First Thursday

First Thursday

By Richard Poulson, LRISGovernment
Download on the App Store

First Thursday episodes

  • First Thursday, July 2014

    In this month’s First Thursday podcast, Will discusses the impact of three major Supreme Court decisions dealing with ‘Fair Share’, cell phone searches and Garcetti.

    http://d33ejgwsompntb.cloudfront.net/2014_07.m4a

    Download the podcast (Use this link to listen on Apple devices)

    Subscribe to this podcast via RSS or iTunes

    Subscribe to this podcast by email

    1 hr 2 min
  • Supreme Court Rejects Request To Hold ‘Fair Share’ Unconstitutional

    In what some have termed the most significant labor case in years, the United States Supreme Court has rejected a request to hold “fair share” assessments unconstitutional.

    http://d33ejgwsompntb.cloudfront.net/Harris_Quinn.m4a

    “Fair share” assessments occur under the laws of 20 states which not only grant public employees the right to bargain, but also impose upon unions the duty to fairly represent all members of their bargaining units. Under “fair share” provisions, non-union members who benefit from the union’s performance of its duty (through contract negotiations and grievance handling, for example) must pay their “fair share” of the costs of negotiating and administering the contract, but cannot be assessed any fees for the union’s political activity.

    The case the Supreme Court was considering was Harris v. Quinn, and like many challenges in recent years to union dues, was being litigated by the National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation, an organization which has received significant funding and assistance from groups founded by Charles and David Koch. The employees in Harris worked in Illinois’ Home Services Program, which allows Medicaid recipients who would normally need institutional care to hire a “personal assistant” to provide homecare services.

    Under State law, the homecare recipients (designated “customers”) and the State both play some role in the employment relationship with the personal assistants. Customers control most aspects of the employment relationship, including the hiring, firing, training, supervising, and disciplining of assistant, and define job duties by proposing a “Service Plan.” Other than compensating the personal assistants, the State’s involvement in employment matters is minimal. Its employer status was created by executive order, and later codified by the legislature, solely to permit assistants to join a labor union and engage in collective bargaining under Illinois’ Public Labor Relations Act.

    When the case was accepted by the Supreme Court, the Right To Work Foundation asked the Court to use Harris to overturn Abood v. Detroit Bd. of Ed., 431 U. S. 209 (1977), the almost 40-year old Supreme Court decision finding that “fair share” rules did not violate the free speech guarantees of the First Amendment. When the case was orally argued before the Court in January 2014, there were some questions whether all five members of the reliably conservative wing of the Court were ready to overturn Abood and, in effect, turn the country into a “right to work” environment for public employees.

    That reluctance is clearly what produced a narrow decision in Harris. The Court did hold that applying “fair share” rules to personal assistants was unconstitutional. The assistants, the Court found, simply didn’t have a strong enough employment relationship with the State to allow fair share to be applied. As the Court put it, “Abood involved full-fledged public employees, but in this case, the status of the personal assistants is much different. The Illinois Legislature has taken pains to specify that personal assistants are public employees for one purpose only: collective bargaining. For all other purposes, Illinois regards the personal assistants as private sector employees. This approach has important practical consequences.”

    The Court pointed to the fact that the customer, not the State, set the job duties for personal assistants, and that customers had complete discretion to hire and fire the assistants. Customers, not the State, supervised the assistants, and assistants were not eligible for State benefits such as health insurance and pensions. Even wages were non-negotiable.

    This meant, the Court found, that “Abood’s rationale, whatever its strengths and weaknesses, is based on the assumption that the union possesses the full scope of powers and duties generally available under American labor law. Under the Illinois scheme now before us, however, the union’s powers and duties are sharply circumscribed, and as a result, even the best argument for the “extraordinary power” that Abood allows a union to wield, is a poor fit.”

    The Court’s opinion stopped there, and expressly did not overturn Abood, leaving fair share in place throughout the country. This did not stop the five-justice majority from raising a series of questions about Abood’s continuing viability, nor did it stop the four dissenting judges from fiercely defending the principles of fair share” and asking pointed questions about why the personal assistants were really all that different.

    In the end, though, “fair share” rules remain generally intact, even if an unusual group of employees in Illinois are exempt from them.

    Harris v. Quinn, 573 US ____ (June 30, 2014).

    Download the podcast (Use this link to listen on Apple devices)

    Subscribe to this podcast via RSS or iTunes

    Subscribe to this podcast by email

    15 min
  • First Thursday, June 2014

    Featured in this month’s podcast:

    • Preview of the Supreme Court’s decision on Fair Share case, Harris v. Quinn
    • California PERB holds factfinding applies to mid-term bargaining
    • How the ADA and FMLA interact in the fitness-for-duty process
    • Discussions at union e-board meeting privileged
    • Union has right to conduct parallel disciplinary investigation
    • Court upholds arbitrator’s opinion in sex case
    • A reminder that state laws can be more stringent than the FLSA
    • 59 min
    • First Thursday, May 2014

      Featured in this month’s podcast:

      • Supreme Court upholds Michigan’s ban on race and gender preferences in employment, education
      • Retired police firefighters reach deal with Detroit
      • Two important California PERB decisions
      • Privacy for personal email and cell phone records of public officials
      • Yet another Brady case (Yay!)
      • http://d33ejgwsompntb.cloudfront.net/2014_05.m4a

        Download the podcast (Use this link to listen on Apple devices)

        Subscribe to this podcast via RSS or iTunes

        Subscribe to this podcast by email

        52 min
      • First Thursday, April 2014

        Featured in this month’s podcast:

        • Does state’s flex time system violate the FLSA?
        • Is county required to pay corrections officers overtime for meal periods?
        • LAFD dispatchers, aeromedical technicians not firefighters for FLSA purposes
        • Supreme Court to rule on Amazon workers FLSA
        • Can employer force employee to use FMLA leave at the same time employee is using sick leave?
        • Threat of a seizure enough to disqualify recruit
        • Discipline not negotiable for Denver firefighters
        • California bill of rights claims can be arbitrated
        • Retirees not ‘members’ for purposes of grievance procedure
        • [jwplayer file=”2014_04.m4a?Expires=1585782463&Signature=Pefa~2JKbfgFadS7ccvA-0RJlzfWxXfF4CXSjeknYRulEtvWMurmOIZhW0haEupJU0sAKJvYOsIcpU-CvWm6GqM29ZnWxO-5GS-ekIGM4GvDR7fNACQIjwLPai0kos0tpcwQtJLouKxPsUKPAS6FngrCX50T2wMlS~UNrEuu4N8_&Key-Pair-Id=APKAJIHMHD36AUGYELAQ” streamer=”rtmp://s237mamheirpem.cloudfront.net/cfx/st/” provider=”rtmp” image=”http://www.lris.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/first_thursday.jpg”]

          Download the podcast (Use this link to listen on Apple devices)

          Subscribe to this podcast via RSS or iTunes

          Subscribe to this podcast by email

          1 hr 1 min
        • First Thursday, March 2014

          Featured in this month’s podcast:

          • Required retirement contributions do not violate ‘Contracts Clause’
          • Will answers an FLSA question submitted on our website
          • Officer can be disciplined for working without permission
          • Officer’s injury during paid lunch not compensable under workers’ comp
          • Court rules that seeing suspect killed is ‘normal’ for police
          • Due process requires pre-discipline hearing even if appeal rights exist
          • Unsuccessful applicant can review civil service exam
          • Why “I’m sorry” can be the two most important words in a disciplinary hearing
          • [jwplayer file=”2014_03.m4a?Expires=1583619836&Signature=IlgpSThEEASbZZNAxBdZUoGs0hkzWfT2OxmvGYvlyQFWejMTPq1lEWfHaGXFYSx~UrugCnGqKnzKCDS4Be3sAKcauB1yBSO1NUjdvM1hLSRJ3HFetBD7mi2MuXsW3fkTmv5bxaBn297Jqwh5fajolOoS9aSd7mTxM1cGteadwaY_&Key-Pair-Id=APKAJIHMHD36AUGYELAQ” streamer=”rtmp://s237mamheirpem.cloudfront.net/cfx/st/” provider=”rtmp” image=”http://www.lris.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/first_thursday.jpg”]

            Download the podcast (Use this link to listen on Apple devices)

            Subscribe to this podcast via RSS or iTunes

            Subscribe to this podcast by email

            50 min
          • First Thursday, February 2014

            [jwplayer file=”2014_02.m4a?Expires=1581030733&Signature=S4IO2Kr8k5~WWzumxAgCo1-ddqEjj1J1z5OvZ-IQgKJa5zpsSXa7vM~D9O7BcrHnaG5DkpQprBQbT9mriliM469BugN36RXoZi6UzWBnHisr25aa9Eg~wuA3FQZD2liDm0EETDOLHPXFPIq6PuNLP1E0tJ7WcFHGJkq-u6qNHP8_&Key-Pair-Id=APKAJIHMHD36AUGYELAQ” streamer=”rtmp://s237mamheirpem.cloudfront.net/cfx/st/” provider=”rtmp” image=”http://www.lris.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/first_thursday.jpg”]

            Left click to play, right click to download

            Featured in this month’s podcast:

            • The Supreme Court’s decision in the donning and doffing case Sandifer v. United States Steel Corp.
            • An important ADA case from the 4th Circuit court
            • More news on the Genetic Information Disclosure Act
            • A discussion of cases from across the country
            • The last CPI numbers
            • Subscribe to this podcast via RSS or iTunes

              Subscribe to this podcast by email

              58 min
            • First Thursday, January 2014
              Now with improved audio quality!

              As part of our constant effort to provide you with the best quality products, we spared no expense in building a state-of-the-art sound studio to improve the audio quality of our podcasts. That means Will will no longer sound like he’s speaking in an empty fish tank. Of course, if you miss that sound you could always listen to the podcast in an empty fish tank.

              Featured in this month’s podcast:

              • Economic forecasts for 2014
              • What does the Detroit bankruptcy case mean for constitutional protections for pensions?
              • Can a department have residency bonuses in promotions?
              • Does a not-sustained allegation trigger a hearing under a Police Officer Bill Of Rights?
              • Recent Brady and Garcetti cases
              • [jwplayer file=”2014_01.m4a?Expires=1546888212&Signature=NCqj0s7CeMsQhwFVohbKixF3Jb~AVpXXoa~M3vSww2zBLruLvxYc~pKAOX5uW9e9IIxyITfmn8bamAmUGTUDXDbDJy-xuolLFjv1CWrDK-2r4W0Z4sguXIGdAO0aCOij6-wEKFypss109y5MCAryFNEkoWIny3ENvnee6yTz-Qg_&Key-Pair-Id=APKAJIHMHD36AUGYELAQ” streamer=”rtmp://s237mamheirpem.cloudfront.net/cfx/st/” provider=”rtmp” image=”http://www.lris.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/thumbsupear.jpg”]

                Download the podcast (Use this link to listen on Apple devices)

                1 hr 1 min
              • First Thursday, December 2013

                [jwplayer file=”011_first_thurs.m4a?Expires=1575569079&Signature=MLFLEQVWAVWx9QLs-~uCozJ0HZksJfSLHKNgoKtpG0ih~GIbZu7mpX8DNI-zA-qMVlvRRKAXxVyJQnNCNcvwzJgKNFI-Sl2jKBFad9-lMnMNM4vI3rH2QIH~xpnFvJKMZTi4UMsNYPE1bgvIEdq6T8ca8gElL2UTCQJZ7DPloTQ_&Key-Pair-Id=APKAJIHMHD36AUGYELAQ” streamer=”rtmp://s237mamheirpem.cloudfront.net/cfx/st/” provider=”rtmp” image=”http://www.lris.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/facialhair.jpg”]

                Download the podcast (Use this link to listen on Apple devices)

                Subscribe to this podcast via RSS or iTunes

                Subscribe to this podcast by email

                We’re big on facial hair here at LRIS headquarters, but that’s not the only reason it features prominently in this month’s podcast. Rules on facial hair represent just one of several employer policies that can have a constitutional or protected class impact.

                This month’s podcast also features the following non-beard-related topics:

                • No Free Speech Violation Posed By Ban On Releasing PD Materials While Criminal Investigation Active
                • Arbitrator’s Sexual Harassment Opinion Upheld
                • Arbitration Decisions And Civil Rights Litigation
                • Demotion, Not Termination, Usually The Appropriate Punishment For Supervisory Failures
                • Conviction Of Misdemeanor Crime Of Domestic Violence Extinguishes Due Process Rights
                • State Police Successfully Opposes Troopers PTSD Claim
                • No Violation To Freeze Pension When Retired Firefighter Elected To City Council
                • Discussion on the Consumer Price Index
                • 1 hr 2 min
                • First Thursday, November 2013

                  [jwplayer file=”010_first_thurs.m4a?Expires=1550104028&Signature=ePF36NoW1dK7XBDkKOEMvpQc7dr60bxnghXFy2vkFZgtJ0NUL9ZeJiznb4ssPHjVPkcU0PazbgWmekmb1r-xM7CsvXxhMEVUEbgCI1N0O8UG4wKU6C2xiU~0tdEhyIH5rxrmLXhHBKAi3odSVxHaFVmqAkQCRSdNULaxP5gwhMQ_&Key-Pair-Id=APKAJIHMHD36AUGYELAQ” streamer=”rtmp://s237mamheirpem.cloudfront.net/cfx/st/” provider=”rtmp” image=”http://www.lris.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/first_thursday.jpg”]

                  Download the podcast (Use this link to listen on Apple devices)

                  Subscribe to this podcast via RSS or iTunes

                  Subscribe to this podcast by email

                  Featured in this month’s podcast:

                  • New California statute protects against Brady List abuses
                  • Another arbitrator weighs in on Brady List and discipline
                  • Heart-lung presumption applies to diseases with no known cause
                  • If time limits in bill of rights not met, discipline is void
                  • No ‘high level of privacy’ in viewing porn on work computer
                  • 54 min

                  About First Thursday

                  From the publisher's feed

                  A monthly podcast from LRIS that provides in-depth coverage of trends in public sector labor relations.

                  More shows like First Thursday

                  Stuff You Should Know by iHeartPodcasts

                  Stuff You Should Know

                  78,248 Listeners

                  Craig Groeschel Leadership Podcast by Life.Church

                  Craig Groeschel Leadership Podcast

                  10,733 Listeners