Alex has a theory, Josh has a theory, and Freddie Highmore is kind of a freak. This episode: August Rush with Freddie "Haley Joel" Highmore, Robin "Bad Peter Pan" Williams, Keri "Not Actually in Stranger Things" Russell, and Jonathan Rhys "Loon" Meyes.

Alex thinks manic pixie dream girls were designed for you and me. Josh hates women. Welcome to Booty Town, AKA 2007's Music and Lyrics, starring Hugh Grant and Drew Barrymore.

A cookie controversy is born. Josh wants more cars. Alex has feelings about Jackie Chan.

Josh is scared. Alex would thrive with this much loneliness. This episode: 2009's Moon starring Sam Rockwell, Sam Rockwell, Kevin Spacey, and Sam Rockwell.

Josh doesn't like movies. Alex raises the stakes.

Josh is a little cynical. Alex is glad this tickled you so much. "Let's just call her a terrorist."

Alex just sees white people, and Josh gets lost in all the details. "It's not really a movie." This episode: WILD HOGS with Tim Allen, John Travolta, Martin Lawrence, and William H. Macy.