What aquatic beast describes each of our hosts best? Which of us should be called Ishmael? What is Mary's saga with sharks? What's so scary about these monsters? What makes Quint's monologue soooo great? What makes a good house guest?

Maegan, Mary Kay, and their lovely guest, Charles Ray, answer questions like, Is Natural Born Killers scary? What makes Mickey and Mallory Knox so sexy? What's with all the production tricks? How about the snakes?

What's scary about Guillermo del Toro's movie, Pan's Labyrinth? What would be at the center of YOUR labyrinth? How real is the magic? Which fairy tales inspired this movie? Is the Capitan hot or scary, and are those mutually exclusive? What do you know...

In this episode, Mary Kay, Mary, Maegan, and their lovely guest Terence talk about Julia Ducournau's film, Raw. Is it a coming of age tale? What makes cannibalism scary? Is cannibalism the same for women and men? What should we make of this ending?

In this episode, the hosts of Everything Trying to Kill you, and their lovely guest, Jack, wonder, what makes Evil Dead so popular? How much do we love Bruce Campbell? Do we also love Ash? Is Evil Dead a good movie? Is it problematic? And of course, you...

The gang (and Ben) gets real about panties, penis monsters, and patriarchy, as usual.

Grab a vodka blush and join Maegan, Mary Kay and Mary with guest Trista Edwards as they discuss Roman Polanski's 1968 film: Rosemary's Baby. Given his history, how is it possible that Roman Polanski made a film with such strong feminist tones? Other...

What makes American Psycho a classic? Is it funny? What's the difference between a horror movie and pornography? If you were the ATM, what would you demand Patrick Bateman to feed to you? What exactly just happened to me?

In this mini, tweener-episode, Mary Kay and Emily talk about their childhood favorite books, Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark, by Alvin Schwartz and Stephen Gammel. What makes these stories classic? What makes them scary? Are these the modern fairy...