
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Before sunrise this morning, after maybe two hours of sleep on a red-eye flight, I had the honor of recommitting to my meditation practice in the atrium of the Atlanta airport. All the chairs had been corralled by uncomfortable sleepers, and the “Interfaith Chapel” appeared to be closed for renovations, so I just plopped my bags down on a bench in the center, sat down next to them, closed my eyes, and tried to do my thing.
I considered headphones. I could have used white noise like I did on the flight, or I could have tried guided meditations from buddhify, which I have bought but am yet to try (remind me to write about meditation apps another time). Instead, I opted to just be with the sounds of the airport waking up. It was a poignant experience of what it means to be “passing through.”
I only sat for seven minutes all told, but it surprised me how much this practice felt like the real deal. I couldn’t go as deep as I can in a long, uninterrupted stretch on my cushion, but I realized the good stuff isn’t always that deep down. Airports are sites of real stress and anxiety. I usually spend my time in them huffing and puffing and struggling to get through it. It was surprisingly healing just to sit and be calm in the middle of the airport. It feels like I loosened up about it in a way I’ll remember on my return leg.
I keep getting stuck on the word “mindfulness” this morning. I guess most of the time I can just glide past the word and experience the reality to which it refers. But you know that phenomenon where, if you repeat a perfectly reasonable, commonplace word enough times, it starts to sound like nonsense? Try it: Button. Button. Button. Button. Button. Something like that occasionally happens to me with a word like “mindfulness,” where I gradually realize it’s just a bunch of blah-blah syllables that don’t really convey the meaning of this word.
I’m no pro etymologist — is that even a thing? — but according to the thought loops I was having on my meditation cushion this morning, it′s obvious from the structure of the word that the cultures who produced English didn’t have an indigenous term for this, so it had to be invented.
“Mind-” seems like a reasonable start; it’s a jolly old English word for the place, if you will, where mindfulness takes place, whatever it is. Then we get the suffix “-ful-,” which is kinda like the standalone word “full,” but in a specific sense that indicates self-possession. The best reference for it I can come up with is the word “careful.” I guess to be mindful is to be self-possessed of mind in the same sense in which to be careful is to be self-possessed of care. Doesn’t help much.
Then you tack on that irritatingly New Age suffix “-ness” to make a noun out of it, and now it has the sound of some immutable essence that’s out there to be taken possession of, and that seems all wrong. The English word for this should be a verb! It’s not something you get, it’s something you do.
I have a somewhat fraught relationship with routine.
On one hand, I crave it. I like to know what to expect, I like to know where everything is, I like to know what’s coming up next. I have a limited appetite for surprises. I know lots of creative people like to be constantly bombarded with new inputs for inspiration, but it’s usually the opposite for me: I like a stable ground and a regular cycle that lets me reliably crank stuff out at my peak creative times and iterate every day.
On the other hand, I go from boredom to insanity on a dime. As soon as something in my routine isn’t working anymore, it starts to grind and grate until it feels like the source of all my problems, and pulling it out by the roots seems like the only way to get my groove back.
I have a pretty long cycle for this; a solid routine can last me a year or two. But when I make a change, I tend to do it thunderously. I might declare, “I’m not Jewish, I’m Buddhist now!”, or “I’m not Buddhist, I’m Jewish now!”, you know, for example. Making such sweeping declarations feels good in the moment, but it can be disruptive, especially to anyone around me trying to keep up.
But there has to be a reason why meditation has come back into my routine over and over, no matter what religion I happen to be at the time. I’m finally starting to understand that it threads the needle between my two states of routine and disruption. Like anything healthy and alive, meditation represents the whole system in microcosm — it cultivates stability and embraces change.
One of my favorite paradoxes of meditation is that it’s the only activity I can keep doing after I do it. Sometimes I only start meditating after I meditate.
For example, this morning, I slept in a little bit, so rather than exercising first, as I’ve been doing this summer, I just got up, brushed my teeth, drank some water, and sat. It was a much dreamier, sleepier, more distracted sit than I’ve been having lately. When I wake up, exercise, shower, and then sit, I feel very bright and active, and meditation seems easy! But today, it was a slog. I was repeatedly carried away into thick jungles of emotionally intense daydreaming, and I had to hack my way back to my cushion.
When the timer went off, I unfolded my legs, shook my right one until it woke back up, then went to the counter to heat water for tea. I’ve been trying to replace coffee with matcha, mainly because I want to reduce my caffeine dosage, but there’s a nice side effect that matcha preparation is a lovely, easy mindfulness ritual. Without too much conscious thought, I paid effortless attention to pouring the water and whisking the tea until the froth was spinning clockwise like a green galaxy. Then I carried the cup to the couch, sat, and sipped. And sat. And sipped.
Now I feel perfectly awake and concentrated. Sure, some of that is attributable to the caffeine. On other days, my awakeness is attributable to endorphins from exercise. That’s just the situation. The point is that I spent some time this morning mindfully doing something. That’s the practice.
At times I’ve felt that daily meditation was too passive a practice — that the conditions of the world demand action, and blocking out time for repose is a literal retreat from the world’s battles.
But when my practice is strong, I see the destructive and chaotic potential of uncontrolled action, and I realize that meditative control is an active process that must be strengthened like a muscle, so it can guide that impulse to action.
Control is an uncomfortable word for it, though. When I search for a better verb for what the will is doing in meditation, the source that comes to mind for me is the Torah: *“Vayishbot bayom ha’shvi’i mikol melachto asher asah.”* It’s the verb lashevet, literally “to sit,” from the biblical source of the practice of Shabbat. Hear the shared root of those words? Much hay has been made by Jewish meditators about the fact that ”Shabbat” basically means “the sit.”
That passage would typically be translated, “And God rested on the seventh day from all the work that God had done,” but literally it could be rendered, “God sat.” To me, the ambiguity in English comes from a different sensibility about the quality of action in the verb. Think about it: God is all-powerful. God didn’t need a break after creating the universe. God exercised God’s will to limit creative action, to dedicate a fixed amount of time for blessing what is already made. To sit is an action.
That’s what we practice tonight at sundown until tomorrow night when the stars come out. If meditation can be defined as applying the will to sustain a particular consciousness for a period of time, Shabbat — the Sit — is a 25-hour meditation. See you on the other side!
Shabbat shalom.
Today I’m grateful for the Burmese posture, and to Rav James for instructing me to finally find my seat in it. For years, I struggled in a sort of 1/3-lotus position (not a real thing), with my left foot up on my right calf — as high as it would go — the ankle rolled dangerously to the inside. This was the only way I could imitate the severe images I had in my mind of The Right Way to Meditate™.
When I came to Rav James for my first interview on this retreat and told him pain in my legs was distracting me constantly, he first tested whether I was just having trouble sitting with discomfort. I had thought of that, and I was “sitting with the pain” as long as I could stand it, but it was becoming overwhelming every sit. He then asked if I had ever tried Burmese posture. I had, I replied, but “I thought it was cheating.”
“Oh, no, I sit that way,” Rav James said.
He had been sitting in a chair this retreat because of an injury. Usually, this great teacher sits in a posture I had just described as “cheating.” We laughed, and then I realized I was free to sit in a posture I had only used as emergency relief before. My next sit was my most stable in years.
The stability and dignity of sitting on the floor with the knees down just feels right to me. But now I know how my body wants to find its seat. Instead of being attached to exotic ideals, I’m letting what is be what is.
Last night I dreamt about taking photos and making art with a bunch of merry weirdos in a foreign country. It was a carefree, sensuous dream with a palpable sense of living with no rules.
The art we made was gritty and human, but its subject was nature. The photo I took was of a hardy mountain tree with dark, tightly packed leaves on thin branches swooping upward like flames. The project had an underlying environmentalist ethos; it was almost a form of protest. Upon waking, it reminded me of The Overstory, which I just read, and Riddley Walker, which I haven’t read since high school.
This dream was suffused with that nostalgia unique to dreams, evoked by intimately familiar experiences somehow more real than the ones from waking life. It was pleasant in its own right, but the intensity of the pleasure was more noticeable in contrast to what arose in my mind after being awake for a few minutes.
By far, the most frequent kind of intrusive thought I have is about work. I don’t know how long this has been the case, but I certainly recognize it as a core part of my experience in my current job, which I’ve had for about four years. Work pops into my mind constantly, in action and meditation.
The dream was a return to play. But it was really a playful form of work — and one not unlike the one my job is kinda all about. My meditation this morning gave me a little spaciousness around both work and play, and I’m starting to suspect they’re both just action with a different attitude.
This morning was the first time since the retreat that I didn’t look at my watch once during my morning sit. I’m settling back in after the transition. But even though I didn’t check, I still thought about checking, and noticed I was thinking about checking. I always do.
The only reason I didn’t check my watch during the retreat was that I wasn’t wearing one. I think I relate to sitting practice, on some level, as an exercise in counting down until it’s over. There’s an associated feeling of accomplishment when the time is up — “Yes! I just sat for 30 minutes!” — as though I’ve deposited freshly earned meditation credits into my account at the karma bank.
I don’t hold too tightly to that feeling. I’m well aware my KarmaBucks are only redeemable as the price of admission to my own meditation cushion. I recognize this emotional reward as a positive motivation to practice, and that’s a good thing. I’m more concerned about the counting down.
Sitting for x minutes doesn’t seem ideal. I can always hear frustration in teachers’ voices when students like me ask, “How long should I sit each day?” Someday I hope I’ll just be counting up.
Ariel and I have a baby coming this year. Carving out 30 minutes every morning for sitting is not how this is going to work! My practice when the baby comes will be just to be present with the baby until the baby needs something, take care of the need, go back to being present, and repeat as many times as I can. That’s a counting up practice, and it seems much truer to life than these isolated islands of time we use to get started with meditation.
Meditation practice has always been about resilience for me. From the very first session, that aspect of it is the first thing one encounters — as soon as you settle into your posture, you realize, “Oh. I’m going to be here a while, and I’m already tired of it. How am I going to last 14 more minutes?”
At first, meditation may feel like merely withstanding the desire to stop meditating, but the challenges quickly multiply beyond that: physical discomfort, distraction, overwhelming feelings. And there are still nine entire minutes left!
After hanging in there a while, it becomes clear that these challenges are always available, whether one is sitting or not. That’s when gratitude for the practice starts to kick in, when one realizes that it’s resilience training for real situations. When Trungpa rinpoche teaches that “the situations of life start to become your guru,” this is how I understand it. One learns from the practice how to learn from each moment of one’s life.
As one begins to see patterns in those moments and one’s reactions, one can develop more skillful responses, which make one more resilient. It can be dangerous to speak of there being a “point” to meditation, but to me, it seems pretty safe to say this is one. I’ll speak for myself, but one of the primary reasons I meditate is to become more resilient now, so I can be ready for inevitable, ever greater challenges soon.
Walking with my soul brother, Adam, yesterday, we discussed whether the personal resilience available in meditation practice might have political importance. If you could change just one variable in how human beings get along, what would it be? I think I might choose resilience.
When I left for the retreat two weeks ago, my daily spiritual practice had dwindled down to nothing. I felt okay, generally, and that became an excuse I would use not to put in any extra energy towards deepening and stabilizing my okayness through practice.
As I rebuild my home practice from the ground up, incorporating what I learned on the retreat, I’m feeling like I owe my practice an apology. All it has ever done is give to me, but in my resistance and reactions, I’ve repeatedly constructed stories about it that blamed it for my difficulties.
To stop sitting for one day, I never needed an excuse more complicated than, “You know what? I don’t want to sit today.” But to remain stopped, I needed something stronger — something like, “Meditation practice is hurting me.”
It’s amazing how elaborate my negative stories about meditation got. I clearly needed to convince myself I was doing the right thing — like, in a moral sense — by choosing to stop sitting. At its peak, the story was that sitting meditation came from a different religion than mine, and it wasn’t good to mix two religions together because… reasons.
Part of the story of this retreat, which I am in the process of writing, was how I unwound that story and rediscovered mindfulness meditation as a core Jewish spiritual practice. That rediscovery helped quiet my storytelling mind and reduce my resistance, but I’m finding that my reunion with my practice is even deeper than this new story. It’s beneath the layer of religion and identity. Meditating happens as close to my heart as thinking or feeling or knowing. It’s part of me, and I’m sorry for spurning it.
From the publisher's feed