Shaun Morash crowns buffalo chicken the best pizza slice of 2026 and completely leaves pepperoni out of his top five, igniting outrage from Evan Roberts and the callers. The ranking gets even more controversial when Shaun is accused of recycling an old Cinco list, forcing him to challenge the show to find the original audio. The debate expands to stuffed crust, specialty slices and why pizza crust somehow gets better with age.

Don Mattingly publicly fires back at Bryce Harper for pressuring the Phillies’ front office, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe the stunning response exposes a relationship nearing its breaking point. With Philadelphia struggling and Harper still seemingly angry over past criticism, Evan predicts the Phillies could seriously consider trading their superstar.

That possibility leads to a wild New York blockbuster: Harper for Francisco Lindor. Evan and Tiki debate the contracts, roster fits, Juan Soto dynamics and whether either team would actually benefit, while acknowledging the deal could end disastrously for both sides. They also revisit the Yankees’ extra-inning failures and why Aaron Boone’s team must embrace bunting and fundamental baseball.

Breece Hall could be dramatically underpaid before his new Jets contract even begins. Tiki Barber explains why the rising running back market could leave Hall earning millions less than Jahmyr Gibbs and Bijan Robinson, despite believing the Jets star is capable of producing a 1,400-yard season behind an improved offensive line.

Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber put their NFL offseason knowledge to the test in another tightly contested round of “New Team, Who Dis.” Christian Kirk, Nick Folk, Tyrod Taylor and several other familiar names leave both contestants scrambling to remember where they landed.

Cam Schlittler’s emergence has created a high-stakes Yankees playoff debate: Has he done enough to take the Game 1 start from Gerrit Cole? Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash weigh Schlittler’s current dominance against Cole’s postseason experience and explain why Aaron Boone’s decision will face intense scrutiny.

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber revisit the defining mistake, reject every excuse for the unnecessary gamble and explain why Aaron Boone’s public defense only intensified the frustration surrounding another sloppy Yankees loss. The conversation shifts to the Mets’ alarming attendance decline despite extremely cheap tickets, with Evan arguing that disappointed fans have no interest in paying to watch a team that failed to meet major expectations. Shaun Morash also questions the decision to remove Spencer Jones after his productive night.

Ali Sanchez’s disastrous throw helped turn a four-run Yankees lead into their most frustrating loss of the season. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber rip Aaron Boone’s postgame defense, questioning whether the manager’s refusal to demand accountability will allow the same mistakes to haunt the Yankees in October.

Geno Smith addresses the media after an up and down off season, can the Jets lean on him to surprise the NFL world? Plus the Yankees get a dominant Gerrit Cole.

The Jets have invested heavily in their offense, but everything still hinges on Geno Smith. Evan Roberts believes a strong offensive line, Breece Hall, Garrett Wilson and Frank Reich give the Jets a legitimate path toward meaningful football in the winter. Tiki Barber is far less convinced, questioning whether the 36-year-old quarterback can overcome his recent turnovers and offseason distractions.

Their disagreement quickly turns to rookie Cade Klubnik. Tiki insists the fourth-round pick deserves a real opportunity if he outplays Geno, while Evan argues the Jets’ most realistic chance of surprising the league requires Smith to rediscover his Seattle form. They also react to Aaron Glenn’s new approach, Garrett Wilson predicting a special season and the staggering amount of premium draft capital the Jets have spent trying to build a functioning offense.

Robert Saleh is reportedly promising that Tennessee will beat the Jets in Week 1, and Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash are ready to put his trash talk on the bulletin board. The challenge for Aaron Glenn is proving this Jets team can match its offensive talent with a defense featuring eight new starters and a head coach staking his reputation on his own play-calling.

The quarterback debate remains impossible to escape. Geno Smith enters camp with questions, Cade Klubnik is already generating buzz, and the possibility of pursuing Baker Mayfield sparks a larger argument about whether the Jets should finally abandon their failed quarterback-development cycle. The Tiki Time Machine then revisits WFAN’s reaction to the 2013 Geno Smith draft pick, revealing which hosts nailed the moment and how little the franchise’s quarterback conversation has changed.