On this episode of High Proof Ashes, we’re putting two heavy hitters head-to-head in a true side-by-side showdown: Shortbarrel Cigar Batch 2024 vs Shortbarrel Cigar Batch 2025.
Shortbarrel’s Cigar Batch releases are built specifically to stand up to bold, full-flavored cigars. These blends are crafted at higher proof and designed with deeper oak structure, richer caramelization, and amplified spice so they don’t disappear when paired with a robust smoke.
Shortbarrel Cigar Batch 2024 leans into intensity. Expect a nose packed with cinnamon stick, toasted oak, and dark caramel. On the palate, it brings forward baking spice, black pepper, roasted nuts, and dense vanilla sweetness. The finish carries a long, warming oak backbone that lingers — a classic “cigar batch” profile meant to punch through heavier ring gauges and Maduro wrappers.
Shortbarrel Cigar Batch 2025 shows evolution. Still bold, still proof-forward, but slightly more refined. The nose moves into deeper brown sugar, subtle dark fruit, and richer barrel char. The palate balances sweetness and spice more evenly, with layers of toffee, nutmeg, light leather, and a smoother oak integration. The finish feels rounder and more composed, suggesting either subtle blend adjustments or improved barrel selection.
We talk proof, structure, how each year handles spice vs sweetness, and most importantly — which batch actually performs better with a cigar in hand.
And speaking of cigars, we’re keeping it budget-friendly this week with the Oliva Serie G. Featuring an African Cameroon wrapper over Nicaraguan binder and filler, the Serie G is known for its approachable medium body and classic profile. Expect notes of cedar, coffee, light earth, and subtle pepper — a clean, dependable smoke that won’t wreck your wallet. It’s a great test case to see how premium, cigar-focused bourbons perform against a value-driven but well-made cigar.
Can the 2024’s bold spice dominate?
Does the 2025’s refinement give it the edge?
And how does a budget classic like the Serie G stack up in a premium pour pairing?
Pour one, light one, and let’s find out.