In this episode (and the full essay), we dive into the complicated dance between trust and loyalty in the workplace — a relationship that has shaped American work culture for decades, and a relationship that has unraveled just as quickly.
Leaders often want loyalty before they offer trust.Employees often want trust before they can offer loyalty.And somewhere in the middle, both sides wait for the other to go first.
In this reflection, we explore:
• Trust begets loyalty — and loyalty begets trust
It’s not a linear process; it’s a loop. But because leaders hold the positional power, the first move toward trust is almost always theirs to make.
• Why the old model is broken
“Loyalty first” used to be rewarded with stability and longevity.Today? Younger workers see AI replacing jobs, employers monitoring screens, and return-to-office mandates that imply distrust — and leaders still wonder why loyalty feels scarce.
• The modern trust deficit
Surveillance software, shifting policies, layoffs, and unclear expectations have eroded the baseline of trust that prior generations depended on. Employees aren’t less loyal — the conditions are less trustworthy.
• Leaders can rebuild trust, but only in small, deliberate moves
We outline practical steps leaders can take to begin closing the gap:
Stop treating every employee like they’re trying to “get away” with something
Ease up on micromanagement (especially for non-hourly workers)
Hand over small but meaningful responsibilities
Talk openly about the relationship between trust and loyalty
Model consistency — because inconsistency is where trust goes to die
• Trust-building doesn’t require grand gestures
Sometimes it starts with one policy relaxed, one assumption removed, or one project handed over with real autonomy.
Key takeaway:Both sides want the same thing — a workplace built on mutual respect, psychological safety, and a belief in one another. Trust starts with the person who has the most power to give it, and grows from there. Loyalty shows up once trust feels safe.
Get full access to I'm Just Getting Started at anthonydonovan.substack.com/subscribe