St. Alphonsus parishioner Mary Stall, part of the first class of women admitted to the University of Notre Dame, shares the story of her return to the Catholic Church as an adult. Hear Mary's story of faith, the silent retreat that inspired her return and how she continues to grow in holiness today.

In a world filled with distractions and uncertainties, the journey of faith can often be complex and deeply personal. In this episode of Holy Banter, Father Tyler Kreipke shares how a Zionsville Methodist kid became a Catholic priest in the Congregation of Holy Cross—through invitation, prayer, and the slow draw of grace. From engineering and Notre Dame to seminary and ministry in Portland, Oregon, he reflects on listening for God’s call, the power of community, and the hope of Romans 8.

Kim Marks shares her deeply personal journey of faith—from growing up Catholic to encountering God in a more intimate, life-changing way through daily Mass, Scripture, the Eucharist, and surrender. Kim reflects on motherhood, suffering, trust, and courage, including walking with her daughter through anorexia, and how God continues to meet her in both the ordinary and the profound. A beautiful conversation about docility, hope, and letting God lead.

In this special episode of Holy Banter, we reflect with gratitude on our journey, with co-host Annie Sweeney sharing her final moments on the podcast. The conversation reflects on the friendships and God moments that have shaped Holy Banter. As we head into the new year, Christina joyfully s

Holy Banter will return with a new episode on January 1, 2026.

Matt and Colleen Deryckere share the heartbreaking story of their firstborn son Ryan, whose short life changed everything. From an emergency delivery and time in the NICU at Riley, to planning a funeral no parent imagines, they talk honestly about anger, sorrow, and the slow work of healing. Along the way, they share how Ryan’s baptism, a late–night visit from a priest, and the love of their community opened the door to Colleen’s conversion, renewed faith, and a family mission of remembrance and hope.

Fresh from hours of silence, Annie and Christina talk with Fr. Huemmer about discerning God’s voice, the beauty of Ignatian spirituality, and how retreats shape a deeper life of prayer. He reflects on his vocation story, the movements of the heart, and why moments of stillness can lead us closer to Christ.

Three longtime friends from St. Alphonsus—Penny Edmondson, Carol Pata, and Barbara Carpentier—sit down with Christina and Annie to share how faith and friendship have shaped their lives. From Bible study to daily Mass routines, pilgrimage bracelets to bereavement ministry, these “Soul Sisters” reveal how laughter, service, and total trust in God sustain them through joy and hardship. A warm, funny, and tender conversation about living faith out loud.

In this heartfelt episode of Holy Banter, Abby and Dexter share a moving story of faith, honest communication, joyful engagement, and the profound reality of love after loss.

Abby reflects on how her late husband Kyle continues to shape her understanding of marriage, while Dexter embraces their new beginning with grace and steadfast commitment. Together, they remind us that one love doesn’t replace another — it generously expands.

Join Christina and Annie for a tender and inspiring conversation with Abby and Dexter as they explore the sacred work of preparing for a lifetime together.

From their Youngstown courtship to a lifetime of serving others, these loving grandparents show how small, steady practices—prayer, presence, and humor—carry a marriage. Soft laughs, simple wisdom, and a gentle nudge to trust God’s plan.

In this episode, Fr. Matthew Kalu shares his remarkable journey from rural Nigeria to parish life in Indiana. He reflects on his upbringing during the Nigerian Civil War, the influence of Irish missionaries, and the communal culture that shaped his faith. Fr. Matthew discusses the challenges and blessings of ministering in a new country, the importance of catechists in passing on the faith, and the beauty of hospitality across cultures. With humor, joy, and gratitude, he reveals how the universality of the Church connects us all—from village compounds in Nigeria to Coffee and Donuts in Zionsville.