Whether individuals or employers pick your health coverage, you can still make sense of insurance choices to match up with your lifestyle and current medical situation. Knowing the relationships between various insurance components makes each plan type digestible.
Before we even talk about insurance plan types, we need proper self-awareness. If we know ourselves and our health tendencies, we’ll find a better insurance plan fit. This logic applies both to individual patients picking health plans from online marketplaces and businesses purchasing health plans for their employees’ best possible coverage.
The major tradeoffs for any health plan involve the relationships between deductibles, out-of-pocket limits, provider access, and premiums. In general, the monthly premium you pay for the privilege of coverage falls if you have a high deductible and/or a small provider network. On the flipside, paying a ginormous premium should give you both comprehensive and vast coverage. Rather than trying to get lost in the sauce with all those complex numbers, it’s better to ask yourself some targeted questions first to find proper balance of payments with your need for care.
I’m going to link on my Substack a great article from NerdWallet with a full list of insurance considerations and plan comparisons, but for now we’ll cover the two best questions with the most impact on your choice. Ask yourself: do you see your primary doctor or a specialist a lot? If you do, you should keep in mind whether or not your preferred doctors take your insurance and also if you need to drop significant copays and coinsurance when going to the clinic. The next thing to ask is this: are your current medications covered under insurance and are they brand-name drugs? Insurance companies talk about what drugs they do and don’t cover on a huge list called a formulary. You can request the current year’s formulary from the insurance directly or check it out at the company’s matching website so you can know for sure if your current meds are approved or have alternatives.
Once you finish that Q&A with yourself, the next step is knowing the actual plan options. The four most common plans are the PPO, HMO, EPO, and POS. The differences between the plans vary by how wide your provider network is and how your care is coordinated to begin with. Let’s dive right in: the PPO, or preferred provider organization, is where the insurance gives you approved coverage for a specific list of providers and facilities. The people on that list would be considered “in-network” where you can get healthcare at the lowest negotiated cost possible. Think of the PPO like how Apple designs its product in-house with all the features but the action of making that product real happens elsewhere. This insurance dictates your coverage but is otherwise hands-off during the moments when you actually get your healthcare. You’re still welcome see a provider who’s not on the PPO’s list but you would definitely have a higher cost of doing so, usually with increased deductibles and coinsurance.
The HMO, or health maintenance organization, on the other hand is pretty much what happens if an insurer runs the whole supply chain of both medical care and the financial components of coverage. Kaiser Permanente is the example of an HMO and is the largest one in the US. If you happen to be a Kaiser member, you get access to their doctors, their facilities, and insurance administrators for supposedly a better price. The only major disadvantage is that you cannot see anyone outside of Kaiser or another HMO unless you enjoy footing the entire medical bill. You would also need an official referral to see any specialist, like a surgeon or dermatologist, which can slow down your care in some circumstances. In this system you need to have a primary doctor who coordinates all your orders and referrals.
Another insurance type called the EPO, or exclusive provider organization works just like a PPO but you can’t see anyone out-of-network without paying full price. With this plan your provider network is restricted like HMO, but you can see a specialist without a referral or extensive oversight from a primary doctor. If we stick with our previous example using Apple as the PPO, we know that the company designs the iPhone in California, makes the phone in China, and you can use it anywhere once you buy it. If Apple were an EPO plan, imagine being able to use the iPhone only in your state or town and nowhere else. The final major plan, called Point-of-Service or POS, is (to keep things brief) a hybrid of an HMO and PPO. My Substack page for this episode found at rushinagalla.substack.com will have a table showing the major pros and cons between all the plan types I mentioned.
For now though, let’s just pump the brakes: how can you make apples-to-apples comparisons, even if there are more insurance plan variations than there are shades of gray? Believe it or not, it’s possible to line up insurance plan options just like your Amazon shopping cart. The holy grail document you need to pull this off is the summary of benefits and coverage (SBC). The point of the SBC is to show out-of-pocket costs, common medical event scenarios, and covered or excluded services in one place for any given plan. I’ll link an example of this on my Substack home page as well.
SBC documents can be found on any insurance marketplace website or healthcare.gov. If your employer is giving or sponsoring the insurance, then reaching out to your HR department is the best move to get the summary. When you get a chance to lay out each plan’s SBC side by side, you can see at a bird’s-eye view what you need to pay for various items like getting traditional visits, lab draws, complex but routine surgeries, certain therapies, and more. It also doesn’t hurt to ask the insurance company directly for policy documents if you need to check the fine-print coverage for a specific procedure, drug, or lab draw which the SBC may not have room to comment on.
Since we’ve gone over the most critical items for plan considerations, plan types, and comparing those choices with an SBC, we can keep taking steps for learning how other parts of medical care fit your lifestyle and situation. As we’ve discussed before, your insurance plays a huge role in how much power the primary doctor has over your care. However, there will come times when you need to see a specialist with expertise that an internal medicine or family medicine doctor can’t offer. In the next post, I’ll unpack the black box that is getting a specialist referral so that aspect of care will be less daunting, more productive, and empowering for you.
Subscribe and stay tuned to Friendly Neighborhood Patient for more practical healthcare guidance. I’ll catch you at the next episode.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit rushinagalla.substack.com