Welcome to Guilty Pleasures, the show where we put your prepubescent ass to bed so we can make out with our boyfriend and watch bad horror movies.  

This month, it was Stephanie's turn to pick the theme, and she decided to honor a staple of the genre and celebrate National Babysitter's Day (May 13). 

In honor of the occasion, we asked our adoring fans to choose a film for us to stay up late and drink lush lemonades with. You had to choose between the 2013 anthology horror film that first introduced Terrifier’s Art the Clown, ALL HALLOWS’ EVE…or the polarizing 2020 Netflix teen horror comedy THE BABYSITTER: KILLER QUEEN, the McG sequel to 2017’s THE BABYSITTER.

So put on your PJs, get tucked in tight, and let us tell you a bedtime story full of camp, carnage, and a killer scream queen. Does "The Babysitter: Killer Queen" deserve to be crowned a winner? Or is it more like a royal mess? And is it really a Guilty Pleasure? Let's find out together! 

THIS MONTH'S THEMED SPIRIT: LUSH LEMONADE

Pour 2 oz of Captain Morgan's original spiced rum (or spiced rum) over 2-3 ice cubes. Add one bottle of Mike's Hard Lemonade (or non-alcoholic lemonade equivalent). Stir gently and serve.

...

FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL TO VOTE FOR NEXT MONTH'S FILM:

Our Instagram handles are: Morbidly Beautiful @morbidlybeautifulhorror | Stephanie @srgreenhaw | Jack @jack_wells_author | Kelly @kellyemintzer

Follow Morbidly Beautiful on Twitter @xmorbidbeautyx or on Facebook.