference, Yankees offseason talk, Bill Belichick is not a legitimate HC candidate for the Giants, the Knicks have looked lifeless since the NBA Cup, and much more.

Hour 4: Darren Mougey & Aaron Glenn Speak but Did They Say Anything?

Evan and Shaun listen to Aaron Glenn and Darren Mougey meet the media and react in real time, pausing after each answer to break down what was actually said… and what wasn’t. The Jets leadership promises to “exhaust every option” at quarterback, but the follow-ups (or lack of them) leave a lot hanging in the air.

They debate whether the Fields signing was a clear mistake, why Glenn keeps hijacking answers meant for Mougey, and how much confidence fans should have in this staff’s ability to develop a young QB. Plus, the guys kick around potential defensive coordinator candidates (including a big name idea), question the bold “we can be competitive next year” claim, and point out why Jets talk always seems to turn into motivational slogans instead of real substance.

Time for Cinco de Lunch-o the show turns into a full-blown vent session for New York football fans. Evan and Shaun rank the five figureheads fans should be most furious with, starting with the Giants’ defensive mess and ending with the most infuriating answer of all: how the Giants can justify bringing Joe Schoen back. Along the way, they debate whether Aaron Glenn’s “tough guy” approach should matter, and why Jets ownership keeps making the job feel impossible.

Then the show pivots into baseball with a hilarious MLB free agency bingo update where everybody whiffs on where Murakami would land. That leads into Evan’s frustration with the Mets and Yankees seemingly passing on a perfect fit from Japan, and why the price tag makes it even more annoying.

The segment closes with a surprisingly honest conversation about being a sports fan: you scream, you vent, and then you’re forced to live with whatever your team does. Plus, a quick dive into early 2026 win totals and why Mets fans might have to accept an “86 wins is fine” mindset on January 6.

Finally, the phones bring the chaos, including coaching takes, a Nets trade detour, and an all-time moment with a “17-year-old” caller who is definitely, absolutely, totally not cutting school.

Evan and Shaun dive into two key moments from Joe Schoen’s press conference and why Giants fans still aren’t buying what he’s selling. First, they react to Schoen being asked to justify keeping his job, and why his “course correction” explanation feels like it minimizes how bad things have gotten. Shaun lays out the kind of brutally honest answer he wishes Schoen gave, one that actually owns the misses and explains why the last two years should matter.

Then comes the big topic that Giants fans care about most: should Jaxson Dart have any input on the next head coach? Schoen dismissing it sparks a debate about leadership, ego, and whether ignoring your young quarterback’s perspective is a massive mistake even if he’s not making the decision.

The segment rolls into more Giants coaching talk with calls on what the team needs most, why waiting could matter in case a surprise candidate shakes loose, and the idea that the only thing that truly fixes “dynastic ownership” is accidentally hiring the right person and staying out of the way. Plus, a quick detour into Big Mac’s Dolan interview bet story, and whether the Giants should at least have a conversation with Bill Belichick before making the biggest hire of the offseason.

It’s a new edition of Posted and Toasted with old WFAN tweets resurfacing, including some very questionable takes that did not age well. The conversation then swings back to serious Giants coaching debate, comparing Kevin Stefanski, Mike McCarthy, Todd Bowles, and the risk of letting ownership decisions derail the search. Plus, a bizarrely unforgettable Boomer Esiason massage story, Knicks draft lottery intrigue tied to Trae Young rumors, and more calls from fans trying to make sense of everything.

Evan and Shaun dig into James Dolan’s appearance with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle. They break down the short-term bet on Big Mac’s first question, Dolan’s comments on the Knicks, trade deadline expectations, and what it really means when Dolan says Leon Rose can overrule him.

Then the conversation turns to the Rangers, Chris Drury, and Dolan preaching patience, which sparks frustration and skepticism. The Knicks slump comes back into focus with more reaction to their lack of effort and whether this rough stretch actually matters long term. Plus, more Giants coaching search calls, Kafka criticism, defensive coach debates, and a live report from Detroit after another ugly Knicks performance.