Fountains Of Wayne - Valley Winter Song

The other day, I was thinking about creating a playlist of songs that aren't Christmas songs, but sound like they could be Christmas songs. I know, it's wordy. Anyway, I was watching TV and saw an L.L. Bean Christmas commercial featuring this song, and it's perfect for the playlist.

This is from the 2003 FOW album, Welcome Interstate Managers, and it fits the playlist. Now, what else to add?

I can think of Low's Just Like Christmas, The Weepies' All That I Want, and Neil Finn's Sweet Secret Peace. Any more ideas?