The New Monsters: Montauk - Part Three
The Montauk Monster was never just about a strange carcass lying on a Long Island beach.
Why did millions of otherwise rational people immediately believe that a decomposing animal might be the product of secret government experiments? Why did Camp Hero, Plum Island, and decades of Cold War secrecy become inseparable from a single photograph?
In the conclusion to our three-part Montauk investigation, Branden Morgan explores the uncomfortable answer: perhaps the creature itself never mattered.
What mattered was the world that created it.
From MKUltra and government secrecy to the internet's ability to accelerate folklore at unprecedented speed, this episode examines how modern myths emerge—not because people abandon reason, but because uncertainty demands a story.
The Montauk Monster wasn't simply another cryptid.
It may have been one of the first monsters truly born in the digital age.
Why conspiracy theories flourish when public trust erodes
The documented legacy of MKUltra and why it changed public perception
How real government secrecy gave rise to modern folklore
Why Camp Hero and Plum Island became fertile ground for speculation
The psychology behind modern conspiracy thinking
Why myths evolve faster than facts in the internet era
The Montauk Monster as one of the first internet-born cryptids
What the legend ultimately reveals about modern America—not biologyThe greatest monsters are rarely the ones hiding in the shadows. They're the stories we create when certainty disappears.
When people stop trusting the institutions that once explained the world, they don't stop believing altogether. They simply begin searching for new explanations. Sometimes those explanations become science. Sometimes history. And sometimes... they become monsters.
Camp Hero and its Cold War history
Plum Island and the facts behind decades of speculation
MKUltra and the unintended birth of modern conspiracy culture
How folklore migrated from campfires to message boards
Why the internet has become humanity's newest myth-making machineNext Time on The New Monsters
The investigation moves from abandoned military installations into an entirely different wilderness:
In 2009, a simple Photoshop contest gave birth to a faceless figure known as Slender Man. He wasn't discovered in ancient folklore or whispered about for generations. He was deliberately created online.
Then something extraordinary happened.
People began claiming they had seen him.
The story spread across forums, videos, games, and social media before culminating in one of the most disturbing crimes of the digital age. We'll examine how fiction escaped the screen, why the human mind embraced the impossible, and whether the internet has become the birthplace of an entirely new kind of mythology.
If you're enjoying The New Monsters, please follow The Devil Within wherever you get your podcasts.
Watch the video editions and exclusive companion content on the Evio Creative YouTube Channel.
Follow @thedevilwithinpod on Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, and YouTube for behind-the-scenes content, historical photographs, and updates on future investigations.
Written & Hosted by: Branden Morgan
A production of Evio Creative.
📱 Follow The Devil Within
Instagram, TikTok & Facebook: @thedevilwithinpod
Or, if you want to drive engagement a bit harder:
Follow The Devil Within on Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook @thedevilwithinpod for
episode clips, behind-the-scenes content, historical deep dives, and the creepiest stories we can't
Stay up to date with all our shows at @eviocreative on Instagram.
Your complete CTA block would then read:
Follow The Devil Within wherever you get your podcasts so you never miss an episode.
If you're enjoying the show, please leave us a five-star rating and review on Apple Podcasts or
Spotify. It helps more listeners discover the stories that still linger in the dark.
📺 Watch & Subscribe on YouTube
Watch full episodes, video versions, and exclusive content on the Evio Creative YouTube
channel. Be sure to subscribe and turn on notifications.
Have a paranormal encounter, local legend, or case you'd like us to investigate? Email us at
📱 Follow The Devil Within
Instagram, TikTok & Facebook: @thedevilwithinpod
Instagram: @eviocreative
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
