IDEAS IN MOTION

IDEAS IN MOTION

By Dr S A Hamed HosseiniEducation
Download on the App Store

IDEAS IN MOTION episodes

  • Unpacking the Food System True Value

    This is an episode designed to help students in SOCA3780 (Leading Social Change) with their first assignment. The primary focus of the podcast is to guide students on how best to write Part C of Assignment 1, while also touching upon the foundational concepts of Part B

    19 min
  • Rethinking Value Unpacking Capitalism's Distorted Logic and Pathways to Liberation

    This episode helps students in SOCA3780 to prepare their answers to Part B of Assignment 1.


    Here is a description for the episode to go with it on Spotify:

    Leading Social Change Unpacked: Mastering Assignment 1, Part B – True Value vs. Fetish Value

    Welcome to 'Leading Social Change Unpacked', your essential guide for SOCA3780! In this episode, we tackle Assignment 1, Part B: 'True Value vs. Fetish Value: Theoretical Foundations and Implications'. We'll help you build a strong conceptual base by unravelling the core questions for this crucial section.

    Why is value a central concept in this framework? We explain how value is not fixed but is historically shaped, socially contested, and politically important. It's essential for linking critique with transformation.

    Next, we delve into why it's vital to differentiate between true value and fetish value. This dual structure allows for a deeper social analysis, distinguishing between what sustains life and what serves capital. We define true value as that which is advantageous for the survival, self-fulfilment, and liberation of more-than-human organised life, rooted in commoning, achieved through consensual and collaborative means. This contrasts sharply with fetish value, which is an alienated, perverted, and distorted version of true value that capital captures through decommonisation, even without market transactions like unpaid reproductive labour or ecological appropriation.

    We then explore the four distinct sources, or causes, of value, drawing on the Aristotelian framework:

    • Creativity (Efficient Cause): The collective, life-affirming driving force.
    • Liveability (Material Cause): The real conditions and resources that support life.
    • Conviviality (Formal Cause): The cooperative and relational way things are organised.
    • Alterity (Final Cause): The ultimate purpose of liberation and a better life, constantly adapting.We also touch upon how these sources are systematically perverted under capitalism to generate fetish value.

    Understand why the theory adopts a broad conception of the commons as the fundamental basis for true value, highlighting how commoning regenerates true value against capital's extractive logic.

    Finally, we discuss how true value and fetish value are dialectically intertwined in practice, necessitating their theorisation together within a single integrated framework to account for both domination and emancipation. Tune in to refine your understanding and confidently approach Part B!

    20 min
  • Redefining Value to Navigate Our Poly-Crisis World (Summary of the first three Sessions)

    This episode distills the first three weeks of SOCA3780: Leading Social Change into the core arguments of the Commonist Value Theory (CVT). The course frames today’s interconnected “perma-poly-crisis”—climate collapse, inequality, democratic erosion, care breakdowns—as not malfunctions, but defining features of capitalism, rooted in the “unholy trinity” of capitality, coloniality, and modernity. At the heart of the problem is capitalism as a value regime that inverts life-affirming “true value” into abstract, measurable, and profit-driven “fetish value,” shaping what counts as worthwhile in healthcare, education, climate policy, art, and justice.

    CVT proposes an integrated normative-analytical approach: analytical theories diagnose capitalism’s systemic logics but risk normalizing them; normative visions inspire alternatives but risk vagueness or co-option. Together, they provide a transformative critique that links what is with what ought to be, exposing how capital de-commonizes life-generating processes and pointing to strategies for reclaiming them.

    Drawing on a reworked Aristotelian framework, CVT identifies four “commoning causes” of true value—creativity (efficient cause), liveability (material cause), conviviality (formal cause), and alterity (final cause)—and examines how each is distorted under capitalism. Building “beyond Marx, with Marx,” CVT expands value theory to include ecological dynamics, more-than-human agency, non-productive creative work, and diverse forms of inequality.

    Through examples such as the academic publishing industry, the course illustrates how capitalist appropriation erodes true value, how resistance movements emerge, and how they can be co-opted. The challenge is to evolve resistance into structural transformation, replacing fetish value with commons-based, cooperative, and life-affirming systems.

    23 min
  • Bridging What Is and What Ought To Be

    This episode focuses on Part A of Assignment 1 in SOCA3780, which lays the foundation for the entire conceptual analysis. Part A examines why integrating analytical and normative theories of value is essential for a critical engagement with capitalism. Analytical theories excel at diagnosing systemic problems and showing how capitalism generates crises and inequalities; however, without a normative basis, they risk normalizing the status quo. Normative theories articulate what should be valued and imagine alternative futures, yet without analyzing the structures of power that resist or co-opt change, they can remain vague or idealistic. Integrating both perspectives creates a holistic, praxis-oriented critique that links what is with what ought to be, revealing how true value is undermined by capitalist “fetish value.” This approach is central to the commonist value theory and provides the conceptual groundwork for the analysis developed in Part B.

    14 min
  • The Yugoslav Self-Management Experiment from the Commonist Value Theory Lens

    The Yugoslav self-management experiment, while an innovative attempt to democratize production and foster worker participation, likely remained within the operational logic of capital to a significant degree due to its market orientation and interaction with the state. From the Commonist Value Theory's perspective (developed by Hosseini (2022, 2023) and Hosseini and Gills (2024), especially the book Capital Redefined), this means that despite fostering some aspects of "true value" production, it would have been continually susceptible to the processes of decommonization, leading to the persistent generation of fetish value and the "annihilation of any other form of social existence" that truly challenged capital's supremacy.

    20 min
  • What capitalism is and how far it has changed: A conversational overview of Chapter 2 of Jim Stanford's Book Economics for Everyone

    What capitalism is and how far it has changed: A conversational overview of Chapter 2 of Jim Stanford's Book, Economics for Everyone

    According to Stanford, while capitalism may change its "look" with technological and sectoral shifts, its "core features of capitalism are still very much visible." The fundamental tenets of profit-seeking private production and wage labour remain, as do "incredible inequality and an inherent conflict of interest, between the people who own successful companies, and the rest of us."


    16 min
  • On the Urgency of (Re-)Integrating with the Radical

    This episode provides an overview of the short essay written by S.A. Hamed Hosseini for Global Dialogue, published by the International Sociological Association.

    The essay argues that radical transformations are essential to prevent civilizational collapse, particularly in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, which exposed the unsustainability of the "old normal." The author attributes the impending crisis to five interconnected "Cs": Capital, Carbon (extractivism), Compulsive economic growth, Coloniality, and Corruptive politics. Simply addressing one aspect, such as decarbonization, is deemed insufficient; instead, a holistic approach encompassing De-capitalisation, De-growth, Decolonisation, and Deep democratisation of social institutions (the "5Ds") is advocated.

    The text calls for activist academics to co-create knowledge with grassroots movements, leveraging social informatics to foster a transition towards post-5Cs eco-civilizations.

    15 min

About IDEAS IN MOTION

From the publisher's feed

Podcasting personal ideas and speeches as an expert in global social studies, from a commonist point of view. Most episodes are produced out of my extra-teaching and extra-research projects.

More shows like IDEAS IN MOTION

Tarot for the Wild Soul with Lindsay Mack by Lindsay Mack, founder of Tarot for the Wild Soul

Tarot for the Wild Soul with Lindsay Mack

2,880 Listeners