How do you prosecute a murder trial more than nine years after the crime? Are there witnesses still alive? Have their memories faded? Do they still want to be involved? Where are they now living, and how do we find them?
What if people agree with you that the accused committed the murders, but say with confidence, you will never prove it. Too much time has passed, and people have moved on. Just let it go.
Besides, the defendant is a doctor, an emergency room one at that, and the nurses love him. He is successful, has rebuilt his life since the death of his family, says he is totally innocent and alleges he was almost killed himself by the intruders into his home that night.
The only people who want to pursue this are on a vendetta of their own. The mother and grandmother, Mildred, is filled with rage and guilt. The stepfather, Freddy, well, that is a whole other story.
The remaining CID agents are frustrated because they became obsessed and failed in their efforts to get him.
Besides, Jim, you and Brian, are too young, too inexperienced, and he has great lawyers on his side.
Jim, it will not be pretty. It is a circumstantial evidence case with no clear motive.
What was it a former U.S. Attorney once wrote to the Justice Department in Washington, D.C., when he declined to pursue the case? He thought he was guilty, but in his estimation, there was only a 30% chance of conviction. He had other things to do such as train new Assistant U. S. Attorneys.
What makes you want to do this? Why would you?
There is only one reason, because after reviewing all the evidence we had, looking at all the pictures, lab reports, reading all the transcripts of everything every prior witness had said about the case, we came to the one conclusion that overcame it all, in our minds.
It was simple...we believed we were right. He was, in our minds, Guilty as Sin.