Dragons, Virgins, and Cringe-Worthy One-Liners: A Supernatural Adventure

Welcome to this episode of Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast! Join hosts Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor as they dive into Supernatural Season 6 Episode 12 "Like A Virgin"—the much-anticipated dragon episode that Supernatural fans constantly reference. After Sam's soul is restored and Dean's heroic complex kicks into overdrive, the boys face mythical beasts, questionable pickup lines, and enough cringe moments to fuel a drinking game.

The Soul-Crushing Setup & Dragon Drama

The episode picks up with Sam finally getting his soul back from Hell, complete with Death's mysterious wall keeping those traumatic memories locked away. But there's no time for emotional processing when virgin girls start disappearing and getting "snatched" across the country. The investigation leads to everyone's favorite mythical creatures—dragons—who apparently haven't been seen for 700 years but are now collecting virgins and gold like some twisted fantasy game. Dean channels his inner knight by attempting to wield the legendary Sword of Brunswick, though his approach involves more C4 explosives than chivalry.

Lies, Maps, and Awkward Not-Hugs

This episode delivers peak brother dynamics as Dean desperately tries to protect Sam from the truth about his soulless year, leading to a drinking game goldmine of lies between the boys. Bobby struggles with his own feelings about Sam's return, Castiel remains endearingly naive, and there's an abundance of maps scattered throughout their research montages. The hosts particularly enjoyed counting the cringe-worthy moments and pop culture references, including Dean's Comic-Con quip and various Batman jokes that definitely didn't age well:

• Dragon fight sequences that left viewers wanting more actual dragon transformations
• Dr. Visyak's introduction as Bobby's mysterious contact with serious chemistry potential
• The revelation of Eve as the "Mother of All" setting up the season's big bad
• Drinking game rules included shots for awkward not-hugs and sips for every "dragons" mention
• Over 50+ drinks total for players following the full ruleset

Final Thoughts & Next Episode Preview

While "Like A Virgin" delivers on Supernatural mythology and character development, both hosts agreed the dragon execution felt budget-limited despite the episode's ambition. The real treasure lies in Sam's emotional return and the setup for bigger threats ahead. Next episode ventures into Season 12 territory with "Regarding Dean"—promising bunny encounters, witch drama, and what the hosts describe as "top notch work from Jensen Ackles" in a frequently memed episode.

Connect with Gank That Drank

Catch Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor live at Neighborhood Comedy Theatre in Mesa, Arizona, where they'll buy you a drink at the Sacred Pint if you mention you're a listener. Learn more about the theater at nctphoenix.com. For early access, ad-free episodes, and bonus content, become a member at trustory.fm/join. Follow the show's social adventures on Facebook, Instagram, and Bluesky. Rate and review to help combat those "meanest reviews ever" from the podcast's early days!

What's your take on Supernatural's dragon mythology—did the episode deliver enough fantasy action or leave you wanting more legendary creature battles?

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Body Swapped and Ready to Party: Season 5's Comedic Masterpiece

Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor dive into Supernatural’s Season 5 Episode 12 "Swap Meat"—a hilarious body-swap adventure that showcases Jared Padalecki's impressive comedic range. When teenage witch Gary switches bodies with Sam Winchester, chaos ensues as Dean tries to figure out why his brother is suddenly interested in fast food, loud music, and having "the sex."

This monster-of-the-week episode delivers pure entertainment as Sam navigates high school drama while trapped in Gary's teenage body, towering over actual teenagers and struggling with asthma. Meanwhile, Gary-in-Sam's-body wreaks havoc, crashing Baby and throwing away all their cell phones before Dean finally catches on. The hosts praise how this standalone episode works perfectly for newcomers while still delivering classic Supernatural moments, including a satisfying tag-team exorcism ending with Dean's signature "Adios, bitch."

The drinking game rules kept things lively with classics like "drink when they drink" (9 times!), plus episode-specific gems like taking shots for Sasquatch references and Gary getting "glutened." Krissy and Nate particularly loved how the episode balanced comedy with genuine heart, especially Sam's touching moment with Gary about appreciating the life you have.

Additional Highlights:

• Perfect Timing: Released just as the new Freakier Friday movie hits theaters
• Stellar Guest Cast: Features Colton James as Gary plus Grey's Anatomy alum Sarah Drew
• Comedic Gold: Jared Padalecki's dual performance as both Sam-in-Gary's-body and Gary-in-Sam's-body
• Classic Monster Episode: Accessible to newcomers while satisfying longtime fans
• Drinking Game Rating: 4-5 out of 5 banana daiquiris

Krissy rated the drinking game 4/5 banana daiquiris due to many one-time rules, while Nate gave it a perfect 5/5 for capturing the episode's spirit. Next up: Season 6's dragon-filled "Like a Virgin" with plenty of cringe-worthy moments and awkward not-hugs to fuel their next drinking adventure.

Connect with the Hosts

Catch Krissy and Nate live at Neighborhood Comedy Theatre in downtown Mesa, Arizona. Follow the show on Facebook, Instagram, and Bluesky.

Support the show and get episodes a week early with no ads, plus exclusive bonus content, by becoming a member at trustory.fm/join. Learn more about the podcast network at trustory.fm.

What's your favorite body-swap episode in television or movies? Do you think Gary deserved a second chance, or should the Winchesters have been more concerned about leaving Trevor's body for his parents to discover?

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Charlie's Nightmare: When Video Games and Family Secrets Collide

Welcome to this episode of Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast. Hosts Nate McWhorter and Krissy Lenz dive into Supernatural's beloved Season 8 episode "Pac-Man Fever," where Charlie Bradbury returns with secrets darker than her hacking past. This fan-favorite episode blends video game nostalgia with emotional family drama, creating one of the series' most memorable Charlie-centric stories.

The Deep Dive Discussion
The hosts explore how "Pac-Man Fever" masterfully balances Charlie's comedic FBI impersonation fumbles with the heartbreaking revelation about her comatose mother. They discuss how the episode transforms Charlie from a quirky recurring character into someone with genuine emotional depth, particularly through her relationship with Dean that evolves into a true big brother/little sister dynamic. The video game dream sequence serves as both thrilling action and metaphor for Charlie's guilt over her parents' accident.

Nate and Krissy praise the episode's ability to deliver both supernatural thrills and emotional payoffs, noting how the final scenes—from Dean's protective kiss on Charlie's forehead to the brothers' sincere hug—represent some of the series' most genuine moments of familial love. They also can't help but rant about the boys' persistent habit of buying six-packs instead of buying beer in bulk, which becomes a running joke throughout their discussion.

Additional Highlights:

• The drinking game features rules for gunshots (the "doozy" rule), Sam's declining health, and Charlie's signature "dude" catchphrase
• Discussion of guest star appearances, including Manny Jacinto's brief role as one of the unfortunate gamers
• Analysis of how the episode handles the moral complexity of Sam killing a teenage djinn
• Appreciation for the episode's perfect blend of War Games references and emotional storytelling
• Debate over Charlie's mysteriously accurate shooting skills and whether video game experience translates to real-world marksmanship

Final Thoughts
Both hosts agree that "Pac-Man Fever" stands as one of Supernatural's finest episodes, successfully deepening Charlie's character while delivering the monster-of-the-week format fans love. The episode's exploration of family, guilt, and letting go resonates long after the final scene of Charlie reading The Hobbit to her mother one last time.

Ready to gank your own drank? Visit trustory.fm to learn more about the show and discover early, ad-free access plus bonus content for members at trustory.fm/join.

Connect with the hosts: Follow on Facebook, Instagram, and Bluesky. Learn more about their live comedy shows at Neighborhood Comedy Theatre.

What's your favorite Charlie Bradbury episode, and do you think her hacking skills make her the most useful Supernatural ally?

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Bobby Singer's Unfinished Business: A Ghostly Good Time

Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor dive into Supernatural Season 7, Episode 19 "Of Grave Importance"—a haunting Bobby-centric episode that aired on April 20, 2012. When the Winchester brothers investigate mysterious disappearances at the supposedly haunted Van Ness house, they discover more than just restless spirits lurking in the shadows.

A Hunter's Funeral and Ghost Politics

This episode serves as a beautiful showcase for Jim Beaver's acting prowess as Bobby Singer navigates the afterlife with his characteristic wit and determination. The hosts explore how Bobby's ghostly presence creates both touching moments and comedic gold, from his failed attempts at moving objects Swayze-style to his frustration with being ignored by the living. Krissy and Nate particularly appreciate the episode's unique perspective on what happens when hunters become the very things they once laid to rest.

The Van Ness house becomes a supernatural boarding house where ghosts from different eras coexist, each slowly deteriorating over time. The episode's villain, Whitman Van Ness, proves that even in death, some people never stop being terrible. The discussion touches on how Supernatural uses this ghost-heavy episode to explore themes of letting go, the natural order of things, and what it means to truly help the people you love.

Drinking Game Highlights & Episode Gems

• Smooch City: The episode opens with teen romance turned deadly—a classic Supernatural move
• Swayze References: Multiple Ghost movie callbacks that earn the premium drinking penalties
• Bobby's Catchphrases: "Balls" and "idgits" make their expected appearances throughout
• Foxhole Confessions: Everyone apparently had a thing with Annie Hawkins at some point
• Chain Restaurant Philosophy: Dean's existential musings about Taco Bell consistency across America

Final Thoughts

The hosts crown this a standout Bobby episode that balances emotional weight with supernatural fun. While praising the episode's execution, they note some missed opportunities—particularly wondering what happened to the exposition-heavy ghost Haskell who disappears after one scene. The episode successfully sets up future storylines while delivering a satisfying standalone ghost hunt that showcases why Bobby Singer remains one of Supernatural's most beloved characters.

Ready to Join the Hunt?

Learn more about Gank That Drank and discover other great shows at trustory.fm. Members get early, ad-free access plus exclusive bonus content—join the family at trustory.fm/join.

Connect with the hosts: Visit the Neighborhood Comedy Theatre in Mesa, Arizona, or follow them on Facebook, Instagram, and Bluesky.

What's your favorite Bobby Singer moment from the series? Do you think he made the right choice staying behind as a ghost?

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Love bites and so does Famine! Join hosts Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor from Mesa's Neighborhood Comedy Theater as they dive into one of Supernatural's most disturbing Valentine's Day episodes. This chunky episode serves up body horror with a side of burgers as the Winchester brothers face off against the Horseman Famine in a tale that makes cannibalism look like romance gone wrong.

The Feast of Famine

Our hosts break down how Famine's hunger-inducing powers affect everyone differently—from couples literally consuming each other to Castiel's newfound obsession with hamburgers. The episode brilliantly shows Dean's emotional emptiness through his immunity to Famine's effects, while Sam's demon blood addiction becomes the key to victory. It's a masterclass in character development disguised as monster-of-the-week horror.

Drinking Game Carnage

This episode proved to be a heavy drinking game with rules including drinks for "Smooch City" moments, Dean's drinking, deaths (double if named), demon smoke, Cupid hugs, Sam questioning Dean, the word "hungry," and every time Castiel eats. The hosts hilariously disagreed on counts, with Krissy tallying 18 instances of "hungry/hunger" compared to Nate's 8, proving this episode was as packed with content as Famine's victims were with food.

Other Topics Covered:

• Russell and Alice's disturbing opening scene
• Office romance gone murderous with Jimbo, Brad, and Janice
• Dr. Corman's memorable performance and tragic end
• Cupid's emotional breakdown and revelation about the Winchester parents
• The grotesque Biggerson's restaurant massacre
• Sam's demon blood relapse and heroic demon exorcism
• Dean's existential crisis about his inner emptiness
• Castiel's burger addiction and raw hamburger consumption

Next Episode Preview: Season 7 Episode 19 "Of Grave Importance" featuring Bobby as a ghost with drinking rules for ghost appearances, Swayze references, and Bobby's signature phrases.

Find Gank That Drank wherever podcasts are downloaded, and catch Krissy and Nate live at the Neighborhood Comedy Theater in downtown Mesa, Arizona!

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Welcome back to Gank That Drank, the supernatural drinking game podcast where comedians Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor dive into their favorite Supernatural episodes with custom drinking game rules! This week, they're tackling Season 9's eighth episode "Rock and a Hard Place"—a forgettable monster-of-the-week episode that somehow becomes memorable thanks to Dean's hilariously awkward chastity group speech.

The Virgin Episode That's Actually Worth It
While the hosts admit this isn't their favorite episode, it delivers some genuinely funny moments. The standout scene? Dean's cringe-worthy monologue about sex at the church chastity meeting that literally has the group crossing their legs and crunching pamphlets. As Nate puts it, "it's worth the whole episode just to watch that scene."

Jody Mills Saves Everything
Sheriff Jody Mills returns and elevates every scene she's in. Her sucker punch moment becomes one of the episode's highlights, and her heartfelt conversation with Sam about the Winchester brothers' special connection provides genuine emotional depth to an otherwise generic plot.

International Title Madness
The hosts discover wildly different international titles for this episode, ranging from Italy's boring "Between the Devil and the Deep Sea" to Hungary's brilliant "Unmake Virgins!" Germany's "Finally a Virgin Again" perfectly captures the episode's absurd premise.

Topics Covered

• Dean gets re-virginized for the second time in the series
• Vesta, Roman goddess of the hearth, as the big bad
• Susie's bizarre porn star backstory involving tacos
• Sam's mysterious exhaustion (thanks, Ezekiel!)
• The gross nail-scraping blood-drinking scene
• Phoenix Fan Fusion absence and Sacred Pint Brewing partnership
• Drinking game rules: nabbing, churches, virgins, dragons, research, smooch city, blue flames, Jody sucker punches, and Sammy mentions

Next Episode Preview
Get ready for Season 5, Episode 14: "My Bloody Valentine"—the Cupid episode featuring demon blood Sam and plenty of Winchester angst. New drinking rules include Cupid hugs, Dean drinking, and Castiel eating.

Ready to play along? Join Krissy and Nate for more supernatural shenanigans, and remember their motto: "Be excellent to each other and party on!"

Find Gank That Drank at trustory.fm and catch the hosts live at Neighborhood Comedy Theater in Mesa, Arizona.

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Get ready for some supernatural shenanigans as Krissy and Nate dive into Season 5, Episode 6 of Supernatural: "I Believe The Children Are Our Future!" This episode serves up urban legends gone wrong, a tooth fairy that looks like Jim Belushi, and the introduction of Jesse Turner, the most powerful kid you'll never see again.

The Antichrist Dilemma
Our hosts break down one of Supernatural's biggest missed opportunities: Jesse Turner, the half-demon, half-human antichrist with reality-bending powers. This kid can turn angels into toy soldiers and force demons out of their hosts with a simple "get out of her!" Yet he disappears to Australia and is never mentioned again. Talk about underutilized potential!

Urban Legends Run Wild
From deadly itching powder to electrocuting hand buzzers, this episode brings childhood fears to life. The first half focuses on investigating these bizarre deaths caused by seemingly harmless pranks and toys, creating a genuinely creepy monster-of-the-week setup that keeps you guessing.

Family Dynamics & Lies
The episode explores the theme of protective lies parents tell their children, with Dean wishing John Winchester had lied to them more to preserve their innocence. It's a poignant moment that adds emotional depth to what could have been just another case.

Other Topics Covered:

• Drinking game rules featuring tooth fairy mentions, urban legends, and Castiel transformations
• The creepy babysitter opening scene and classic horror tropes
• Page and Plant FBI aliases making multiple appearances
• Castiel's cold pragmatism about killing Jesse
• The boys' moral stance against murdering children
• Jesse's choice to leave the hunting life behind
• References to 2009 pop culture (Twilight, iPhones)
• Comparisons to X-Men and superhero training scenarios

Join Krissy and Nate as they rate their drinking game rules and debate whether Supernatural should have brought back this reality-warping kid. Spoiler alert: they definitely should have! Don't forget to check out the Neighborhood Comedy Theater in Mesa, Arizona, and support the podcast at truestory.fm.

Next episode: Season 9, Episode 8 "Rock and a Hard Place"—featuring virgins, churches, and Jody's sucker punch!

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

When Witchy Exes Go to War

Welcome to another spellbinding episode of Gank That Drank, where hosts Krissy and Nate break down Season 7, Episode 5 of Supernatural, "Shut Up, Dr. Phil"! This bewitching installment features special guest stars James Marsters (Spike from Buffy) and Charisma Carpenter (Cordelia from Buffy) as feuding witch spouses whose marital problems are causing deadly consequences.

The episode delivers some of the season's most creative kills as Maggie Stark (Carpenter) seeks revenge on her philandering husband Don (Marsters) by taking out everyone connected to his affairs. From salon blow dryer deaths to floating nail guns and eyeball martinis, this episode blends horror and humor in classic Supernatural fashion.

Our hosts' drinking game includes rules for force pushes, dead plants, pie moments, and every time someone says "yeah, okay"—which happens repeatedly during Sam and Dean's awkward attempts at conversation. Meanwhile, the boys are dealing with their own issues, as Dean continues to have nightmares about killing Sam's friend Amy while trying to hide his guilt.

The podcast also highlights the episode's significance to the overarching season plot, as we see the Leviathan hunter Chet tracking the Winchesters before being magically incapacitated by Don. Krissy and Nate discuss how this episode showcases Dean's moral inconsistency—he's willing to let the murderous witch couple live while having executed Amy for similar crimes.

Other topics covered:

• The hilarious "bedside beer" Dean reaches for when he wakes from nightmares
• The excellent chemistry between Buffy alums Marsters and Carpenter
• Don's cheesy line: "You're the woman I want to never grow old with"
• Dean's constant teasing of Sam for trying to stay healthy
• The Romanian coin connection between the murders
• The return of Jenny Klein in a future "Clip Show" episode
• Next episode preview: Season 5's "I Believe the Children Are Our Future"

Whether you're a witch enthusiast or just enjoy watching the Winchester brothers struggle with supernatural marital counseling, this episode has something for everyone. Join Krissy and Nate for this delightfully macabre journey through one of Supernatural's most entertaining standalone episodes!

Don't forget to check out Krissy and Nate at the Neighborhood Comedy Theater in downtown Mesa, Arizona, or catch Krissy on the "Most Excellent 80s Movies Podcast." Gang a drank with us on social media and become a member at TruStory.fm for bonus content!

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Welcome to Gank That Drank, where hosts Krissy Lenz and Nate dive into Supernatural episodes with custom drinking games! This week, they tackle Season 11's finale, "Alpha and Omega," where the stakes couldn't be higher as God (Chuck) is dying, and the world faces imminent destruction.

The episode picks up right where the previous one left off: Amara has defeated everyone, Chuck is dying on the floor, and the sun is literally fading away. Our hosts break down how the team scrambles to find a solution by collecting souls to build a bomb powerful enough to destroy Amara, leading Dean to make what appears to be the ultimate sacrifice.

Krissy and Nate discuss the emotional farewells as Dean prepares to be the delivery system for this cosmic bomb, highlighting the touching moment when he hands over the Impala keys to Sam. But in classic Supernatural fashion, the plan goes sideways when Amara instantly detects the bomb. Instead of destruction, the episode culminates in reconciliation between Chuck and Amara, with a shocking final scene revealing Mary Winchester's return.

Episode Highlights

• The drinking game rules included drinking for "milady" mentions, soul references, and Ghostbusters jokes
• Introduction of Lady Toni Bevell and the British Men of Letters storyline
• Chuck and Rowena's amusing parent-like tea conversation
• Dean and Castiel's heartfelt "you're our brother" moment
• Billie the Reaper's cool entrance and soul collection
• The emotional "no chick flick moments" exchange between Sam and Dean
• The cliffhanger ending with Mary Winchester's return and Sam facing Lady Bevell

Our hosts rate this finale as "fine but not spectacular," noting it lacks the emotional punch of previous season finales and relies too heavily on plans that repeatedly fail. They also speculate whether Chuck was manipulating everyone all along, adding another layer to the cosmic drama.

Join Krissy and Nate next episode as they travel back to Season 7 for "Shut Up, Dr. Phil"—and don't forget to catch their live improv shows at the Neighborhood Comedy Theater in downtown Mesa, Arizona!

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.

Join hosts Nate McWhortor and Krissy Lenz as they dive into Supernatural Season 7, Episode 3, "The Girl Next Door"—directed by none other than Jensen Ackles himself! In this episode of Gank That Drank, they break down this controversial episode while sipping along to their carefully crafted drinking game rules.

This episode explores Sam's past connection with a kitsune named Amy Pond (played by Jewel Staite from Firefly), whom he encounters again years later. While Sam believes Amy deserves mercy since she only killed to save her sick son, Dean makes a shocking decision behind Sam's back that raises questions about character consistency and morality in the Supernatural universe.

Krissy and Nate don't hold back their criticism of certain aspects, particularly questioning Dean's uncharacteristic actions and the problematic medical details (that cast over Dean's jeans!). They also highlight the episode's exploration of moral gray areas, the "freak" identity both Sam and Amy share, and Dean's troubling interaction with Amy's son.

Episode Highlights:

• Jensen Ackles' directorial debut for the series
• Young Sam's first meeting with Amy and their connection as "freaks"
• The appearance of Jewel Staite as Amy Pond (a Doctor Who reference)
• Dean's questionable character decision that contradicts his growth
• Introduction of Leviathans and their nacho cheese obsession
• The hosts' drinking game rules including "take a drink for Leviathans" and "take a shot for gank"
• Discussion of Dean's broken/dislocated leg and the problematic prop cast
• Bobby's rescue mission and cabin hideout
• Sam's hallucinations of Lucifer continuing

The hosts wrap up by previewing their next episode covering Season 11, Episode 23, "Alpha and Omega," and teasing bonus content about their top three sexiest monsters in pop culture for their members at TruStory FM.

Whether you're a die-hard Supernatural fan or just enjoy drinking games with your TV shows, this podcast offers an entertaining deep dive into one of the series' most morally complex episodes. Tune in for laughs, insights, and of course, drinks!

---
Learn more about supporting this podcast by becoming a member. It's just $5/month or $55/year. Visit our website to learn more.