Today we are diving in deep about the one issue that seems to vex many outsourcers: hiring the right freelancer.
I break the hiring process into three phases:
Phase 1: Posting our job adPhase 2: Sorting the candidatesPhase 3: Testing and measuring Let’s go through each phase now and I’ll explain how and why I do each of these things.
Phase 1: Posting our job ad
This isn’t as easy as simply copying and pasting the text from our job ad. There are a few little refinements I make to get the best result. It only takes a minute so it’s worth it.
In this instance I’m talking specifically about Upwork but it’s the same process for the others too.
So go ahead and click on the “post a job” link.
This brings up a form that needs to be completed. Critically, you need to select which category your job falls into. Take a bit of time and select the right option because if you choose the wrong sub-category you’ll be missing out on many of your best possible candidates because they’ll only be looking for new jobs in their particular niche
Let’s just say you needed someone to edit your podcast to get rid of the background noise. There’s no specific podcast category so you need to be a little more lateral – the best I could do would be to select Design and Creative and then a sub category of audio production. Go ahead and choose the most relevant you can.
Now you cut and paste the headline from your job ad into the job title space. Don’t make it all caps or use astrices otherwise you’ll look spammy.
In the job description go ahead and paste in the job ad you wrote. You’ll have to fix the spacing and formatting because the bullet points might have come out funny.
There’s a cool space on this form that allows you to select what skills you need the applicants to possess. Be realistic and accurate here because Upwork actually scores the applicants on these skills for you. As you type suggestions will come up and you can choose all that apply.
At this point you have to choose whether you want to go with a fixed price or pay by the hour. For an ongoing job I pay by the hour but there are certain tasks that fixed prices work for. You might want five logo drafts done so you could say $15 fixed for 5 drafts. Be realistic though – you’re not going to get a great result if you want 5 completed logos for $15.
For the rest of the form you have to be both honest and realistic. You’re filling in how much work you expect to be able to offer the freelancer. If you’ve only got a small job, say so. There’s no point saying it’s full time when you’ll only be employing them for a short time. Remember – freelancers are people and you should treat them with respect. That goes for the next section, too, when you fill in the section about desired experience level and corresponding pay rate.
If you’re looking for someone who can work independently and can produce great results in a short amount of time, then obviously you will need to pay for that benefit. If you’re prepared to handle communication issues, lower skill set and a slower turn around, then feel free to set a low price threshold.
But hey, if you’re trying to be the cowboy who’s going to walk into town and post a job ad expecting to hire gun talent for pennies in the dollar, then take a hike. You’re disrespecting the freelancers and giving the rest of us a bad name.
On the post a job screen you can also upload files. This is a good opportunity to show the applicants what you are looking for. You might post a screenshot of a website you like. You might have a video describing a task. Or, and this has saved my bacon on a NUMBER of occasions, try uploading a sketch of what you are looking to get made, built or designed. If you want a list created, post the template spreadsheet for the applicants to have a look at. If it’s too complicated they won’t apply, and that is saving you valuable time weeding out the no-hopers.
At the bottom of this page is a cool section where you can put in screening questions. This serves two purposes:
1) It will check to see if your applicants are switched on enough to write genuine answers or if they’re just writing generic BS2) It will test their written English, which in some cases is really important. Don’t make the questions complicated though – this is just an application.
Finally, in this section you can choose some advanced options to narrow down the type of freelancer you want. If you’re an American start-up looking for an American to answer Skype calls for your customer support, then you can go ahead and select that you only want Americans.
There are a few options in there so just fiddle around to select the options you like.
Bear in mind though, this will not stop everyone applying. It’s not a barrier – it’s a suggestion. But it will be listed on their applications that they don’t meet your criteria.
If you post a job on Upwork you will probably start getting applicants within about 20 minutes. They won’t all be good or suitable but don’t worry about that for the time being. I suggest you post the job and come back to it about 24-hours later. You can go earlier but you’ll be getting applicants throughout that first day so if you get too carried away too early, you might miss a nugget of gold – so to speak.
Sorting the totally unsuitable applicants takes just a few seconds for each. If they didn’t follow your instructions about a code word, delete them. If they don’t have your priority skill set, delete them. It might sound harsh but you set parameters and these people didn’t follow or don’t fit. You’re here to find a great candidate, not consider every applicant.
Once you’ve gone through the initial sort you’ll probably be left with about 50% of the candidates. Now you can dive in and check them out.
Here’s what I do: scan the applicants and look for the people who have more than 4 stars and more than 100 hours of work.
If you want to take a punt on a candidate who’s new to Upwork or hasn’t proven themselves, then go right ahead. But I don’t have time to go through that process and I’m guessing you don’t either.
Read through the list again and right-click-open-in-a-new-tab all the candidates that you think look good. What we’re doing now is sorting out the good from the very good.
You’ll notice that the applicants are all very different. They are possibly from all over the world. They are of different skill level, review scores, hours on site and, most important, their pay rate.
You can automatically discount the applicants who are so far out of your price range you can’t even consider them. What about skill level? Are they lots who are new to Upwork? I delete them. What about review scores less than 4 stars. They’re gone.
Now you can be a little more subjective. Read through what they say they are good at. If you’re looking for someone who’s a Photoshop gun you can probably cross off those people who say they are good at Photoshop, researching, being a personal assistant and an Excel formula expert. If you’re looking for a Photoshop gun then that’s what you need – not a Jack Of All Trades.
By now you are possibly left with about 3 to ten candidates – and you haven’t even read the applications yet.
This leads us to Phase 3 – testing and measuring.
At this point you can start dropping a message back to the candidates if you think they are suitable.
Read through all the applications and cover letters to see what you like. And don’t forget the reviews. These are important but it’s also important to take into account the freelancer’s point of view. I discount reviews left by unreasonable cowboys looking for a $2 Rolls Royce.
When you’ve found the applicants you think might be good, then I have good news for you:
By and large the candidates you are left with now will be pretty similar and possibly able to achieve the task with an equal degree of success.
But you still have to choose.
So open up your trust Microsoft Word and write up a “first reply” email. This should be a pretty comprehensive note to all your chosen applicants outlining that you’d like to interview them through Skype and have a chat.
I’ve put a template letter for this purpose up on Outsourcing All Stars for use by members. Saves you having to write the whole thing from scratch.
Copy and paste the note to your remaining applicants. Can I suggest you don’t contact more than 6 though? Otherwise you’ll be bombarded. And remember – it’s unlikely that one candidate is infinitely better than the others. You just need to select one that you “click” with.
Generally speaking applicants are very fast to reply about an interview. Sometimes within a minute. It’s not unusual for one or two not to reply at all though. They might have taken another job. Don’t be offended – it’s simply another one removed from your list.
Once they have got back to you with their Skype credentials, you can add them and have a chat when they’re both online.
Depending what you are hiring them for, it’s a good idea to set a short test or questionnaire for the final 5 or 6.
If you’re wanting an excel sheet completed, then ask them to make 5 entries and have the result back to them within the hour. Obviously you need to provide the excel template and give specific instructions, such as “Include the details of five pharmacy outlets in the city of Manchester”. Actually, there’s a handy template on Outsourcing All Stars for compiling lists.
If you’re looking for a web developer it might be a little harder but there are different things you can ask them about.
Once you’ve chatted with a few of the candidates it’s likely you will have found someone you can work with. Yes, they’re technically working FOR you but you’ll end up spending a lot of time working WITH them so see if you’ve got chemistry – and the all important respect for each other.
Now that you’ve found someone I suggest you tell them that you want to hire them but that you will be forced to terminate the contract if they fail to live up to your expectations.
Again, be realistic. If you want them to be available 8 hours a day between 9am and 5pm, then that needs to be included in the job ad. If you all of a sudden tell them after a week that you need them to do that, then there’s going to be friction.
Just remember to go through everything you will expect from a freelancer and make it clear. Freelancers are awesome but they are not mind readers. Don’t get upset at something you could have prevented.
That’s it for this episode. Next time I’ll be sharing my strategies for handling problem freelancers so your business or project can continue to be awesome.