Fully & Completely: Redux — Day for Night (1994)

A presentation of The Tragically Hip Podcast Series

Hosted by: jD & Greg LeGros

Release: Monday

Format: Album deep dive (Redux edition)

Runtime: ~1h 45m

In this episode of Fully & Completely: Redux, we turn our full attention to Day for Night — the record many fans point to as the moment The Tragically Hip stopped chasing expectations and fully committed to the dark, patient, cinematic version of themselves.

Released in September 1994, Day for Night arrived at a cultural moment when the ’90s were no longer new, no longer shiny, and no longer pretending everything was okay. What followed was an album that broke rules quietly: hit singles with no choruses, stories without resolutions, grooves that crept instead of charged.

In this Redux episode, jD and Greg revisit the album with fresh perspective — tracing its creation, its reception, and why it remains one of the most singular statements in the Hip’s catalogue.

What We Cover

• Why Day for Night felt like a deliberate pivot after Fully Completely
• How “Grace, Too” announced a darker, stranger Hip — visually and sonically
• The improbability of “Nautical Disaster” becoming a massive hit with no chorus
• Gord Downie’s leap into fully cinematic, image-driven lyricism
• Johnny Fay and Gord Sinclair quietly redefining the band’s rhythmic identity
• The patience, restraint, and atmosphere that hold the album together
• Why this record feels less like a collection of songs and more like a journey

Track-by-Track Highlights

• Grace, Too – A career-defining opener and tonal manifesto
• Daredevil – A tumbling, vertigo-inducing rock song hiding in plain sight
• Greasy Jungle – Off-kilter, playful darkness with a smirk
• Yawning or Snarling – Menace, crowd imagery, and creeping tension
• Fire in the Hole – Nuance over catharsis, patience over payoff
• So Hard Done By – A mid-tempo, grimy, cinematic standout
• Nautical Disaster – One of the boldest hit singles of the decade
• Thugs – Swampy groove, film references, and one of Downie’s greatest opening lines
• Scared – Beauty, menace, and the illusion of safety
• An Inch an Hour / Emergency / Titanic Terrarium – The album’s final descent into reflection and unease

Why Day for Night Endures

More than any other Hip album, Day for Night rewards patience. It doesn’t rush you. It doesn’t explain itself. It invites you into the fog and trusts you to stay there. For many fans — including jD and Greg — this wasn’t just another release. It was the album that turned admiration into devotion.

About the Podcast

Fully & Completely is a chronological, album-by-album exploration of The Tragically Hip’s studio catalogue. Hosted by jD and Greg LeGros, the series blends music history, personal memory, cultural context, and deep fandom — without myth-making or nostalgia goggles. Redux episodes revisit classic installments with improved audio, tighter edits, and the benefit of distance.

Follow, Join, Support

📍 Instagram / YouTube / Facebook: @tthpods

☕ Support the show: buymeacoffee.com/tthtop40

If you enjoy what we’re building here, following, sharing, or tossing a few bucks in the jar genuinely helps keep the lights on.

Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/tthtop40/donations

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy