Erik and Jack record together in person for the first time, from the McCall Library studio. This week's rundown:
Access alert: Recent rainstorms have caused blowouts across the Frank Church, including damage to the Flying B airstrip runway (closed to the public, though commercial air operators are still getting in with a shortened strip) and a major landslide on Highway 21 west of Banner Summit that ITD says could take a week or more to clear — recommend alternate routes for McCall/Cascade-to-Stanley or Boise-to-Stanley travel, and Montana routes for Main Salmon shuttles (with a reminder to review IOGA's DOT compliance guide before crossing state lines).
FWS critical habitat exclusion rule: A new final rule (effective August 20) changes how Fish and Wildlife weighs economic/other costs against conservation benefits when excluding land from critical habitat designations under ESA Section 4(b)(2). Permittees are now explicitly named parties who can submit "credible information" on economic impact, agencies must give more weight to on-the-ground data, and exclusion becomes closer to mandatory once the cost-benefit analysis favors it. Applies only prospectively, only to FWS (not NOAA Fisheries/anadromous species), and could cut both ways for outfitters — helpful for pushing back on overly broad designations, but also opens the door for mining/logging interests to make similar arguments.
Grizzly bear rule follow-up: More detail on the tiered state-management-authority proposal (comment period open through August 17). Doesn't delist the bear, doesn't authorize hunting, and doesn't touch experimental populations (Bitterroot, Cascades). Biggest potential outfitter impact: provisions on incidental take related to predator trapping, which could eventually ease restrictions on wolf/predator trapping in grizzly habitat — though any real change is likely a long way off.
IDL fire budget: Idaho Department of Lands has already spent $20M of its fire budget, with about $17M left for the rest of the summer. If funds run dry, IDL will lean on a "deficiency warrant" (essentially a government credit card) rather than stop fighting fires. A forest fire protection tax increase was discussed but not enacted — yet.
Hatchery study: A major IDFG/Oregon/Washington fish biologist study finds the anadromous hatchery system fundamentally can't deliver the adult fish returns needed to support a sport fishery — smolt production would need to increase 300–1200%, and even then, most programs likely couldn't support a minimal recreational fishery. Erik shares a striking figure from a Fish & Wildlife contact: proposed capital investment to boost production pencils out to roughly $5,000 per additional adult fish returned. The takeaway: the bottleneck is the hydrosystem, not the hatcheries.
Community note: Jack will be in Lewiston (Lewis-Clark State College, 8/3) and Clarkston (Red Line Golf Club, 8/5) with Idaho Rivers United discussing their new lower Snake dam economic impact report.
Interview: Jack sits down with Justin Meuse of The Wilderness Society to unpack the Congressional Review Act (CRA) and its unprecedented use against BLM/Forest Service land use plans — including how the CRA works, why resource management plans were never historically submitted to Congress as "rules," what "substantially the same" means for replacement plans, the pending Cascadia Wildlands v. Burgum lawsuit in Oregon challenging RMP validity, and what a legislative fix might look like. Directly relevant to any outfitter operating under a BLM or Forest Service permit tied to an RMP or forest plan.