Composers Datebook

Hanslick and Thomson, critics at large


Listen Later

Today we take the unusual step of honoring that frequent bane of composers, the music critic. Specifically, Eduard Hanslick, born on this date in Prague, in 1825. He’s remembered today as the arch-conservative 19th century critic who once said an uncut performance of Wagner’s “Tristan und Isolde” would be, quote, “a kind of murder committed upon singers and listeners alike.”
Wagner had his revenge in “Die Meistersinger,” where the Philistine critic Beckmesser is a thinly-disguised parody of Hanslick. Reviewing “Die Meistersinger,” Hanslick wrote that in that opera’s Overture “all the opera’s themes are dumped consecutively into a chromatic flood and finally tossed about in a kind of tonal typhoon.”
A famous and equally quotable 20th century music critic was the late Virgil Thomson, who once defined a music critic as a person “who seldom kisses, but always tells.” In his years as chief music critic of the New York Herald Tribune, his barbs were often as sharp as Hanslick’s. He called Gershwin’s “Porgy and Bess” “fake folklore,” with “fidgety accompaniments.”
Like all music critics, Virgil Thomson called some right — and others wrong. Unlike most critics, though, Thomson was a composer himself — so, in addition to his witty reviews, there’s his genial music to enjoy as well, such as this brass suite titled “Family Portrait.”
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Composers DatebookBy American Public Media

  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7

4.7

176 ratings


More shows like Composers Datebook

View all
The New Yorker Radio Hour by WNYC Studios and The New Yorker

The New Yorker Radio Hour

6,760 Listeners

Wait Wait... Don't Tell Me! by NPR

Wait Wait... Don't Tell Me!

38,802 Listeners

Marketplace by Marketplace

Marketplace

8,786 Listeners

On the Media by WNYC Studios

On the Media

9,223 Listeners

Democracy Now! Audio by Democracy Now!

Democracy Now! Audio

5,778 Listeners

Marketplace Morning Report by Marketplace

Marketplace Morning Report

930 Listeners

Marketplace All-in-One by Marketplace

Marketplace All-in-One

1,392 Listeners

Marketplace Tech by Marketplace

Marketplace Tech

1,287 Listeners

NPR Music by NPR

NPR Music

3,153 Listeners

Sound Opinions by Sound Opinions

Sound Opinions

1,973 Listeners

Piano Puzzler by American Public Media

Piano Puzzler

523 Listeners

New Classical Tracks with Julie Amacher by American Public Media

New Classical Tracks with Julie Amacher

183 Listeners

Brains On! Science podcast for kids by Brains On Universe

Brains On! Science podcast for kids

13,770 Listeners

The Splendid Table: Conversations & Recipes For Curious Cooks & Eaters by American Public Media

The Splendid Table: Conversations & Recipes For Curious Cooks & Eaters

3,080 Listeners

YourClassical Daily Download by American Public Media

YourClassical Daily Download

248 Listeners

In The Dark by The New Yorker

In The Dark

28,115 Listeners

The Nation Podcasts by The Nation Magazine

The Nation Podcasts

432 Listeners

Make Me Smart by Marketplace

Make Me Smart

5,467 Listeners

Sticky Notes: The Classical Music Podcast by Joshua Weilerstein

Sticky Notes: The Classical Music Podcast

2,195 Listeners

Smash Boom Best: A funny, smart debate show for kids and family by Brains On Universe

Smash Boom Best: A funny, smart debate show for kids and family

14,146 Listeners

Forever Ago by Brains On Universe

Forever Ago

6,418 Listeners

Aria Code by WQXR & The Metropolitan Opera

Aria Code

2,509 Listeners

Home Cooking by Samin Nosrat & Hrishikesh Hirway

Home Cooking

4,839 Listeners

Lexicon Valley by Lexicon Valley

Lexicon Valley

576 Listeners

Classical Music Happy Hour by WNYC, WQXR

Classical Music Happy Hour

243 Listeners