This clip sparks an interesting conversation and a much deeper question: Has America given the world a heresy? Inspired by Rory McIlroy’s comments on the United States and Pope Leo XIII’s 1899 condemnation of “Americanism,” the conversation explores the relationship between patriotism, freedom, and Catholic faith. What is the heresy of Americanism? Are we Catholic Americans or American Catholics? And what’s the difference between freedom from restraint and freedom for excellence?

Drawing on Church history, political philosophy, and the witness of figures like Franz Jägerstätter, the episode examines whether the Church should adapt to modern culture—or stand apart from it. America has contributed extraordinary things to the world, including religious liberty and constitutional government, but does every American instinct belong in the life of the Church? This thoughtful and lively discussion unpacks why Pope Leo XIII issued his warning and why the question remains just as relevant for Catholics today.

Read Testem Benevolentiae Nostrae at the link below: https://www.papalencyclicals.net/leo13/l13teste.htm