
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Due to the size of this chapter this is part 2 of the eleventh chapter “Happiness” (starting with subchapter 11.9 “Happiness and Ethics” to the end of Chapter 11) from the book:
Buddhadhamma: The Laws Of Nature And Their Benefits To Life
by Bhikkhu P. A. Payutto (Somdet Phra Buddhaghosacariya)
Published by Buddhadhamma Foundation
Copyright © Buddhadhamma Foundation 2021
Translated by Robin Philip Moore
Editor: Bhikkhu Kovilo, typesetting: Bhikkhu Gambhīro
Download this e-book in PDF, EPUB and MOBI formats at the following address: https://buddhadhamma.github.io
This is a gift not for sale / to be sold. I just read it and claim zero copyright. Please support https://www.buddhadhammafoundation.com
Integrating Presence is made with Jetpack Podcast. Full show notes and every episode at https://integratingpresence.com/
[Note: Wendy’s audio improves significantly after four minutes]
In this forty-third installment of the ongoing live series with Wendy Nash, we continue our inquiry into meditation practice both on and off the cushion this time with the massive topic of non-harm. Our last Q and A on the five ethical training precepts took some interesting turns. This time we look at what those five are mostly based on: non-harming. This is big and basic yet foundational for meditation practice, wisdom and everyday life with massive range for our inner worlds, the outer world and beyond
(Ai more or less puts this talk thus:) Non-harming is explored as the foundational principle underlying Buddhist ethical precepts, meditation practice, and daily life: how harm manifests internally (self-blame, hurt feelings, “spikiness”) and externally (difficult relationships, power dynamics, manipulation, political rhetoric), emphasizing self-responsibility, honest self-reflection, and skillful communication over blame.
Key themes include:
The tone is personal, reflective, and conversational, blending everyday examples with Buddhist wisdom.
Some resources for a few things mentioned:
Mahayana traditions often emphasize the Bodhisattva Precepts (from the Brahma Net Sutra), which include the Three Pure Precepts plus sets of major and minor vows focused on benefiting all beings.
Lojong is a Tibetan Mahayana practice with 59 slogans (organized into 7 points) by Atisha and Chekawa Yeshe Dorje. It focuses on transforming adversity into the path of awakening, compassion, and reducing self-centeredness.
*There’s naturally an ongoing open call for meditation (related) questions for the (roughly) monthly “Meditation Q & A” either by the various social media means listed; integratingpresence[at]protonmail.com or just showing to type/ask live.*
Regular, current and past visitors to Integrating Presence may recall the monthly series “Ask Us Anything” I did with Denny K Miu from August 2020 until January 2022 — partially including and continuing on with Lydia Grace as co-host for awhile until March 2022.
For a few months thereafter I did various Insight Timer live events exploring potential new directions and/or a continuation of the Ask Us Anything format while weaving in other related teachings to these events.
Then, after chats with meditation coach Wendy Nash, it became clear to start a new collaboration similar to “Ask Us Anything” simply and clearly called “Meditation Q & A” especially due to the original intent of the Ask Us Anything’s being “discussions about meditation and related topics.”
Past chats with Wendy:
Unedited transcript via YouTube:
Full Raw Verbatim Transcript (with timestamps removed via ai):
Hey homelessness, welcome. This is Josh, integrating presence Wendy Nash. What’s going on today?
Well, I’m here on Gubby Gubby country in Queensland in culture. Josh, you’re I think in Colorado at the moment.
No, I’m back from Colorado. Back in Missouri. So, yes, it’s a little confusing. I didn’t change the thing on my website that had mountain time, which is in Colorado. So, I was confused on how long I was going to be there, but back here in Missouri. And so, today
Yeah, today we’ve we’re doing I just might as well just jump right in here.
Um, and it looks like another platform is working at this time. So, I’m just I just started that. So, this is our 43rd installment of our ongoing live series with Wendy Nash here and we we’re going to continue our inquiry into meditation practice both on and off the cushion.
This time with the massive topic of nonharm.
The last Q&A we did was on the uh five ethical training precepts took it took some interesting turns. This time we’ll look at those uh what those five are mostly based on which is nonharming.
This is big and basic yet foundational for meditation practice wisdom and everyday life with a massive range for our inner worlds, the outer world and beyond. So where do we start with this one?
Well, actually, you know how I’ve got this thing at the moment where I’m talking about hurt and ache? Yes. You can hear in my chair.
Oh, no.
Yes. So, this morning I was in my meditation thinking about what because I love um when I’m meditating to think why is it in that situation it doesn’t bother me but in that situation it does.
I like the compare and contrast model because like what is the difference there? And so I think about hurt. Why when do I feel hurt? And I realized this morning because I I kind of get into the blame game. Talk about nonharm. Haha.
Not. So um and what I realized is that I feel hurt. I mean I blame people when I feel hurt. When I feel hurt, it’s because I actually am somehow believing that what they’re saying is true.
I know that’s a bit controversial, but when I feel completely like, well, that has nothing to do with me. They’re just a bit nuts. Then I go, okay. But there is a part of me that realizes that maybe I’m not all squid clean and, you know, all the rest. And I realized that there was a part of me that actually um I was a bit spiky still like I knew I used to be but I it still sits there and I can feel it in some of the way that I’ve interacted with people and and I just got and some comments on Facebook you know you can get there pretty pretty quick and so I was just sorry about mentioning that social media account.
Um, so I was just um reflecting on how the only way to step into that space is well, this is the way that I do it anyway, which is to ask myself in meditation, what needs to be known here? So, I’ve got an identity. I’m hurt. what’s what else is here in the picture?
You know, what am I not seeing about this? And I just went, “Wow, I’m actually quite spiky. Well, you know, I’m not always my best self. What can I say?” But instead of trying to excuse, well, everybody’s not, you know, their best self all the time. I thought, well, I am actually sometimes not my best self. And maybe I agree with them that there is a part of me that doesn’t that sort of deserves to be hurt. Now I’m not being all, you know, you deserve to be treated badly or anything like that. I’m certainly not advocating in that space, but just to recognize that sometimes I can be not my, you know, I’m not being my best self. as well.
Well, that’s this is really I mean this is the nitty-gritty of everyday life.
And before I jump into my response here, um I think we had this last time that it’s it’s just a little bit muddy on the audio, but not too bad. It’s still it’s still um it’s still okay otherwise. Um so sorry to to detract from that, but it’s it’s all good. I will set I will change my u audio settings. I’m just going to go to this venerable’s response that I love surrounding the well first off I will say that that’s my tendency too and see I’m even one of blaming the fact that I’m blaming so that’s my tendency too to go to someone else and say oh it’s on them not me right and then I even want to blame like my my parents or whoever my upbringing and external circumstances for me to be blaming. And so to me, this this speaks to self- responsibility. But the the the way this one venerable put it, um, when someone says something about me, there’s basically two main options. Either we learn something about ourselves and what they’re actually saying has some validity, or we learn about them, what kind of person they are, right? And a lot of times I find what someone says has a lot to do about actually what’s been done to them. And so they’re they’re saying the same thing. But but sometimes it’s totally legitimate and it is about me and it’s a completely valid point. Now you know um then then we come to discernment. That’s why meditation is so in reflection and contemplation is so great because then I can take that in and say okay is there anything to this? like you’re saying from what I remember is basically, you know, like yeah, where is there anything to that? And what do I need to do about it? You know, I was I being a little bit harsh. I like the word spiky. That’s good. You know, like um and yeah, did my words cause harm? And even though I might not have meant that um at least that’s what I tell myself. Was there actually something deeper going on where I wanted to have some kind of harm and I just wasn’t conscious or um maybe I just wasn’t aware of that and I don’t want that to happen. So then I want that feedback if it’s valid and legitimate and helpful to then inform how I go forward because at the root of this like we I mentioned at the beginning harm is kind of the harm and non-harming is the the core of ethical practice. And not to get too political here, but you know, apparently there’s a war going on. And war is big business in America, you know, and there’s all kinds of rhetoric on why it’s okay to harm, how one is in the right to do it, what kind of stories and narratives and imperatives and just, you know, even religious um righteousness because my God said it’s we’re justified in killing, you know, and all manner of craziness. I would just or just ridiculousness about why it’s okay to harm and that’s a radical statement but uh in today’s society but but so be it you know yeah I just going back to your first statement you know venerable who said either it’s about them or it’s about you and I would like to say actually who says it’s binary either or you know these things relationships are dependent arising so there’s nothing to say that both of us aren’t sitting there being hurt and there’s a particular instance, a particular person and M Reed is here on the scene. Hi Josh. Hi Wendy. So good to be here on this topic. Love to have you here. Maybe is there something that you would like to share now? You’re a little bit behind just because of the way the recordings go, but um you’ll catch up quick. Welcome. We put it put your question in now while we’re on this topic and then we’ll come back to you.
But there’s one particular person who I find quite there’s two people in my life. One is in my family and one is in my professional world who are both quite difficult characters and both of them play the power game. Now, I know a lot of powerful people because I deal with politicians and stuff like that, but it’s really interesting when people feel like very quickly threatened by me. Now, I don’t like to think of myself as being threatening, you know, like I’m what 55 kilo woman and I’m 165 cm tall. So I don’t know what that is in the old numbers but um but you know not physically threatening but what I’ve realized is that threat comes in many forms and we have identities about mirror mirror on the wall who’s the somethingest of us all and so I do feel that these two people that I know one is very threatened by the fact that um they want to be the both of them want to be the center of attention actually they want to both of them be the leaders in this space and I’m just doing my thing and I just want to do what I do and I’m happy to collaborate but both of those are solo players and want to be the one who claims the glory they want to be the one who who’s got that But that’s because in their own world they too have wounds and hurts.
But that doesn’t mean to say that when they kind of cut me off or say something mean to me, I don’t say something mean back just in my frustration, in my own hurt.
And so I think it’s like this pinball machine of like bing bing bing bing bing bing bing where you’re ricocheting around your own hurts. So I I often think of Shanti Deva. I don’t know if you’ve read much of Shanti Deva, but I do like this example of the stick, you know, was blaming someone for their bad behavior is like blaming the stick for hitting me, you know, like you can’t. So Emmery says here, “Yeah, I can do harm and not know I do harm. So what is the best approach to this?” Well, so I don’t know if you noticed, but at the beginning, Emmery, I said my approach is when I’m meditating to ask myself, what needs to be known here? Just sort of sit in the middle of this unpleasant feeling because this particular kind of thing where everything gets quite still and I’m going, h, okay, I’m in the zone. What needs to be known here? And I just keep repeating that. And often I’ll put in um things like uh what’s the theme common to all these thoughts or what’s the emotion common to all these thoughts and I find that very helpful. So that’s me.
What about you Josh? What do you say is um what’s the best approach? Well there’s there’s a lot here. Yeah.
Let me let me pick up on uh what you said. Yes. And it’s not as simple as the we either learn something about the other person or we learn something about ourselves. A lot of times that’s particularly helpful if I can’t figure out, oh, is that them or is that me? Is what they’re saying actually about me or what they’re saying is actually shows me where they’re at and what’s been done to them when there’s some kind of confusion or just taking these extra perspectives.
Yeah, it’s not as simple as a binary thing. That’s for sure. I want to ask Wendy before I get to the the question here is did did you ever ask them d I’m curious did you ever ask them directly if if the the people you say that um they they they what was the language you use that they think that you’re um harming them or yeah do did you ever ask them directly or did you just kind of assume that they think that you’re hurtful towards them do you know what I mean or how do you how how did you know how did you find out that how did you come to that assessment.
Well, one is somebody he’s one of my local he’s my local counselor and he’s blocked me from his Facebook page. He doesn’t email anymore. Yeah. And um now you know and I I had to kind of write to him and just go, “Yeah, you can’t actually behave like that.” Like he he came up behind and put his hand on me and he’s a bit sleazy and creepy and stuff. And I had to write to him and just go, “No, you can’t do that.” It’s actually a power play. It’s a status power play. So, um, yeah. And the other person, that’s a more complicated relationship to do with other stuff in both of our personal lives. It’s a family situation. So, it it starts from a long long time ago in the galaxies of past eons. And yeah.
Oh, okay. Thanks. Good. Thank you. So yes, well here’s here’s how awesome Wendy’s advice is is really good too. So the introspection and contemplating on it and asking the questions but and the other external ones for me are just sometimes it’s embarrassing and sometimes I don’t have the courage to do it but I just say oh is you know if I’m getting something intuitively from them like oh did is is that I mean did you just asking for feedback basically you know how did that land for you or um I I it seems like you’re upset are are are you really upset and was it has something to do with me. But usually a lot of the people that I interact, they have no qualms about telling me right away. You you know, you you I can’t believe you said that to me or you you’re you know, yeah, it’s it’s my fault. It’s so this what we talked about at the beginning is this and I do that too. I do it a lot is blame other people and yeah so it’s it’s a tough one too because sometimes there is something to that where I need to um to say that but other times it’s a vicious cycle then right so one of the ways I like to do uh this but I’m not usually mindful enough to do it is when it just say oh when when I I’m feeling like this right now you know use like describing feeling language and I’m not really good at this you know I have the concept but then putting into practice is another thing you know instead of saying oh you made me feel this way saying oh wow I’m I’m feeling like this right now you know um when I when I hear that I feel this way you know uh and then they say oh oh am I to blame for that and I go usually I go well I don’t know because um so this is the other thing when we when we speak my intentionality is 100% my responsibility when but when I say something I’m only partially responsible for that because otherwise I can’t control how anyone takes my language but I’m still partially responsible. If I was 100% responsible then I should be able to control exactly how they take it. I want you to take what I say in this way and not in this way you know because this is but that’s not how it works. I don’t have that kind of control but there has to be some shared responsibility uh and how it lands for another I feel. So yeah and now we’re just talking about language too. I mean, the most obvious form of hurt is physical violence, I would think. You know, unless someone’s like pleasure center is inverted, and unfortunately, I’ve seen this happening where they they get into things where they they feel that physical pain is actually pleasurable. That’s a whole another ridic um thing. That’s that’s not what we’re talking about here. That’s that’s kind of a pathology, I would say, almost, you know. Um Yeah. So, that’s a that’s another thing.
So, Emmery has said, “Oh, good. So good communication skills and feedback. So there you go. Now just two things. I think there are other channels where people are giving us uh feedback live and comments, but I actually can’t see see those other channels. So do you want to just see?
Sure. I’ll check. I I I want to say in in in the chat it should be all combined now, but maybe it’s not. Okay.
Because just wanted to just find out.
Sure. So I I thought about that, you know, I feel this and you know, it’s been part of our language for quite a while. It’s part of our contemporary practice.
And I’m going to say I don’t like it because I think for some people, you know, like I lived in England for a while and to talk about your feelings is so culturally inappropriate. It’s it’s really and then what I notice is that it makes the other person aware of their emotional stuff and they may not be ready. So if I think about these two people in in my life, professional and personal, neither of them are emotionally available particularly. It’s very interesting because the counselor is very very close to with his wife. I because I see them together around they do stuff together. Um but the other person Yeah. No, not not at all. Just just is very finds that she calls that you’re dumping on me.
So, so I would just I would just flag that one that that means that that person is illequipped to ex to navigate the emotional landscape. What I prefer is what I hear you care about is.
So in this um conversation, what I would say for you is what I hear you care about is treading carefully and kind of owning your own stuff, trying to repair and mend relationships and recognize that you are don’t always do your best, but you try, but it doesn’t always go well. So, that’s what I hear you care about. Now, when I said that, how do you how what’s your internal experience?
Of course, that’s that’s beautiful, Wendy. And of course, that’s way more skillful and adept and applies in more situations, right? that my the the the thing that I’m trying to fumble through only works right when there’s some emotional availability, which is a really good word. Not that I’m always emotionally available either. And my emotional IQ is not where I’d like it to be either. You know, I don’t lead with that. A lot of times it’s a kind of a train skill and I have to drop everything usually and go into that because usually I’m, you know, business, you know, it’s like cross things off the list, get it done. And that’s not the best way to, you know, be in a lot of different relationships. I mean, it’s efficient and it can keep things, you know, uh, in harmony to some degree, but it’s it’s really kind of a surface level business type thing. But you’re you’re right, not everybody’s emotionally available or emotionally equipped to to to to go in that way. But the way that you illustrated there I think is applicable in almost any situ or lots of situations whether the person has any emotional intelligence you know any you know any sensitivity you know emotional availability it it’s a great way to do it not only that but it shows that you’re actually paying attention and you care you know as long the as long as it doesn’t get inverted. There are unfortunately a few people where I’ve found where they use that as a kind of a and I’m not saying you’re doing this because I don’t get that at all. It’s just like an a manipulative thing. So, so you kind of you kind of gather what someone says and then you kind of summarize it in a way that or not you, let’s just say I I summarize it in a way that I want for my agenda and then I kind of try to put words in their mouth where it’s not necessarily untrue, but it’s a leaning and slanting towards what I want rather than deeply honestly caring uh you know about the other uh the other person’s point of view. But again that’s hopefully we won’t have to encounter that too much you know the manipulation of these techniques too because unfortunately they can be reversed and inverted and used you know in the wrong ways too but yeah overall though people I think most people can tell whether the other person’s heart is genuine or not you know so it’s not that big a deal I find so
I mean our topic is non harm today and it’s very interesting so earlier on this year I was in a meeting with a a company and uh well with with one person in a company and in the meeting I was like oh she really got it that was really and I felt and then I left and I was like wow I was so had she just played me like a violin like totally and I lost all respect for her in that moment I had heard very good things about her and I just went yeah you are just something else and I bumped into her another time. And yeah, she’s as shallow as a saucer, you know, and I just thought, yeah, like I I kind of don’t I don’t have any respect for you.
Which means that the way that you behaved had harm because I’m not going to lose respect for somebody who I see is working with non nonharm. You know, that’s just somebody who is performing that. And you know, I do like the Lo Jong slogans. Do you know much about the I know I knew I know a few of these and I’ve heard them read off before. They’re beautiful trainings. Yeah. Please um share with those with us. And then I want to see how you view these type of people in these I find them really fascinating uh part of practice to and how to view and respond to these type of people that you’re talking about you know that’s it’s it’s a really fascinating um um you know thinking about that person I just feel um you know there is a saying you cannot be lied to unless you want to believe the lie.
So that’s always worth thinking, ah, you know, how could you betray me? How could you lie to me? Actually, you were a a co-articipant in that lie. There’s a saying, let those who want to be fooled be fooled. Something like that, you know. Yeah, exactly.
Um, yeah. So, I just feel like I was complicit in thinking she understood me as opposed to being able to see through her cuz I wanted I was like, “Oh, you know, she’s she’s whatever. She’s invited me to the meeting. This is amazing.” And then it turned out, yeah, no, this is just a tickbox exercise.
So, so how do I navigate that? You can hear the hurt in that experience. You can hear the sense of mistrust. You can hear the contempt. and derision and scorn and so and the defensiveness and so I think I just have to recognize that you know still plenty of material to work with and and I just I you know there’s such a deep yearning in me from my childhood that I want to be liked and I thought she liked me and then I realized Oh no, she wasn’t my friend. She didn’t want to play with me. She was just playing a game.
Yeah. And for me, my response usually is I get infuriated. That really the dishonesty is something that just absolutely infuriates me and I have to I have to deal with that because part of it is a protective mechanism, right? And and I kind of laugh at these things because to to keep from crying in some sense, you know, because it’s just the the the range of behavior and it almost seems like the the character I don’t want to speak for because I’ve never met this woman, but what I’m thinking of is is different interactions I’ve in past.
And then if you were to try to express that honestly to some people, it it does it doesn’t do anything. you know, it’s just like they almost get off on that they’re kind of superior and that they’re, you know, uh, in a position that they are and they can do what they want and pretend otherwise, you know.
And I think it’s said in this in the Buddhist scriptures and it really resonates with me. If someone shows no sense of remorse for telling lies, there is no amount of like harm that they can do, you know, because if they don’t really think there’s anything wrong with it, then they can do just about anything and think it’s okay, you know, and so is super dangerous in a sense. You know what I mean? And and some people just don’t know, you know, but there is psychopathy or psych, yeah, that’s the right word, right? And sociopathy. And so I’m not saying that’s a full-blown thing, but like like what do we do? And the big thing is I um I if I lash out or get upset, they just it just seems they feed on that, right? And it will just perpetuate. So there needs to be other strategies because that is um there’s a famous line the damapata that uh uh nonharm or harm is never overcome with harm. Only with nonharm is is harm overcome. this is an ancient eternal law or something like this, right? Because it it and Dr. Martin Luther King said something similar too, but it is so to me uh when when something comes harmful at me um and it’s just kind of verbal, then there has to be a strength and a courage and a patience to take that initial hit because usually I will just lash out and return the same energy and then it comes back and it perpetuates and it just makes things work at worse and it escalates, it snowballs. So I almost have to not that I need to be a martyr or anything but if I want something different to happen I need to do so some something different has to happen. So one of the things is taking that initial hit being uncomfortable. Oh this is unpleasant. This hurts. I know that it’ll only be there for a moment but that is the way forward that I want to be happy or in the long run not right because usually it’s just tit for tat. I’ll just get back at them and then I will overcome them and I’ll be right and then I’ll win. But no, the other person is in pain that they still that doesn’t they’re oh yeah, you’re right. Let’s all be friends now, you know. Oh, thanks for speaking so horribly to me. Now we’re just No, it doesn’t usually there’s kind of immity still in the heart. So something has to be different. Okay, that’s enough.
So about uh 13 years ago um I was in a job and my line manager she resigned or I left whatever it was. No, she resigned and I gave her a hug and I said something and because she’s English and she had actually no idea that I had actually said really something patronizing and condescending and I had and I didn’t know I had said it, but I I I said it and it just didn’t reverberate with her. And so it just landed back to me and I went, “Wow, okay, I can see why people don’t like me because I’m just going,”Wow, I’m not really not a pleasant person here.” And so I think that so my goal with people who are like that is if you if you feel tortured by their experience, you either react or you feel succumbed. I’ll put it that way. They have won either way. But what if through our own practice and our own experience of clarity and awake, you know, like owning more and more basically it gets to the point where it just passes through a bit like I did with this uh boss and actually they just get it back to themselves when they start to see who they are and and they may become enraged with me but I haven’t done anything except do nothing. So they kind of can’t accept experience their own uh thing. So I do think it so I have some friends with psychopathic traits and what I notice about them and what I notice about myself when I get into very power oriented systems is there is a sense of paranoia that emerges and I have the feeling that when somebody becomes paranoid when they start to feel paranoid about and I’m not talking about schizophrenia or anything like that I’m just sort of talking about um this sense of they’re out to at me or you know like they they’re attacking me or whatever. That actually um that is because there is a part of the mind that knows that there is something you should be shameful of but you’re not willing to own it and so it becomes inverted into par into paranoia.
Wow. That’s that’s that’s great. So that it’s so it’s a signaling the saying that something needs to change here. Something’s happening that I’m doing that I’m not seeing that needs to be called to attention and and and owned and admitted. Yeah. Wow. Huh. How’ you go ahead or I I would say the thing because it the psychopathic structures and I don’t want to get too much into it but um because it’s not one where it can turn internally. Paranoia is internalized experience of discomfort of shame that is projected outwards onto other they are going to get me. Someone out there is going to do some me some harm. And it’s actually because their their own egoic structure is unable to experience shame and tolerable to tolerate it and so it just gets twisted into this outwards thing. So you what kind of sh What kind of shame though? I’m interested in what kind of shame do you think?
Well, I guess it’s a little bit like I was saying at the beginning, you know, ah well actually I am not always my best self and I am and I think I would say for that structure it would be power plays and that wouldn’t surprise me then why people who are very into power become more and more paranoid about killing the opponents because because and in fact it feeds onto itself. So then they become more paranoid. So they set it up so they’re more p power oriented and then they become more paranoid and it just you can see how it just sort of spirals.
Well, it is too because to to get in a sense of worldly power a lot of times harm I shouldn’t say a lot of times I’m imagining that some harm has to be done or because for a lot of things in the world if I get something someone else has to miss out on it, right? But that one person that’s missing out on it probably doesn’t want to miss out on it. And so they might want to go into competition to get that thing. So if there is, and there’s different degrees of scarcity. And you know, I’m speaking a little bit abstractly, but those who rise in power, there’s other people that are competing to want to have the same type of power or position that they’re in. And so if that person wants to cling on to that position, then they have to watch their back, right? And if you’re constantly watching your back all the time, you might be in fear or that might escalate into paranoia too, right? And so, yeah, these are really the this is really interesting um human behavior we’re we’re talking about here. Yeah. And now I think I the other if if I could jump back to in Reed’s question here too. Another way that I um look to the wise, you know, and wisdom teachings and the wise and teachers to find out if I’m being uh harmful too. And um yeah, and a lot of times I don’t realize it. Another good practice is just to do a blanket forgiveness practice. I find too when I can remember it’s it’s customary in certain monasteries to do that to just say you know if if I’ve done anything knowingly or unknowingly uh please forgive me you know and then also to forgive others and it it’s tough because it doesn’t it can’t really be a superficial thing either and some people have problems with this word forgiveness and that’s understandable too because of different baggage and uh thinking that you know uh anyway it’s complicated and that’s for another time but I think that’s another beautiful practice if it’s done the right way and feel comfortable and it’s the right time to to do it and sincere as well. So yeah, just about the word forgive. Um, so in the European languages, so take that from a from a Christian talked about this too. Yeah, mine it means that I forgo the right to uh for retribution. And so I don’t think that’s what we’re talking about. we’re talking about. I think it’s more like I feel resentful and I and I want to stop feeling resentful. I think it’s got a different twist to it when we talk about it in the contemporary sense.
It does, but that that inter I think it’s there’s some similarity because there’s an internal thing there. At least I’ve noticed when I’ve harbored grudges, there’s an ill will sometimes there. Like I really want to hurt that person because what they did to me even though I won’t act on it, the ill will is still there or maybe I have in the past at least said something nasty, you know, but the type of but so in a way that’s yeah, it’s letting go of in a sense that uh notion to want to that person to have some harm come to them because of what they did to me or whatever. Wrong. So yeah, wrong. I I I interpret. But the thing is that yeah, it’s that it’s it’s hurting me. It’s not hurting them to harbor that ill will, right? Um but and then the other confusion I think it comes around forgiveness is saying if I forgive them, then that says what they did is right or what they did is okay. And that’s not what it means. That’s not what we’re talking about. So if we need a different word to mean that it it’s the burden I’m carrying around that’s not harming them or not making anything I’m the one suffering and and hurting from this not them anymore or you know it’s not has anything to do with them. So and it does not mean what they did is okay you know not at all.
Oh I’m and I’m very partial to holding on to a good grudge. I do like to do it. I’m I’ve noticed how much I love to do it. I wish I didn’t like it so much, but it’s such a great addiction, you know? I’m like, “Oh, I’m the ones who’s so harmed. I’m the one who’s, you know,” and it’s like some bad 1970s program of, you know, and and you see this in the movies all the time, you know, revenge of the soul kind of hero and and there’s a whole lot of American stuff about that. It’s like, oh, victim victimizer is huge, you know, or bully victim. And then the throw the hero in for the other drama part of the triangle here where you know the the bully becomes the victim and the victim becomes the bully and then oh maybe a hero will come and stop all this or maybe I’ll be the hero and save somebody else’s from from the bully and it just it just cycles on and on and on and people know this and they that some people use that to their advantage and fuel this this drama triangle right and take advantage of that because of how uh certain people are, you know, and the habit patterns, the energy and the culture around this stuff.
What I noticed with that counselor is that what he does is he will create drama and then come in and want to be the rescue person. Oh yeah. And then he offends everybody. He’ll just suddenly get up and then he’ll be completely dismissive and rude in a whole lot of ways to a whole lot of people. And I’m going, you’re an elected official. I think your name, you should really be focusing on gaining connections, not not kind of creating enemies. I just, you know, there’s a part of me that goes, I kind of feel really sorry for you because and it’s pity actually. I guess that’s contempt, but there’s just like, man, you’re so clueless.
No, but it’s it’s it’s like once you see um you see the this pattern, how it plays out, it is laughable because like what’s going on here? Can’t people see this and how it’s going and how like it’s like a caricature, right? Like a cartoon almost when you kind of see how the how this thing plays out. And yeah, I mean it my it’s so absurd. I I mean that’s why I think that the laughing for me it’s just so absurd. I don’t know really how what am I supposed to do with this, you know? How am I supposed to respond to this? Uh, seriously, in some senses, you know, but but I’m like the the orange hair man on I mean the things that come out of the this I was like I don’t know what to do with that. I just kind of like that’s so absurd. Like what am I supposed to how am I supposed to view that or respond to what am I supposed to do with that? It’s what I you know there was there’s a federal a federal politician I was listening to.
So we were at a conference and so there’s a television. We don’t normally have a television. So, it’s like, oh, that’s a television. Let’s go for the channel which has the most provocative makes the most provocative statements. We happened to tune into this federal politician ranting with this like appalling journalist and and we were sitting there and and I and I put the timer on and I went, “Okay, how long can we last?” And I got I couldn’t make it to three minutes. But um and this see this politician, he’d been around for a long long time. Mr. Australian politician, are I sitting there kind of going, I actually don’t even know what you’re saying. It’s not even like what you’re saying is just really nasty and, you know, and hurtful, but I’m just going I don’t think I heard one coherent sentence in that. And the journalist is this particularly unpleasant character and he just goes exactly and and I think he’s all he’s he’s just doing it to incite hatred in the audience.
So that’s that’s harm. You know, there’s a lot of harm in there, but there’s something about this banding together that makes people feel that they’re on the right side.
And but the problem is it becomes more and more infighting. I’ve been looking at messaging for this. You know, I’ve got this not for profofit for transport and I’m going how do we talk about stuff? And what’s very interesting is to look in at um Schwarz’s values. And there’s the self-trcendent stuff which is all about communitarian positive stuff. And then there’s the self-enhancement which is money, power, that stuff. Ex. And one is implicit. This is what we all want. We all want good community. And the other one is explicit which is more about me versus you.
And what I what I have noticed is that when you have political parties that are more me me and less communitarian, what happens with that is that um and I don’t mean the inclusive stuff because a lot of the inclusive stuff is really alienating and irritating but but if you have community goals then that more people will sort of stick into that space for sure. Um but what happens with the self-enhancement goals is the more you talk about money and power it increases your selfishness and so you start off being a mob and then slowly it sort of kind of that you start off going well us against them and then the the us becomes smaller and smaller and then it becomes me against you and it just becomes increasingly increasingly kind of um separ separatist I don’t know what the word And for all the good things that sports do, I guess I think they they lent to that though, you know, they lent to that. And you know, going uh so this is really important that some spiritual circles there’s a lot of new age distortions, but one of the dichotoies that are sometimes helpful although I think it’s still off is service to self or service to others, you know, and what what are we doing here? Are we am I feeding me only me? You know, there’s that’s a difference between taking uh self- responsibility, making sure I’m in a good place, and then I can help others. That’s different than than it’s all about me and my clan and nobody else. And we’ll go into competition and fighting. No, it’s u as my my girlfriend says, the the highest um first of many for the highest good of the many, you know. So, this is um yeah, so that we can we can help each other uh when when we’re a good place to do so. Especially now going back to the politician, what I kept thinking is do you know about neurallingistic programming? Uh and I I was wondering if they they use that too and about this notion you point out a really interesting thing too about how they they band people together sometimes out of outrage and you know all kinds of different things. But then what interesting ends up happening is then you get the us versus them but then you get more division inside and so you have infighting as well. And so it’s divide and conquer. So those on top then they can s they can rule and control those who are divided and fighting amongst each other too. And I also want to um say since it is a meditation Q&A uh on a personal level um if I’ve harmed somebody that’s going to be one of the first things that comes up when I sit in silence you know and that was the first few years of my practice uh waking up to the fact of how much harm I have done how much harm had been done to me and not to fall into the victim again but it sometimes it that’s it didn’t even realize that all this stuff is going on and so that’s compass I mean um yeah self-compassion but also forgiveness was really helpful forgiving myself that was huge being able to do that and then u forgiving others and asking for forgiveness too uh for what I had totally forgotten about or didn’t see the full extent of so it’s it’s uh self-nowledge is rarely good news as they say but as that clears out take self- responsibility but then it becomes more and more sensitized I think so what what I used to be able to kind of get away with and not suffer like consequence or whatever. Now it’s become more and more subtle. So where even slighter things that I wouldn’t even probably have noticed before the blowback is more and that’s very noticeable uh especially if you sit down in silence and not keeping precepts you know find it comes back fairly quick these days.
And I also wanted to remind you about long j help me out with the pronunciation this Tibetan training if you want to go into some of those too. I think. Yeah, Lojang. Thank you. Easy for me to say.
Well, I’ll just pull them up here on the side because I think that’s So, one some of them that I really like um some I one of them is don’t act with a twist. So, I think that’s really clear. You don’t that doesn’t need any explaining.
Um and I the other one I like is of the two witnesses, trust the principal one. And that has two meanings as far as I’m aware. And one of them is only you know when you’re kidding yourself and only you know what is right for you. So they’re my sort of so that that one is my thing and the other one is um or what is it? I’ll I’ll let me just pull up a list.
Sure. And while you’re saying don’t act with a twist. This is yeah definitely guilt and guilty I don’t know is the right word but alter I think of ulterior motives here like I’m saying one thing but the way I’m presenting it is not completely I I have something else behind it or in context that I’m not explicitly stating that I that I find is too harsh and that I don’t want to say directly but uh but but it’s there and I I I want to kind of get to that thing behind what I’m saying instead of just directly saying that because it’s either too harsh or it will um be explosive or cause too much. So, it’s it’s like this subtle thing in the background saying one thing but not uh but having something else right there like a Trojan horse almost, you know what I mean? And yeah, speaking in circles or not speaking as directly or having hidden agendas, hidden motives sometimes, you know, and it’s not always necessarily for a bad thing. It’s just that uh sometimes it’s easier to do do it that way. It seems like, you know, which but it’s it’s slimy. It’s it’s really is slimy you. Yeah. So, I was at this transport conference and I bumped into a colleague and she’s such a snake and I and she’s sort of inserting herself with the sort of big hero honchos, you know, all this sort of stuff and she’s at the head table with the big politicians and and it just and then I mentioned, “Oh, look, here’s some data. You might be interested for your thing.” And she replied, “Oh, yeah. And shall I give you a call afterwards?” And I said, “Well, just have a look at it and see what you think.” Oh, and so shall I give you a call afterwards? Well, why don’t you just find out what it is and then just sort of see how you can use that information in your strategy? And then she didn’t say, and so shall I give you a call because it’s like, yeah, don’t call me actually. And she said it another time, you know, it’s all about the relationships. And I’m thinking, yeah, it is all about this game is all about the relationships. And you it’s about integrity. You have you can’t have a relationship with somebody where you’re liked one minute for what you uh for your power cuz the minute you lose the power you actually nobody will have anything to do with you. Um yeah.
So I’ve got a number of the um uh slogans here.
Cool. Let me let me ask real quick. So I’m a little bit confused. So she actually What was she meaning by uh can I call you afterwards? What what was what was the deal with repeating that? Did she really think uh like I I’m I’m still not following that for some reason.
It’s a way of her kind So what she does is she inserts herself into relationships to kind of claim territory. It doesn’t feel like so if I said to you, “Oh, look, have a look at this information.” and you said, “Oh, can I give you a call afterwards?” I’d be like, “That would be amazing. Sure. Well, let’s let’s have a chat about it.” But it felt like this was her trying to insert herself into a place in the relationship.
So, so, so yeah, exact. So, you know that that that smmy feeling that you get where you go, someone’s not straight with you. I’m going, you’re not being you’re not straight. And I also know through on the grapevine it’s like so this watch for this person. She didn’t really care about what you were having to say. She just wanted to make sure that she had um Yeah. She wasn’t put the she wasn’t putting the emphasis where where you wanted it to be right. You know what I mean? She was wanting to have it in what kind of power play she could have with what you were trying to um bring to attention.
So that’s what it seems like. We both very early on like three years ago um we we both gave feedback to this council document and I and she said oh you know and can I is it okay if I can have a look at your your submission and I was at the time I was like yeah sure and I never heard and I asked her oh you know can I have yours and then that never appeared and so there’s that’s one that’s kind of one of those flags where people say I want your information so I can use it for me but or you know they kind of whatever.
Well, especially when you asked for it to you asked to to have be reciprocated and she basically lied or forgot about it or whatever but or maybe I didn’t ask but and I just expected that. So the thing about it is it’s about reciprocity and I think relationships nonharm fundamentally is about reciprocal relationships which are based on integrity, kindness and connection and safety and um uh and sort of sharing this relationship together and all that we do and we have working together in the space. So, it has a collaborative feel to it.
And I think the minute you end up with this feeling of like uh it doesn’t feel reciprocated, I think that’s where you start to get this harm experience because it just feels something feels off and you don’t know what but it suddenly feels a little bit onesided or did I did I miss did am I reading this you know did I did I miss what am I because you can feel it’s not only what people do say. I think what we notice is it’s like what people don’t say, what they don’t offer. And I think that is where it’s the more subtle version of harm can come about. And this is what they say with child abuse or abuse. It’s not the acts of violence which necessarily cause the problem. I mean, that does obviously cause problems and the unpredictability of it, but it’s in some ways harder when people are neglected. Children are neglected. It’s harder to prove you don’t have the bruises and the broken bones. So, it’s sort of a different thing.
Yeah, neglect is a huge core wound that many of us have along with, you know, abuse. And I’m trying to think of these other core wounds, but yeah, neglect is, yeah, it’s it’s not as noticeable. And and I just the other comment when you talked about watching the politicians on TV. Yeah. Three minutes. That’s that’s great. I don’t know if I could have made it that much. Usually I start yelling at the TV. Not yell but commenting on the TV and annoying people around me because it’s just it it is too much uh a lot of times you know. Okay.
Uh so uh did you find these did you find these okay any of them make sense worth worth reading or in this context or not and you know the go ahead so so what I’ve done is I’ve said sum sum up the fi the low jung slogans into five slogans just so for sake of brevity here everything can become the path don’t wait for perfect conditions joy conflict failure illness success and uncertainty are all opportunities to train your mind. So train all mis transform all mishaps into the path of awakening. Yes.
To turn your attention inward first instead of blaming, judging or trying to change others. Examine your own reactions and take responsibility for your part. drive all blames into one as opposed to drive all blames into Juan which is when one perma children speaks about that. Why is everybody blaming Juan? It’s like yeah, you know, nice part. Um yeah, put others at the center.
Cultivate genuine concern for other people’s well-being. Practice generosity, empathy, and the willingness to bear discomfort for the benefit of others. be grateful to everyone and practice sending and taking. So that’s um tongland practice where you are um you are breathing in their pain and you you’re taking on their pain and you are sending out the antidote ease in some way. So that’s that. And then four, hold your views lightly. Your stories about yourself, other people and the world are not reality. Stay curious. Be willing to let go of certainty. Regard all things as dreams. And five, keep practicing, especially when it’s hard.
Mind training isn’t something you do only when you’re calm or inspired. The difficult moments are the practice. If you can practice even when distracted, you are well trained. So the five these five capture the spirit of low jung remarkably well. Use everything. Start with yourself. Care for others. Hold your stories lightly. Keep practicing.
So the Lojong Lojong slogans aren’t primarily about becoming calmer or happier. It’s about becoming less self-centered and more useful. Peace of mind is seen as a consequence of the shift, not the goal itself.
These are really beautiful and um admirable practices for the most part.
And this is Mahayana. The only thing I want to point out and boy I have a hard time of letting go of those holding those those views you know still working on that one for sure but I do want to point out uh in the Mahayana one of the things I caution against is is um they have one of the precepts is even though which is really weird they say know when to hold the precepts and when to break them but that’s really no different than ordinary worldling I think you know because um but but what what I want to say is I think they have one that you’re not supposed to speak um you’re not supposed to speak badly of others or something like this. You’re not supposed to, you know, ever. And so wait a second. I mean I see that where the wisdom is in that. But one thing is if someone is actually abusing someone else, they need to be called out. You know, that needs to be that needs to be called out for what it is. A spade a spade. you can’t just uh not speak unless I I guess there are skillful ways to do it in another way with without you know speaking ill of one someone or blaming someone. The other thing is I just want to caution some people that have like an inferiority complex probably not Wendy and I but like to take on uh this martyrhood you know or having some kind of okay I’m going to be the world’s savior and just take on everybody’s crap. That’s that’s not what they’re saying. But I just wanted to say that, you know, if it’s if it’s interpreted in the wrong way and not done done in the way that it’s supposed to, I think with this, I think it could fall into martyr or u messiahood kind of thing, too. And that’s not what these are pointing to. You know what I mean?
So, we have to be careful, especially some personality types that are quick to blame themselves for everything and little me and you know, I can never do anything right and I’m always wrong. You know, this type of thing. So we got to be careful if that that personality type comes into play here I find. But for a lot of us that’s you know that’s not the case and these are these are beautiful.
So um so don’t malign others don’t talk about injured limbs. So don’t dwell on or publicize others faults or weaknesses which I’m not very good at because I get really hurt by that. Don’t ponder others. Don’t obsess over other people’s shortcomings. Don’t seek others pain as the limbs of your own happiness.
So that’s great. Those are way more nuanced than I’ve heard them put before.
Actually, those are those the way to put it that is I think is more helpful than the other translations I’ve heard of those. Yeah.
Um there is one which he says don’t be a martyr. Let me just um so there is don’t act with a twist. Don’t abandon any hope of fruition. Don’t seek praise or gain. Don’t expect applause.
Um uh but in the in those long gen uh the long you just read too. Yeah.
So so it’s something like you know don’t make an identity out of self-sacrifice. I think that’s what you’re sort of saying. It doesn’t say that but that is that is somewhere in there because that’s acting with a twist. That’s not being sincere for sure. Oh, we’re at time, Josh.
We are. This just flew by again. So, yeah, this was great. This was this was great. There’s so much I mean, non harm is is so massive and it uh can boil down kind of all of our actions. Are they, you know, are they being harmful or not in in a sense? Are, you know, it’s not as black and white as that. Uh there’s a lot of nuance too and there’s a lot of subtleties, but it’s this is this is the core of a lot of ethics and I’m glad we got to talk a little bit about it. So I’ve just I was just looking up know when to break the sleep precepts. Um maybe that’s a Zen thing. Maybe that’s a Zen thing.
There is a Mahayana principle that can look like that from the outside.
So, it’s not know when to bro break break the precepts. It’s don’t make the rules for the goal. Don’t mistake the rules for the goal. Let compassion guide the rules, not the other way around.
See, that’s a better reframing than know when to keep the preexpects and when to break them. That’s kind of a more straightforward Zen approach to saying the same thing you did, which is way more nuanced. I find it maybe helpful. Maybe not as direct and clear, but Yeah.
And but it Yeah. Well, actually we’ve come to the end. We’re over time.
All right, we got to go. Everybody be well and keep keep your nonharm hand strong.
Yeah. And you know, just be ordinary, whatever that is. All right.
Bye, everybody.
Integrating Presence is made with Jetpack Podcast. Full show notes and every episode at https://integratingpresence.com/
My apologies for the disjointedness while my internet connection kept dropping and dropping during the live recording
In this forty-second installment of the ongoing live series with Wendy Nash, we continue our inquiry into meditation practice both on and off the cushion intending to turn attention to our ethical foundation of the five precepts: training to refrain from harming; dishonesty/untruthfulness; taking/receiving what’s not given (thieving); sexual (energy) misconduct; and intoxicants while actually ending up more addressing earnestness, hurt, conditioning from upbringing, misunderstandings around attachment, needs in relationships and more.
In our last Q and A Wendy mentioned that “a few years ago, I was really earnest. I’ve always been a bit of a goody-two-shoes type of person. I can get pretty earnest and pretty serious about being good. Like, ‘We’ve got to be good, folks. We can’t just be out having fun — we’ve got to be good.'”
Wendy’s statement kind of raised an eyebrow for me. In this Q and A on the five precepts and ethics we unpack this comment of Wendy’s along with exploring: directly seeing and knowing the purpose and benefits of precepts; “may I” vs. “shoulds” and expectations; excuses / justifications; how belonging, self-deception, and trust / (self-)confidence factor in; exploring (unconscious) distortions around views like: “only this is what’s best (for me)” and/or “this and this needs to happen (first) and (to) be a certain way for me and things to be OK” and of course how all this relates to meditation practice
A selection from the blog post Faith that Straightens the Mind:
Confidence is required for the establishment of virtue. Without confidence and trust, one does not firmly resolve to act rightly.
If you cannot trust your own mind to remain upright in moral conduct, then uprightness will never be sustained. If you do not trust yourself to refrain from false speech, your speech will remain crooked. If you do not trust yourself to refrain from taking what is not given, bodily actions will continue to incline in that direction. If one does not establish firm restraint over lust, sexual misconduct will recur again and again. If you keep giving excuses to break precepts, the mind will always justify its own crookedness. If you do not trust in the benefits of the precepts, transgressions will keep recurring.
Moreover, if one continues to deceive oneself—pretending that the precepts are being maintained when they are not—then the cycle of transgression continues without interruption.
One must have confidence in one’s own ability to uphold the precepts; without that trust, their observance will never be firmly established. And if one lacks that confidence, the mind can remain crooked.
*There’s naturally an ongoing open call for meditation (related) questions for the (roughly) monthly “Meditation Q & A” either by the various social media means listed; integratingpresence[at]protonmail.com or just showing to type/ask live.*
Regular, current and past visitors to Integrating Presence may recall the monthly series “Ask Us Anything” I did with Denny K Miu from August 2020 until January 2022 — partially including and continuing on with Lydia Grace as co-host for awhile until March 2022.
For a few months thereafter I did various Insight Timer live events exploring potential new directions and/or a continuation of the Ask Us Anything format while weaving in other related teachings to these events.
Then, after chats with meditation coach Wendy Nash, it became clear to start a new collaboration similar to “Ask Us Anything” simply and clearly called “Meditation Q & A” especially due to the original intent of the Ask Us Anything’s being “discussions about meditation and related topics.”
Past chats with Wendy:
Ai assisted somewhat cleaned up transcript:
Hey, wholeness. Welcome.
This is Josh of Integrating Presence and today I’m not yet joined by Wendy Nash. I apologize. I had the times a little bit off several times now. So, we originally changed the first time and then the second time I accidentally put a half an hour later. So, I’ll give Wendy a little bit of time. to get here.
She might have been under the impression too that it was a little bit later.
So the this one is called the five ethical precepts.
So I’ll just go ahead and read the description I have here.
In this 42nd installment on the ongoing series live series with Wendy Nash, we continue our inquiry into meditation practice both on and off the cushion. Turning attention to our ethical foundation of the five precepts. training to refrain from harming, dishonesty, untruthfulness, taking receiving what’s not given, thieving, sexual energy, misconduct, and intoxicants. In our last Q&A, Wendy mentioned that a few years ago, I was really earnest. I’ve always been a bit of a goody two shoes type of person. I can get pretty earnest and pretty serious about being good. Like, we’ve got to be good, folks. We can’t just be out having fun. We’ve got to be good.
Wendy’s statement kind of raised an eyebrow for me. In this Q&A on the five precepts and ethics, we plan to unpack this comment of Wendy’s along with exploring directly seeing and knowing the purpose and benefits of precepts. And here’s Wendy.
Hey, you’re on.
We had a time zone difference. So, I’m very sorry about that. Sorry everybody for being a little bit late.
It It’s okay. And like I I just got done saying first we’ve we changed the original time and then I made a mistake in the in the description putting it at 8:30 instead of 8 central European. So no big deal. So I was right in the middle of reading the the intro and I’ll just back up just a little bit and and won’t reread the five precepts. I’m I’m assuming most people are familiar with those, but we we can maybe get into we’ll get into each individual one.
Anyway, so I I said in our last Oh, by the way, u the the standard formalities here. Sorry. Wendy, what’s going on?
And how’s it going where you’re at today? oh, M. Reed is on the call. Woohoo. Great to see you here again.
Likewise. You’re always fantastic to have. It’s something it means so much, isn’t it? when somebody you know regularly joins us now even though we’re late we dis anything kind of well life so it’s always just such a joy to have Emily here with us what’s going on well I I spoke at a parliamentary inquiry yesterday oh wow and so as a witness you know it’s like I don’t know what you call it in maybe the US but you have some legislation and then you write a submission and then you might get called back if the committee decides to be a witness. So I was a witness and so there’s like the left wing and the right wing on the political spectrum and they’re playing tit for tat through me. It was just like oh wow this is really awful. This is very interesting from a dharma perspective.
4 minutes, 1 second How do you navigate that space? How do you remain loving and kind? And you know, I’ve started to really think about how people are really trapped in their minds and this is where we’re going wrong. It’s like, and we’re all trapped in our minds cuz I was like, whoa. And I was, you know, on my way home, I was just going talk to me about happy chickens to my friend. I just need something, please laugh on me.
And yeah, because I needed I needed to feel like human beings were around me. And I just happened to been to a very very senior politician as I walked out of the building. And I thought, I do not like this man. I know a lot of politicians, so they’re not all like that, but it’s just like and it’s hard to to not hate them or really dislike them. and to see them as human. You know, this is the 5 minutes, 1 second dilemma. This is what we’re working with. So, that’s what’s going on for me.
Josh, a bit more of an answer than perhaps you wanted.
It’s it reminds me of that old Ramdas, this the this spiritual guru who’s no longer with us before he died because of all the the president in America. He had a picture of him on his altar because there was so much hate and he said he loved everything, everybody. I mean, that was his path.
It’s a little bit we don’t have time to go into that now, but I I know what you mean with this this polit. It’s almost like some of them feed on that hatred, you know. It’s more to get attention and power. even it doesn’t matter if it’s bad, you know, just to get all those eyeballs and attention and energy on them, you know, and this will fit perfectly into to to ethical precepts too, you know. So, I I think that’s that’s great. And yes and I would just say the the political process is a little bit different in America. No parliament. And it’s interesting how you were so personally involved in this process. Usually in America it’s it’s not like that in the Congress as far as I know. But maybe for another time.
We’ll see. Well, cool. Okay. I’ll jump back into this. in our last Q&A I’m reading here again. In our last Q&A, Wendy mentioned that a few years ago I was really earnest. I’ve always been a bit of a goodie two shoes type of person. I can get pretty earnest and pretty serious about being good. Like, we’ve got to be good, folks.
Oh, he’s gone. Sorry about that, everybody. I don’t know where he’s gone.
I’m hoping he’ll come back. So, have you ever found yourself being earnest? And do you know what the word means? So, by the word earnest, I see it as that I’m I have this really strong need and desire to be good. And so, I just f because Josh is gone. I’m wondering if it’s me who’s gone. So, can anybody say something so that Emry, can you just say something? Here we are.
There we are. Okay. Was it me who went or you who went? Oh, that’s the other thing. I I don’t know. but my connection on this island has been dropping off. If if it happens again just we’ll it will come back. We just have to be patient. It just takes a few seconds to come back on. So Okay, keep going. So keep going.
All right. and then how belonging, self-deception and trust or self-confidence factor in and exploring unconscious distortions around views like only this is what’s best for me and this and this this and this and this needs to happen first for me to be okay or things need to be a certain way and things for things to be okay and of course how all this relates to meditation practice. So that was a big mouthful there. There’s so much to explore. We could probably dedicate an entire show to each one of these these five precepts of nonharming.
refrain from dishonesty and untruthfulness. refrain from taking what’s not given. not misusing sexual energy. or sexual misconduct and refraining from intoxicants. And I will just say, Wendy, you’re I don’t know if there’s the this your sound is okay, but there was something you did last time that made even more crystal clear. So, I was just wondering about that. Let me change my microphone.
Oh, is that what it is? Okay.
Probably what it is cuz I was running late and I was like, quick, jump on. That’s okay. So, let me just check my settings.
Sure. and why Wendy does that. I will just say start off by saying when it comes to precepts from my own personal experience I did not see the value of these before I it was too late basically and this is a training this is not like a thou shalt not this is a gradual training so it’s really all based on nonharming but we’ll go into that because I have some friends that you know they’re they’re still hunters or you know that people are involved in in waring now I guess.
and so let me throw it back to Wendy here to see Well, can you hear me? Does the sound sound any different? Because I can’t see my microphone. So try it.
It’s okay. Let’s just see. Is that any different?
No, but that’s good enough. windy. I think I’ll I’ll I’ll jump I’ll leave and I’ll come back. Okay. We’re just here like winging it here.
Yes, we are. This is live in real time.
So So Wendy, you’ll come back and with with nonharming.
Okay.
And then we’re here this. All right. I don’t think it’s made any difference.
I don’t know what it is. It’s like your software isn’t picking it up. Yeah, it sounds a little bit better. So, I think this is definitely adequate. The post-prouction usually fixes a lot of or makes it even clearer. So, all right.
Apologize for the technical difficulty or the you know, I guess maybe it’s my perfectionism.
I don’t know. But this is this is this is sufficient.
The only one is Oh, no. There it is.
There it is. Okay. It’s called something else on my thing. That’s why I couldn’t find it. We got there. We got there. Okay, that’s super clear now.
Okay, sorry about that. Sorry about that. So, I think, you know, we’re talking about being earnest. That’s the fundamental thing rather than the precepts because I think if we get caught in the precepts, I think that’s actually where the problem is. If I can be so bold.
Well, tell me what you mean by earnest, too. Let’s let’s give a definition of this.
I think for me, it’s being really serious about being good.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that to me is what it is. I mean in Oscar Wild’s time, the importance of being earnest was actually a reference.
So today we would use the term gay which means homosexual.
So that’s that shift. It’s exactly that same language shift. So instead of saying homosexual, we say gay.
so but what what but with earnest? So what would be the o? So I don’t so the importance of being earnest. So that’s what that was about. So that’s what that the importance of being earnest back in Oscar Wild’s day. That’s what it meant.
And then Oh yeah, I guess. Yeah. So that’s what that meant. Yeah.
But but today well the way I use earnest is that I sort of had I didn’t have a sense of humor. I sort of felt like I had to live tightly within some ethical guideline what was good. And I was always having this argument in my mind on always kind of feeling like hemmed in by the need to be really good to ensure that I was a good Buddhist or a good oh yeah whatever.
But I think it depends on how joyful you are. So joy is very very what do you call it?
antidotal anti antidotally in antidotes earnestness and I I just think so what would be it’s like there’s some element of fun you forget to have fun and it’s all about being serious to have fun like you can’t laugh at yourself or you can’t I don’t know Emmery Reed, you are here on the call. Okay.
Would you describe that as well? I know I’d like to hear yours. Yes.
Yes, please. Let me read this definition of earnest, though. Earnest is a cl meaning as an adjective. It says when used as a descriptive word, earnest implies that someone is showing deep and sincere conviction.
yeah. Resulting from a sincere and intense conviction, not light, playful, or trivial, she made an earnest effort to complete the project.
I think that’s right. But I think that there is this it’s this element of intensity, doing something seriously with or with full force. Yes.
Yes. Yes. And I think if you if you feel like you’re always living within ethical guidelines.
So I thought it was very interesting that you went and you talked about the precepts because I wasn’t talking about the precepts at all when I talked about it.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It just reminded me and I Yeah. But that’s right. And I think that’s the mistake. And I think that would be if I may dare to put it forward on the counter just you know as a flavor. Could it be that you are very earnest because you immediately put the two together whereas I go they’re actually very different and it might be just cuz I’m Australian and and whatever but to me okay how do you describe earnest you know like I said I had to look it up I don’t even know yeah the the seriousness okay so my teacher mentions that we shouldn’t take our suffering so seriously seriously in in a sense and what that means is that there’s nothing super special about the way I suffer right that there’s millions of others that have suffered in the exact same way because a lot of times we want to cling 15 minutes, 1 second on to oh but this is my suffering you know this is my special breed of how bad I’ve got it kind of thing you know what I mean but as far as I think taking the our practice seriously we have to take something seriously ly now ourselves. I mean, yeah, now this is I think this righteousness, you know, being overly righteous about something is is maybe not the way to go, you know, but I think the the danger is if we don’t take anything seriously, then it turns into maybe a type of solopism and then there’s no really incentive to do to really think anything has any consequences. You know, I wonder about the slippery soap. And the reason I’ve come from this is because of my the past way that I used to be in the world, you know. So, I would imagine if I wasn’t the kind of the way I was and the trouble I got into and the crash and burn style that maybe I wouldn’t come out with a little more force towards and in and the in the situation that we seem like with the Epstein things, you know, with with that and all the corruption and things in the world. Yeah. And but I do and at the on the other hand I see your your point of taking it too seriously and not being lighthearted and and playful. I think playfulness is great, you know, and I will I will agree. I’m a little bit kind of stodgy, you know. I’ve got like this Germanic American background and I was raised Lutheran and we sat in church and we didn’t make a peep and you never expressed yourself like individually.
And then living in Denmark, it’s kind of, you know, kind of the same thing where absolutely a little bit, you know, yeah, it it to me it’s refreshing from America though where everybody’s trying to stand out and get attention and have all the eyeballs on them. But yeah, so yeah, we can we can explore this a little bit. So if we want to go more in that direction instead of the actual precepts themselves, my I just don’t want the danger to be that we’re not that they’re disregarding the the value and importance of precepts either.
It’s a practice. I mean, it’s just a way of relating and being in the world that’s for my benefit and happiness. And I noticed that since I’ve started doing these with a little bit more just as a practice that it just seems so obvious to me now. But yeah, I also don’t want to be like on a soapbox preaching to people, you know, I would like to see what people do here. so I’ll throw it back to you before I I launch into something else here.
So I what is it that I am describing? I think you know often when we’re in the dharma centers and we come in and we start what energy would you call that?
Well, there’s so much right there are the people that are this strict. Okay.
But this this ties back to what you started about to begin with that a lot of our experience I find the most is a 18 minutes, 1 second story about reality. The narrative of what’s happening instead of what’s actually happening, right? There’s a story about what’s happening. And if the narrative is there, so people have their own way of framing things and the story they tell about the way things are and the way things should be, you know, and yeah, so that’s I think that’s that’s one big element. And a lot of the work is just actually communicating with people to find out what that is, where they’re at, where I’m at, where we’re at, and what we’re doing here, and how we go about it. I don’t know. Maybe. So, so, so you know, I guess I sort of thought about it because I came to Buddhism like a lot of people and meditation like a lot of people. I was having a bad time in life. Somebody told me I should take it up. So, I did and I loved it. And then I was trying to fit me and kind of who I was into this new persona. I think there’s something in that there. And I so Emry has said know thyself and be tr real true full authentic full authenticity living no emotional attachments of desire etc of being right etc seeing things as they are allows for what’s needed etc not filling a narrative so I think that fills in that but there is this trying to fit myself into it and I I sort of was very I guess a bit self-righteous in there and a bit good and bit try hard and there’s sort of like an a bit intense and it’s like a little bit frozen in the mind and so I found myself feeling like I had to be good in order to feel that I was and I’ve dropped out a little bit here.
Okay, you’re on. You’re still here. Oh, he’s gone. So, Emry Reed, it’s just you and me.
so just to continue with that. So, I went into the meditation centers 20 odd years ago and I tried to fit myself in and then I found myself being very serious about what it meant to fit in.
and I tried to do all the rules and I just realized that I didn’t have a sense of humor anymore. I didn’t feel like life was light.
I just felt there was a certain heaviness and I’ve seen a lot of people and you know there’s this obviously joy is one of the big it’s the four awakening factors and the Dalai Lama and Desmond Tutu they are both really big into joy because I think being earnest in the way that I imagine it has this kind of this is the right way to be and it’s demure and it’s self-eacing in a kind of staltifying kind of way. So that’s what I meant.
Yeah. And and I get that. And by the way, it dropped out again for about 10 15 seconds. So I it got most of it though. And yeah, that’s this is a good thing. So then I would ask Wendy, well, what’s what’s the alternative then? And why I guess why did you feel so like you the the the rules because yes when you’re when you’re actually in a meditation setting you know or a monastery setting there there are rules just like everywhere in life right I mean some there’s a little bit less rules and things like this but so yes and I will agree obviously that they do seem way more confining than what we’re used to in daily life. And I think one of the reasons not to def def necessarily defend, it’s so that everybody there can do an internal practice because then that’s more of what it’s like instead of a like an outward- facing practice where we’re we’re interacting. So then we’re kind of it’s it’s a container so we can go inward and do do inner work. Now, however, I would say at a monastery and depending on which one it is, there’s a little bit more challenging because people are not doing as much meditation and they’re they’re interacting with each other and they’re doing task in lots of different other activities going on and meditation is only a small part of it. So, that’s where it’s it’s real different and yes and and I will agree I’ve seen the same things Winnie was talking about and I’ve felt that in myself as well. So the I guess the way I the way I I address that is okay how maybe how much of this is for the external and how much is it for internal how much of this is a temporary container for training and will that in the long run lead to more welfare and happiness and and and well-being and and we could just say fun, right? and how much is it going to detract from that? You know, so these are all questions. So to to take on a temporary more constraint and stodgginess maybe or seriousness in order to then in the long run then once release from this, you know, so these are all kind of really complicated things. Yeah. or how much will that condition me to then continue that way where it’s not where it actually contributes to what we don’t want, you know? So, yeah. And and how are we holding it all, you know? Are we are we taking the rules are there but do we have to take them up so seriously and so earnestly like you’re saying or can we hold those lightly too and say okay now it makes sense to adhere to this rule hold it tightly or this this one okay this rule doesn’t even apply right now so I don’t even need to be bothered with it so I don’t know there’s it’s such a rich complex dynamic when we when we talk about these things and this is part of the training too. I mean, how can I think we can still have fun and not be too serious if we’re nonharming, you know, with with we’re not stealing. I mean, these are kind of basic things that I don’t think interfere with with with that we don’t have to take so seriously because some of them are really second nature for all of us, you know. and thieving and then also, you know, alcohol intoxicants. That’s that’s a tough one. That’s the one I had the hardest one with. our sexual energy and that’s a kind of a a gray area for a lot of people too. You know, what does that even mean? But yeah, so I threw plenty of stuff out there.
I you know, one of the I don’t know if I said before totally being playful is good. And I think it’s the playfulness that I think is really important. You know, it doesn’t have to be so intense or something. But with regards to addiction, so Josh has popped off there. it’s been a while since I’ve gone to a monastery or a a meditation center.
But what I’ve started to see is that instead of talking about giving up alcohol, cigarettes, drugs for the fifth precept, but instead to talk about phone addiction and device addiction and app addiction. So, and that one I would have to say is much harder because unlike alcohol, cigarettes, drugs, you can put them down and still get on in society.
Whereas actually our phones and devices, you cannot function very well without that. Like it’s a it’s a big thing. And that our seniors are very challenged by the fact because none of them are online.
It is. And again, Wendy, I’m going to switch over. Speaking of devices, I’m going to switch over to a hot spot now because it dropped off. So, I missed your transition from what I said into devices. so I I missed that whole thing.
Precepts and addiction. So, I just going winging it, Josh.
No, this is great. No, this is actually Yeah. So, I think this is it. Yeah. So, I think this is it. When you’re really earnest, it’s like it’s got to work really perfectly.
And when and when you’re more agile and more confident in your dharma, then I think then you can just kind of wing it. And mere says, “Is it a trap?”
Being earnest. The point is I think it is a trap and I think you can think that you’re very Buddhist and and be a good Buddhist.
Yeah. Yeah.
And I think that that’s not being Buddhist because it’s about spontane you you know I find the Dalai Lama tremendously inspiring.
Yeah. you know, it’s so you said the the what were you saying right before Emir’s comment? The it was about addiction to the devices and how we can’t actually live in a connect in our worlds with our families and friends and and people without a device. We can’t go anywhere.
It is. But there was something between that and Reed’s comment. And yeah.
So so this is this is well maybe it’ll come back here but yeah start talking about this because this is this is what Oh no. You you talked about well authenticity and but talk about the devices. Yeah. What what kind of advice do you have? oh no hang on now. I used to give it I used to give advice about devices, but I have long since given up because I’m an addict. Uhhuh.
And I would like not to be, but I think I have such a desperate love to be it’s a desperate yearning to be loved that I’m like somebody might like me and I get a full-on dopamine hit. And I think that’s that’s it. You know, at at its base, addiction is not feeling confident that who I am is is okay. You know, it’s full ego experience.
And but but we do want to feel loved and we want to feel safe and we want to feel like we don’t have to carry everything and we want to feel like we’re able to do things and act on on the things that are important to us.
Yes. And to me, this is again, this is where going inside.
I mean, it’s easier said than than realized. But if the reason I’m looking a lot of times for dopamine hits is because I think that I’m not worthy enough or that I’m not likable and that I need to get that kind of verification, something from outside myself. Now it does seem like maybe a consolation prize that I go inside and say no there is inherent worth and worthiness and likability and it’s not dependent on anyone anything from outside to get that you know now that’s easier said than done and it does feel like if I if that’s only coming from within then that’s some kind of consolation but I I really feel that bring builds up a a foundation and a reservoir so where I’m not so depleted and I’m looking outside of it for for myself. You know, one of the things I found too with this device thing is actually going into a retreat when getting that one of the hardest things I ever did was giving all electronic devices away for a month. I mean absolutely insane how much I was dependent that that I realize that I’m dependent on these for my sense of reality even you know it it’s really eyeopening and yeah it’s a rude awakening really and but it was a really good really good challenging experience that that is very worthwhile because you see the depth of it we don’t really until that kind of absence is totally there 100% don’t really see the depths of how how dependent we are on these things now. Yeah.
Well, we’re we’re made to feel that that that we are dependent. I mean, humans have lived for millennia without devices. I think Josh is about to drop off. you here Josh?
so I think we are, you know, anyway, maybe maybe the answer here isn’t to talk about addiction and the five precepts.
The purpose is to talk about let’s not go into addiction, Josh.
Yes. Let’s not let’s talk about well whatever we were supposed to be talking about.
Yes. And to to go back to your your what you mentioned here and now I’ve got it these well we we did talk about self- belonging right how self- belonging and then self-confidence and trust factor in how we can deceive ourselves too and this notion that I have to have what’s I have to have this to be okay basically things need to be this way before I can be okay Right.
And I have to have things in a certain way before they can be okay. And this is this is the thing that can happen sometime for sure. You’re right.
Like I have to have it this way or it’s not okay. yeah, actually it’s very interesting because a friend of mine was talking about, you know, she’s got this kind of on again, off again thing happening at at a in a relationship and and as you say that, I’m going, “Oh, she needs this relationship to feel that good about herself.” And I keep trying to bring in other ideas and dharma and like not overtly but you know how to think about the mind and she’s so stuck in the way that no but this is how it is and this is what I need to do for me and that doesn’t work for me and this sort of stuff and sorry but I’m a bit orange here with my light.
Okay.
I actually got like a whole lot of orange paint. I’m a little bit red. So, there was a We had a program called The Partridge Family in the 70s.
Yeah. Yeah. I remember. I mean, and Susan Susan Day one one time she actually ate so many carrots that she turned orange and they couldn’t get her rid of it. So, all the other actors in that episode had to make up all their orange. Wow. I didn’t know that was a thing.
There you go. So, but it but it does I think there is this kind of at what point do we ask ourselves you know what do I need to feel whole because I before I met my partner I tried to be single and I was actually really miserable and I tried to not be attached and that was when I was very earnest and I I think I found I think there is something about as a good Buddhist I’m not supposed to yearn for connection and it was also to do with my own family history. So it was like I actually got my family history of what it is to be a good person and shoehorn that into being Buddhist. I shouldn’t depend on anyone. I should be able to do it on my own. I should be independent. as if we’re not, you know, dependent arising doesn’t exist and we’re not all completely embedded in our relationships. It’s completely nuts. But actually I was just deeply hurt by my solitude and loneliness and I couldn’t get out of that because I was sort of frozen.
And I think and and so I think we can take on this Buddhist identity and the med good meditator and we can go through spiritual bypassing and last week I had an insight where you know where you see yourself you see yourself outside yourself and you see yourself and I went to a a work function in the evening and I was I’m going to let you know Josh I was a bit of a Because what happened is that my ego took over the sense of sort of some sort of spirituality clarity thing and I was obnoxious and I gave some poor woman a bit of hell. but it was cuz actually I was really hurt by something that she had done and she and her friends had done. So I was using this mind state for some kind of crazy wisdom excuse.
And I think that when you you use your ego through spirituality, I think you can be like that. And I think that that’s the same with being this serious, earnest kind of Buddhisty person. So that’s all I was wanting to say.
It it’s really wow. It’s so fascinating, you know. I would say I’m coming from a different place where my upbringing there was no kind of okay, this is how you do it to be a good person. There was like I was constantly in trouble acting out. You know, my I didn’t have any role models. The role models I had were not not good to to learn any kind. I didn’t know ethic. I laughed at ethics. I thought this this is completely ridiculous. Why should I be bothered with that? That’s for squares and you know that’s not that’s not anything. So, it came from a more kind of self-destructive place of being to then crashing and burning and saying, “Oh, wait a second. This is not stupid. This is actually, you know, this is how most people actually are when they’re when they’re okay.” And then this actually leads to some well-being, you know. and I didn’t see it before. I I was had no idea that that it actually you you you cause and effect basically, right? The things I was doing. Well, no wonder. So that’s where I’m coming from. So it’s a little bit different. And then now you go into the the crazy wisdom thing. And that’s right. And I think this is why it’s so important for the four brahma viharas, the four like best ways for relate relating to everything basically. And I think those are a great counterbalance to maybe some dryness and roughness of precept training, you know, like being kind to ourselves that we fell down and we got it wrong again. that we we harmed and we didn’t mean to but u so not beating ourselves up or then saying okay I’m done with all this throw I don’t I don’t care I’ll just do whatever I want because it’s too hard or it’s ridiculous it’s it’s too much earnestness or whatever so this is where I think the the brahavar has come in here for relating to ourselves and I I know what you mean we talked about this several times now about this hurt you know and there is a kind of a self-justification when it comes to hurt because that is the kind the hardest thing to do you know and again when I found when I can remember to do so when I’m hurt the Brahma vajara is you know compassion self-compassion right there you know because and it’s for me because did no oh Josh is about to drop off so before as Josh is going to drop off any second now I’ve actually been thinking about duka and that another way of translating duka is feeling hurt or feeling an ache and I think that when we feel hurt and we don’t want to own it because we are distanced from it I think it can come I think we experience it as a kind of a I think that’s where bypassing happens when we really actually just incredibly hurt and we don’t want to own that hurt. And so and the other one is ache. You know, we have heartache and I think that that can also be just another word for duka. I think it’s a more embodied work way of thinking about duka rather than as this abstract idea.
So that would be that. And Emry, I would love your thoughts on this. And I don’t know if I said it last time we spoke, but there you go. I’m hoping Josh is going to be back. Otherwise, it’s just you and me, babe, until the end of the session. So, here’s Josh.
I’m back again. He’s back. We’re almost Sorry about this. Yeah.
What you missed what you missed is that and I don’t know if I talked about it last time but I was talking about hurt and how I’ve sort of started substituting the word duka with the word hurt and ache because both of those have this kind of emotional physical aspect to it.
So instead of using the word duker and I think if we use duka it becomes another bypassy kind of thing. I don’t that’s duker. I don’t do that. But if we I found it really helpful when I start being like I was the other day with those that woman. I was a bit of a and it was actually because I was hurt and I didn’t want to acknowledge that and I had some crazy wisdom thing going on as well. So I think we can get really caught about our idea of what it means to be enlightened because it was one of those enlightening experiences. And the other thing about that experience is that I thought, you know, you can have any level of clarity you like, but if you don’t have compassion with it, if you don’t have the love and joy and spaciousness around it, it’s not worth anything. It really isn’t worth anything. I I don’t care how much.
Oh, not again.
Okay. Back. That that only that only dropped for that only dropped for a second.
They do. Oh, is like and M Reed has gone too.
Oh no. So you’re you’re you’re you’re so right. when this is this is really important and there’s a Lumpour Ajan Samato he was it was a famous time when he said I don’t want a bunch of bloody Buddhists is what he said. So, I think this is a pro not a problem, but it points to a a potential challenge like you’ve been going on about in a good way that I don’t consider myself a Buddhist per se. I I study and practice this, but it’s not a it’s been turned into a religion by the West and ism. But if you look at it from what I understand, it’s just here’s someone that that that was this is what they did and they shared what they did and they said, you know, check it out for yourself. You know, you have to, you know, if it’s helpful, you know, look into it. This is this is what I found. You have to verify it for yourself and you have to find your own way, you know. So that’s what it’s about and it’s the best way of going about that. Best meaning the optimal way and that includes the heart too. So I think that that is it can people that are really hardline Buddhists they can fall into the traps Wendy you’re talking about. So again holding it lightly and eventually all that has to be let go of anyway right the raft of dharma once you’ve crossed them the further shore you have to you don’t carry around that raft that took you there you put it down eventually that will be what happens anyway. So you take up what’s helpful, but don’t hold it too tightly, but also don’t let go of it when right in the middle of when you need it to keep from drowning either. now you also go into relationships, too. And yes, this is where this is where it’s so not so cut and dry, right? Traditionally, are you Yeah, you’re still there. Okay.
You’re Yeah. Yeah. I’m here. I’m here.
The the the attachment, right? They they in Buddhism it’s not like this attachment but then psychology has co-opted this and say you have to have healthy attachment styles you know so it’s like okay yeah whatever I just I just want to talk about healthy attachment styles that is not the same as attachment in Buddhism exactly and this is where language sorry yeah it’s very important you’re right yes absolutely that’s what I’m getting to yeah one Tibetan called it stickiness and attachment is this like it’s stuck and I’m like, you know, you’ve got that bit of sticky tape that’s stuck to your foot or something or a gum or something.
Yeah. And I think stickiness is kind of like clinging, you know, it doesn’t work for me either, but I think stickiness entanglement. Entanglement. Yes.
Yeah. I think it’s totally there in Exactly.
Attachment stars from a psychological sense is to do with the carer and the child. Usually I’m going to say mom, mom and bub.
Yep. and what that means is you you build this relationship of trust that when the bub wants something there is a sense that the mother will respond and and just attends to the child. So the bids for attention are attended to and when that is reliable enough the child gets a sense that I can actually be safe and as the bub then turns into a toddler then the the toddler can wander off go and explore come back and that’s a secure attachment style. So I just wanted to clarify that that is a completely different Absolutely. It’s so important because people start about getting questions in Buddhist circles about attachment and they they it seems to be a lot of confusion between the psychological version of healthy attachment that language and then you know don’t having attachments in in Buddhism which confuses a lot of people because of the similar language but it’s not anywhere close to the same thing we’re talking about. However, now when we go back to relationships about and this ties into needs, right? So in relationships there’s needs, right? So this is, you know, this is lots of fertile ground for work because what one might perceive as a need might another might perceive as you know I don’t know a demand or being too this and that and that right that okay so where where you know where do we how do we help each other meet each other’s needs in 46 minutes, 1 second relationship but also don’t come along with all the other things like it being either a demand or like thinking that if I just get this this certain way that I want it and have to have it, then everything’s going to be okay, which isn’t a long-term thing for success either because eventually there’ll be situations where we won’t get it how we want it, you know, and then how much is a want and how much is a need, you know? How much are we willing to compromise? How much are we not? You know, there’s so many relationships are so rich for practice and experience. you know, how much similarity and harmony is there and how much is not? How much is that as helpful and how much is not? So, yeah. So when we when we talk about relationships it comes you know it comes to needs I think and compromising and then of course it always comes back to right view you know what is the right view in this situation is this going to lead towards more ache pain or what did you call it hurt we did talk about it because you conflated pain and hurt last time I just remember you’re right thank you so this is it’s a key distinction that’s right how much is this going to lead towards hurt and how is going to lead away from hurt, you know.
So, so just about that about needs and wants, demands, and I’ve thought about that for a long time because I was raised with that there’s a difference between need and want. So, you could never want anything.
You had to sure you can.
No, no, no. You couldn’t have anything if you wanted it. That’s just greedy.
You can’t possibly, you know, this is this very English kind of Sure. Sure.
We can’t. And my parents were my mother was born before both my parents were born before the war and you know I was in England and and there was a lot of deprivation in that time. You just couldn’t do you need it or do you want it? This is an important distinction back in the Oh big time. Oh yeah. And so I grew up and I think this is where that where I have inculcated and shoehorned my own childhood need which is I mustn’t want anything and I kind of became this very good person who didn’t want anything and who wouldn’t would be very cautious about buying anything because well it was a want it wasn’t a need and if I bought a pretty skirt well I was vain and all this sort of stuff and so I think there can be an ex sort of a sense of sort of deni it was very interesting a couple of years ago I really got it where I felt like I was denying myself and and I realized that I I I had actually yeah become full of denial because I was actually really hurt and I think denial and it can be very hard and be very subtle. Now Emry has said earnest what is it that you’re looking searching for etc. Best to drop the trap completely and know your why questions etc. And I personally sorry amid I’m going to disagree with you on this one.
I personally dislike why questions because I think it doesn’t lead us anything. It’s like why am I wearing a black jumper? Why is the sky blue? Like we can talk about it but I think it’s better to ask what or how or where something where you can give a sort of a proper answer to. So with regards to the denial question and want and need and what is sort of a bid for a connection with one person feels like a demand for the other for another is I think a process of mindful inquiry of learning the mistakes. So that woman that I met the other day at the professional event, I just went, “Wow, I was a I cannot do that again.” That is I am I cannot do that. I’ll I’ll go You can do it once, but you can’t. Why?
Yeah.
If I bump into her, I would I would have to say, which I might do on Friday morning, by the way, which I Today’s Thursday.
So I I might see her tomorrow morning, and I might have to say, “Woo!” Wow, I was pretty unpleasant. I’m sorry about that. Like, I owe you a big apology. Oh, was it mean of me? So, I think and and then you end up in a repair and and then you you start to build these relationships. But I think it sort of dig Oh, he’s gone. But I think there is something about how we can deny our own hurts, shift that into a language of non-attachment, and we don’t even realize it, which is I think when you get further on, I think it becomes more and more subtle the forms of attachment and hurt.
And I I have yet to come across anyone personally in my circle that I can see close enough or a teacher or something where I go, yeah, they have no attachment.
Yeah. So, I would certainly love to hear you, Emry, you know, whether you have any questions about that. I would love to know that.
So, what else can I share before Josh comes back? oh, it’s just me again. So, I guess what it it highlights that there’s this dynamic question. He’s back. Fantastic. You missed all that.
It’s okay. I didn’t on on the on the the replay. And yeah, I so apologize for this connection. It’s it’s it’s ridiculous. We’ve this has been happening for the last month, but the next show will be back in the United States. So, this is it won’t it won’t be like this. Apologize. so, I don’t know what you do you want to say here, but I want to while I’m back on and interrupting intruding here like they do in England, right?
Well, you mustn’t you know what what you want. You want to intrude.
So what what I think Wendy was me and Wendy what I enreed was getting at is that the intentionality. So that’s what why so what is the intent behind the action you know what is the intent that was driving and you you mentioned it right why you said what you said to to her although a lot of times we’re not fully it’s coming as a at least it seems sometimes it’s it’s a it’s a lashing out at being hurt right it’s it’s a it’s a it’s a reaction to being hurt so we don’t think or at least in my experience I know that I don’t when I when I react I don’t think I don’t I’m not cognizant or aware of what’s driving my act. It’s it’s it’s a reaction because I’m hurt, you know. They hurt me, I’m hurting them, you know. that’s it’s just kind of a almost an inbuilt unconscious self-defense mechanism. And this comes Go ahead. Sure.
Sorry, just about that. So this woman and what happened and it was not intentional on her part to hurt me. So she arrived and she’s in her I don’t know mid20ies or something maybe late 20s something and she sat with her friends not talking to anybody else in the room and when I was a child I was like you have to go I I wanted to hide as well but no you had to go forward and you had to go and talk to everybody and you had to make sure that you you knew who was there and that’s called having good manners and social grace.
Yeah. And so I was kind of in this space and I use that just as an example to kind of go I had no idea that it had touched this deep deep nerve that I had never even noticed that I even had before. So that’s all I wanted to say, Josh.
And this goes back to Im Reed’s statement about knowing oneself because there’s a classic saying that self-nowledge is rarely good news, right? Because that’s right. It is. And that’s why a lot of people don’t want to do this work because it is shocking and quite unpleasant to see our the things that we haven’t seen before about ourselves and our upbringing and our conditioning. And this again, this is why the heart practices are so helpful with that because it is painful to have to see that and know that. However, in the long run, it’s better because then we have a chance. Did it freeze again? I’m I’m here. I’m here. So, just Josh is obviously going to drop off in about a nancond.
So, I was just thinking about that. You know I often think with meditation and this these insights that what it gives today no drugs what they give today they take tomorrow and you can say that with anger what it gives today it takes tomorrow or like my friend who’s going back to this relationship it gives her a sense of fulfillment but it’s going to take tomorrow whereas with meditation I think oh it’s really awful a lot of the time and you see there going oh my friend who I was helping for a a while and she she and I was meeting her every day cuz she was having a really really tough time and she’s going, “Oh, okay. I’m here.” And it’s only recently she told me she hated all of it, but she did it because that thing is like, “Well, it is getting better.” Yeah, but it was just so unpleasant to own and acknowledge and just go.
She just went, I am such a something something something I was going, “Yeah, I know you’re you’re a bit mean with your husband there.
You’re a bit awful with him. Gosh, you know, I I would have walked out on you.” No uncertain terms. I wouldn’t have put up with any of that rubbish, let me tell you. But a husband, you know, and he has he’s got he’s a challenge, too. But he was very loyal and given they have two small children I think kind of admirable in that regard not entirely many many quirks we all we’re all different you know it’s not like we’re any one thing it’s and it’s always changing no self or something I believe there’s a teaching on it yes and I think we we want given the horrible connectivity issues today on my part here we should probably start wrapping wrapping up. And I think yeah, this it really speaks to to to to tie it all back to meditation. This is the container where it happens to have a laboratory to to to look at this stuff and to to face whatever we’re facing in a in a socially acceptable way, in a healing way. And then yes, even when the times are really challenging, when we come out of it and how we feel going forward is way better than if we just pretended it wasn’t there, ignored it, denied it, and it’s going to c catch up with us anyway, you know. So, yeah, have friends on the path. Ha, have have those we can confide in and practice with and teachers and also do like you’re saying the the joy practices, too, whenever that’s available. So those are those are really supportive and it it does yeah there there’s those to feed and the the pleasantness in order to give the incentive to stay with in in my opinion this is what it’s all about you know because yeah I mean what yeah I don’t know I I don’t need to preach to the choir here but yeah this is this is this is our work and it doesn’t have to it doesn’t have always have to slog through and be horrible. either. You know, there’s lots of joy on the path, too, and there’s lots of aha moments and epiphies and and and kind of just spontaneous well-being and it’s gradual for a lot of people too, right?
Yeah.
I think gradual is better than the spontaneous insight because I think it’s more grounded. you get better at cuz I think the only other part that I would add and we’re at time here is that it is about noticing kind of how you experience what it is that you’re doing so that you can learn from it so you can do it once but not twice on that note I’m going to say and thank you very much everybody have a great time until we are here back online Hey, thanks everyone.
Thanks everybody. And yes, speaking of spontaneity, there was a little bit of spontaneity here with all the drops and the the things, but I think we did it well and show some realness on on our parts, I guess. whatever.
If that’s the worst thing that we have to worry about, let me tell you, we don’t have anything to worry about.
Yeah, exactly. Worry is the worst kind of fantasy anyway. Oh, no. All right.
Let’s see if you’re on here.
1:00:09 1 hour, 9 seconds And yeah, how about that for irony of ending? Have you We’re still live. We’re still alive. Yeah, that’s the irony. So 1:00:16 1 hour, 16 seconds we got to really end
Integrating Presence is made with Jetpack Podcast. Full show notes and every episode at https://integratingpresence.com/
In this forty-first installment of the ongoing live series with Wendy Nash, we continue our inquiry into meditation practice both on and off the cushion, turning our attention to the question of peace—especially in a time when conflict is close at hand.
Rather than focusing on politics, we explore some of what can be done practically within practice itself: how peace is cultivated and supported in formal meditation, how it carries into everyday life, and where it tends to wane or destabilize.
Areas of exploration include the conditions that give rise to and sustain peace; how it is revealed or obscured in relationship; the difference between brief glimpses and more stable baselines; the role of awareness; and perhaps a little of how some inquiries can clarify or deepen peace.
0:00 Welcome & Setting the Scene
1:18 Wendy’s Day & Small Incremental Actions
3:21 Episode Theme: Practical Peace & Ease
5:27 Joy as a Responsible Practice
8:46 Awakening Factors & Mudita (Sympathetic Joy)
12:00 Working with Hurt vs Physical Pain
17:18 Feeling Hurt in the Body – Dukkha Embodied
23:23 Distinguishing Hurt from Pain
29:06 What Does Peace Really Mean? (UN Definition & Dignity)
36:41 Baselines of Peace & Conflict Avoidance
43:59 Meditation, Unpleasant Sensations & Capacity
48:30 Real Life Example: The Vape Shop Frustration
55:28 Understanding Root Causes – Trauma & Resources
59:38 Closing Reflections & Wishes for Ease
1:01:44 Final Thoughts & Invitation
Other topics include:
*There’s naturally an ongoing open call for meditation (related) questions for the (roughly) monthly “Meditation Q & A” either by the various social media means listed; integratingpresence[at]protonmail.com or just showing to type/ask live.*
Regular, current and past visitors to Integrating Presence may recall the monthly series “Ask Us Anything” I did with Denny K Miu from August 2020 until January 2022 — partially including and continuing on with Lydia Grace as co-host for awhile until March 2022.
For a few months thereafter I did various Insight Timer live events exploring potential new directions and/or a continuation of the Ask Us Anything format while weaving in other related teachings to these events.
Then, after chats with meditation coach Wendy Nash, it became clear to start a new collaboration similar to “Ask Us Anything” simply and clearly called “Meditation Q & A” especially due to the original intent of the Ask Us Anything’s being “discussions about meditation and related topics.”
Past chats with Wendy:
https://integratingpresence.com/2026/03/12/worship-respect-inspiration-meditation-q-and-a-with-wendy-nash-40/
Mostly unedited transcript using ai to “clean up” by removing timestamps:
. . . and today I’m joined with Wendy Nash. Wendy, what’s going on?
Well, I’m looking at your not background actual real environment. Now, you have to do a kind of a this is not AI. Just saying folks, this is actually the real McCoy. So, I I’m here. I’m here. I I’m here on my I’m just getting an echo here. Sorry about that. I got the YouTube up. So, I got the video up. Um, so I um I’m here on Gummy Gummy Country in Queensland in Kabula and my background is nothing like as exciting as yours is. That’s kind of amazing.
Now, you’re in Crete at some place where there’s a lighthouse at the back.
Yeah. And I thought and also I guess I don’t know if you can hear this in the background, but military jets. Um, I think there’s an American military base here on Crete and this is in Chania. If you see right behind me here, I’ve got the video louder. And uh, that’s a lighthouse, like an old Venetian lighthouse. That’s kind of the main fixture of the town. But Wendy, I’m going to throw it over to you and mute for a second.
Sure.
Well, Josh, I’m very excited. Apart from anything else, I’ve been having a quite a cool day. It was really inspiring. Then I just went so basically, you know, I have my transport thing. So I looked at what there’s an event called the week without driving in October that happens in the US and I’m bringing it up to here. I’ve done it a couple of times and I looked at all the amazing stuff everyone’s doing and I’m going, “Oh man, I can’t do any of that.” And I felt really down in the dumps. And then I just thought, but what can I do? Like I can’t do all that stuff. I don’t have the social media and I don’t have, you know, there is there is nobody really other than me. I mean, that’s not entirely true, but there are it’s pretty thin on the ground. And then I went, well, what can I do? And I thought, I can do this and I can do that and I can do that. And I thought, okay, that’s pretty cool. Actually, if I just got that, that would be amazing. And we had M Reed 1747 on today. Hi Josh. Hi Wendy. Welcome Emry. And hey, how’s it going?
So, you know, Wendy, that’s a really good point because um a lot of times it seems uh we can get discouraged before we do anything and we think that we can’t do anything, but usually there’s a lot of things we can do and we write it off as insignificant like, oh, that’s not good enough. But again, incremental steps, uh drop by drop, we can fill things up. I mean, yes, it could be frustrating that the progress we don’t have access to enough resources. We we know what we want, but we can’t do it. But we there’s usually something that can be possibly done. I mean said this time and time again and uh that uh support and encouragement and trust that what we do and say does make a difference, you know, especially with the intentionality behind it. So today is also our 40th one of these, you know. So let me read the description we have here. We’re going to call we’re calling this one practical 41st.
Oh, it is. Okay. My bad. You’re right. I need to change that in the description.
Oh wow. So numbers and dates aren’t my time. So I’m we’re calling this practical ease. I was wanting to call it practical peace just because of the alliteration, right? PP, but I think ease is more um relatable. So in this 41st installment of the ongoing live series with Whitney Nash, we continue our inquiry into meditation practice both on and off the cushion, turning our attention to the question of peace, especially in a time when conflict is close at hand. Rather than focusing on politics so much, we’ll explore what can be done practically within practice itself. How peace is cultivated and supported in formal meditation, how it carries into everyday life, and where it tends to wane or destabilize.
Areas of exploration here may include the conditions that give rise to and sustain peace, how it is revealed or obscured in relationship, the difference between brief glimpses and more stable baselines of peace and ease, the role of awareness, and how inquiry itself can clarify or deepen peace. So, kind of a lot of fancy words there and descriptions. Um, but the the the main thing today I think is practicality and we we’re we’re told there’s a war going on. I mean uh war sucks. I I don’t think war is ever okay really my personal opinion. Um but like how how does that what relevance does it have in our lives? And if anything, I think it draws our attention to, okay, how peaceful is my life um and those around me and how much at ease am I and how much the opposite and why is that important and what’s how does that work?
Yeah. So, I’m going to be really I’m going to speak to a bit about that. So, a few years ago, I was really really earnest. I’m a very kind of goody two shoes kind of person. By the way, M Reed says, “I can totally relate, Wendy.” I think that was the up and down thing. And uh it’s always great to have M Reed because she’s so supportive and such a lovely person. And at least I assume it’s a woman, but anyway, we’ll just It is as far as I know it is. Yes, I I know. I’m saying the f Reed’s mi Miz Reed’s first name, but I’m pretty sure I know.
Yeah. So, um, you know, I can get pretty earnest and pretty serious about being good. We’ve got to be good, folks. We can’t be like fun. We’ve got to be good. And I just I read this book called Awakening Joy. I realized I was really boring. And so, I I read this book, Awakening Joy, by Jamie Barers. I’m sure you know him. And it says something like page one or two or certainly in the first chapter, what stops you being feeling joyful right now like in daily life? And I just thought I actually feel really guilty for feeling joyful. You know, there’s so much bad stuff that people experience and war, of course, is one of those things. I mean, they it’s like awful. I have a um an acquaintance in Iran and it’s I just said I’m sending you lots of love through one of the social media or email and she said that just made my day. I was she’s so heartbroken by the situation that she just is going just that one good kind word made her day.
Can you imagine what your life is like when that happens? That’s that’s war. That’s what war does. And um and but I thought I I I thought I I felt really guilty cuz there were all these things. And then I thought when I’m when I’m down in the dumps, who do I like to hang out with? And I thought I do not like to hang out with miserable gits. I like people who are negative and naysayers and they should and I like to hang out with people who are joyful and fun and light-hearted and kids and people who just bring this lightness and love. Now, I’m not talking about the positive uh toxic positivity stuff where it’s like be happy no matter what. I’m not talking about any of that. I’m talking about being just like playful and joyful. If if the Dalai Lama and Desmond Tutu do that and they are, you know, really important spiritual leaders in our in our world. I think Desmond Tutu has died. Um, and they are really keen on joy. That’s a big big topic for them. It’s a really important practice and a very needed practice. So, I think it’s really important to bring that um into the picture. So, and I also want to talk about hurt, but before I do that, let’s hear what you have to say.
It is a it’s a really good point. And you know, joy um if we’re doing the traditional Buddhist line here, it’s one of the awakening factors. You know, it’s um it’s also one of the brahmaviharas altruistic joy or sympathetic joy or um vicarious joy. I like vicarious. So I can be happy for someone’s happiness and it help it helps counterbalance and equal out if I’m slogging through really challenging time and it’s really really hard and I have to do lots and lots of compassion and kindness to myself. It is a counterbalance to that because it that can get too kind of weighty and o you know so the joy lifts up and it’s not Yeah, that’s the thing Winnie makes such a good point. Some pe we we misinterpret as like uh overindulgent right um like I how can I be happy and joyful when all this horrible stuff is going in the world it it’s not responsible but the fact is it actually is responsible because how can we uh we have to have some uplift in our heart all the sometime because things can get really challenging in life and how do we nourish that and balance that if I’m constantly in a state I can’t meet everything with compassion. Not everything requires that. So when someone else is happy that that the the the best mind and heart state for that is to be happy for their happiness without any kind of jealous jealousness.
And it’s a practice too. So I can’t beat myself up for for not doing that when I slip into envy. Like why am I why am I not happy? I want to be happy. How come they’re happy and I’m not? That’s that’s without training. That’s kind of where my heart goes, you know? uh but but it but but it can be trained and then because it is an innate part of our our heart that that it can rejoice and be happy for others. It doesn’t have to slide into jealousy but it it takes work for some people. Some people it’s more of a natural response and yeah um so I think that’s that’s uh wants to be uh really put forth here and it can’t be stressed enough. This is actually a responsible thing for us to do is to seek out wholesome joy uh for ourselves and rejoice in the happiness of others because it is a a nourishing supportive heart quality again and I’m doing samata meditation this concentration on one object and one of the jhanic factors that arise is joy pity pity and suka pity is like this rapture uplifting kind of bubbly you know energetic uplift that’s that’s h you know that’s joyful and then suka is a more um not as it’s it’s more smooth happiness. So these are these are things that that happen when there’s um concentration practice that they they arise and they’re they’re needed for Jhana deeper states of concentration. So yes, absolutely. And the the Buddha praised these these states as well, right? And it’s the appropriateness of it as well. So I think that’s key here to joy.
So um there’s a word in English that nobody ever uses. It’s the opposite of Schadenfreude and it is confelicity. That you take joy in somebody else’s happiness. There you go. Confelicity. Why is it that in English we don’t even know our own words for being happy for somebody else? Are we such awful people? Anyway, so Emry has said, “I just had a penny drop with what you shared here.” Thank you. I’d like to work in trinities. I like to work in trinities. Shed of three and I had a part I hadn’t heard before and never saw in a context I needed to see but I just did. Yay. We love that.
We love that. Yeah, that’s very that’s that’s awesome. And yes, sometimes you get caught in only two sides, but I love you, you know, working with with three different things because it’s not always black and white, you know, square uh kinds of thinking. There’s a yeah, a try effect a lot of times. So, yeah.
So when you go ahead Yeah. So, I was going to talk about hurt cuz I’ve been meditating a lot and I think you know we take these difficult situations and we can be I mean you know I work in uh social justice transport justice basically and I’m always fighting for people who don’t have transport choice and I don’t have transport choice but I can kind of work around it but other people that makes a difference to their whether they can get to a job or a medical appointment or whatever you you know, like it has really serious implications and and so I look sometimes have to I obviously have to deal with politicians and infrastructure professionals and transport professionals and I can feel myself get really worked up and I realize that actually I feel hurt on behalf of the people who don’t have that choice and perhaps maybe my younger self. I feel hurt for that person who didn’t feel who felt very trapped and unable to have independence.
And I’ve been thinking a lot about this about dukkha actually. And there are lots of translations for dukkha, but I really like the embodied experience. So we can say the intellectual it feels unsatisfactory, but that feels a bit airy fairy up here somewhere. But I think if we bring it back down into the body and say it aches, you know, we it when we want something and we can’t get it, it aches in our body. When somebody says something that is um hurtful, what’s that is sharp and unkind or whatever or they ignore us. It hurts. It hurts in the body. So we have these like heartaches and hurts and aches and um I think that’s really where dukkha lies because it’s true that there is the physical pain. So when I go to the dentist, sorry if you’re traumatized by that, but I’m willingly putting myself into a painful situation. I get the injection, I get the cleaning, whatever. And that is unpleasant and it’s painful but I’m okay with that. So there’s no dukkha with that. So for me when I look at the what is dukkha it’s actually that there is um an experience of hurt in the body a sort of an emotional hurt and ache in the body and when I get all like they should reply to me and they should do my things and they should agree with me and all these things when I write all these letters and when I get carried away like that I go ah actually I just feel hurt or even ask myself, am I feeling hurt? No, I’m not feeling hurt. I’m like really happy and I this this is their problem. And then I go, oh no, I’m actually just hurt. But it’s really useful to sit and kind of go, ah, actually this is hurt. Because what I’ve realized is that we are resisting feeling hurt. We are resisting feeling the sort of this body ache. We are resisting feeling that and we are defending this. So when you have an ache and your body when you when your body hurts you contract. Yeah. And this gives the imp and then at the same time the mind goes once it sort of exits the body. It sort of and dulls down the body. The mind will go and then he said she said she said he said and it’s not fair and they’re an idiot and all this sort of stuff. So you have the impression that when you’re hurt or it aches that it’s all one system because then the body, you know, your tummy’s clenched, your chest is tight. Uh you can’t really feel all that and you’ve got this worrying I this and I that and them there and da da da. But it’s it’s if you just sit there and go actually I feel a hurt or an ache all that dissipates and you can start to feel it in the body. So there you go. What do you reckon Josh?
This is really timely. been dealing with this lately as well and you know the depths of this and I don’t know the the complete depths of this but my inkling my my guess is that you know there’s a low level of this inherent in all of existence you know it’s there on a low level all the time it’s just that we’re not either sensitive enough or willing enough or capable enough to really see and know the depths of this, you know, on very very subtle levels. So, but on a practical day-to-day thing, I’ve been working with this too, or maybe not working as much as I’d like because I’ve um and I’ve noticed what I’ve been seeing as a pain response. And so whenever I don’t see in mindful of what Wendy’s talking about, then I can give a pain response that I that I basically don’t want to give, you know. But that’s why mindfulness I think and uh feeling and seeing and knowing is so important because when I have the the mindfulness and the heartfulness to to see and know what Wendy’s talking about, then I have more of a choice how I’m going to how I’m going to uh view this and respond to what Wendy’s talking about because that’s what it is. And uh yeah the emotional pain it’s usually has a correspondence in the body of a effect that when he was talking tightening in the chest you know for me there is some kind of maybe psychic pain or mental pain sometimes and it’s like in the head or just kind of a scattering and um yeah that that’s that’s an effect too. So sometimes I’m not connected to my body and that’s not an option. So then there’s there’s other things I have to deal with like okay maybe it’s showing up as chaos or in my life or like a a scattered mind and you know that those can also be indications when those of us aren’t as connected to our bodies sometimes and need other indicators to see okay there’s pain here and and uh what kind of pain response is happening or not happening. Um, and the benefit for me of seeing this is then then um it helps when I can catch it, it I can help contain it. Um, and I’m far from being uh anywhere successful at this. But when I do and then I can say, okay, I have a choice. I can say something that could actually be more hurtful to myself and another or I can refrain from saying something right now and wait till the time is more appropriate to respond, you know. So yeah, I think it also for me it has to do with restraint a lot of times and and actually not restraining when I need to restrain and pull back and actually just feel the pain, you know, and say, “Oh, oh, yeah. Oh, this is this is this is dukkha. This is this is pain, you know, now.” And then that’s the first step because yes, like we were talking, everything’s going to be we’re going to have moments of pain. You don’t get out of a human existence without pain. However, what we then do about that and how we view it and respond to it is going to make the difference between adding piles and piles and piles of extra suffering on top of that pain or dealing with it in a way that that will minimize or help not do that. And it’s tricky too, I think, because sometimes it it it feels so good to be angry, right? They talk about like a honey tip and poison root of anger. Sometimes it feels so good to be justified that I’m right, but at the end of the day it’s it it’s only like momentary and then there’s consequences and fallout of that, you know, either from feeling shameful and guilty about it or actually having um another like nobody wants to be lashed out on, right? So they they some people can lash back out on me and then it just keeps compounding and compounding and compounding. But this notion that it oh it feels so good to just be right and lash out and say my choice and but I but I found that’s not really a solution long term, right? I I guess it’s it’s it’s understandable in some senses and it’s not as simple straightforward as this either because you know some some of us have been felt and this isn’t me because I had no uh shyness coming up about emotionally conflict with my family. We just mired it and we were all doing the best we could but we didn’t really have any tools or anything to know how to do anything different unfortunately. But some people they’ve been they they’ve suppressed. They think, “Oh, I need to be like Wendy was talking. I need to be the good girl. I know. I I need to be the good boy and be make sure everything is going okay and make sure everybody’s happy and I don’t want to show any kind of anger or anything because you know I’m not really allowed to or you know I or for whatever reasons, right?” And so then when they they find out, oh wow, I’ve been suppressing this and then I need to deal with this in a different way. one of the options then I guess is to come out um and just just express it you know um and now I think yeah we so I think that’s that’s enough to get to get us started here and I’ve been going on a little bit but um to bring it back to Wendy’s point feeling it in the body is so helpful because it does dissipate if I can just sit and be with it and say oh yes this is this is pain and you just feel it really deeply without really any kind of judgment and like I was taking care of a 5-year-old child in pain, you know, and how would I respond to that 5-year-old child in pain and and giving that to myself and when when um it will dissipate, right? It will dissipate and it’s okay um to feel it because because it’s there anyway, right?
So, I want to just uh question this thing about pain because I don’t think it is pain. I think it is hurt. And I want to distinguish because I I I think what the ego does is it says I I’m not not hurt. I don’t hurt. And so there’s a whole lot of different strategies that the mind will do to say I’m never hurt. And and I know that I used to say, “Oh, I don’t feel hurt.” And I know I meet other people and they say, “Oh, I don’t feel hurt.” You know, it takes a lot to hurt me. And I know that that’s not true for me anymore. I look back and I’m like, “Oh man, I was like one big hurt giant bumblebee, you know, or bubble of whatever.” And um uh so and the people who say, “Oh, it’s takes a lot to hurt me.” are the ones you want to go. They’re really likely to get really hurt really quickly.
So I think it’s really important to just really lean into terrible expression but really allow your yourself to experience hurt because it’s not pain because when you go to the dentist that’s pain but when you are in this experience when it’s relational it’s actually hurt and you can have a relationship with your body like why does this why does my cancer do this or why you know why my one of our volunteers and she’s going I get all these migraines and the migraine is separate from her and she’s hurt by the fact that these migraines are hurting her and yes it’s excruciatingly painful and it knocks her out so I’m not belittling the enormous physical pain and the debilitation and the disability that arises for people who experience a lot of migraines but um I do want to say that hurt and pain are different. That’s all.
Thank you so much. It absolutely couldn’t agree more and that’s it’s it’s a really significant um difference you know and u correction and I just look back in my own not to get too overly confessional or um you know go on go on go it’s more fun if you if you speak about your direct experience. Well, sure. It’s more helpful. Absolutely. It’s more helpful if you sort of speak in theoretical abstract terms. It’s like, you know, who cares? I don’t care if I can get that out of a book, you know. So, give me the real McCoy here. I want the real thing, Josh.
Totally. And it’s way more juicy. And I I I don’t know if the these uh fighter jets are showing up, but yeah, I totally agree. However, I do like lots of books and lots of study, too. So, but to remind uh thanks for the reminder. We’re we’re not reading a book here, right? we’re having a conversation and talking. So, it’s this isn’t a uh classroom setting as far as I know. So, but the the the hurt thing, yes, you know, I I look back in the really low points of my life and there was so much hurt that I and I didn’t have any kind of tools or know how to deal with it and the only thing that I could think of is I want someone this is horrible, you know, and I’m so glad that this is not the case anymore as far as I know or it’s very rare. Thank goodness I hope so too that I’m not being delusional in this is that I I was I felt so hurt that I just wanted someone to feel the the amount of hurt that I was going through you know like that was going to be any kind any better for me or anyone else. But there was no kind of reasoning. There was no kind of I would say hardly ethics of course around that, you know, especially not the ethics of non-harming. It was just that I’m in pain and I hurt and I want somebody else to know what I’m going through. You know what I mean? and this denial or this um this delusion that my hurt is is is unique and that no one else can really relate to it. And that makes it even worse, right? Because we know that’s not true. I mean, of course, it’s not going to be exactly the same as someone else’s hurt pain, but it’s going to be similar, you know, and this notion that my hurt is so unique that, you know, that and that I really want to cling to my special flavor of dukkha because it’s so it’s it’s mine and that’s what I know and it’s it’s kind of unique. No, not really. You know what I mean? It’s there’s nothing really special about it. Um, usually now now I don’t want to be not to be insensitive, but what I’m saying is that um, sometimes I can also cling on to my my special version of of what I’m going through, but it is a universality. We all suffer, you know, until we’re fully awakened. Oh, yeah. I know. But I mean, you know, it’s quite, you know, the whole, “Oh, woe is me. My life is terrible, which often comes with alcohol. I find it’s they they come together, you know, like you get the up and then you get the down. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And good point. I was that that was when I used to drink, too, you know. Yeah. So, very good point.
Yeah. Yeah. So, now we’re talking about uh the our installment. How do we how do we bring peace? To me, it’s like we bring peace to it by acknowledging that we feel hurt or we have an ache, a heartache. And I also want to put in this caveat that when it something really awful happens, you know, you you hear about people and their loved one dies and people are told, you know, they have to kind of come to terms with it and go through it and stuff, but they’re sort of living in denial. And I’m just going, “Wow, you know, give it a break because it’s really awful sometimes.” And denial sometimes is the right response. It because it keeps you psychologically safe during a really tough period. It’s not healthy to live like that forever, but if that’s what gets you through a really bad phase, hey, I’m all for it.
So, just to put that in there. Um, so how do we cultivate and support peace in formal meditation? And I want to ask what peace means. Before I do that, I’m going to give you a United Nations definition. So I was listening to the radio and it was this guy talking about what does peace mean now in the United Nations the formal he was some big UN diplomat from wherever in the world and um he said in the United Nations which is basically the Anglo um sphere and European European peace means no conflict. But everywhere else in the world, what it means is that you you actually everybody lives with dignity because then you have peace. But if it just means no conflict, it means you’re not aware of things and you can silence things. Now in the moment, Emry says in the moment it is then when you see the larger point that it’s not. So I’m a little bit confused. Tell me in the moment. In the moment it is then when you see the larger point when it’s not.
So I’m very sorry. I I’m not quite sure I get it. So um I’m not wanting to be rude or anything, but I just don’t understand. So, but I I think that difference between um living with dignity and not living with conflict is a really useful thing here. That’s that’s my take.
You you’ve mentioned this before and it’s a really helpful point. Let me just let me guess on uh Emry’s comment. uh at least I don’t know what what the what the specific point is but this is something like if we’re focused maybe on too much minutia and we think something is the way it is but then we have a larger picture of it then we realize the what we’ve been kind of hyperfocused on then that’s that’s actually not the case because now we have a larger perspective and we can see that what we had before was only a tiny little piece of the puzzle and why it was probably still Um uh about being unique. Okay. So she said about being unique. So yeah, now now we get the now we get it. I mean Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So that’s right. Okay. So before I comment on Wendy’s uh definition of peace, you talked about and I think this is a really important point to touch on again too is the denial. And so yes, you know, if we were in in a perfect world and we all had the perfect conditions, anytime we felt hurt, we could go within and do a formal practice and address it in all the that the the highest helpful ways. But the matter of the fact is we don’t always have access to that. Um, and so we have to have other uh coping mechanisms, right, and other strategies for dealing with things. And like Wendy said, actually from what I guess the psychologists say, this denial is part of the grieving process, right? It’s one of the stages. And so just because I’m in denial about something doesn’t necessarily mean that I’m completely delusional or off track or we’ll never get through it or am I doing it wrong, right? It’s just one of these stages.
And sometimes things do get too overwhelming and or hurt too much that it’s just unbearable to be with it. And so at those times there we need other helpful ways uh not just the the the ideal way to to deal with something. So I just wanted to echo and and validate it and and amplify that point of that denial is is yeah is is part of the grieving process and in a strategy as far as I know you know now like and then like you said though if we get stuck there well then that’s another thing then we have to address that maybe in a different way. But uh okay so so you said about peace and it’s really interesting I mean yeah if we frame peace as lack of conflict then it’s almost like pre uh sub assuming that that that there’s conflict or that I’m on the edge of conflict or that it could go into conflict any moment and I don’t want conflict get it away from me you know uh that’s not peaceful and then there’s maybe an avoidant tendency or a a judging about it and um maybe or denial or lack of to to confront it, to go into it, you know, to um to be like so yeah, you’re right. So, I think that definition is helpful to a certain uh degree because who who wants a lot of extra conflict internally or externally. Yes, of course, we as far as I know, unless we’re like psychopathic, we don’t really want that or thrive on that. Or if we’re a chaos maker and think that I can somehow get some power by stirring up chaos and then and then stepping in and say, “Oh, I got this. I’m going to make order out of chaos.” kind of uh silliness that uh we hear the slogan order of chaos, but if they’re deliberately stirring up chaos so they can step in and then control it and so that’s that’s something else and that’s ridiculous. Um so I’m not not necessarily talking about that. So, but dignity. So, that brings it it it takes it away from a theoretical level and it puts it on a very humanistic day-to-day heart level. I think you know dignity you know where if I’m not treating someone with dignity including myself what what’s going on you know why is that is it because I was not treated with dignity does it feel maybe I feel justified and in being indignant you know does it feel good to be indignant um you know do I feel do I feel like I can now uh feel better about myself because I can put someone else down and not des or maybe I’m just too overwhelmed and stressed and I can’t I need to show myself dignity before I can express it to another or consider it for another because I’m so stressed out now that I can’t even show myself dignity, you know. So, I think yes, um I they both go hand in hand, but I do feel that this dignity thing is that we’re all deserving of that and that’s where we’re all on equal footing is that we’re all worthy of of dignity, you know. And I’m not there all the time either. Of course, there’s times when I lack dignity for myself and others, you know, and and I appreciate being called out on it because that way I can change uh if I don’t see it, you know.
Yeah, I think there’s definitely a lot in there. So, here in your I’ve just got the um video here on my right. It says areas of exploration may include the conditions that give rise to and sustain peace. And I think we’ve just talked about that how it is revealed or obscured obscured in relationship and I think we’ve addressed that the difference between brief glimpses and more stable baselines.
Let’s go there.
Very good moderator Wendy. Yeah. So I think what we mean here is we have we all have we’ve I hope the heck that you’ve experienced peace, right? So that’s a given. And then how long? Um, so I guess if we if we reflect, where is our baseline of peace? What would we consider peaceful most of the time? If it goes a little bit away from it, then I feel like that I’ve lost peace in my life. But if I go a little bit stronger into peace, maybe really on a long retreat or you happen to be around really wise, calm, peaceful people or just the circumstances and conditions, then we kind of know the opposite end of this is, oh wow, that I’ve seen that even more peace is possible, you know.
So that’s what so that’s um so then we can kind of maybe establish our baseline if we see where we get really off track or it it gets really off track and then where it can really be solid and peaceful and so yeah so how do we I guess re reflecting on my own baseline to that you know I I honestly I I think I yeah I don’t like conflict I I and I try to avoid it actually you And it’s it’s it feels easier and nicer for me not not to do it. And so I do think I have some avoidance for conflict. And it doesn’t work too well in relationship though because we’re going to be we’re going to be uh confronted I think for the most part with with conflict whether we want it or not. So that is one of the challenges and um rewards I think of of relationship is that you can’t really avoid it. uh it’s going to come out sooner and later whether we want it to or not. I think if if I had to guess for uh a significant part of relationships, you know, I mean there’s a degrees of severity, I think. But uh yeah, so as far as baseline, I think my baseline is actually not so healthy, you know. I think I’m uh avoidant when it comes to conflict and then it ends up coming out kind of all at once because I’ve been lazy and neglectful um for something that needs to be addressed headon and in depth in more detail until it’s too late and then it can kind of turn into conflict sometimes. And in conflict I just mean like okay I can’t get out of this where we have to address it now. There’s no other option you know we can’t put this off anymore. it needs to be gone through right now.
I think it’s it’s hard, you know, when you’re in a relationship. I mean, relationships are hard, you know, and I was thinking I think the anglosphere is very um conflict averse and there’s lots of silences and withdrawal that arise rather than, you know, say in I’m going to be a bit stereotypical, but like an Italian family or in other families where it’s more robust, they have these really stronger relationships. And um so just while I think about it, M Reed has said great definition. This was I think before about conflict peace. Great definition. Thank you for sharing it. Sharing it says so much about our current times. And she’s now said we start with where we are real authentic. Look into it. Awesome chat. Love the chat. Um thank you. So, where was I before I interrupted myself?
Well, we were we were talking about conflict and I I just it doesn’t necessarily have to escalate conflict address so I you know when you when I you know in poor communities they actually get used to conflict because they’re so dependent on each other and they they have these big baries and they they get used to relationships. But in the Anglosphere, middle class and up, we we don’t like that. We just do no speakies and all that sort of stuff. And I I feel that that can be really an unhelpful way.
I’ve you know, I’ve lived in Sweden and I think the Germanic side of the Anglosphere is a bit like that. Um whereas in I’ve also lived in France and they are more robust and they family is more important and they you know let you know things. So I think I think it is an an I think the anglosphere is an anomaly in terms of conflict. And we think that when conflict must mean an argument, we think a conflict must mean that we are hurting each other. But I’ve been sort of looking at this sense of hurt and ache a lot and thinking what if we’re so not allowing ourselves to enter into the body to feel the body. You know, I realized after living in England that they kind of anything to do with the body is completely denied through their sense of humor and everything. You know, that the way they dress, the way they eat, the way they use alcohol, the way they present themselves, it’s all sort of anti-body. And I and I think as I you know I’ve got English heritage. As I think about that um and that denial of the body when you feel hurt it feels such a shock to be connected with the body. And so maybe conflict is just saying well this is a bit uncomfortable boys and girls. Let’s have this is a bit miserable. is a bit and maybe what we can do is come forward gently.
But it’s really frustrating. People park on the footpath near the vape shop. Drives me mad. Vapes are illegal here. And I see them parked on the footpath and they block it and I have to ride on the road. It’s really dangerous for me. and I’m railing at them and yelling into the shop and you know I have my days because I get really tired of it. And I think when we don’t when we don’t feel we have resources that’s when we get into this argumentative space as opposed to conflict being well you think this and I think this and let’s have a you know a lovely we chat about it.
Yeah, really good stuff, Wendy. The uh Yeah. So, the that’s that’s the thing that’s so great about meditation is that uh when we’re not in relationship and there is some kind of hurt there and some kind of what what does that boil down to? Uh in one sense, maybe it’s too ins sensitive or oversimplified. It’s unpleasantness in the body. There’s unpleasantness in the body. Now, this isn’t the full extent. There could actually be some abuse that needs to be uh dealt with, right? But when we’re dealing with it on the cushion, um this hurt, I think, can can be simplified down or in one degree to okay, what is my threshold for being with hurt, unpleasantness in the body, you know, how do I do that? What are the benefits of why should I bother doing that? What’s the point of that? how is it going to help me? And uh yeah, so this is this is what it comes down to.
And if if if I can address some of the those own questions, I would say um it’s happening anyway. It’s it’s it’s when I become aware of it that I can really have a choice of how to deal with it. But I look at my own when when I when I can deeply feel it and be with it, then it it tends to dissipate. Then I realize then I have a sensitivity. Then I have kind of a feedback of my own um my own voice and what I say and what other people say to me. There’s an increased sensitivity. So then when when I have more of a feedback that’s I think more instantaneous um more direct more sensitive then I can then I can get uh quickly oh when I say this it might have these impacts when I don’t say this when I don’t listen u when I try to be avoidant or when I be too direct when I’m not a direct enough these are kind of the the feedback and responses and it’s not like I have to think about all this in micromanagement. It it’s it’s um can be felt in real time effortlessly in the body sometimes, right? And so then there’s just comes into intuitively having a sense a wise sense of uh how to think uh speak and act that’s going to have an impact on others and myself and kind of let wisdom take the reigns on what to know and realize that I’m not going to get it right all the time. I’m going to screw up. Uh but there’s a willingness to go forward and and to and continue doing the best I can. And if I could do better, I would. And allow that to inform um how I am. And using the outcome to reflect on, okay, what kind of intentions do I need to adjust here? Um what kind of speech and action do I need to do different? What what’s what’s helpful? You know, what kind of thing is going to be helpful? um in my speech and actions with others that’s going to lead towards uh my well-being and theirs, you know, and it’s it’s an ongoing learning process in these things in in in life and and how to do it. And you know, a big support too is having friends like Wendy and someone I can talk to that’s on the same page, has the same interest, has kind of on the same path and that can keep me in check, you know, that can show me my blind spots, call me out, but not do so out of hate and spite, you know, or unhelpful. Yeah. Right. But like there’s a genuine caring and interest to to to for for well-being, you know, and that we’re we’re all figuring our way out through this and we can help each other when we can, you know, and uh teachers, too. So, so all right. So, I think I was just thinking about my vape shop and they park and they they it’s illegal. They get closed down. They’ve got their trading thing and you know, I contact the uh various um authorities and go they’ve got their little because I’m like really ped because I you know it’s unsafe and it drives me nuts. So here you are. See I’m getting really worked up about this cuz it drives me nuts cuz they shouldn’t be pugging the footpath. So, I’m going nuts. And so tell me like, you know, it’s like people who rail at the television, you know, Uncle Uncle Bob, he’s always railing at the television, you know, and so how do we like without being all avoidant and kind of fake and like theoretical when you’re really worked up like, okay, I can I actually know the police constable. So I could write to the police constable for highway high highway patrol and just email him and go right just so you know. So I should do that but I think it’s good to yell don’t yell don’t park on the foot path too cuz for me I just feel like mind you I’m also a bit nervous that one of them’s going to come after me and run me down while I’m on my bicycle. So that’s the problem with anger, you know, we think it can make us safe. And I I used to have such a foul temper. Then I started counting up how many times getting angry made me safe. And I was like, oh, not very many. And how many times does it make me feel unsafe? Well, plenty actually. So that that made me kind of keep in check. But I don’t want to be fake and I don’t want to be suppression and I don’t want to avoid and like what do you do when you’re kind of something like that where you’re physically harmed and you’re frustrated that this keeps coming up and it’s an illegal thing and you know they’re thugs. They’re all gangs run by gangs and stuff. They have no compunction about anything. Now you tell me how I deal with that, Josh.
Well, as a female, you don’t do it this way. um with as a guy this is a little bit more um likely to do. Although I don’t know if I could recommend it either. I’d have to see, you know, the extent of it, how big it is, and how many friends I have to take with me, you know. So, so to me, when it’s in a a challenging situation, if I can and it feels safe to do, uh, even though it takes it takes a lot of courage, it this doesn’t apply to Wendy. I’m sorry, but this would this is maybe how I might deal with it. Is actually just to walk up and say, “Hey, bro. What’s going on? How’s it going here?” And just I’m just two minutes. I’m just two minutes. What’s your problem? No, but see, that’s the thing. Like if um if you were on Okay, so put yourself in in their shoes and if someone was yelling and screaming, I can walk 50 meters and 100 meters down the road. It’s not impossible. This is exactly how I feel. Bam.
This this brings me to then the next point that I’ve been working with a lot lately is it’s um what we say, but also how we say it, you know. So, how receptive and you know this doesn’t really apply to to to gang members too because they they operate on a different rule set as well. So, I don’t recommend also going in there and being harmful or the tough guy either, you know, but I wonder how and not as Wendy, but if some guys out there around Wendy’s neighborhood that have had enough of it, too. Yeah.
Come on. But this is where it’s really important is is how you do it because this is actually potentially dangerous situation. But I don’t think it’s beyond going in with the right heart and the right attitude in the right way. Not being a pushover, but not being overly aggressive and and and condemning either, but just say, “Hey, what I don’t know exactly how to say it, but how you say it is going to be important. But is there I’ll just say, is there a possibility for some guys to go up there and directly talk to them and just see what’s going on? see what the options are here, you know, and I don’t I don’t I don’t know if that would be too wise because it is illegal. That’s a rubbish answer, Josh.
Could you like anonymous? These are things you go you do could you could you send an anonymous message to the police so you don’t have to give your name?
I know I know the police counsel write him an email. He He would He’s fine. He He’d be all right. last time I complained about well he would he would be all right but I don’t know about you so that’s why I’m wondering if you could just contact anonymously yeah it’d be all right I’ve contacted through through the various things but the point is you know like as I was saying there probably you know it’s about me just letting off steam apart from anything else um because I get so so frustrated by it and am I better for it no but I just it’s like I just see red you know so that Yeah. What do you do with that?
What do you do? Because it’s completely valid. It’s completely valid. It’s completely valid feeling. Of course, I’m completely right, Josh. There you go. Finally, I’ve convinced you. I’m right. Of course, I’m right. But they’re still there. You’re right. But they’re still there, right?
I know. See, then then then how does it work? Like, what do you do in that situation? Normally, I’m pretty I I’m pretty pretty chill and I’m I’m much better about that. And I do it a bit more jovially. I’m I don’t do it with like All right. You don’t park on the book path a little bit. But I do kind of, you know, do that and and sometimes, you know, I go, “Stop parking on the foot path.” They go, “Oh, sorry.” So, there have been patrons who who have done that, but it’s just, you know, it’s like they shut down the vape shop and it was fantastic. I didn’t have to worry about my safety. It was fantastic. And then it popped back up cuz they’re thugs. So, it it is Yeah. Yeah, you go go in there. Go in there and buy it and buy a vape from them and then break it right in front of their face, throw it on the ground and walk out without saying a word. What about that?
Cost me money. I’m not going to give those sons money by goodwill, young man.
Yeah.
So, you see, but but I think we get we we we get like caught in these things and it’s really hard when we’re we’re in that thing and it’s that thing that drives us mad and we’re railing at the telly and we look at those I don’t know politicians or people or whatever and we just kind of blood boils, you know. Yeah. And it’s I I think they they they pray on that actually. They deliberately show things that are going to be emotionally triggering because that’s what sells ads. You know, oh, how dare they? How could they? Can you believe this? Well, that’s what that’s they’re deliberately putting material and presenting material in a certain way that will deliberately uh invoke those responses because then I’m emotionally invested involved and that’s very powerful and alluring and charging, you know. So, that’s the thing. Yeah. But you actually have a real life situation, not something that was deliberately manufactured on a wide scale to have an emotional or trigger response, right? Yeah. So this is this is your work, right? Yeah.
Yeah. I mean, it it the thing is that it wasn’t such a problem and then it’s just when the vape shop is there and people are desperate because they’re all like exactly, you know, those stupid vapes. Um, and you know, and and they hate them. like people I know it just they hate them. I’m I meet people and they go I I they’re more addictive than even cigarettes, you know. Yeah. Yeah. Um so yeah. Um if if we look so if you know if we look at that the behavior is at least I know when I used to smoke it’s because I was nervous uh I didn’t feel good and then when I smoked cigarette I felt some sense of false basically or very conditional peace and relaxation right it felt like a release and there was a a few minutes of calm and ease until it wore off and then I had to have another like you’re saying it’s highly addictive but if we look at the root of that there there’s hurt and pain there and this is one of the ways that they’ve been suckered into dealing with that because they don’t have any other resources and that’s the other thing you mentioned about trauma the definition I heard of trauma I really like is un integrated resources so yeah I think that’s it so yeah you talked about resourcing and it’s like having resources or whatever resources we do have because I think everybody has some but they’re just not kind of integrated properly. But, you know, that doesn’t make their behavior right though. You know, that doesn’t make that it doesn’t make that Yeah. I’m not saying what they’re doing is right because they’re in pain. No, but if we’re trying to have some kind of baseline understanding, they’re in extreme pain and that’s that’s one of the ways they’re dealing with it. Now, how they’re dealing with it, not not okay. And and actually you rais a really good point because I need to just look in the mirror and know that when I was a driver and when I used to and I used to park on the foot path, what’s wrong with parking on the footpath? And I was very well, yeah, I can’t park anywhere else. Got to park on the foot path. And I was completely selfish. So yeah. So, I think I’m just arguing with myself to be honest, you know, and I think I think I’m just being adversarial because I’m not putting myself in my in my own shadow experience, you know. Maybe I’m overly practical, but I think if there was a choice for somewhere else for them to park other than the footpath, they wouldn’t park in the foot path. But the it’s the opportunity is not even there, you know. And I think maybe you’re if I’m had to venture a guess, you you might feel invalidated for the work you’re doing. You know, here I’m trying to do this and make things better for people. I’m being completely disregarded. They don’t even think, you know what I mean? Absolutely. And how I’m You see me after all this work I’ve done, I’ve devoted my life to this and they just they’re completely ignoring it. They are off my Christmas card list. Let me tell you, Josh. Okay.
So, yes, but it just goes to show, you know, you know, we kind of work workshop that in real time because I’m going actually there was one person who had this stupid big van and it was completely enormous and I couldn’t pass. And yes, there are parking spaces over there, but they don’t, you know, the footpath, the road, everything’s just car. You know, when you’re in a car, you just think, “Oh, well, it’s just everything’s there for a car.” And I used to be exactly the same. And um and actually I’ve conflated all these things together and I’m now going to write to my police officer friend and just go, “All right, by the way, they’re doing this. They’re driving me nuts.” So, I’ll do it in a more formal tone.
So, we’re coming up to the end. Josh, yes, we are. How do you feel about today’s little catchup?
I feel we I have a long way to go to be uh more peaceful and I want you all listening to this to chime in and actually say how you find peace and ease in your practice in your life because I can use the more help as well and yeah so and but I’m aiming towards it and peace is said to be the highest happiness ease is one of the things in the Metta Sutta I thought about reading the Metta Sutta again on here because it’s short but we’re we’re out of time Now, and one of the things that’s repeated in there, may all beings be at ease. And it is a great wish and and the highest happiness, you know, and it’s an ongoing uh work in process for us too, but it is also available in our hearts. So, it’s not anything super special. Uh but it it it it does take cultivating and um and and yeah, dealing with things the way we can best deal with them when we’re able to. I guess hopefully that’s not too convoluted and watered down, but I I wish everyone peace here and peace and ease in their hearts, in their lives, in their relationships, in the world at large, too. And um you think, well, maybe that’s wishy-washy, you know, hopeful uh thing that that’s not practical. But what it does is it starts uh pointing and aiming the heart in in a right direction. And it’s for me too because it conditions the heart. And so the the more I can work and condition or I don’t know about work but you know incline the heart and mind in that sense and have a genuine sense of goodness and well-being then that really does uh have an impact on the heart and then by default those I come into contact just be more likely that I won’t be such a sour sour puss um uh when I don’t have to be you know or I can see maybe I have a choice now and I’m I’m treating myself with some peace and ease so maybe that will rub off in in the relationships around me. So, and I’m the first recipient of my well-wishing and and u alignment and wanting peace. So, and I think have a bit of joy. Take yourself not so seriously and look at what how much are you the problem I think is the other one. Anyway, we’re out of time.
We’re out of time. One one more point just I learned the other day too. How much priority are we putting on something? Am I giving it too much of importance? Like Wendy said, am I taking this too seriously? You know, I’m putting too much importance on this. You know, is it really that important as well? So, yes, as Wendy says, have fun and we’ll catch you next time. Right.
Integrating Presence is made with Jetpack Podcast. Full show notes and every episode at https://integratingpresence.com/
Due to the size of this chapter this is part 1 of the eleventh chapter “Happiness” (spanning to the end of subchapter 11.8 “Review of Different Forms of Happiness”) from the book:
Buddhadhamma: The Laws Of Nature And Their Benefits To Life
by Bhikkhu P. A. Payutto (Somdet Phra Buddhaghosacariya)
Published by Buddhadhamma Foundation
Copyright © Buddhadhamma Foundation 2021
Translated by Robin Philip Moore
Editor: Bhikkhu Kovilo, typesetting: Bhikkhu Gambhīro
Download this e-book in PDF, EPUB and MOBI formats at the following address: https://buddhadhamma.github.io
This is a gift not for sale / to be sold. I just read it and claim zero copyright. Please support https://www.buddhadhammafoundation.com
Integrating Presence is made with Jetpack Podcast. Full show notes and every episode at https://integratingpresence.com/
[Brief notes before the ai assisted summary that Ajahn Dhammasiha requested audio only and requested I kept my camera on so he could see me while we talked and recorded on Dec 1, 2025. I also didn’t edit out anything and there’s lots of my stammering. Apologies if any of this comes off as too much about “me and my practice” however Ajahn skillfully leverages this on multiple levels making it applicable across many demographics and often universally too.
I’m also very grateful for him for making new connections and suggestions about practice that hadn’t occurred to me before and some of them very subtle that while I don’t really seem to be able to grasp the full depth and potential of some of these now there’s a type of intuitive sense that these seeds have potential for major impact and fruit down the line when wisdom and pāramī ripen. Also, I reflexively stopped the recording too early so it ends abruptly truncating Ajahn’s closing thanks]
(Ai assist:) Ajahn Dhammasiha (from Dhammagiri Forest Hermitage, Brisbane) and I explore the Buddha’s instructions on Ānāpānasati (mindfulness of breathing) from MN 118. We emphasize that breath meditation is meant to be joyful — “breathing in having fun, breathing out having fun” — and that true joy arises from wholesome, non-sensual happiness (pīti & sukha). The discussion covers the importance of strong ethical foundations (sīla) and good kamma, the difference between worldly and spiritual happiness, how the breath is experienced as whole-body energy/prāna, the value of calming thought completely, when to supplement ānāpānasati with other practices (especially mettā), practical challenges of maintaining the breath in daily lay life, and the need to stay aware not only of the breath but also of the state of the mind itself.
Chapters:
0:00 – Introduction & weather small-talk
0:50 – Jumping into Ānāpānasati – “Breathing in having fun”
2:18 – The Buddha’s own words: training in rapture (pīti) & happiness (sukha)
3:51 – Wholesome vs unwholesome “fun”; the Bodhisatta’s past mistake
5:51 – The Bodhisatta’s journey: jhāna → austerity → middle way under the rose-apple tree
7:23 – The 16 steps of Ānāpānasati (MN 118) & why it was the Buddha’s favourite practice
9:12 – Common challenges & the absolute necessity of foundations (sīla + puñña)
13:03 – Personal stories: healing, giving up alcohol, the power of precepts
17:20 – Recalling goodness & mettā before sitting; breath as whole-body energy/prāna
20:15 – Reflection/contemplation vs silent observation in meditation
22:16 – Calming thought completely – the unique gift of ānāpānasati
26:05 – When the mind “can’t take more quiet” → switch to walking + reflection
29:07 – Training wholesome thinking first, then silencing it
32:32 – Ānāpānasati in daily life & jobs – be realistic, use transitions (e.g. mettā)
37:29 – Supplementing breath meditation with mettā, compassion, body contemplation, etc.
39:58 – Continuity of practice & retreat vs lay-life realities
43:24 – Awareness of the breath AND awareness of the state of the mind
45:58 – Closing thanks & invitation to Dhammagiri Forest Hermitage
46:33 – Monastery info, daily program, Bodhi trees in Brisbane — Related link mentioned: https://integratingpresence.com/2020/12/21/historical-trees-of-enlightenment/
Mindfulness of Breathing – All 16 Steps | Breath Meditation | Anapanasati | Ajahn Dhammasiha https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gq8zKJ12wgI
Other talks:
Power of Bodh Gaya, Place of Buddha’s Enlightenment | Mahabodhi Temple | Vajirasana Diamond Throne | Ajahn Dhammasiha
July 14, 2025 https://overcast.fm/+pBqoCSfJc
“Euthanasia: Killing of Human Beings is BAD Karma. It’s NOT Compassionate” (Dhammagiri Forest Hermitage) — https://www.youtube.com/live/viU8MCO10Ok
Related article: https://www.dhammagiri.net/post/euthanasia-is-bad-karma
I initially found Dhammagiri through searching a Venerable Kalyano that a Dhamma friend mentioned and found a different Venerable Kalyano and was fascinated by this:
How Do Relics Appear? | Ajahn Kalyano | Ascent to Stupa on Summit | Dhammagiri Stupa Consecration 02 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nf_FiVkO41Q . . . (shorter audio selection version: https://overcast.fm/+pBqqcGP7Y)
Stupa Relic Enshrinement Ceremony | Ven Ajahn Anan with 16 Monks | Dhammagiri Stupa Consecration 03 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aTpcvqOtoo4
dhammagiri.net
https://www.youtube.com/@dhammatalksatdhammagiri8724
Audio Podcasts:
https://open.spotify.com/show/0SHWfWEGkO8OAtSWNJlqyD
Dhammagiri Newsletter: https://dhammagiri.net/newsletter
Unedited transcript via YouTube:
Holmes, welcome. Today I have Ajan Damasia with me from Australia. Ajan,
how are you doing today? How’s it going? I’m happy to join you here. I think we
talked already we have the opposite weather here. It’s nice, hot, and sunny.
I never get Christmas feelings here in Brisbane. It just doesn’t work.
Yeah, that’s that’s definitely interesting. here in the middle of the United States. Um there’s snow coming down now, I
think, a little bit north St. Louis. They’ve uh my nephew is a little bit upset that they didn’t call off school
and they’re going 30 miles an hour very slowly. A short trip is now taking a long time. But anyway, this is the the
the nature of the weather. I suppose it it varies a lot. So we’re here today and I’d like to just
jump right into Anapana Santati um with this series and continuing with it. I
reached out to um Ajan to request he come on and talk about it. And the very
next Dharma talk he gave was actually on an upanisanti. So I’m going to include that in the show notes. And what I found
really um fascinating and warmed my heart is when Ajan said
breathing in having fun, breathing out having fun. Of course, this is not, you
know, a literal translation from the anapana sadi suta, but I like I love the sentiment that this gives um because
sometimes I think it’s a a you know sometimes a really um hard duty to do
this. It it can feel like sometimes without the right attitude. And another jumping in point here I mentioned before
is the detailed instructions that the Buddha gave on meditation. And there seems to be only two major ones in
detail and it’s the satipana suta or the four foundations of mindfulness four
frames of reference and this one the anapana sati suta and I was just interested in the parallels and anywhere
else you want to take this a john for for starting off with mindfulness of breathing
what you mentioned that I said breathing in having fun breathing out having fun.
You see it basically goes back straight to the Buddha.
There’s a Buddha himself who tells us we should train ourself breathing in
experiencing rapture. We should train ourselves breathing in, breathing out,
experiencing happiness, experiencing gladness, joy, fun.
That is for me always crucial. This is basically my original approach. I always
wanted to know what did the Buddha himself say and I can only recommend to anyone who
wants to do breath meditation according to the Buddha’s instructions
and to go straight away to the Buddha’s instructions as we have them.
Uh John, I want to jump in here real uh quick. And so my confusion then was that
because of my kind of unskillful, unh wholesome um things in the past, I had
misassociated fun with things that are unh wholesome and unskillful, right? But that’s not necessarily the case. We can
still have quote unquote fun and it be entirely skillful and wholesome, right? So that’s where my confusion was because
due to how I was in the past, what I considered fun uh had had gotten to that
quote unquote fun in ways that are less becoming of, you know, things that I
don’t want to do now, right? Things that I don’t want to behave in certain ways. But there’s entirely
um many possible ways to have fun, so to speak, or that are that involve pity and
suka, right? joy, you know, bliss is a little high mark. Some people are a
little adversive to that. I like that word. Bliss is great for me. Um but uh
yeah, um joy and happiness. So yeah, I just wanted to put that out there because I I don’t normally associate um
yeah, there’s also the what what some people call fun that’s it’s not so
wholesome. So don’t be too harsh on you Josh for
getting that point wrong because even the bodhic sata before his awakening
got that same point wrong. This is why he did the extreme aesthetic practices
and he thought if we want to reach awakening enlightenment
the way there is by not having any fun not having any happy feelings but basically to only have the discomfort
and pain and the crucial breakthrough was that he
realized that this doesn’t work and instead we have to distinguish between
worldly fun and unh wholesome or even evil fund or happiness
and the other form the spiritual happiness the happiness that is not based on central gratification
and then that led him to practicing the samadi practicing janna
which is an extreme intense forms of joy happiness and bliss and they realize now
that this is actually a support for awakening
Yeah, it it’s it’s it’s interesting, right? Because um it kind of came full
circle in a way, right? Because he left to go practice at first with the two teachers that taught him Janna, right?
And it went all the way into that and he said, “Well, this isn’t going to take me all the way. This is not what I’m
looking for, more or less, right? Please um refine this sentiment.” And then when did the in aesthetic practices and then
um what was it then he finally took took food right and then had a memory of
under the rose apple tree when um when he experienced Janna as a as a young
child almost spontaneously or who knows how much parammy in the past or what what led up to that and and then then
changed um mindsets from the aesthetic practices. Yeah. My point was that like
drinking alcohol, thinking that’s fun. Just basically being under a lot of delusion of of what to do that’s going
to cause some kind of um short-term diluted happiness. But then yeah
realizing that’s okay you know that’s that’s right that that um maybe I had to go through that due to past actions but
had the good fortune now to have encountered the Buddhist teachings and and practice too and realize that no
there’s there’s a much better way. So yeah I I appreciate that um encouragement too.
So now go for the instructions as the Buddha has given them and there are these 16 steps
and uh you were correct that this is one of the most extensive complete
excellent instructions we have about any meditation object from the Buddha as the
anapana sati suta and matrianikaya and the middle length discourses
the number 118 and just just reading it in particular
the heart disease so-called four tetrits the covering the four satana
the four instructions for each of the four satana
and anapana is so fantastic because it is a meditation object that can develop
both samata samadi but also So inside so it’s really complete
and by the way it was the favorite meditation object of the Buddha himself
that the Buddha would sometimes go and retreat and we can read about that and he would ask that only one monk is
allowed to see him bringing him the food and later he said that he mostly dwelt
in that kind of meditation during the retreat worth meditation
It also appears that he practiced breath meditation uh
at the moment just before pavono.
So there’s many arguments for cultivating this meditation object.
Indeed. So what do you find are some of the challenges
just starting from the beginning right? um some of the common challenges and how
to address breath meditation. I think that’s a kind of good simplistic place to start.
The very crucial point is the foundations.
If you look at the places where the Buddha talks about anatasi,
there’s many occasions where he first mentions other more basic practices.
So it is quite a refined meditation.
It was an excellent meditation object for the Buddha. But we have to keep in mind that the Buddha has this fullness
of all spiritual perfections and poweries and spiritual faculties.
So for most people they have to make sure that they get the
foundations and in order to experience that
nonsensual happiness that is not relating to any unhud or evil states or
unskillful states. It is much easier to get there if we build up a stock of what is called puna,
good karma because then we already have a background happiness in our heart.
If we have very poor precepts that someone who’s regularly breaking major
precepts and at the same time the person also may not be particular generous, not so kind
to other people, be egoistic, materialistic and so on. And there’s no
basis in stored up good karma. Then when you try to focus inside
it may actually be not so pleasant what you first encounter.
If that is the case, if someone focuses inside and it feels a bit scary and dark
and so on, that may be an indication make more good karma in a in a basic
way. Just like the motto of the scouts and then every day a good deed or maybe
better every day 10 good deeds. being generous, being kind, being
compassionate to other beings, helping others, the supporting the SA
and then very important keeping the five precepts. It may not be so apparent
what is a direct relationship if I use some polite lie or
bit imprecise about the truth and so on. What has it got to do with watching the
breath? But if we have uh confidence in the
Buddha, we clearly pointed out it is related. And if we are doing unskillful
actions, even if we try to convince ourselves and we have some excuse in the back of our
mind that we have this faculty called conscience and we know quite well if we did
something which wasn’t good in the background it is there and that
darkens the mind and that reduces his internal brightness and happiness and
then it’s much more difficult to bring that up in the breath meditation.
So these two foundations accumulating good karma by good actions and keeping
the five precepts not to kill, not to steal, no sensual misconduct,
not lying and avoiding equivalent other intoxicants. Yeah, it’s
a very good basis. Yeah. And it’s it’s wild, you know, of of course I verified this in my own
experience because when I first started um besides having a lot of relief,
right, at first having maybe a semi- mystical experience, but then for the first year, maybe two years of my daily
practice, it was basically remembering all the things that I had forgotten about, unskillful um ways of treating
others and treating myself. And so there’s a lot of healing because I didn’t have proper meditation
instructions, right? Or like a teacher or SA to go to, but it was my own therapy. And so then I saw in vivid
detail the things that I had, you know, put off or um yeah, didn’t address. And
so I was I was um calling up people asking for forgiveness. There was um you
know, weeping when when it was appropriate because I was by myself, right? and just a lot of healing. And so
then it’s just it just gradually more and more where one one beer where I
could, you know, stay out drinking all night then eventually got to be one beer I would have a a hangover for like a day
or something. So I just I mean what’s the point at that point you know of doing that? So I just it gave that up
and then so I can see in my own experience you know from past action reflecting on
that and then going forward. So it’s so obvious and and in the Ty force tradition I’m really grateful for this
tradition too cuz it’s very practical down to earth um but the wisdom is very
deep and profound and it’s useful um very very very useful and I resonate with it and there’s a big emphasis on
you know the the the precepts and why I’m only a five preceptor through daily
life when I go and you know take on eight precepts too. So a huge boost in
practice. So yeah, I just wanted to kind of verify that for myself and I think it’s often overlooked in people that are
interested in meditation. Now a lot of times you know and even in therapeutic circles where I don’t know due to
certain laws that um some therapists aren’t really um there’s only a certain
amount they they can say about ethics, right? Um so it’s a huge it’s foundational and that that’s right. It’s
just kind of like the practice won’t go as deep or as far if that foundation
isn’t there. Yeah. You see this shows your wisdom faculty,
the pa faculty Josh that you could recognize in your own experience
the relation between you asking forgiveness, you doing the healing,
you improving your general interaction with other beings and the effect it has
on your meditation. Now the wisdom faculty is not necessarily what we consider high
intelligence that someone can
evolve in the beautiful mathematical proofs or theoretical physics but is
being able to recognize the causal relationships in our own heart between
things like that. asking forgiveness, being kind to others
and then actually being more calm in one’s meditation to identify internal
causal relationships and one can do that in both directions.
If you have a really bad argument with someone, we we get really upset, we lose
it, we are yelling at people and then an hour later you try to sit down to do
anapana. I think almost anyone can notice that the mind just can’t settle on this
subtle object. On the other hand, maybe your mom or
some elderly relative and you make a big effort to visit them, bring some
flowers, a nice gift, give them some time. They’re so over the moon to see you. And then you you feel so happy know
that someone can be made happy with something so simple. And then out of that feeling of
happiness, you sit down to meditate and suddenly this joy and happiness actually does
come up while you watch the west. It it’s so great and I love Lampur
Suchito’s um recommendation too of bringing that up bring recalling
goodness at the at the front you know and a little do some meta but sometimes
it’s on automatic you know so really let giving some time to transition into
practice I I find is really helpful and recalling goodness and the goodness that others have showed me and goodness that
I have shown as well it it really helps um um I guess center and brighten the
chitta for for for being with with the object the meditation for sure and you
know another thing he talks about is um energy and I haven’t heard too many ajons and teachers um in the typhor
tradition and other well some traditions I guess but talk about the breath in
terms of energy I guess Ajan Jeff does as well do you do you approach the breath in these terms You
totally you see breathing is not something that happens only at the nose tip.
If you look at it more from the modern western so-called scientific view the
breath is transported by the oxygen by the blood
throughout the whole body. Every single cell in the body is metabolizing oxygen
and the mitochondria. So even from that perspective the breath
is not just at the nose tip. Oxygen goes everywhere transported by the blood and
then every cell is metabolizing it. Or if you look at the Chinese system of
chi, you know, you do tai chi or chi kong and you know there’s this energy
flowing or the Indian system of prana. The breath is an energy which you can
subjectively experience throughout your whole body. And this is exactly what the Buddha
says in the instructions. We train ourselves breathing in experiencing the whole
body. We train ourselves breathing out experiencing this whole physical body.
And even I think he mentions prana is like yeah prana or the the poly
equivalent of um yeah so that’s it makes sense and you know we can experience the
different types of energetic qualities of the breath as we breathe in and out too and there’s just it just so many
different seeming causes and conditions that can go into it. Now another challenge I have too that I just
recently reflecting on actually is is convoluting or mixing together reflection and contemplation with
meditation. So you know sometimes insights you we’ll just say psychological insights will arise during
meditation and it’s okay um
it’s different when it there’s a conscious choice to either go with it or set it aside and continue with the
meditation. Right. Then uh but I think I conflate these two sometimes and think
that it’s part of the meditation. Um I mean one of the suggestions I I I hear
is you it arises and you just put it on a shelf and you can come back to it later. I think that’s the most kind of
straightforward one that’s agreeable. But um I I wonder if you have any other kind of advice for for either separating
out contemplation and reflection with meditation or or or what and then you
know like sati is also remembering so maybe sometimes memories will arise or
different connections will just kind of happen or we’ll see something that we
normally didn’t see see quote unquote before. So yeah and uh I think that will
go into the other phenomenon which is I I find quite prevalent of of a
distraction um and I’m speaking more to the situs side of this I guess um about just being
lost in thought or having a juicy alluring thought come up and then not
really realizing that it’s there. next thing. Uh I know I’m going into that and
forgetting about the object, forgetting about um I guess the intention or the purpose
and yeah getting drawn off course. So just some general suggestions and advice
for both um contemplation and reflection time and also dealing with mental
activity in meditation. The one thing that’s so beautiful about
anapana is exactly and that you don’t have to
think. There are other meditation objects that require a much higher level
of conceptualization and basically thinking. There’s meditations which are often
taught in terms of a little mantra meditations. the repeating Buddha or Buddho Buddho.
There are meditations like meta which is often also done more like a mantra by
repeating a formula. May I be happy and well, may all beings be happy and well.
A particular feature of anapanasi is that it is meant to really calm down
thought. It is something where we can finally we don’t have to think in our
society. We are constantly trained and challenged
to to think to think too much is such a big obstruction nowadays.
So the main idea from anapana sati propana would be to actually calm down
all the thinking and then to simply observe
you see to develop deep wisdom deep insight
you you can’t do that by by thinking anyhow this chint mayaan
you can develop a certain depth of wisdom understanding through thinking.
But to go really deep, you simply have to observe.
For example, impermanence. Whatever you say an emotion coming up
and it’s changing, it goes away. Another emotion comes. You can simply observe
that and know how it comes and goes. and maybe even see the conditions
that cause it to come up. But you don’t have to actually think that.
Say now I see you here on the screen. I I can uh I don’t have to think Josh
Josh but I still recognize you.
So the main thrust of anapana in my understanding would be that you actually
calm down the thinking and try if you then want to shift more over towards the vipasana insight
part of it to do that more by silent observation and silently recognizing
impermanence unsatisfactory not have.
You can also go into thinking for sure. And when you start calming
down and a lot of the obstructions and become weaker going down and then you
bring up a theme you like to think about that may also work quite well because
you have a certain level of samata already established now with the prana sati
and that can happen however that wouldn’t usually go that
deep. I would I would suggest that try to make
it really calm as calm as you can get at some stage. Most people notice that the
mind can’t take the the calmness anyhow anymore that it has to become more active again and that is in a good
chance to bring up the more reflective part of meditation. For example, they never neglect walking
meditation. The one option you can sit on a panasi you can also do it during walking but it
requires now quite some skill for most people usually easier while sitting
and then when you notice that your mind just can’t really go more into this
quiet and calm then maybe get up and now when you’re walking you you go for these
reflections which are more conceptual
But so importantly, you don’t have to necessarily think to recognize something as impermanent. There doesn’t have to be
a a thought impermanent. There doesn’t have to be a thought. This is the condition causing that. You can kind of
observe and recognize that with the mind silent
just seeing there just needs to be well the the
intention to do that right in in aiming and inclining the mind towards that practice. And I like um I I never really
contemplate or or notice that of that the mind doesn’t want to be any quieter. I think that I
haven’t heard that instruction before. That’s that’s really that’s really um fascinating. Um yeah, cuz I was
thinking, you know, they’ve got these these psychological barriers for me where kind of like you said, where
society conditions us at least a certain demographic, I think, oh, to get ahead,
you need to be smart and and that inquire requires thinking, right? And
then next thing you know it the identity is tied to the thinking and how well I’m doing that. Um so there’s that kind of
baggage to to see through. Um then when you point the awareness right at the the
thinking mind then it’s it quiets down quite a bit. Um but be maybe because due
to to a lot of habit patterns then when that dies down and then the mindfulness
dies off and then next thing you know just the really subtle thought will
creep in. Not that it’s an enemy or anything but then it’s there and this the habit patterns repeating and then
since the mindfulness isn’t strong enough usually then then the the habit pattern can kind of continue. So then
it’s this kind of back and forth of of then then looking directly at the
thoughts, them quieting down and then forgetting. So So I don’t know that that
was kind of a a push and pull that I’ve seen in in my practice. I don’t know how common or um unusual that is. Um but
yeah, it’s yeah, I think that’s what I wanted to say for now on that. Um
the way there are two parts to the practice and the one is thinking
skillfully and wholesome and beneficial. The other one is quietening the thinking
down completely. The Buddha describes now he did that himself when he was still practicing not
yet the Buddha. And the certain thoughts they are not really a problem. For example, if you
think may all beings be happy and well, may all beings be free from all suffering. You can think that all day,
it will not cause any harm to yourself or anyone and make feel very happy.
However, the Buddha recognized even if you have very and good thoughts,
it is still a form of agitation from a very subtle perspective.
So the more basic practice is usually to train ourself to think more wholesome
and more skillful. And if we have the mindfulness to watch
not every single thought but roughly how wholesome is my thinking and you notice
that maybe 90% of the day my thoughts are rather about anger or about
hankering after something or being irritated and only 10% are about may all beings be
happy and well and other holds some thoughts. it will be very difficult to quieten that one down.
If the proportion is the other way around and you notice that 90% of your
thoughts is on compassion, on kindness, on for noble truths, on causal
relationships, in one’s own heart of emotions, how they
wise and pass and so on. and only 10% is about me being angry or grumpy or
hankering after something. With that proportion, it would be much
much easier now to quieten it down. Really good points. Yes, it’s um just
thinking it’s it’s probably just I don’t know on the surface neutral, but usually
there’s there’s things that you know um
I like how cut like you made the line really easy, right? Um wholesome unh
wholesome examples. The other things they think of is just what about all the people out there on their day jobs and
working and all the stuff they have to, you know, use their mind towards through
their their daily whatever they’re doing for a living. And you know, I I don’t
know if I should get into this now, but it just seems usually without deep deeper reflection
may just seem like, oh, just kind of mundane, not really charged one way or
another, more functional. But I I wonder if that’s really the case. Uh, and of course, I’d have to do my own reflection
here before drawing up that AC assessment because I don’t feel the wisdom is strong enough, the mindfulness
strong enough to to make a percentage guess. Um unfortunately I wish I I wish I was I could. So I’ll take this as
encouragement to to do that reflection. That’s u very yeah very helpful. Um
it’s good you mention people’s normal daily life and their job. You see one
thing about anapana when the Buddha introduces it he usually says they say a
monk gone into the forest at the root of a tree or in an empty dwelling sitting
down cross-legged establishing mindfulness in front so it
is an introduction a very actually solitude where you have a very formal meditation posture
on the other hand for meta the Buddha explicitly mentioned whether walking, standing, seated or lying down and just
stay with it. So at least in my mind and also if you
read know the instruction of the Buddha there’s a tendency with anapana that you
become a bit withdrawn if you have a oneh hour session with anapana you know even if it goes very
well and you have the drawing happiness you wouldn’t really want to jump into a
crowd of people when you come out normally you would rather want to be a
little bit alone and quiet and something very refined. This is important to keep in mind. So if
you have to do some very stressful activity under time pressure with many
people in your job whether ananti is the best preparation for that I’m not sure
sometimes meta may be more helpful for that and what you can also do if you’re
in that situation and you do say anapana maybe in the morning
and now you have to go out and face this quite challenging world and your job and
so on, you may want to do a proper transition. And for example, once you
stop the breath meditation, the do go don’t go out straight away, but maybe
shift a bit more towards matter. I think if you bring up this matter,
it’s usually quite easy. If honor upon us that he goes well and you feel happy if we feel happy it’s usually easy for
us to wish others to be happy as well and maybe then to come out more on the
meta side and also to be aware of this whole thing that to come out and now to say okay now
please show me I have quietened my mind and now show me what have you got to
weaken that equinimity I have established to weaken that compassion and kindness
to take it as actively as a challenge because if you go out now and you want
to maintain this completely refined beautiful solitary state throughout your
daily life I think in very few jobs you can do that yeah I haven’t been in that situation
for many years now arranged my life so um don’t have to do that and in some
ways very fortunate for it but then can sometimes be quite challenged when I and go back into those situations. So, I I
find that really helpful, too, you know, because uh even a vacant building, you know, or a vacant dwelling, I I find the
the amount of peace in that versus even someone um in there, you know, almost so
the solitude is really important, right? And what other better dwelling than under a tree or in in a wilderness for
some people? Now, some people that might frighten them, right? But you know so the the idea here is in um somewhat
ideal conditions um and solitude for for doing this practice right and um I think
the only isn’t it the only thing that you shouldn’t be doing meta is when you’re sleepy but ideally we doing it
through all three postures all the time when we’re not sleepy. I mean, it’s a high bar, but it’s it’s it’s it’s such a
beautiful thing. And that is a dwelling, right? It’s a sublime dwelling. So, I mean, that’s appropriate to quote
unquote live in um no matter where we’re at. And it’s relational, too. So, I
think that’s what’s so amazing about the Brahma Bahares as well. And um yeah,
maybe we can’t go as deep with those, but it’s it’s functional, and there’s
going to be a lot of times when it will be very helpful. So, yeah. And um it’s really good advice as well.
Um yeah, and especially I’m thinking of the the more challenging relations ships
that I have sometimes that it’s yeah, it’s far better than just about anything that I can come up with, you know. Well,
and then of course when when when that friendliness meets um challenge, then it
goes to compassion. And um when we can rejoice, we rejoice when it meets
happiness. And then when I’m stymied and can’t do anything really at all, then the the equinimity comes in. So
yeah, what I mean is consider supporting your practice of honor panasi with additional
supplementary meditation objects. The breath meditation is fantastic is a
great meditation object. But there are certain things for example what I just
mentioned if you have to get into a very special situation to do that straight
out of this very refined state may be difficult
other things if if we really feel strong anger irritation
for sure if you’re really good in ana panat it will calm that down but there
are other meditation objects in particular loving kindness meta or compassion which are a more direct
antidote for anger irritation. Similar if it is more on the side of
desire and passion again if the anapana goes well it will calm that down but it’s not the most
direct antidote things like the death contemplation things like
contemplating the nature of the body the bodily organs that is much more directly the antidote
and effectiveness against the desire and passion. So keeping that in mind that it can be
helpful to supplement if you have anapana as a main meditation
object with other objects which are more powerful for
certain problems arising in the mind. Very good. And since we’re on the the
supporting thing, um some other things that are coming up as far as support is
this um like you said, if if it’s strong enough because some some say that if
it’s possible, you would stay with the object all day long, you know, through everything. And it takes an incredible
amount of uh mindfulness and who knows what else, right? that the if if we’re
in a retreat condition, it seems way more possible than if we’re going and doing who knows what in the the work
world, you know, depending on what kind of um task and people and situations
that have to be dealt with, maybe that we’d be even more challenging. And so the the techniques that you talk about
would be very helpful, even more so, but I think ideally we’d be able to stay with it. And I I just um wondering if
you want to stress the importance of continuity uh of staying with the object too as far as going more deep and
subtle. And then one of the other things I was wondering about too is so we have
the object the breath but we also have what’s the object the knowing of the object. So is there a way to how would
you say is there a way to address it on that side too? The the knowing the awareness um the attentional aspect of
it and if if if that can be supported and um how to work with that as well.
Well, I I agree with you that it will be much more easy, much more suitable to
try to maintain breath meditation continuously in a in a retreat
situation. I think it it will be quite difficult to try to sustain that through a typical
typical job people have nowadays and it may cause you quite a lot of uh
frustration and even resentment if you’re interacting with other people
how can you be fully focused on the breath I would say the main task here is using
anapana For example, in the morning in a quiet situation
and getting your mind to quite a good high level of mindfulness,
a high level of calm, a high level of equinimity, a high level of the wholesome joy and
happiness to face the day and then to try to maintain these qualities I just
mentioned throughout the day. But I think you will have to give uh the majority of your
attention and your focus on the task at hand. There may be some jobs which allow
you doing that. Fortunately, a monastic life for example
things people typically do a monastic life traditionally like sweeping the monastery or holding
some water. These kind of activities and some um wooding cleaning jobs. I think that that
can be done. You can sustain your honor. But the the level of speed and time
pressure and interaction required in many jobs. I think you have to be careful not to create a cause for
resentment there. If you can’t maintain that subtle meditation object
rather use it to bring up all these wholesome qualities in a sharp mindfulness,
joy, happiness and then try to sustain these things anapana has generated in your mind
throughout the day.
Yeah, that’s very straightforward wise practical advice. I appreciate that. So
the like the wisdom will know to what degree that’s possible because I I have no I found in my uh practice it’s you
don’t want to turn it into another thing to blame myself for not doing right right or why couldn’t I be with this
more and and stuff like that that’s not helpful. So it’s uh very straightforward
practical advice. I I appreciate that. Um what about the the attentional aspect before we start wrapping up here? Um uh
is there a way to work with the the awareness and the attention on the breath or the importance of that in
addressing that? No, but in a sense know the breath is always there as long as we are alive.
This is almost like the the old definition of death. They changed it that the breath stops at death. So in
that sense no can sustain it because the breath is always there
and to some extent we we can maintain the mindfulness but one just has to be
aware if you want to really keep that throughout your normal daily life and
lay life in particular even amongst life you will not be able to have that on
this refined level it would be on a much coarser level
the The other thing which you were indicating one thing is being aware of
your meditation object. The other thing is being aware of your
mind and what the meditation object is doing to your mind.
The second one is what people often forget about. They put now all their focus, all their
mental energy of being with that meditation object, focusing on that.
But we should never neglect to also have mindfulness and some focus on what does
it actually do to my mind? What is a general state of awareness?
Not getting lost so to speak only in the focus on the object but also recognizing being mindful what
is the general state of the mind and in particular how does the meditation
object now relate to that and influences that how these two now interacting
indeed yes very helpful and wise I I’ve I’ve um
yeah because at in it’s kind of like a built-in um gauge of you know what is
this even doing right yeah like you’re saying if we’re focusing entirely on the object and um the whole point is to
train the mind so then to to to see that as well to to know and see what is what
kind of effect is this actually having I find helpful to as you said well John I
appreciate you coming on today and um speaking to me and the audience and whoever’s listening this. Oh,
yes. It was a it was a joy, pleasure, and honor. So, I appreciate it. Um could
you I mean, maybe if it’s okay to say what monastery you’re at now and how the
maybe the services that are there. Do you have a Sunday service? Um just give
you a moment to draw attention to anything else besides anapana that you want to draw people’s attention to
before we go. And then if you’d like to just close on a final message briefly.
Well, I’m at Damagi Forestage in Brisbane. Damag.net. If you want any
more information, uh we have program every single day at least the meal offering and the
discussion after the meal that’s happening every day. Uh we have
meditation chanting from the afternoon. We have a morning precept and refuge
session every Saturday. One day full moon retreat
on the Sunday usually closest to the full moon. And uh please drop in. Please
Josh, if you’re ever here in Australia. It’s a long way away, but if you’re ever
here, please drop in. We have a beautiful stupa views. I I would I would love to because I I’ve
been doing um a Q&A with someone in Bris near Brisbane for years now and so I
hopefully I get a chance to to visit that area at some point and if if time permits opportunity permits I would love
to. So thanks again. can grow the trees. We are same latitude as Lumbini, the birthplace
of the Buddha, only southern hemisphere in the 727 degrees about the southern
latitude. So the Bodhi trees grow really well here, even though
I was wanting to get a cutting from one and grow one myself, but there’s uh in the climate that I’m in, it it takes a
lot of extra u care uh to to do it. So that that would be amazing. I I would I
would love to to see all the Bodie trees around there and imagine. So all right
Ajan, thanks again for joining and thanks everyone for listening. Bye now. Thanks for your
Integrating Presence is made with Jetpack Podcast. Full show notes and every episode at https://integratingpresence.com/
Things change and I’m due back in Denmark earlier than originally planned. In this fortieth installment of the ongoing live series with Wendy Nash inquiring into meditation practice on and off the cushion we delve into the areas of worship, respect and inspiration. How can some activities like pujas (easily) get attributed to worship when they are not actually that? How can we not fall into (blind) worship? Where and how does inspiration and that which deserves respect play into this? And where does all this fit into meditation practice? (This episode was originally spurred primarily by the billboard below)
According to Ai:
The billboard campaign was put up by the Knowing Buddha Organization in Bangkok, Thailand
The billboard has appeared along major highways near Suvarnabhumi Airport and into Bangkok, where tourists first arrive in Thailand.
https://factcheck.afp.com/billboard-calling-buddha-statues-and-images-be-treated-respect-were-installed-bangkok-thailand-not
Zen story on respect and worship:
On a cold winter night, Ikkyū was staying at a temple. Freezing, he took a wooden Buddha statue and burned it in the fire to keep warm.
The caretaker was horrified.
“How dare you burn the Buddha!”
Ikkyū calmly poked through the ashes with a stick.
The caretaker asked, “What are you doing?”
Ikkyū replied, “I’m looking for the sacred relics (śarīra).”
The caretaker said, “But it’s only wood — there are no relics in it!”
Ikkyū answered, “If there are no relics, then it’s just wood. Why not burn it?”
Later, when the caretaker saw Ikkyū bowing to a stone by the road, he asked, “Why bow to that?”
Ikkyū replied, “If you can burn a Buddha, you can bow to a stone.”
A short morning talk by Thanissaro Bhikkhu entitled “Respect Opens Your Mind” — https://overcast.fm/+AAvZro9lDww
PUJA: RITUAL THAT BRIGHTENS THE HEART
[Excerpt from KAMMA AND THE END OF KAMMA by Ajahn Sucitto]
In Buddhism, and in other religions, access to and dwelling in the heart-tone of bright kamma is occasioned by devotion and recollection. In Buddhism, this is called ‘pūja’ – an act of raising up, and honouring that which is worthy of our respect. The very fact that there are human models and actions that one can feel deep respect for is itself a blessing to take note of: honouring opens and uplifts the heart. With pūja, we attend to a skilful felt meaning, linger there and allow the effects to nourish the citta. From this basis, it’s likely that inclinations or even specific ideas in line with bright kamma will arise. Either that, or the mind easily settles into a state that supports meditation. This is how and why one should linger in any bright kamma.
So in the act of honouring the Buddha, one first opens the heart in respect and brings to mind the meaning of an Awakened One: someone of deep clarity; a speaker of truths that penetrate and bring healing to the human condition; one accomplished in understanding and action – a sage whose teachings can still be tested and put into action. If one has a Buddha-image, it’s something that should be held with respect – one cleans it, illuminates it with light, and offers flowers and incense to it. We place it on an altar, bow to it and chant recollections and teachings.
This is not a mindless activity; we use ritual means and resound words and phrases because this full engagement embodies and strengthens the quality of respect in a way that thinking can’t. With the openness of heart that these attitudes bring, any aspect of the teaching that’s brought to mind goes deeper.The act of offering that begins a pūja is a case in point: offering flowers symbolizes bringing forth virtue, offering light is about bringing forth clarity, and incense does the same for meditative concentration. In this way, pūja introduces the heart to important Dhamma themes.
Pūja is especially helpful when people perform it as a group. Then we are participating in the Dhamma as both the expression and the Way of awakening, as well as in the collective commitment to, and engagement with, that Dhamma. This collective engagement ritualizes the ‘Sangha’, that is, the assembly of disciples. Chanting in a group has a harmonizing, settling effect: sonorous and unhurried, it steadies bodily and mental energies and supports an atmosphere of harmony with fellow practitioners. Tuning in and participating brings us out of ourselves and into a deep resonance with heart-impressions of the sacred. We can be touched by a sense of timeless stability, purpose and beauty. If these intentions, felt senses and recollections are established regularly, we know where to find good heart, how to attend to it, and how to allow ourselves to be uplifted. Such kamma feels bright.
The expressions that are used in recollecting Dhamma are that it is experienced directly (not just as a theory), is of timeless significance, and is accessible and furthering for those who practice it. So that gives us an encouragement to look into what the Buddha taught and modeled: the way to the end of suffering and stress. With this, we recollect aspiration, learning and commitment as our common touchstone, and suffering and ignorance as our common challenge. Then we no longer feel so alone with our difficult mind-states, and we can handle them in a more open and aware way. Recollection of Sangha reminds us that although there is greed, anger and confusion in the human world, there are also people who cultivate a way out of that.
If you use pūja on a regular basis, it aligns you to the ‘Triple Gem’ – Buddha, Dhamma and Sangha – by presenting content in terms of images, ideas and themes, and values and practices that guide the heart. It also occasions acts of steering and composing attention. So pūja works both on what the mind is dealing with, and how it operates.
‘At any time when a disciple of the noble ones is recollecting the
Tathāgata … the Dhamma … the Sangha … their own virtues: “[They
are] untorn, unbroken, unspotted, unsplattered, liberating, praised
by the wise, untarnished, conducive to concentration.” At any time
when a disciple of the noble ones is recollecting virtue, his mind is not
overcome with passion, not overcome with aversion, not overcome
with delusion. His mind heads straight, based on virtue. And when the
mind is headed straight, the disciple of the noble ones gains a sense of
the goal, gains a sense of the Dhamma, gains joy connected with the
Dhamma. In one who is joyful, rapture arises. In one who is rapturous,
the body grows calm. One whose body is calmed experiences ease. In
one at ease, the mind becomes concentrated.
‘Mahānāma, you should develop this recollection of virtue while you
are walking, while you are standing, while you are sitting, while you
are lying down, while you are busy at work, while you are resting in
your home crowded with children.’
~ (A.11:12; B. BODHI, TRANS.)
. . . . ‘Or is there then, Vāseṭṭha, a single one of the Brahmans up to the seventh generation who has seen Brahmā face to face?’
‘No, indeed, Gotama!’
‘Well then, Vāseṭṭha, those ancient Rishis of the Brahmans versed in the Three Vedas, the authors of the verses, the utterers of the verses, whose ancient form of words so chanted, uttered, or composed, the Brahmans of to-day chant over again or repeat; intoning or reciting exactly as has been intoned or recited—to wit, Aṭṭhaka, Vāmaka, Vāmadeva, Vessāmitta, Yamataggi, Aṅgirasa, Bhāradvāja, Vāsettha, Kassapa, and Bhagu—did even they speak thus, saying: “We know it, we have seen it, where Brahmā is, whence Brahmā is, whither Brahmā is?”’
‘Not so, Gotama!’
‘Then you say, Vāseṭṭha, that none of the Brahmans, or of their teachers, or of their pupils, even up to the seventh generation, has ever seen Brahmā face to face. And that even the Rishis of old, the authors and utterers of the verses, of the ancient form of words which the Brahmans of to-day so carefully intone and recite precisely as they have been handed down—even they did not pretend to know or to have seen where or whence or whither Brahmā is. So that the Brahmans versed in the Three Vedas have forsooth said thus: “What we know not, what we have not seen, to a state of union with that we can show the way, and can say: ‘This is the straight path, this is the direct way which makes for salvation, and leads him, who acts according to it, into a state of union with Brahmā!’”
~selection from DN 13 Tevijjasutta — The Three Knowledges
*There’s naturally an ongoing open call for meditation (related) questions for the (roughly) monthly “Meditation Q & A” either by the various social media means listed; integratingpresence[at]protonmail.com or just showing to type/ask live.*
Regular, current and past visitors to Integrating Presence may recall the monthly series “Ask Us Anything” I did with Denny K Miu from August 2020 until January 2022 — partially including and continuing on with Lydia Grace as co-host for awhile until March 2022.
For a few months thereafter I did various Insight Timer live events exploring potential new directions and/or a continuation of the Ask Us Anything format while weaving in other related teachings to these events.
Then, after chats with meditation coach Wendy Nash, it became clear to start a new collaboration similar to “Ask Us Anything” simply and clearly called “Meditation Q & A” especially due to the original intent of the Ask Us Anything’s being “discussions about meditation and related topics.”
Past chats with Wendy:
Unedited transcript via YouTube:
Most welcome. This is Josh integrating presence in her skill. Today I have Wendy Nash back again. Wendy, how’s it going? Yeah, I’m here on Gabby Gabby country in Queensland in Kabula. And how’s it going? Uh, pretty good actually. I’m feeling inspired. So, not only in my dharma practice, that’s always inspiring, but also just generally in life.
So, but we’ll talk about that. Well, that’s cool. Yeah, I’m interested in hearing about that, too. Um, inspiration is always a great thing, especially uh when I’m lacking it, then it’s even more important. Um, I wouldn’t say I’m necessarily lacking it, but I don’t think I have a huge amount of it either.
But so today’s uh topic I’ve I’ve uh titled Oh, um let’s see here. I’m getting my screen up. if I just accidentally closed out one thing, but it’s called worship, respect, inspiration, and this is our 40th meditation Q&A that Wendy and I have done. So, yeah, that’s a little bit of a milestone. So, that’s cool. So, here’s the description.
I I put things um actually, I don’t need to read the the first sentence. So, in this 40th installment of the ongoing live series with Wendy Nash, inquiring into meditation practice on and off the cushion, we plan to delve into the area of worship, respect, and inspiration. Um, how can some activities like pujas, which we’ll go into what that means if you’re not familiar with the term.
How can some activities like pujas easily get attributed to worship when they are not actually that? How can we not fall into blind worship? Where and how does inspiration and that which deserves respect play into this? And where does this all fit into meditation practice? So, this came from a billboard um that I saw from a dharma friend.
And I want to see if I can actually share it on screen. Um but we’ll we’ll see. Um maybe I can I’m not prepared. Um, but maybe I can get that while while we’re talking here if it’s not too distracting. So, um, so let me just just describe that billboard before I throw it up. It shows the Buddha.
Um, this is a billboard in Thailand. It says, “The Buddha is not for decoration. Respect is common sense.” So, it shows a big red X over a Buddha head and saying no tattoos, meaning no Buddha tattoos. And basically, now I’m missing the other image. It’s there’s um an image basically saying they’re not for Oh, here it’s it’s wrong to use symbols of Buddha in the in the bar for decoration or tattoos. This means no respect.
And I also want to talk about this Buddha head too that’s in a retreat center that I was at that is interesting and how this um there’s certain um removals now of Buddhahads and and whatever. So we can we can talk about that. But so I just want to throw it over to Wendy here to see what Wendy makes of all this and where we should start with this too.
Yeah, it’s an interesting thing. So a long while ago I was in a cafe and they had a Buddha sitting on the counter and they had business cards on it and it was like a business card holder. And so I said to one of the people behind the counter, I said, “Would you have Mary or Jesus?” Turned out she was French.
So, um, she’s deeply Catholic. And she said, “Oh, no. This is completely offensive.” And, and I thought this was a really good way of describing it. Well, would you have, you know, Mary or Jesus do doing that, you know, and how how would that be? So I think we have as a sort of a non less religious society not understood that for some people Jesus, Mary, Buddha, the prophet Muhammad, whoever it is are key figures and you can’t des you know, you know, what is the word? Descrate. Descrate. Yeah.
No, this is a really um uh really So, what I wanted to do actually because of the potentially inflammatory nature of uh if I got too far to one side or the other, I mean, I’m sure I’m going to maybe upset some Buddhists by not being reverent and respectful enough uh with some of the things I might bring up.
Um, and these aren’t my personal beliefs or opinions. I just want to cover kind of the whole spectrum of this if we can as much as we can within a wise reason, you know, and as as respectful as we can as kind of an outside like archaeologist looking at things or something like this. And then I’m I I could potentially do that, but also um to the the to the other end where um that that uh maybe I’m too religious around this, you know what I mean? over that’s the other extreme kind of too fundamental and religious around this and not opening up um you know
maybe too orthodox. So um just just due to that and then all the things in the world going on right now. Apparently my my partner uh read some things about more war mongering and saber rattling and um war beating the war drums. And so and some of this um I would imagine has religious undertones, overtones um involvements and how this could potentially even though we’re putting it in context of Buddhist how it could potentially be extrapolated out to other religions who actually do worship.
So it is it can be a potentially sensitive in issue for for people on both sides whether people think that religion is horrible and it’s a cause of a lot of problems or other people who say it’s because we don’t have religions that there’s you know what I mean so it’s just on all sides you know uh they say not to talk about religion and politics in polite company but this this um this topic we’re talking about does play into our meditation practice.
So if um if we just just what I call the three breath highway. So I like to just close our eyes and take um just well a couple deep breaths before we even do the deep breath or the three breath highway and come into the body and just follow three full entire breaths from every moment of the inhale to any pause and then every moment of the exhale. So I’ll give a silence here.
It doesn’t have to be every single moment if you can’t do it. It doesn’t have to be exactly three breaths. Just staying with every moment you can. Inhaling, pausing, exhaling, pausing. And however it is, it’s okay. And I’ve just noticed that my breath is really kind of shallow and and fast now because of I’ve had a cup of coffee this morning, which I normally don’t before these things. I like to do tea.
And um and then with that, I’d actually like to have Wendy do a brief um reflection on loving kindness because that’s her main practice and how she does it. Sure. But I do want to say a highway is a like that is an inflammatory word for me because that’s about that’s all the car dependence.
We do not worship the car. Just say that’s right. It’s need if you’re like if you’re near a highway, you definitely need this. And we can change it to the bike path, right? We can say maybe a bike path or you could just say a path. There we go. Uh yes. How we’re getting on someplace uh where we can both be challenged extremely but also it can be of benefit to us um that we have a path.
Right. All right. So we’ll do I’ll do my my version which is very hands-on very straightforward. You don’t need to close your eyes, but if you feel like it, by all means. And basically what what I like to do for loving kindness meditation is to notice the small gestures that help you feel at ease.
So for instance, Josh opened today thinking ah it be really good to make sure that people who might feel unsettled by the topic would be um would like to feel at ease and so he created a meditation and then he thought well I too would like to do that and he knows that loving kindness meditation is an important uh aspect for me and then when I raised the name of it that he took that with some humility and response which shows just within these few minutes how important it’s been to just appreciate these small tiny gestures that Josh has helped us feel at ease and
that applies to anyone anywhere. So for instance, wherever you are here, where whatever you were doing this time yesterday, just think back to what was somebody doing to help you feel at ease. You know, whatever time of the day it was. So for me, it’s coming up to dinner time.
Did somebody cook? Did somebody clean for you? Did somebody text you something? Like somebody messaged me today and said, “You might be interested in this.” And it was actually two people did that today and it was such a lovely gesture. And so just looking for these small things. Did somebody turn up to a meeting prepared? Josh came prepared today.
Did somebody pay an invoice on time? A supplier. So these are small things perhaps we can take for granted. But just noticing any small acts in the last 24 hours that just made your life easier for the fact that if it hadn’t been there, you would have really felt irritated. So these are small acts to help you feel at ease.
So that’s the that’s the journey. I don’t know if that was okay, but there you go. So beautiful. And just let me reinforce this because it it also helps mindfulness and posit uh it counters our negativity bias because I I know that a lot of times I’m looking and the the problems stand out, you know, and I’m not always like this like this is an artificial container, right? And Wendy helps um provide that space and helps draw this out, which I would say this this is true and accurate.
It’s just not I’m not just not like this all the time, right? So, this is a special container where this a certain qualities can be amplified just like Wendy’s practice too. Uh, and it’s it’s authentic. It’s not lying or pretending some kind of um you know um some kind of um a uh affirmation that you know that I hope to get to someday. It’s real true.
It’s happened. It’s inclining the mind towards something helpful. It’s taking time. Then we have to review, right? we have to be mindful and use memory and uh recall uh things. So it’s it’s helping us and then it’s helping it condition to be on the lookout for this to condition the mind to see this and then to not as a theoretical thing but like an energetic feedback and can feel how beneficial this feels and it’s also I just go on and on like it’s conducive for relationships and interactions as well because you’re automatically
showing value towards someone else and not taking that for granted and how we’re all interdependent on each other. So yeah, I can’t say enough good things about this this um this version of loving kindness that that Wendy puts forth. It’s so it’s so beneficial, you know. And speaking of of relationships, my partner, you know, we have a relationship like any other relationship.
And every now and again I get irritated with him cuz that’s what I get irritated with myself. Why wouldn’t I get irritated with somebody else, you know? So of course I’m going to do that. And it just means that that time when I want to kind of get irritated, which is often it just I instead of being irritable, I just go, “Oh, thanks for doing this.
Thanks for doing that.” And we both do it. And it it just really creates such a nice space. So, it’s interesting how you talk about the negativity bias. I don’t think I’ve got that anymore because I think I’m just so I’ve been training in this for five years now, maybe a bit longer. I I’m just always looking for the good stuff and always noticing everything positive and yeah so things don’t work my well but work my way but actually I’m so trained to look for the good stuff I kind of go ah and then I go oh well oh well there you go
and it’s also helpful too once I have that momentum I found when I did this practice more then it when we really faced with something really negative in life it helps counterbalance that because I and reflecting on how I’ve been more negative Nancy or you know been in that kind of tail spin of negativity then the positivity helps balance that out as well you know and we’re looking we’re we’re trying to incline the heart and mind to things that are beneficial for us and for others especially in the long term now
I’m I’m not saying that so I guess the the the counterbalance is not to and Wendy’s is really good about calling out BS that’s what I another thing I really appreciate it and she does it in a kind helpful way too. So this is um this you know this is it helps condition the heart to deal with things that are negative and not beneficial in life and how then to go about the best way to deal with those to view with those situations and instances and then how to respond to them because if um if I don’t have enough resources to deal with that
then the tendency for me is just to match the same type of energy and just continue to go down the toilet or down the spiral right if I don’t have like a reference point and a strength of the opposite type of energy and uh view to to bring to a situation. So yeah. Well, you know, we talked about inspiration, so that’s inspiring.
And I recently feel inspired because um well, maybe I’ll talk about that a little bit later on, but I find that a really inspiring practice because then it makes me recognize the goodness in others all the time. So, I really like it. But there’s no polyiana. So, look, I have to deal with I’ve got a a not for-p profofit.
I have to deal with state departments. I have to deal with, you know, software producers. I have to deal with all that. And Yep. And I don’t want to deal with it. And I get really irritated by the letters and I and the interactions and all that sort of stuff. Um but but but but nonetheless, I think it’s more that we just aren’t looking for the other stuff to counter counter it. So that’s that.
So I think I don’t know. I found that a very inspiring practice and I think that’s why my partner speaking before I think that’s why we managed to have such a high level of respect for each other because he then notices every time I notice what he’s doing. So doesn’t give the opportunity for resentment to arise because he knows that I’m always noticing everything he does.
So it’s a sort of a respecting little I don’t know ping pong or something we’ve got going. It is. Yeah. It’s it’s compounding as well, right? And you know especially for guys I think is the it’s a big deal for guys to be respected or disrespected. You know what I mean? So uh if you you know traditionally speaking the masculine tendency I think these this day and age it’s it’s really kind of a big bigger deal for for guys I think is this respect or lack of respect and uh yeah we can we can go into that too.
And then also value we show that we value and things are validated when they’re kind of we get external reinforcement and external um cues and indications that something is valuable. something is valued. Yeah. So it and that’s kind of a feminine tendency maybe traditionally and so both it reinforces and helps both of these things. Yes.
So yeah. So I don’t go with a whole masculine feminine. I’m just not a feminine person at all. You know I just get cranky and I have to work with that and I so I don’t I don’t go with that sort of stuff. I’m much more interested in introverts and extroverts I find. And they it’s Yeah.
But but I think everybody wants to be respected. No one wants to be taken for granted. Exactly. And I think that often um everybody takes everybody a little bit for granted. And and that practice of just saying thank you every time you do something. Every time the other person does something for you, it just is fantastic.
And the other thing to do is to say sorry. And that’s respectful as well. And you know, it just seems like it’s nothing. Why should I say sorry? And it’s like, does it really matter? Just say sorry. Like, no one likes to upset anybody. I’m sorry I upset you. It uh I found in relationships, too. It saves a lot of time, hassle, and trouble and and squabbbling.
It’s just come out as soon as I can and admit my wrong my u shortcomings, you know. And yeah, it takes a it it takes a lot of strength and courage to do that for some people too. And I like just that like you say making it habitual in a way. It doesn’t mean that I’m um less than or anything like that.
It’s for I feel like the greater balance and harmony of um you know the relationship which then can have a snowball effect and help those around us and those we interact with too. So yeah, it really is. And and I’m I I think I’m learning that the hard way more. I it’s it’s like I should get that quicker, I feel.
But it better late than never. And did you use the word highway again? No, I don’t think I did actually. What did you I I misheard I was slightly distracted by We’ve got a couple of comments here. One is by flight because which is one of those random kind of are you guys on a date? Whatever. Not interested. So don’t post stuff that’s not about meditation.
And then somebody’s written Dave Thomas 30. He got Josh, what are you on? And I think that’s also an irrelevant thing. So I think we’ll skip that one. So if you’re hoping for an answer for that, delete. The uh the trolls are out. We don’t we’re not feeding the trolls, right? Uh but yeah, I’ll just just transform that into some playful humorous guy banter.
Let’s just say that. And just a haha, that’s funny, dude. Something like that. Um but okay so but maybe that’s also an indication to go ahead Wendy. Yeah. Yeah. So I looked up the etmology of the word worship. So respect and inspiration is one that sort of ones that we talk about pretty commonly here. Mhm.
And worship comes from the old English word. I’m just looking up in one of the AI things and it says worship comes from the old English word worthship pronounced worth but it’s got funny letters in there and it said which meant the condition of being worthy or honor dignity glory so worth means worthy or valuable and ship skip is state condition ship as in friendship or leadership by the 13th century worship began to take on religious connotations.
So it didn’t actually start there. It just meant that it’s worthyful. It’s a state of worth. Wow. So that is that. So that’s and I think I think that makes it much more like in that way. Okay. So by the 13th century, so 1200 something or rather worship began to take on a religious conversation conversation convers connotation and connotation.
Our friend M. Reed is here. Hello. So lovely to see you again. Really nice really nice to have you back. Uh worship began to take on a religious connotation referring to the act of showing reverence, devotion or honor to a deity or sacred object. Hence its relevance to us today. It has also retained its secular meaning referring to honor or respect shown at to someone of high status.
For example, uh we worship you know royalty or whatever. Modern usage today worship primarily refers to religious devotional rituals attending a worship service. It can also describe deep admiration or love for someone or something. Eg she worships her favorite musician. So, so this is completely different than what I take worship to mean now.
you know, um, respect is is from the modern day at least connotation that I have of worship is that worship is can be potentially distorted that there’s no kind of um thought process involved or wisdom involved that it’s maybe like an automaton um on automatic and that I’m giving my energy away uh mindlessly.
So I I don’t know if that’s an accurate refraction, but that’s kind of what I when I think of worship, that’s what I kind of uh think of that, right? Um now that’s different from like you saying the ethmology. So and I would say I’m not too far off maybe in what people think about worship or the way it’s sometimes used these days.
Now honor and respect might be similar to that, but it’s not um what I just laid out there, but it’s it’s it’s different. If I respect something, it doesn’t there’s a kind of a okay I um some people I guess do it on automatic pilot without thinking or they do it in fear out of fear or without um vetting if it’s worthy of honor and respect or not.
They just do it for other reasons. But yeah, so the the reason this also came up is cuz I just got back from a meditation retreat like at a monastery, right? A winter retreat where we were doing puja pretty much uh many days. And so let’s just for people that don’t know puja um how maybe I would describe it is just more literally in this context you you you go early and in the morning you’re you’re doing silent meditation and then after that period of silent meditation which is maybe around 40 minutes to an hour then we’re doing some chanting uh
out of a chanting book and it has it’s it’s about basically Buddha Dhamama sanga and various themes um for the most part let’s just say to simplify it and Um yeah and then um that that that’s pretty much what it constitutes and then in the evening it’s the the opposite or reverse where you’re doing some chanting first uh and then and then doing the silent sitting.
Um but that’s that’s the kind of then there’s a huge there’s a damah hall right there’s a huge Buddha statue a Buddha rupa at the front candles and incense are lit there’s monastics and robes and so we can talk about all these externalizations and there’s also bowing involved so that’s uh I think very uh foreign at least for me in the west to do the these type of things right so if from an outsider with no context just walking in and observing this from the outside it looks like a worship like um like I was uh you know raised in um uh Lutheran which is a
Protestant um Christianity and so they’re basically you know the things they say the the hymns they sing you know the the sentiments that are expressed even though it’s kind of dialed back and more I would say repressive that that is yeah it’s it’s that’s known as worship that’s my reference point for what worship is and they’re they’re um explicitly acknowledging that it’s worship in Christianity this some people would say this is worship and some Buddhists say this is worship um but some like me I I I wouldn’t consider it that and we have
to go into details of why I wouldn’t considered worship that I would consider it more inspirational there’s the word right and um respectful and conducive to meditation practice and faith and wisdom so there’s kind of maybe some splitting hairs here and some fine lines that we can I don’t know how granular We want to go into details on this, but I have put the image up now um for this as well.
Um and maybe we can talk about Wendy already mentioned one story around this. There’s so much to say for me around this, but I don’t want to talk the entire time. I want to throw it back here to Wendy and see uh where we should go with all this. Yeah. So, as it’s interesting because I have a completely different take on the word worship.
Um I got I was more like that with devotion. I’m like I’m not devoted. I’m not going to be devote. So I had a funny reaction and I think it’s just my own um childhood something or other. I I I don’t really have that. But it’s interesting. I’m supporting a friend at the moment who’s got some mental health issues and some marital issues and stuff like that.
he follows a different religion and I always encourage him to really think about the and he’s he’s very attentive to the book of that religion and uh so I encourage him always to kind of well what is the essence of that so rather than going through the ritual of it what is the essence and it turned out that he had been doing things sort of uh because he felt he should so through the ritual what you would call the worship and then I was going but you don’t really practice it and I think it’s because it’s got this punitive you should be you know doing this this this
is part of your um rituals your worship you’re showing your devotion and um yeah it’s been a very interesting experience for me to sort of see who somebody who is very very faithoriented actually to go actually I practice because I just I do go through the motions of it whereas I because I I mean he was born into that religion whereas I’m I was born into Christianity I suppose but not really and then I have found my own path into Buddhism and so I think I for me I mean I maybe it’s just me in the way that I see it
but I see it’s about practice There’s no point for me participating in a religion unless I want to take it with some um unless I want to become a better person. I don’t want to become one of these earnest, boring, self-righteous people. I can be like that. I’ve been like that. I’m still like that. But I think it is important also to recognize that I don’t know like everyone’s trying their best but I really dislike the whole ritual stepping it through the sun what do they call it the Sunday Christian or something you know I I
don’t like that at all because to me it just feels fake and insincere and I don’t care what I’m doing I don’t like it when people are fake and insincere and that doesn’t apply to that doesn’t apply just to religion. So yeah, I couldn’t agree more, Wendy. And that that’s the whole point of doing this because when I found myself doing the pua when I’m not when I wasn’t mindful, I found myself potentially going falling into that trap and just going on pilot, everyone around me is doing the same thing, right? And as soon as I lose
heatfulness or mindfulness, then I’m just kind of going through the motions because everybody else is and I’m doing this every day. And I don’t want to do that because that’s to me that’s not helpful. and then that could fall into worship and I don’t want to do that. Right? Wendy says, “How is this going to be a support for my practice? And how is this going to be a support for the the betterment of my life and those around me instead of just falling into another ritual that I do every day and and do it mindlessly and and it’s it’s just on
automatic, right? So so that’s the that’s the potential danger of this, but that’s not the intent in the practice behind it. I feel with with these pujas now I can obviously see how people can mistake it for that and I know firsthand how easy it is to actually fall into that.
Um but I can also see how this can be a very good mindfulness practice in the intentionality behind it. And also when I’m when I’m go to bow then I uh when I’m mindful I bring to the heart okay how authentic do I feel doing this? Sometimes I feel, oh well, this doesn’t feel natural. And then notice that as a as a response in the heart.
Other times it does feel authentic and natural and out of sincere honor and respect and one that’s going to benefit u my practice and those around me by showing u respect and honor to that which is deserves it basically and is worthy of it and and because of that is helpful. And yeah, this this notion um reminds me too, I want to say this, of um the the kind of head of the western SA in Taiforce tradition of Ajan Cha, the monasteries who has been practicing out in in um in England.
um Lumpur Suchito Ajan I’m sorry um Ajan Sumido uh um Lumpur Sumo he’s famously known for and I’m going to take this out of context a little and not paint the context but it’s just kind of almost a shocking statement he’s he’s known for saying if I’m getting this right I don’t want a bunch of bloody Buddhists you know and I thought that was actually really inspiring in a way a little bit controversial but what that for to me what that points to and I could be getting it wrong in our context is that he doesn’t want a bunch of uh followers and worshippers and people
that take this on as a religion. What he wants is sincere practitioners who are going to you know have honest uh true faith as best as they can and uh confidence and um you know the the qualities that are going to be helpful and also um their own sincere practice and ability to verify this faith and confidence with their own wisdom or the cultivation of wisdom through their practice of meditation um is kind of what I get about this. Yeah.
So, I guess the other thing to do is talk about the opposite of this is um dishonor and dis disrespect. So, I’ve got the you can Can you see the billboard up here in the screen? Okay. So, yeah, we got it up now. I can take it down a little bit after we talk about it. But yeah, just trying to turn my light so I got don’t look like I’m sitting in the dark.
Um yeah, it’s an interesting thing that you know what does it mean like who am I to decide what is what is fake what is sincere but it’s true interestingly I read an article about tattoos and there’s a whole lot of people who’ve got this eye disease because of the ink in tattoos so there’s some yeah so I think they’ve got like it’s a cancer let me see if I can pull it up so it just that’s an aside.
So, apart from anything, don’t get a a tattoo of a Buddha, but don’t get a tattoo actually in general. Yeah, I’ve had a guest on recently that talked about the dangers of tattoos, or I haven’t heard him say, but he he recommends it. I’m It’s almost more rebellious not to have a tattoo these days anyway because so many people have them.
So, here it is. A small but increasing number of Australians are being diagnosed with a rare tattoo related eye condition. It’s known as tattoo associated u u ititis and can cause permanent vision loss. So it’s to do with the chemicals they use in um in the ink. Yeah. And and they’re wandering around the body.
So that’s Yeah. And it’s interesting because a lot of people who are really into a lot of natural stuff get tattoos and I’m like they don’t re recognize that that’s just another thing. So yeah. Interesting. So Emmery has said authentic living the only way to live. Well, it would be nice if we could all do it.
But imagine if you were in a really horrible place and and actually being authentic created problems, then what do you do? Well, it’s it’s a really good point. Uh and so I think we kind of each know that for ourselves that that statement I I take to mean that people that are fake, right? That statement is meant for people that kind of know they’re kind of lying to themselves and that they’re they’re they’re not being true to um themselves or having honesty.
So that’s when I find it’s really but yeah just let’s preface that with just because I’m authentic doesn’t mean that I don’t have to be ethical now because you know I’m just going to be however I want and be real, right? That’s not what we mean by at least that’s what I take it to mean. So, so that statement I think is meant for people that are just okay, they see something and they want to be pretend to be a certain way because of certain reasons, right? Um, yeah.
And so, yeah, it’s a good point, Winnie, because that that the other extreme of that it could be overdone. Oh, hey, I’m real. I’m honest. I’m just going to speak truth the entire time and not have any regard for anything else. So, which is a good point here. So yeah, when we do this talk it just reminding of white speech here to to keep myself in check.
The first one is it true that’s and that’s the the most important you know is it honest and true to the best of my knowledge right now. Then is it is it kind because it’s then we can be inflammatory and cause which the next one we want to make it con um for concord instead of division. So that’s where the kindness helps out to bring concord instead of division.
And then is it the right time to say that say this? And actually if we get if I push it a little bit too far maybe it’s not the right time to go into religious fervor for some or can say because of because of the state of the world right now. So is it the right time to say it? And then is it necess is it helpful you know uh and then is it necessary is it is this really necessary to say and that’s a tough one because uh with yeah always chatting you know so Emry Emmery said move I think it means authentic living the only way to
move I think that’s where oh I guess to move maybe to move about in the world to to to to yeah we can we can ask for for clarification. Yeah, she said, “Silence has power as speech does knowing when to do one over the other.” A great chat. Thanks. It’s always lovely to have you here. Um I think you know there is something about the a pregnant pause or you know silence is louder than words often.
So there’s there’s that too. It’s a response as well. Choosing to remain silent is a choice in response as well. You know what I mean? not to speak out on something, not to say something, to hold back is a type of um response as well. So, let me um so we we’ve we’ve talked a little bit, sorry, I get this um we’ve talked a little bit about um you know the the the disrespect.
So for me um the let me just say the Buddha head um it’s if you don’t know this then then maybe fly in the radar and so education um from what I understand some of these Buddha heads have been ripped off of statues and things you know um like as kind of a well if you if you’re after someone’s head right you some waring cultures used to take it as a trophy so they would cut off people’s heads put it on a stake you know put it for display and say okay this is what happens to people to do this.
This is our prowess as warriors and things like that. So I I’m taking some people interpret it as that, right? They they desecrate um a Buddha rupa which in itself, you know, um uh is is just a form. So this is again this is a complex issue from what I understand. Actually, the Buddha uh if we’re going to be strict about this, he he didn’t want a lot of religious imagery around to begin with.
I think there was only approval of like footprints. um a wheel, an empty throne. Um trying to think of a few other ones, but over time um those became like uh because of our I would say I can’t speak for everybody because of our lack of decline in understanding and uh wisdom that those then beca those images that were approved u if I’m getting that right now someone chime in if I’m getting that wrong then meant nothing and so they were kind of empty and hollow.
So then we needed a more um a Buddha rupa like is a Buddha form to then uh have a reminder of like what this notion of the Buddha is or was and what it represents. So so then we have that and to me I it it depends how we use that. Yeah. It’s a reminder and Wendy wants to jump in here. Sure. Go ahead. I do.
I do. The Gandara Buddha which is the one that we see everywhere which is the robes and everything like that. So Alexander the Great um who was great I think according to his own legend rather than anything that anybody else did because he was pretty ruthless and nasty. Um he died at 33 interestingly didn’t live a long life but he brought it over from Maced Macedonia.
So it’s the Roman kind of robes and Greek robes that we’re seeing that’s that’s it is he’s buff Buddha you know he’s not emaciated is he? He’s strong and he’s tough and all the rest. So, um I’ll look up the history of that. Sure. Sure. And that’s my understanding. That’s one version. That’s right. That’s one version of it.
We do have like an emaciated uh Buddha. That was before he was Buddha, you know, as he was an aesthetic, but that’s not a common one. We do have thinner Buddhas, you know, there’s there’s Buddha Rupas from Burma that aren’t as, you know, big and buff and Roman-esque, let’s just say. Um so there’s various different types of Buddha images.
Um, where I was going with this though is okay, it’s like what is the intention in the heart and what is this respect now and I also go into the Zen thing that goes to the other extreme of how I wouldn’t say extreme but points out that some people are taking this over um being over um reverent towards it and almost religious towards it and then maybe mistaking the image for the actual thing and being overly um overly protective of it.
So, let me just read this little Zen story here that um talks to the opposite of this. So, on a cold winter night, uh I don’t know how to say this. I KK Ku Yu a Caillou was staying at a temple. Freezing, he took a wooden Buddha statue and burned it in the fire to keep warm. The caretaker was horrified.
How dare you burn the Buddha? I you calmly poke through the ashes with the stick. The caretaker asked, “What are you doing?” Um, he replied, “I’m looking for the sacred relics, Seria.” So, what this really um that this is what happens when um you um when you kind of um cremate a body and there’s things left in the body that science can’t explain and some of them look like gems, some little things remaining that should have burned up for regular people, but there’s now things in the ashes. So, back to the story.
The caretaker said, “But it’s only wood. There are no relics in it.” And then I answered, “If there are no relics, then it’s just wood. Why not burn it?” Later, when the caretaker saw Ikyu bowing to a stone by the road, he asked, “Why bow to that?” Iku replied, “If you can burn a Buddha, you can bow to a stone.
” There we are. So, I’ve looked up through my AI thing. The evolution of how the Buddha was depicted in art is a fascinating journey. So, it’s got pretty bad text, but anyway, reflecting changes in religious thought, cultural exchange, and artistic traditions. Here’s a concise history. So, the aniconic symbols, the 5th to the 1st century B.C.E.
In the earliest period, the Buddha was not depicted in human form. Instead, artists use symbols to represent his presence and teachings. the dharma wheel, footprints, empty throne or bo uh bodhic tree, lotus flower or a stuper. So early Buddhists may have avoided human depictions due to the influence of an iconism avoiding idolatry because the Buddhist physical form was considered too transcendent to represent anthropomorphic depictions first century CE onward.
The shift to human depictions of the Buddha began around 1st century CE influenced by several factors. Gandara and Mthura schools which is the first to third century Gandara modernday Pakistan Afghanistan under Greco Roman and Persian influence the Buddha was depicted as a human figure with helenistic features wavy hair draped robes and a serene expression hardly Asian.
Um this style reflected the Greek artistic tradition the Gandara Buddha Matura which is in India. The Buddha was shown with Indian features wearing a monastic robe and often with a halo. These depictions emphasized his spiritual authority and divine nature. Key features usha cranial bump the third eye the m the mudras the hand gestures.
Why the change? Cultural exchange. The Silk Road facilitated the blending of Greek, Roman, and Indian artistic styles. Devotional needs as Buddhism Buddhism spread. Followers wanted tangible images for worship and meditation. There’s your thing. Mahayana Buddhism emphasized the Buddha’s divine and compassionate aspects, encouraging more humanlike representations.
So as it spread across Asia in the 4th to the 13th century CE, China became Buddha became more round and serene. Confus reflecting confusion and dowist ideals of harmony. Southeast Asia, Thailand, Cambodia, Indonesia. Depictions include elaborate headdresses, ornate robes, and mudras blending Indian and indigenous styles.
In Tibet, it’s often shown with intense expressions and intricate mandalas. In Japan, the Buddha’s image became more abstract and symbolic with influences from Shinto and Zen. The buff Buddha, which is what I called it, um, as a jolly round figure, also called laughing Buddha or Buddha, is a misconception. Buddha is a hotel in Japan.
The 10th century Chinese monk known for his laughter, kindness, and large belly. He was not the historical Buddha but became a folk symbol of happiness and abundance. Confusion over time Buddha’s image merged with the Buddhas in western pop culture leading to the fat Buddha stereotype. Depictions of Sedata Gutama the historical Buddha uh remain slender and serene in traditional Buddhist art reflecting his acetic origins.
So there’s reclining Buddha which is in Thailand obviously standing Buddha shows him performing miracles or teaching and cosmic Buddha abstract formless representations in esoteric traditions. So it just depends on what your what your thing is your cultural artistic representations. So continues to evolve I think and so why is this all important you know why is this all important for like meditation practice and you know I we one might say well this is all superficial this is external trappings you know where’s the
real internal and and I would agree with that to a certain degree it’s just that uh we normally don’t interact in our waking life in the external world like that you know unless you’re a really deep accomplished practitioner you know that you can see through these these um changing form, you know, forms in the external.
But for a lot of us who are are not that accomplished and wise yet and who can see that this this this these these images are images are very powerful, right? They’re they’re huge. They they they they evoke emotions. Our emotions are with them. We turn on the news and how we can get triggered out by just seeing certain images. How um watching a movie can be completely involved in and loss.
So, so images are very um um striking and powerful and you know going to a monastery and but it’s not just some book or some idea or you know a statue or some guy on an island in Denmark you know practice talking really good stuff but like is that real you know is how is he when the camera goes off and things like this.
No, you go you can go to these places and monasteries today. You can see people um venerables that are wearing these robes and they’re they’re they’re holding each other to account of this very high standards of conduct and and practice. And of course they’re not perfect either, but there it’s a living uh breathing tradition today that they’re open to um you know seeking the truth of the way things are and the best way to go about it for their own well-being and and that of those around them.
And so it’s not it’s a it’s a real living tradition and that visual images are very powerful but at the end of the day how is all this affecting the heart and mind right this is not an abstract all mental thing not all emotional either but like where is the balance of heart and mind what is the benefit and and what are the drawbacks of all this and how I’m seeing it viewing it and responding to it you know where’s the balance yeah so uh Emry Reed says, “You asked the question, Wendy.
What does it one do in a not so nice environment, etc. I answered move, walk away.” So that’s where that Oh, yes. Got it. Okay. Yes. Yes. So, yeah. I mean, I think that’s right. So, we’ve still got another 15 minutes. Yeah. And so, I guess images of I mean, anything can be good or bad. And often I don’t know that we know what is good or bad.
And I I don’t know. Uh do we have to be perfect? No such thing. So I guess in terms of worship, respect, inspiration, if someone’s just going through the motions, how bad is it? Does it mean that you know in 10 years down the track when it suddenly goes, “Oh, actually now the some terrible calamity happens.
” and they go, “Ah, that’s what that means.” And they take it to heart. So, is that good enough? It’s a really good point, Wendy. And I think that’s for each individual kind of to know for themselves and figure out for themselves. Um, so here’s I want to read if it’s okay this this some of this passage from Ajan Suchito.
And I think this is really um the heart of what kind of pua is. So, it’s a ritual that brightens the heart. Do you think it would make sense to read read that? Um, yeah. Excuse me. How rude am I? I’m yelling. No, it’s it’s okay. Maybe I’ll just read a couple things. And so this kind of is the whole point behind this for for those who look at this and say, you know, maybe this is pointless or what’s the point of this? So in Buddhism and other religions, and this is from Ajan Suchito, in Buddhism and other religions, access to and dwelling in the
heart tone of bright comma is associated by devotion and recollection. in Buddhism is called puja. An act of raising up and honoring that which is worthy of our respect. The very fact that there are human models and actions that one can feel deep respect for is in itself a blessing to take note of. Honoring opens and uplifts the heart.
With puja we attend to skillful felt meaning, linger there and allow the effects to nourish the chitta which is the heart mind. uh from this basis it’s likely that inclinations or uh even specific ideas in line with bright comma will arise either that or the mind easily settles into a state that supports meditation.
This is how and why one should linger in any bright comma. So in the act of honoring the Buddha, one first opens the heart in respect and brings to mind the meaning of an awakened one, someone with deep clarity, a speaker of truths that permeate and bring healing to the human condition, one accomplished in understanding and action, a sage whose teachings can still be tested and put into action.
If one has a Buddha image, it’s something that should be held with respect. One cleans it, illuminates it with light, and offers flowers and incense to it. We place it on an altar and bow to it and chant recollections and teachings. This is not a mindless activity. We use ritual means and resound words and phrases because this this full engagement embodies and strengthens the quality of respect in a way that thinking can’t.
With the openness of heart that these attitudes bring, any aspect of the teaching that’s brought to mind goes deeper. The act of offering that begins a puja is a case in point. Offering flowers symbolizes bringing forth virtue. Offering light is about bringing forth clarity. And incense does the same for meditative concentration.
In this way, puja introduces the heart to important dharma themes. So, and then one more, I’ll just read another one paragraph. Oh, puja is especially helpful when people perform it as a group. Then we are participating in the dharma as both the expression and the way of awakening as well as the in the collective commitment to and engagement with that dharma.
This collective engagement ritualizes the sa that is the assembly of disciples. Chanting in a group has a harmonizing settling effect. Um sonoris and unhurried. It steadies bodily and mentally mental energies and supports an atmosphere of harmony with fellow practitioners. Tuning in and participating brings us out of ourselves and into deep resonance with heart impressions of the sacred.
We can be touched by a sense of timeless stability, purpose, and beauty. If these intentions, felt senses and recollections are established regularly, we know where to find good heart, how to attend to it, and how to allow ourselves to be uplifted. Such comma feels bright. And by comma here uh means action. So yeah, it’s this kind of that’s the kind of sentiment that’s um that that that I when I’m not mindful of that, it’s easy to fall away and fall into worship.
But that’s the whole point of kind of puja having a Buddha image and going through different kind of rituals and practices and chanting and things like that. So yeah, it’s easily confused as otherwise especially I think in the west when we have this uh when I have this um um other notion of what this is where you go to church you’re just repeating and believing without you know really verifying and not that there’s anything wrong actually I I it’s commendable to some degree because other having no ethics or having kind of um just falling into heedlessness and doing
things mindlessly that is is a better alternative. especially to start with than the alternative I find uh perhaps. Yeah. Oh, Wendy, I can’t uh so I’m I I’m not hearing you, Wendy. That’s all right. That’s okay. My mistake. I turned it on to mute. Okay. Uh Emry says, “Thank you for this chat. Was very insightful.
I also look into the ethmology of words. Thank you both for this chat. Nice to be here listening in.” So, always great to have Emry here every time. Yes. Um, yeah. I was thinking about the word worship and puja and the sort of ritual process and I’m wondering if what you’re describing is the empty worship like to me you worship is worship you know it’s just I worship whatever and and I think what I’m hearing is if it’s empty and if Like the thing that bothers me more is not so much whether you’re mindful in the moment, but that you are
a Sunday Christian for lack of a better word. And I think that makes it um harmful. So even if you fall for you’re not perfect, there’s something about um being say for instance in a in a meditation place and doing one thing and then you’re different the rest of the week or when you’re outside there. And I think that’s really really and then you’re self-righteous about how good am I cuz I go to the church, the synagogue, the mosque, the um temple.
But yeah, and I think it’s that that causes the problems. That’s me anyway. That’s so well put. I mean, I really couldn’t put it more clearly and concisely than that, Wendy. Uh and that’s what it’s about. And this is where and even that’s not perfect too, right? So if we do find ourselves in that situation, okay, now what do I do about that? How can then I be more authentic and um rectify or how do I address that? If I find myself in that position where I’m actually being, you know, self-righteous and maybe fake
about it or, you know, just being a Sunday Christian and then I’m considering changing that. How do I do that? and how do I not beat myself up over that and get out of that and be more authentic, you know, and be more real and uh helpful as well. So, so yeah, so that’s it’s a possibility to do that or or when I find myself falling into that, how do I how do I best address that without either beating myself up or uh on the other end not taking it seriously enough, you know, like, oh, no big deal or, you know, um
oh, I got to get out of that. On one hand, it’s I’m shouldn’t do that. On the on one hand, on the other hand, oh, who cares? I I can just do that. I’ll fall into that. No big deal, you know. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, we’ve got five minutes left or a bit less because we inspiration, too.
I want to hear about the inspiration thing you mentioned at the beginning. Yeah. Uh ah yes. So, it’s interesting. So, I have this community not for profit grassroots thing for more active and public transport in my town. And I I’ve done and I kind of am doing okay. I’m doing quite well given I started with nothing and I’ve done kind of okay.
But I was doing a course on communication the other day and it just helped me reframe how to talk about it with other people with more confidence. And there’s something about now that I like this is something I talk to people all the time and now that I know kind of how to frame things, what to look for and how not to frame things and how to move away from contentious for from from ways of describing it that are going to only end up down a negative spiral, so to speak.
then it’s been really helpful because that’s having felt sort of not very good at it and having this course and a bit of training and I’ve gone ah I feel so much more confident and now I’m going ah I feel really more inspired to go out and do more stuff. So I don’t know if that’s a good way of thinking about the word inspired but what I was thinking of is in terms of the dharma that we might not understand.
We sort of think we know understand. We go what am I doing? What am I doing? And then we actually somebody tells us this is a way of approaching it. And then we go ah now I have some confidence about how to approach it and now I can actually apply that really easily. So I’ve Yeah. So, I’ve just been thinking about that and how helpful it is. Yeah, you go.
No, that’s that’s great. And that’s where I wanted to go into this because this this way you illustrate here the inspiration, it plays uh hand in hand with this faith or we can call it um trust and confidence like you’re saying, right? And we can um we can see living examples of this you know and then that it can provide what you’re talking about.
So yeah, it can provide confidence. It can, you know, fa at least consider, oh wow, I really admire this in this person or this teaching and then oh wow, what would it be like if I could be you know like that or I could adopt the same qualities or I embodied the same type of qualities. How beneficial that would be for myself and others and how helpful that would be.
And so that brings about this uh kind of inspired faith and and trust and confidence. you know, we can kind of like borrow it or, you know, um, yeah, have support in a way. I don’t know exactly how to put it, but be inspired by that brightness and what what those qualities we see and know that it’s possible for us too to to train to be like that and to have the same qualities that we’re observing and those we respect and admire and be inspired like, okay, what do I need to do? I I’m inspired now. what what what do I need
to do to get there to be like that, you know, for my own self authentically? Yeah. Excuse me. So, what it really speaks to is that we learn vicariously. Like, it’s such a huge thing. Speaking of vicariously, look at that. Oh my goodness. Time’s up. We have to turn into a pumpkin. I will vicariously end this with you.
Yeah. Have fun everyone. All right. Bye, everybody. Thanks. Thanks again.
Integrating Presence is made with Jetpack Podcast. Full show notes and every episode at https://integratingpresence.com/
(Ai assist:) Saw Myint (a 52-year-old woman originally from Myanmar, now living in Sydney, Australia) shares her personal journey of healing from childhood trauma and mental health challenges through practical, non-religious insights inspired by Buddhist teachings.
Saw Myint is a qualified mortgage broker with a background in accounting who has also ventured into property development. She describes her difficult early years under age 10. Living in a comfortable but neglectful family environment in Myanmar, she endured exploitation and mistreatment by an aunt who lived in the household, treating her like a servant (tasks such as washing and ironing) while her parents—often fighting—remained unaware or uninvolved. This unresolved trauma lingered as painful memories and attachments, nearly leading her toward destructive paths, but she avoided them and instead channeled the experience into building resilience, humility, and strong interpersonal skills that later fueled her professional success in business and client relations.
Since her early 20s, Saw Myint has dedicated time, money, skills, and connections to helping others, particularly immigrants and those in need in her home country and Australia. At age 30, she deepened her engagement with Buddhist principles—not as a religion, but as a pragmatic, testable approach to reality emphasizing self-reliance, impermanence (anicca), and the end of stress/dukkha. She credits these insights with her recovery and forgiveness, enabling her to view even the abuse as a paradoxical gift that shaped her positively while rejecting any justification for harm.
Through her charity Wake Up, she promotes mental health awareness, urging people to seek help via helplines and professionals, especially in confusing or grey areas of suffering. She emphasizes promoting accessible support, as those in pain often feel too confused or scared to reach out.
Contact Saw Myint: https://www.facebook.com/likesawkmyint
Saw Myint presents two practical steps for well-being, accessible without formal meditation:
[Note: I, Josh, forgot to mention it during recording so added in the intro that this perception in the advanced step requires strong ethical commitment to non-harming and must not excuse any misconduct because if there is not strong ethical commitment, and there’s a unbalanced perception of “nothing is real” then this could falsely provide grounds for giving excuses for harming a la “it doesn’t matter, it is not real.” If nothing is real and nothing matters then this could also incentivize lack of right effort because “there’s no point to anything if nothing is real”. This is not what Saw means. I just wanted to put this in here to clear up any potential misunderstandings. I also forgot to mention that I find that belief and disbelief are not necessary when it comes to this. Belief and disbelief can be set aside while picking up these steps to try them out for oneself]
Throughout, Saw Myint stresses human imperfection (“we’re all a little crazy”), the value of feeling emotions without dragging them on, comparing oneself only to one’s past self, and letting go repeatedly for a balanced, happier life. She avoids dogma, aligns teachings with universal science, and expresses a desire to spread these ideas decentralized (inspired by S.N. Goenka’s model) via communities rather than centralized centers.
The episode concludes with her invitation to connect via her Facebook page for direct help or collaboration in teaching others, and a warm reminder: good and bad feelings pass—feel them, then move on and let go.
Takeaways:
(Approximate) Chapters:
0:00 Intro & Important Ethics Disclaimer
1:07 Guest Introduction – Saw Mint from Myanmar/Australia
2:25 From Accounting to Mortgage Broking – Life & Charity Path
3:12 Childhood Trauma & Early Mental Health Struggles
11:15 How the Aunt’s Treatment Shaped Her (and the Silver Lining)
13:59 Moving to Australia & Starting to Help Others
15:19 Discovering Buddhism at 30 – Recovery & Forgiveness
16:10 Charity “Wake Up” – Why the Name & Mission
17:49 Impermanence Basics: Good & Bad Things Don’t Last
19:37 Memory, Imagination & Attachment – What’s Really Causing Pain?
20:58 Easy Step 1: Notice Feelings Pass in Daily Life (No Formal Meditation Needed)
22:37 Death Reminder – Wake Up, Everything Changes Anytime
25:04 Advanced Step 2: Science + Buddha – Mind/Body Moving Millions Times/Second
26:51 Everything We Feel Is Already Gone – Dream-Like Reality
29:34 “Nothing Is Real” – Letting Go of the Illusion
33:18 Mind Precedes All Things – Dhammapada Insight
36:05 Practice Tip: Focus on Yourself, Be Present, Compound Effect
39:26 No True Present Moment – Continuous Letting Go
41:30 Feel It, Then Let It Go – We’re Still Human
44:22 Acceptance & Turning Pain into Growth
46:13 How to Connect with Saw Mint & Spread the Teachings
47:56 Final Message: Good & Bad Don’t Last – Just Move On
49:13 Closing & Goodbye
https://www.facebook.com/likesawkmyint
Unedited transcript via YouTube:
And just a brief disclaimer for this upcoming episode
when she uses this step two technique
that basically kind of arrives at a concept a perception of nothing is real,
everything is an image. Um, she’ll go into detail. I don’t want to spoil too much, but with as with any
of these types of things in spirituality, even though it came up at the time, I didn’t say it that it needs
to be taken with ethics and it’s not an excuse
to behave however you want or do anything you want because nothing is real. It’s all a dream. So, who cares
what I think, say, and do? It doesn’t matter if everything isn’t real like a dream, right? That’s not what we’re
saying. So there needs to be a strong commitment to nonharming in ethics when
we take on a concept or perception like this and you’ll see the relevance as she
explains it into the episode. So thanks and enjoy. Hello. Hey, this is Josh from
Integrating Presence and today I have Saw Mint with me. So how’s it going today?
Good, good, good. The sun is shining over here 11 10 11 a.m. in Sydney,
Australia. Everything good? How’s everyone? Yeah, thanks for having me here, George.
You’re you’re welcome. And so I was from Bur Burma, Myanmar, and where my
meditation teacher happens to be from too. So I’m um glad to to speak with
her. And yeah, I’m um we talked a little bit before about politics. We’re not going to get into that today. So who is
Saw? What kind of work does she do? Okay. So, it’s just a lady.
I am 52 years old. I have a husband and a son and a girl.
The son is 30 years old. The girl is 17. Um, I’m CBA qualified. I got to
Australia when I was 17. Now I’m 52. Um I used to do accounting but uh for the
past 10 years I’ve been mortgage broking. Lately I get involved in property development etc as my way up to
retirement so I could do more charity and um but I’m here to talk about my
passion. Okay. Um it’s all about mental health and um Buddha helped me but I’m
not in distri I’m not in any way distributing religion and but I want to appreciate who helped
me that’s why I mentioned his name um but you know I also suffer
mental health issue when I was young and I was so young under 10 that I didn’t
know how to get help and now I learned enough that I forgive
forget and I got over and that’s why I wanted to help others what I can not
everyone going to resonate with me I understand you know but um I’m here out
there opening up my story to help others okay well great yeah you know so so many
people that get interested in Buddhism you know there’s other reasons but a lot of people I meet is what I call the
ducador right come through the ducador or when things get really um let’s just
say really challenging and there’s no way to deny it anymore. That’s kind of how I did. But like what would you say
um what do you feel comfortable sharing about your story? Um and then how did you address it and maybe how did some of
the Buddhist uh Buddhist teachings um help with that? And uh you know it’s
it’s okay if we do talk about orthodox or modern Buddhism or whatever. But I I
don’t even like to word use the word ism. That’s a a western thing to me. I just look at it as okay here’s um a very
wise being um or even beyond that right it means awake and this is he shared
some things and he said go check it out for yourself. To me it’s just okay this
is reality. this is how I this is um the best um see seeing things for how they
actually are and then the best way and the best way to go about it. That’s how I look at it. Not as a religion, you
know, because there’s nothing to believe. You don’t have to believe anything. Yeah. No, no. See it for yourself. That’s what
he said. You know, like nobody helping you, no God helping
you. We got to help ourself. But he gave us the strategy and we have to practice
to find ourself you know we looking outside you know we finding others every
day but what about you you know and like people who are successful who are busy
also um busy busy but we never look at ourselves so we don’t usually look after
ourselves so we die young etc you know so it’s just a thing about balancing you
still have to live your life etc. Um so in the beginning what you said in my
story I I don’t mind sharing okay I started on social media um about this um
you know Facebook because I’m good at it mortgage broking I do video to add value
people come to me so but then social media they see me as a woman you know
what whatever I say however I look I look I don’t look pretty sexy right but
then people see me as a woman But here I think you guys have the right audience.
So that helped me you know. So yeah and Buddha even said you know um like
he said there’s only sand like the sw and the water in the wall. Okay there’s
a lot of swah in the world but he was only able to help handful of swah you
know. So you know what he teach is not a relating it’s the facts of life but not
everyone will resonate with him now same here you know I’m not saying any method
is right or wrong there’s different way and different people resonate with different thing I’m here out there if
even if I could help one person you know because I needed help and I didn’t know
how to get help and in every develop country there’s a lot of like help life.
I think we should promote more. You know, people who need help, they too
scared to come to you. We have to be like come come you know they may be
adult I was a child you know child don’t naturally know but even if you are adult
you people who are suffering especially mental health and that it’s a very gray area they don’t know how to get help
they’re very confused we got to promote our help you know that’s why I’m here to do what I can okay um also I think we
should promote helpline etc every developed country has all these help lines Right. Um yeah, even Australia,
Australia is very safe with gun etc. all these fightings and can’t I don’t know
what do you call you know m uh yeah I don’t know what they call but uh but there was Sydney famous beach
bondai you know there was a terror attack uh last week a week ago or so um
yeah 15 Jewish people died a lot of people injured um so it’s all to do with
mental health okay uh back to my story okay is it too long you want to cuz you
want me to go on specifically. No, I would just I’ll just echo that. You know, uh well-being, you know, the
um I don’t know if you’re referring to the suta, the handful of leaves, you know, where he he said he took the monks
of the forest, you know, what’s what’s more in my hand. The leaves in my hand are leaves in the forest. Of course there’s the leaves in the forest but in
his hand he said this is but this is I know everything or you know my knowledge is as vast as all the leaves in the
forest but all I teach is this handful of leaves suffering and the end of suffering or duka and the end of dooka
or we could say stress and the end of stress or even unsatisfactoriness and the end of unsatisfactoriness that
gets more subtle but yeah stress people can relate with this right and where do we turn so it this is about well-being
right? And um uh living a good quality life um more and more uh for our own
benefit and for that of others and and eventually all beings hopefully you know
uh since we’re all interconnected and especially in the long term too you know we really get more spiritual and then we
think even more long term than than just you know this life even maybe we can be
open to that too. So, so yeah. Um, yeah, I totally in agreement here. Uh, it’s
about because if we don’t have that, then all the other aspects of our life
are going to not be as good as they could be or not be as beneficial as they could be. So, this is core, you know, of
all the things he could have done, he he he honed in on this stress and the end
of stress as the most important thing. So, um, yeah. So, yeah. And then and if you want to
make it uh kind of relatable in your own story, you don’t you don’t have to really share much if you but then um
I’m happy to how you dealt with whatever you dealt with too and how you help people. Yeah.
Yeah. Um yeah, I I went intro too much and I didn’t get there. Uh what I was
trying to say is um he tried to help the world but only a handful of people get
it. So, you know, because um also I said in my um Bible, etc., you got to be
open-minded and face the facts of life and don’t see this as a religion. It’s
just a way of you know like just one of the practice to make your mind happy
healthy. So it it will help the rest like if your mind is
healthy and it will help your body and everything you do etc. Okay, that’s what
we’re trying to do. And and what he said is you know I think also because a lot
of people comfortable you know if we think we got everything then we don’t really look for the answer you know you
know western war even if you don’t work there’s a wayfair etc right but only
when you think you have a challenge you know you’re not comfortable you find the answer right maybe that’s why a lot of
people missed out because they feel too comfortable book right the government help etc. But then yeah I was lucky
enough I had suffer I had challenges that’s why that’s why I searched the answer and I I’m not a saint yet but I
got to the stage that I can fix myself you know that’s why I’m here to help. Okay. What happened to me is uh when I
was young under 10, I can’t remember exactly how old I was. Um I had my
parents I I never been rich but I never been comfort poor. I was comfortable. My
government give my late dad a big home as long as he hold the position. So like
a lot of my mom relative relatives come and live with us.
And there was my mom, younger sister, single lady, my auntie.
Um, she lived in my parents’ home and but she treated me like a little slave,
little helper, little servant and nobody a woman. People see me as I follow her
everywhere. I don’t know how I end up there, but she should know what is in my
best interest, you know, like she lived at my place. She know my mom um like you
know I don’t know I was put in a situation I don’t know how to get up she asked me to do her job you know I I
remember yeah like washing her Andy ironing for
her passing her day while she getting ready to go to um
I don’t know how to
Okay. Yeah, I can’t hear you anymore.
Sorry about that. If um if you could silence the phone too, that might might help because there was a couple notifications to just
Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Um Yeah. So, you were you were saying your aunt was kind of taking
advantage of like child labor. Um, where was your can I ask your mom? How come
your mother didn’t say anything or did you go to your mom? She didn’t know. It was a big people.
My parents are always fighting. She didn’t pay too much attention to me. It’s okay.
really um that’s why now um I do whatever is in my in the best interest
of my children you know I put up with anything so that my children are always
happy cuz I be there sa you know and you know I think that’s why people
especially developed countries say like be careful how you treat children they
don’t know but they remember it stick with me for a long time you know you
think they don’t know but you know they have suffered they remember but I did I
I turned into religion but what if I turn into drugs and you know everything
that bad for me you know so yeah I needed help I don’t know how to get help
I don’t even know how to open up my to my mother but she wasn’t close to me
that’s why I’m saying When you are someone who are helpful, we got to promote our help. People who need help,
they confused. They don’t know how to get help. I was a child, but even if you’re a adult, if your mind is in, you
know, like depressed, confused mode. You you’re not there. You know what I mean?
So, but then but then a few years later, my dad come
here to Australia. So we you know we moved to smaller home. So my my auntie
yeah she bought an apartment she move out. So that was all right.
But then you know I was in my mind back then like I always wanted to be free but
don’t forget the positive thing is she made me successful business woman. She
made me able to put up with customer people like you know and I am I have a
decent education but I’m not I have no pride in me. So that’s why people like
me you know she make me the person I am. I thank her for that but then I also
treated the right way. What if I I took drugs and you know all the other thing
alcohol blah blah blah and I go down because I have suffer you know Buddha
helped me so because of that since I was 20 years old I was always there for
people part time I I still have to work you know study said but I didn’t have
much money so with my money my time my skill my connection even to this
stranger people who come close to me especially in my country people you know they they try to settle here or people
over there I send money etc since I was 20 now I’m 52
um but when I was 30 I found religion I become religious and slowly help me
recover right that’s why I’m here to help others you know I’ve been doing a
lot of charity but then later I found that people never had enough even if you
help them with other things. So I f I want to help people with this. This is
like you giving you know something that you can’t attach money to it and if I
could help someone with um their mindset etc. They will help themsel be
successful whatever they want. Right? In business sense, right? If you have no
stress, that mean no limit. You can fly anywhere you want. You know, in life, if
you know how to handle the stress, you have a happy life. Whatever happened to you, whether someone leave you, you
behold you, you are dying, whatever, it’s all in your mind. You know our
body, we are dying. Okay? That’s that’s also wake me up. That’s why my charity
is called wake up. Okay. My accountant thought, “Oh, this word too simple.
Maybe there’s other people already taking it because it’s too simple. Nobody taken it.” Right? I was able to
get this name wake up, right? Wake up. What I mean is um what I’m trying to say
and now we’re a bit lost. So um yeah. So
all you you were going to say oh the the name behind your charity I mean this is a classic spiritual thing waking up you
know um yeah so isn’t it Mhm. uh even in life you know if you
stay in balance you know then you know it’ll help
whatever you face like you know okay so the method I tried to teach
which I learned from a monk a few years ago I think it’s kind of lost in
translation Buddha teaching but kind of lost in translation so if you are Buddhist or something you might not you
can find this method. Okay, there’s two step I I let you know first easy step.
What he said is okay before that what um wake me up.
Yeah, that’s what I was trying to say. Um now I got over but what wake me up is
that we could die any moment. Okay, all of us we look different but we all the
same inside. We all warm blooded members. Okay. And we could at any
moment that wakes me up, you know. So that’s why I’m here to tell other most
of us are comfortable. You know, even if we don’t work, government help us, right? But then knowing that whatever we
have don’t last forever, wake up. But then I’m not saying this to let you
down. Just face the fact so you can live with yourself you know because every day
so the m teach step easy step is what it is is every day while you living your
life there’s only good and bad thing happen to you okay what you got to
realize is they don’t last okay so okay good thing right
good food good drugs good sex do they ever last just a few minute Right? What
it lasts is memory, imagination, your attachment. Right? Bad thing. Someone
leave you, someone die, you know, terror attack, uh, flood, I don’t know, as
whatever. Yes. Sickness, old age. Yep. Yeah. O a sorry.
Yeah. Sickness, old age, sorrow, grief, lamentation, despair, grief.
Yeah. They also pass pain. How my aunt treat my auntie
treated me already gone. What I’m dragging on is my memory, you know, and
I can’t go back and fix it, right? It’s the past. What killing me is my memory,
my attachment, my imagination. Knowing that thing pass already, I can’t do it
again. And memory is a memory not real. Okay. So every day while you living your
life, I’m not asking you to sit down and meditate. I don’t even meditate because I got to I’m like a stubborn lady, okay?
I’m I got to um I’m more after strategy. It got to make sense to me whatever I
do. Okay? So if you know the strategy, you can
practice whatever you do. You don’t because yeah people can’t even find five
minute to see themsel. But we are living every second. Right? Why you living
every moment? You won’t be able to catch every moment. But when you able to catch
it, see that good feeling, bad feeling, good thing happened to you, bad thing happened to you, they don’t ask. Okay?
So don’t drag on about it. See um one billionaire tell me he’s 70 years old.
He said if you take could take me back to 35 year old self I give you
everything I have so because he can’t you know if you billionaire know that you could go any moment you know so good
thing don’t last bad thing you know well it already passed right so if we don’t
if we are open-minded face the facts you know look at yourself don’t look at
other don’t compare yourself with other others are not you. We have a different
I don’t know environment. We grow up different I mean you know we all the same inside but we we have a different
life right so just compare yourself yesterday to today and
you know try your best but and something not under control don’t drag on about it
even if you’re if you are billionaire you could die any moment you know and
even if you are dying you know good a healthy person could die
in front of you before you lucky if you have a cancer you know you’ll die in a
year other healthy people they don’t know when they’re going to die they could die tomorrow before you right so
that’s what an said you know good thing bad thing don’t get attached you know they all go that’s the easy step that
you can see right if you look sure yeah look first and even the even the Buddhist said that
you know just the time it takes to eat one bite of food, we could be gone. The time it takes for one breath, there’s no
guarantee. I mean, maybe there’s some really adept meditators and yogis and
psychics that know when they’re going to go, but for most of us, I mean, I could have a heart attack. I could drop over
dead, you know, bolts of light. We don’t know how we’re going to go. Yeah. And and there’s no guarantee. We don’t know
when, we don’t know where, and we don’t know how usually. Um, so yeah. Yeah. Everybody appreciate their life.
Everybody even they poor whatever happened to them they don’t want to lose their life right that’s the most
precious thing that don’t even last also the bad thing people treat you bad you
suffering you great but that also has passed nothing you can about it all I’m
trying to say is have a balanced life don’t drag on anything that good or bad they always a moment you know
this is impermanence right Anicha that you put it really down to earth that
Even uh positive and negative things, you know, they’re all constantly arising, passing away. That’s right. So,
yeah, there’s no need to get stuck on the the past like you said because it you can’t go back and change it.
And even the good things, how much satisfaction are they going to bring and maybe for a few moments or a day or two,
but then we’ll be wanting the next thing and the next thing and the next thing, you know, they don’t last either.
Nothing nothing lasts forever. Yeah. Yeah. Totally. But then we not say it.
We still human. We still a little bit crazy. We attach to our children, our
loved one. It’s okay. Like but just just be balanced. Don’t, you know, go to one
side or the other. It’s all about balancing, right? Because we still have to live our life. You know, normal
craziness is okay. It’s we still human. But then, you know what I mean? That’s what Buddha trying to teach. I see. But
to see it, you got to look at yourself, you know, and um and you know, be
open-minded, be able to face the back. So there’s always like criteria. Like if
you’re not that kind of person, then Buddha can’t really help. I can’t, you know, but that’s only easy step. If you
look, you can see this. But there’s another step. Okay? Another step we can’t see. That’s why I’m trying to take
it universal and making it scientifically because I love science. I believe in chemistry and physics. Um you
know because science say um okay science say things are moving millions of time
per second. Okay. And Buddha say there’s only mind and body in the whole world.
We well if to understand difficult subject we have to make things simple. Okay. He say if you look at it only mind
and body your mind or other people mind or other living mind or your body or
other people body or m living body that’s all we have in the whole world
right and science say mind and body are moving millions of time per second okay
so and there’s only two feeling good feeling bad feeling okay so when you feel good your feeling have to based on
something you no weirdo you it it it doesn’t b you know it has to base on something right you’re not crazy just
feeling weird or nothing so the your feeling good or bad have to base on
something but whatever you are based on when you feel that because mind and body
are moving millions of time per second we’re playing catchup whatever you based
it on is already gone or it’s non-living so we are feeling good about things that
already passed. We feeling bad about things that already passed. What stick our mind is memory, imagination,
reflection, corpor.
We are two in two different part of the world. You can’t see me, I can’t see you. But we think it’s here, right? It’s
all these our being human. You know, this is a little bit hard, but you got to concentrate. Okay, you get it. Do you
want to put it in your own work? Tell me. You know, I love this uh simplified
version because um you know, I’m working with advanced meditative practitioners
that are their wisdom and concentration is so sharp. they’re able to see these
kalapas you know these individual um in and Burma Myanmar is known for abidama
the really deep profound uh advanced Buddhist psychology and these
practitioners I I’m not there yet they can see these when you deconstruct rupa
or you know matter is as far down as it can be subdivided there’s supposedly
these things called kalapas that are ceaselessly arising and passing like you said millions I mean, I think it’s
mapped out in Abid Dhama how fast it actually is. And so, it just blows my mind. It makes my heart just fill with
joy that they’re they’re they can see these in their own wisdom with the the the the light of wisdom. Um, ceaselessly
arising and passing away. And each one even has its own characteristics. I mean, but we don’t need to at least see
that and know that in our own experience. I mean, that’s where I’m actually aiming for. But what you’re saying here is I love um the the
simplified relatable version of this that because we’re not basically sharp
enough or wise enough to see this even though science corroborates this. Right?
Um we’re too slow, right? So we have to use a concept to kind of grapple with this
because I I’m my wisdom isn’t sharp enough to see this. But some people can and I they’re very wise and I take their
word for it, you know. But this is how I can connect with with what they’re doing right now that everything is so quick
that there’s like this lag or delay. And so we’re all we have left is this kind
of concept or this almost like illusion or dream or delay, right? uh you know,
you’re just waiting for the echo to stop uh and then wait and then talk and then you know, it’s like a delay on the line
and then the other person has to wait and even though we’re going on, they’re sitting there waiting for the the word
to happen, you know, we’ve experienced this maybe on a bad connection or something. So, yeah, I really love that
uh concept. So, thank you for that’s helpful. Yes. Yes. And I mean there
Yeah. Um a lot of people don’t see and it’s okay we just human it’s natural and
we until we become like saint we we won’t see but if see if this concept
makes sense to you you believe in it then there you see you know because
science already say it gone already how would you be able to see if you if you say you see this you lying you know
pretty ones but you if you believe in science that’s why I’m trying to make it universal You know every people have
different religion. I don’t want to offend anyone that’s why but science is universe right not everyone believe in
science either but people’s science is science right that’s why that’s what
science say it they are moving millions of time per second that’s the reason we
can’t see if you say you can see you lying you know even say whatever because they also human they can’t see it just
how do you how do you know so you have you so I would just Hey um do
concentration practice right do all 40 meditation objects so where you can get
all eight uh jas and then master and then johnic mastery for all and then I
think it’s don’t give up yet if you really wanted to dedicate to to meditation I think it’s way more
possible than you think I feel you know but the the mind has to be really strong and powerful and wieldy and malleable
you know to do this and I I believe I don’t think that people that the very few people that I practice with that
that that can see, you know, um ultimate materiality,
um I don’t think I don’t think they can. They’re lying, you know. I really don’t think they’re lying. I don’t think they’re making it up, you know.
Uh because it’s already gone. But what I’m I’m trying to relate to normal what
I’m sure is like you don’t have to be a saint. You don’t have to see this. Just believe in
it. Right. I think all these belief drive your behavior and it will drive
you you know everything. Well, I am definitely inspired by those those beings who can actually do it and
I see how well their life is and so I in um I’m inspired and there’s faith for me
to know that there’s so much more out there than than I can see and know for
myself right now. Yeah, I have faith in that. Um so maybe listen to this and see
if you can relate to it and but if you can believe it if you believe it um take
this belief and just behave in a way that go with the belief and you’ll be
okay you know you don’t have to see it just believe in it because it’s science it even if you don’t believe in Buddha
um science is the facts of life right Buddhism is also facts of life but
People may get offended if they believe other religion but then you know you
know so um because we trying to relate to what these different people but then
you know test it uh you can’t really test you can’t see it so but um you know listen to this and see if you can relate
and if you relate be um behave in such a way then it will help you. So if you
have a good um what do you call if you have a good mental health like a good
mind and you know Buddha say you know all these meditation especially all come
down to is if you have a good mind it’ll help your body flow and out the blood
flow and that cure a lot of diseases you know naturally because it’s all related
right everything starts in the mind you know
first version of Dhamapata even you know everything is led by mind made by mind
and uh no it’s it’s everything is um mind precedes everything mind’s the forerunner mind is the chief you know
and this is something you can if you if you look at your own mind you know in the right way and with the right
training and practice you can see how this is so but I want you to tell me how um
could you explain a little bit how this this notion you’re talking about of everything that we’re dealing with is
basically in the past because it rises and ceases so quickly. So does this does
this give a deeper insight to the first step or how how does that help for people to know that or to believe that
as you say? Okay. Um so like I said I tell you the
easier version first the first step everyone can see but even there you have
to look you have to focus you know if you just you know every day passes we do
things we do things as a routine we’re not really focusing right so when you
focus you see what you’re doing when you’re eating a good food if you focus
You see that 2 minute is gone right? If you’re not focusing on what you doing
then you don’t know whether it good or you feel that and then you don’t see that it’s gone right. So while you
living your life if you look at yourself focus then you see that everything passes good or bad. Okay. And all you
got left is memory. Your addiction, your imagination, reflection. And see that
they not real. Your memory is not wrong. Your reflection is not real. You’re
seeing my reflection. It’s an image. It’s not real. But we think it’s real. It’s all these people, right? So face
the reality. That’s why I said you need to be open-minded. You should be able to face the facts of life. If you are
wishyw I can’t help, right? But then pe people who are in trouble they like
that. So before we get there I think you got to face your issue first and talk to
like realize that you have an issue like you suffering something and like I you
know you don’t have to tell publicly like us but then still talk to someone you know or next step talk to
professional this might help but there’s also other methods psychiatric etc. Right. Um yeah. So then when you are a
little bit recover and do this every day you passes and focus on yourself and see
that good thing and bad thing don’t last. Okay. And then that’s the first step. Then you see that what’s left is
your memory that you suffering from. I’m suffering from my memory of how my aunt
treated me. Right? And then you see I have to say that the memory is the
memory. It’s not here. It’s not real. Okay? It’s my addiction.
That’s how you see the second step. I think if you look at each moment, it already passes. So like going mind and
body are moving millions of time per second. We can’t really see with the human eye. Okay? Human mind we can’t
see. But if you know that whatever we have been feeling or good or bad is all
memory. So memory is not real is not here. If you can even just see that
that’s enough you know. Second step is advanced. You know if you even see that
good feeling bad feeling they already passes they just memory your imagination
they’re not real then you will wake up slowly. But every day you got to
practice slowly. Focus on yourself. Don’t compare yourself to your environment. People, everybody have
different life. You know, you just look at yourself. Just if you want to compare, compare yourself with yesterday
you and today you you know what I mean? And you will see and you have less stress. If you have less stress, it’s
good for people who are still working, who are doing business. It good for people who are dying. uh because you
know you know maybe you suffering say cancer or whatever um uh you know know
that you know you having a bad feeling but that also based on memory it’s not
here if you look at each moment right at the moment it’s also a little bit to do
with being in the present. Yeah, we got to practice to be being in the present basically mean you look at yourself.
Don’t look at if you look at yourself, you see, you know, you see what’s happening to you. You know, I’m saying
good feeling, bad feeling. Unless you look at yourself, you don’t
see whether you feel good or bad. You don’t see whether it passes. You know, you’re just in routine, right? So, yeah.
So, if you just look at yourself, take it easy. Um you know every day we
passing we doing stuff even if you can’t catch it all all the time even if you
catch 10 10 minute a day slowly help you know it multip it compound right you
know it’s a compound effect you know yes so when you’re about to die you know
that you know like you’re not letting go everything right
at moment We are letting go everything every second you know and our body Buddha say
physical body is dying every moment we can’t really
well what we can take medicine etc try to fix it but it’ll go one day we can’t
make it last forever you know so when you’re about to die something when you’re dying
everything you feeling it’s just a memory so you take it easy so you go peacefully you know this could help
people mentally suffering also people dying you know I want to help them you
know yeah so you know I what I what’s coming up for me now is that you know if we’re
we’re not ever really living in it when people say the present moment by the
time we can even grasp that it’s already gone so that in a way there is no present moment right so we’re in this
continuous dream state or we’re in this like nothing is really
yeah solid or real in a sense. So if we can’t even really experience the true
reality then like what’s the point of this and how I would answer that is like
we’ve been talking about is seeing this nature of reality that it is not
satisfactory ultimately right in that it’s fleeting and that there yeah and that’s the whole
point is to to to see this duca and to to have it um be completely
gone, you know. So, um, cease. Yeah. Yeah. Because even present is not there.
Yeah. So, your that’s what I’m trying to relate to is your good or bad feelings
are based on pretty much nothing. So, what I’m saying is if you’re feeling
good or bad, don’t drag on about it. You weird. We are naturally we our feeling
good or bad are based on nothing. Okay? So just let it go. That’s what I’m trying to say. You know whether you
having good feeling or bad feeling, you know, we still human. You feel good.
Okay, feel it. Then what’s next? Okay, you feel bad. Okay, feel it. What’s
next? That’s what I’m trying to help people to feel, you know.
Yeah, that that that that really is beautiful. And um you know like the what
is it you said earlier you know um ha having enough well um even a mountain of
gold would never be enough you know no matter how much people have they never have enough either and I’ve talked to
people that they’ve done everything in the west that society wanted them to do you know went to school got the house
the car the kids you know have the the job the vacation the retirement and it
didn’t didn’t you know they they gave it all up. They quit because it wasn’t satisfying them, you know, they they it
wasn’t making them happy. Um, now some some people it’s okay, that’s great, you know, but other people they want
something else. They want something deeper that there’s there’s more to to whatever this is than what they’re led
to believe. Um, so yeah, I just wanted to echo that. Yeah. So if you’re searching for good stuff,
it’ll never end. If you’re searching for but while we s when we suffering I think we really searching for bad stuff it you
go keep down and down it’ll never end either so just stay in balance because they don’t last you know you billionaire
you try to be trillionaire never last and you could go anywhere what’s the point well you still trying like I’m
still doing businesses but I don’t mind if you go tomorrow you know knowing this
you I’ll be okay otherwise I’ll go crazy you know where’s all my you know we paying a lot of tax here you know
otherwise what go I’m like you know I’m helping other with social welfare you
know and I when I feel bad like when people I love pass they leave me well I
can’t go back right I just have to move on you know and when you do business when you do job you know uh people let
you go redundancy whatever Well, there’s one door closed, make another door open.
You know, when you lose a business, well, you wouldn’t want to deal with that customer, that business anyway. You
know what’s next? You know, good or bad. What’s next? You know, you
feel it. I’m not trying to tell you don’t feel it. You feel it. We’re still human, right? We have to know also know that we
human. We’re not sick. But then let it go. It’s all able. It’s all about being able to let go. But we
can like we don’t have to be as safe to let go. If you do this slowly, you’ll be
able to let go. And that’s what it’s all about. It’s not
so much accumulating. It’s letting go, letting go, letting go. And how much do we have that we’re not letting go of
that we could and our life would be so much better, you know? And because we can’t take it with us anyway, right?
None nothing we can take with us anyway. So, yeah. And uh yeah, it’s just more and
more layers of letting go of things I don’t even realize I’m holding on to. And then sometimes I want to let go of
something, but I can’t. Uh and so sometimes it’s almost like it lets go of me when the time’s right, you know? Um
yeah, we’re still human. It’s okay. Slowly trying to get there and starting
with our issue, you know. Sure. Yeah. At least if it fix your issue
then. Yeah. And you know that that acceptance you’re talking about is really wonderful too. You know that that
mantra of it’s okay. It really helped me as well. And it’s okay not to be okay sometimes.
Yeah. We we human. You know, we’re all a little bit crazy.
And and that uh like I like to u borrow this phrase the golden question. You
know, what if the worst thing that ever happened was the greatest gift I’ve ever been given? And it’s it’s it’s it’s
wonderful how you thanked your aunt for actually helping you when it it seems like, you know, um that there’s no
redeemable value, but you turned it around and actually looked at is it a
gift? You know, not that abuse is ever okay. It’s just once something happens now, what do we do with it? And I really
appreciate your approach to this. And I I I loved my um my mind like uh seeing
through this new lens that you provided for me I find really helpful because the Buddha was a pra pragmatist right he
would teach people what level they were on and to help them all walks of life
and he taught directly so they could understand and it’s useful and he said if this didn’t work I wouldn’t teach it
you know so so I so let’s let’s start wrapping up
here why don’t you tell people how they can get in touch with you, how they can work with you, anything else you want to
draw people’s attention to. Um, and yeah, and then, uh, take take us out on
take the listeners and I out on a message, please. Oh, okay. Um, I don’t know if you got my
Facebook page. I’m always on Facebook. You can reach me there. Um, actually, I
I would love to be like, have have you seen Goinga?
Goinka the the meditation tradition. Yeah. Oh yeah. Familiar him.
I’m a woman because I’m like his strategy. I would love to reach
the world with this. So I can’t do all by myself if I’m teaching individual. So
I would love to spread this by teaching people who have community. But this is a
charity. And then they can spread it that way you know.
Yeah. So I think goinga this Buddha teaching that goa strategy
spread it even no man can spread it you know like because he he you know there’s
a his follower who want to who want to help others he teach them and they
spread it is like a multi level marketing it spread that way. No, he was a great business guy. Going was a great
business guy. Yeah. Yeah. Emma, I’m also a business lady and that’s how that’s my aim. So if
you are interested in you know helping other please come to me and I’m you know
I’m helping to yeah teach you this so you could help others. But if you’re
individual in the beginning I might also be able to help you directly but I would
love to help like going guys spread it all over the country I don’t need any
meditation center I want to decentralize it no one has a I don’t think going ever
want to control this but everybody still you know I don’t know listening to his tape like you know but then he never
that’s why he let it go that’s how he could be able to spread it. So, and all
what I want to leave. Okay. Um I just Yeah, we all human, we all crazy, but
then you we we all have issue. But um
I don’t know when you’re feeling bad, there’s also good feeling come, you know. Just know that good or bad feeling
they don’t last and you’ll be okay. Just move on, you know. you know uh if you’re
still feeling that or still feeling or memory which you can’t redo. Okay. So
just let it go. Okay. Okay. Thank you very much. My daughter calling me.
Okay. Beautiful. All right. I will let you go. Saul. Thank you so much. May all beings everywhere realize awakening and
be free. Bye now. Thank you. Thank you. Bye-bye. Bye.
Integrating Presence is made with Jetpack Podcast. Full show notes and every episode at https://integratingpresence.com/
March 2, 2026 Update: Things have changed and I’ve relinquished my retreat slot to a practitioner eager to return to winter retreat and take my place and am in UK for a short time until returning to Denmark
If you only have a chance to listen to this podcast or meditate, please meditate
Integrating Presence is made with Jetpack Podcast. Full show notes and every episode at https://integratingpresence.com/
(Ai assist:) In this wide-ranging Dharma conversation and a kind of follow up episode, Asoka and I discuss types of identity and self-exploration (e.g., her ongoing shaved-head practice as a lay eight-precept holder despite no longer living monastically), then pivot to the viral Walk for Peace—a 120-day, ~2,300-mile pilgrimage by ~18–26 Vietnamese/Theravada-aligned Buddhist monastics from Huong Dao Vipassana Bhavana Center in Fort Worth, Texas, to Washington, D.C. (started October 26, 2025; expected end mid-February 2026). Accompanied by rescue dog Aloka, they promote inner peace, compassion, non-harming, and healing through meditative walking (inspired by traditional Thudong but with an engaged-Buddhism focus), drawing thousands of supporters, media attention, and occasional challenges (e.g., confrontations with preachers, a traffic accident injuring monastics).
Key themes include:
https://www.instagram.com/walkforpeace.usa/
Takeaways:
“Inner peace is your strength.”
“You can only rely on your own inner peace.”
“Compassion for others starts with compassion for yourself.”
“Freedom from desire leads to true contentment.”
“Navigating duality requires a strong foundation in ethical practice.”
“The middle way is about finding balance in all aspects of life.”
“Self-honesty is a form of self-love.”
“Everything can disappear from your life in just one instant.”
“The seeds of inner peace grow from consistent practice.”
Chapters:
00:00 Introduction and Identity Exploration
02:28 The Walk for Peace: Purpose and Impact
06:32 Challenges and Encounters on the Journey
09:04 Inner Peace and the Brahma Viharas
13:30 The Role of Politics in Personal Peace
18:42 Non-Duality and Interdependence
28:39 Dissolving Boundaries: Self and Other
32:00 The Dangers of Idiot Compassion
36:24 Embracing Paradoxes in Spirituality
40:44 Understanding Compassion and Boundaries
47:28 Compassion in Politics and Society
51:42 The Importance of Authentic Teachings
57:32 The Significance of Pilgrimage Sites
58:25 Preserving Teachings Amidst Impermanence
01:00:00 Unity in Diversity: Bodhgaya’s Role
01:02:21 Defining Salvation and Inner Peace
01:05:09 Freedom from Distractions
01:07:14 Navigating Modern Challenges with Mindfulness
01:13:58 Building Resilience Through Inner Peace
01:18:18 The Middle Way in Practice
Links:
https://www.facebook.com/walkforpeaceusa
https://tricycle.org/article/what-do-buddhists-think-of-fort-worths-walk-for-peace-monks/
Past episode with Asoka: https://integratingpresence.com/2025/10/13/bridging-ancient-modern-bhutans-landmark-global-peace-prayer-festival-with-asoka/
Asoka’s Echoes & Stories of Dharma podcast:
https://echoesofdhamma.wordpress.com/
https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/78a58d8c-70d1-411c-8c86-b9c49d76e696/echoes-stories-of-dharma
https://www.instagram.com/echoes_and_stories_of_dharma
https://www.youtube.com/@Dhammaonthesidewalk108
Unedited transcript via YouTube:
Introduction and Identity Exploration
Holless welcome. This is Josh from Integrating Presence and today I have Ahsoka with me. Osoka, what’s happening?
Sorry. Yeah, you already said good good morning. So, good morning. Good morning. Good afternoon here in
Bangkok. Happy New Year. A bit late. It is. So, Ahsoka’s back for the uh
maybe a part two, but something different too. So, we’re going to figure it out kind as we go along. We’ve already talked for probably over a half
an hour beforehand about all kinds of Dhamma talk uh topics and I would consider a dama uh SOA dharma protector,
dhhamma enthusiast and dhamma globeer maybe I don’t know amongst many other titles. So um if there’s any kind of
introduction you want to give to yourself for people who haven’t listened to the first episode or we can skip
right over that and jump in to kind of what you want to talk to talk about today. It’s interesting that you’re
asking me this because I’ve been wondering myself in terms of identity. What kind of identity do I have? Do I
have a solid identity or not? None in disguise basically. That’s why my head is shaved still. Although I’m not living
in a monastery and usually how I introduce myself is an a precepta.
So an a preceptly practitioner. And um
can I add a little something? Go straight into the topic. The more I’m the more the more I’m watching the walk
for peace of all these monks, monastics walking and doing something which concretely contributes to let some
uh practices some schools of Buddhism actually be a little more known because usually Buddhism isn’t really proaliding
right especially they are very and it’s very it’s also very culturally
associated with Southeast Asia and you So the more I watch them, I’m saying
sometimes I’m really thinking why haven’t I ordained? Why I’m still an lay person.
So So here here we are in uh what what month are we in? January of 2026 for for
people that don’t know don’t know what you’re talking about. Um I would imagine a lot of people do because it’s been
kind of a media sensation. uh tell people a little bit about what you’re talking about this this walk for peace
and then why do you think it’s uh become so popular of all because I I’m I’m imagining things like this happen every
once in a while but just don’t get the media attention that this has gotten so far.
Yes. So, we’re talking about a group of I think initially there were 26
The Walk for Peace: Purpose and Impact
monastics and they come from a monastery in Texas
but I just found out recently as well that they had also done a similar walk
in India and that’s how they brought this dog Aloca how they brought it back
to how it were brought back to the U I mean brought to the US basically. So they at the moment they currently are
engaged in a 120 days practice of walking but while the practice of
walking from monasteries from places to places is very common in Theravada it’s
called the practice of tudong usually that’s what monks do during certain times of the year from monastery to
monastery which is a practice of normadism and a practice of non-attachment but in their case they
are doing it with a specific purpose of peace. So the message is peace. So it’s
a sort of engaged Buddhism. They’re walking for peace. In listening to so-called the leader, the the one the
monk who walks ahead in the line of monks. Usually they walk on seniority of
vasa. So they walk in seniority of how long they’ve been ordained. Something
like this. But I don’t know if they follow that in the in the current box. So I’ve listened to one of his talk you
know when they stop for walking or when they stop for having a meal or when they stop for for post um overnight he said
peace is something you achieve inside first.
So he’s giving he’s basically giving snapshots nano dharmat talk every time
to a population that is from all walks of life and and and that’s that’s very
we we we might be accustomed to listen to this you know develop inner peace
be mindful of what you’re doing before you talk be aware of your your you know
your mind’s defilements Be aware how you speak to others. Be aware how you position your body. Be
aware of of your actions and things like this. So body, speech, and mind. You know, these are the three components of
your training. But he speaks in a way that is really accessible to all and
especially people of all ages and all walks of lives. And he’s gathering momentum in the US at the moment. What
started to with just a few I would say just a handful of people you can count
on your on your two hands it’s now thousands thin thousands of people so what is going to happen when they reach
in Washington DC I don’t know but it’s going to be massive and the thing is they also
encounter some challenges so I’ve I’ve seen in a a video past few days they
were stopped on the road by by a preacher who was telling them stop
you’re going straight to hell because you’re diverting from the word of Jesus you know things like this so what was
interesting in that moment was the calm the non-engaging
and a very gentle way of saying okay we are not going to hell anyway but if that
is what you think we’re doing let us do it you know no you cannot do says
because I love you you cannot do this please don’t go to hell and he said we are not going to hell anyway if that is
your belief thank you so much for sharing it but we would like now to continue to walk because we are on a
different you know on a different path so these little events but the majority
of the encounters are really really a message of peace and also how to break
it down to really understanding how living in the world today requires that
Challenges and Encounters on the Journey
sort of inner peace that we’ve been developing with our practice or that we
might be more attuned to because we are in a we are
yeah to to just yeah to say the least and you know I haven’t followed this
very carefully I have seen it online and yeah it just surprises me how much media
attention that it’s got but of course the the message um the true message of peace if it were really sincere about
this and there’s no other political purposes involved which we’ll see you know what happens in Washington right uh
we don’t I don’t know the backgrounds of these these these monks or or anything like that but which just go on what’s
presented to us right this notion and message of peace the true message of peace is so very important and I feel
with all the shenanigans going on I mean I like my country, you know, and at the same time there is so much wararm
mongering and so much war that America is known for, right? And I don’t want to
have anything to do with it completely into nonharming. So that’s that’s the core. And so, but now when we take that
and leave that aside as a political topic and and internalize nonharming, that to me is peace,
non-conlict because um I would say at least in in the past for me there there’s so much
inner conflict, right? Uh just within us and so how is that going to inform how
I’m with everyone else? So once we have come to terms with this inner conflict
then uh of course my whole external life and my interactions and the way I re relate and respond to everything around
me is going to benefit when I work directly on such inner conflict and work
to resolve that and come to terms and and know how to deal with re relate and
manage that and let go of a lot of it too because we if we look closely within we realize a lot of it’s not really
needed and necess necessary and I think the Brahma viharas are are really helpful for resolving and dissolving
some of this inner conflict and not only that but relating to everything. It’s the best way I’ve come across to
relating to everything internally and externally is with these four Brahma viharas these four divine abidings.
Yeah. Yeah. So the four divine abidings is loving kindness and uh sympathetic
Inner Peace and the Brahma Viharas
sympathetic joy or you know supporting the effort of others also because
sympathetic joy say well I don’t like that fellow I don’t so I don’t care what
you know it remove you know it has so rejoicing I like rejoicing rejoicing yeah rejoicing at the success
of others and then compassion and equinimity basically equinimity
That’s a good Yes. I like this. I I’m a little maybe
because I speak numerous languages. So I’ve come and realize Yeah. But you know if you go into that language and speak
of equinimity it’s understood to a carteesian to a French carteesian structure of
language. It says yes but then I need to it’s not but if you speak about resilience it
becomes okay now I know what you mean but equinimity means I have to be equal
I have to so I I think it’s because I know a lot of languages I’ve come to my
understanding but yes so if I may just make a point the f one of the first talk
I heard about this monastic he said we we are not connected with any politics
it’s I my witnessing in my life as a monastic I’ve witnessed so much
suffering so I want to do something and basically along the road they speak to a number of
people and everybody start lots of people burst into tears and he said I’ve witnessed a lot of suffering and I want
to realize that that I want people to realize how that suffering is not
necessarily only caused by external condition but we we create we we might
be the ones who who are rep um maintaining it. So you have to
understand you’re training your mind. So he’s coming into that point of saying the mind and that comes with you know
start loving yourself. So you know loving kindness for yourself before for some people it’s very difficult to be
kind to themsel. So understanding that and then develop and understanding how
some of the what is called in Buddhism the three poisons greed, hatred and delusion or you can
call it greed, violence and delusion or whatever is you know how ill will I like
the word ill will. Yeah ill will how those are actually connected to everything that stands
behind the mind. So a root root they’re the unh wholesome poisonous roots. Yes,
exactly. I know that in Himalayan Buddhism it is also there are two more
uh in the poisons two more I have added. One is jaluzi
which is a jaluzi basically the opposite sort of rejoicing but it has other dimension and
also there is ignorance which is basically a ini which comes
as delusion but they they define it differently in the sense they they go it
goes from the point of not having not having right view. So your starting
point your starting point is already kind of unh wholesome in the basic
but I really appreciate the work that they are doing and that momentum that
they are gathering because I think it’s there’s there’s a seed being planted
there somehow it might dissolve and it’s not planned because there is an opposition as something happening
politically in the US at the moment it’s just that’s a good timing for things to happen you know maybe they will become
you know like Tiknatan also did something similar many many many actually that main monkey is actually
Vietnamese you were right in that sense anyway the braiharas to come to come to
the point of inner peace how do you develop inner peace when it’s completely crazy outside
you can’t avoid what’s happening outside unless you are in a position of decision
making or you are involved in that you can only work in your own leverage your own environment leverage and your first
immediate environment is your mind.
Yeah, I would I was just going to jump in here and say and this is why I’ve been so disillusioned by politics in
general is because it’s just if the problem was politically created, I don’t
The Role of Politics in Personal Peace
think another political solution is going to to solve it. So I I look at this and I look at politics in the
United States and it just goes back from left and right and there’s these two false choices. The only way I think
anything is ever going to change on a fundamental lasting level and maybe this is an oversimplification but it has to
come from within. We have to work on ourselves and that’s the only way really and I found this in my own experience
that when I change internally then my whole world around me seems to change. I
mean now if it does literally or not that’s not what I mean so much. I mean maybe yeah but it’s it’s how I view
things and then how I can respond to things instead of reacting right it’s
I’m able to see so much more than I couldn’t see before then working to on
these defilements like you talked about you know this these are like the roots of everything wrong in the world greed
how much of the ills of the world are driven by greed but we can’t just go and fight people that are greedy you know
because in the dhamapata right says ill will then ill will that’s the antidote
is meta or non-ill will so ill will never be overcome by more ill will only
by non-ill will it be overcome this is an ancient eternal law so these things
are done internally first I feel and foremost because if if I don’t have a degree of non- greed non-ill non-d
delusion well then how am I going to help change anything in the external world uh to the degree that I can if if
it’s there within first, you know, and so that’s that’s that’s the way I look at it. Again, I wouldn’t see the
value of this until, you know, um how do we get people to actually value that and
see how important it is? Because for us, it’s second nature and a no-brainer. But for other people, we’re trained
everything external, right? We’re trained to through is this is the external world. There’s nothing I mean
within that’s that’s something else for like therapists maybe or something like
this. Yeah. Yeah, but there’s what you what you’re talking here is people see
there’s a tendency to see the reality in terms of duality,
right? So the conventional the conventional world the conventional
reality which we need to act you know conventionally I cannot go to the bank
and say Josh promised me that he would give me a h 100,000 and Josh is my
friend so please behind I have to say I have to show papers my identity Josh
here yeah you can’t say money is a concept you can’t say money is a concept it doesn’t mean anything so you can just
give me all this you can just give me all this paper. It means nothing, right? Yeah. You need to use some of the the tracks
or the path that allow you to be conventionally to go from from on Monday to go from Bangkok to Bodgaya. I can’t
just teleport. Although I can do a lot of teleporting. I need to go to the airport and take a plane and physically
go to Bodgaya. I haven’t seen anyone yet flying in the sky. But maybe it would
happen. But this is one way of saying that we we tend to live in a dual world and that dual world creates is
reinforcing I think in my personal observation humble token it reinforces
the the the the how do you say the the triggering or the springing of these poisons of the unh wholesome roots
because I’m good they’re bad. So if you haven’t trained your mind to actually
see, yeah, but hold on. What makes me say this that I’m good, they’re bad. Yeah, okay, they’re not very wholesome,
but what can I do? Can I go to XY Z and say, hey, what you’re doing here is not correct. I could, but I don’t have that
leverage. And that’s I’ve had a long I’ve had several conversation with people talking even about people who
come from countries who that have been constantly on conflict right and when
you talk to them and you say how are you still alive well because I
develop compassion and eventually you develop compassion and you also realize
that to a certain extent you can’t function so you need to step out of this
conventional world and develop your own inner peace. Now for some people it
means stepping completely outside and maybe not developing training the mind but just I develop compassion. My state
has been in conflict. Millions of people have been passing away and dying for the
past millennia. It seems like it will never stop. What can I do as a human
being to stop that? Nothing. So I can step out. But other people say
those as you say for us no-brainer. If you develop your mind, you train the
mind to see that hold on as Gandhi was
saying somehow you know you have to do your cleaning in your own kitchen before you can actually do certain things. It
Non-Duality and Interdependence
means look at yourself first. You need to change you to have the change happening.
So oh yes but has never happened. I’ve made all those people walking months walking in the street will never make up
the America a peaceful world. Me being trained in mindfulness will never not
make my environment but it might make my family more peaceful. You learn to have a non to start living
in a nondual reality where what you put in comes back at you in a way but also
in a nondual world you realize how there is not just a conventional world there
is a different world that you can tap into. So when you start really observing
what is as you say for us maybe a little more normal you know you kind of stop having synchronistic thought with
someone you start having only realities that are made of meta so loving kindness
personally can say give you example you know there I never really have obstacle where people have obstacles why I don’t
know I live maybe in a So there are different planes of existence. But if you definitely only live on the
conventional level, you’re going to have several issues because the samsara is
made of these unh wholesome roots. And I think also if you remember yourself, the
Buddha also spoke about this, you know. Yes. So some someone the other day was
asking why is the Buddha always presented as sitting down and why is the
Buddha always presented as someone who detached himself from everything. I said yes he detached himself from everything
but to come back in a better way there is a level of detachment. You have to go
a little bit on feet. You have to step out a bit from what you accustomed to and that’s that comfort zone that little
void between the comfort zone and stretching in the comfort zone or stepping out where
how do I start? Okay, every morning
before you can decide every morning before touching the phone first thing I
take a breath. Okay, how is that going to help? Well, try it.
I’m just saying try this is because I scientifically it’s proven it works but if you don’t try you would not
know how can you I try not to be angry at being bullied well realize that that
person is having a bad day it’s not about you you know things like this it requires so much that
eventually the seeds of this m of the mindfulness path for yourself start and
then you start entering a completely different realm where
it becomes easy to go to the bank and ask for money from you know I mean living in around monastics also helps
understanding these how to because the monastics even though they on retreat they still have to interact with the
conventional world for instance receiving meals or in other traditions
as well having answer questions that for them are completely maybe irrelevant. You know, if they are not householders,
how can a monastic who’s not a householder, who’s never been a householder understand
the issues of a householder, divorcing, children going to school
because we, you know, for them it’s they are going to give you the base for you
to understand your own problem. So I think that that inner peace is the the
the seed of for for at least developing better
humans in this world somehow. And it’s important whether it is expressed by
walking in a walk of peace for 2,500 kilometers miles or whether it is to sit
down meditation. I don’t know what your take is on this any good raised so many good things
Ahsoka and um I think the kind of skepticism you present there is is
really helpful too cuz people you know what what difference does it make you know this kind of apathetic giving up
and I would say people in power they bank on that that that people get either
outraged in conflict or they throw up their heads and say what can I do I can’t do anything it’s pointless I don’t
care just going to check out and do nothing But even, you know, the Buddha said, “Drop by drop, the water buckets
filled.” I say this a lot. I use this a lot. But everything could potentially add up to something. So don’t think, you
know, good’s not going to come to me, bad’s not going to come to me or whatever. Every little thing does matter. And you know, the it’s cliche,
but the longest journey starts with one step. You know, we’re seeing that in this play out, right? So don’t think
that it doesn’t matter. I mean this gradual effort just a little bit here and there it will add up over time
especially if you keep with it and a seed like you mentioned a seed is another great metaphor for that you know
some seeds won’t sprout but others will and others will be very fruitful and and plentiful and beneficial and you know
others maybe are more weeds and sometimes they take really long time but they can get really huge too over time.
So you know you mentioned uh why you have all these good things coming and they reminded me of another suta that
basically uh preceptors they get their wishes granted in a way you know I don’t know I have to find the exact suta but
basically especially eight preceptors they’re saying that their their wishes are more easily fulfilled when they’re
keeping precepts. So it it’s it’s it’s really amazing how foundational this
ethical practice is for me and how important it is. And in Ty force tradition too I I feel in Thailand that
the precepts are really important you know. Now the non-duel thing this one
maybe we can explore more because I know this is you have more of a vajriana background and for me I I think it’s a
great concept and it’s it’s really helpful and some of these teachings are so deep and so profound and they’re
helpful to me. The one the few things I have trouble that let’s just say not trouble or maybe but I’ll ask you about
I don’t really have a clear definition on what nonduality means and then not
even the term non-dual right there accepts that there is a duality right so
how can there you know be nonduel with the duality and then but what I’m the
most um want to know about is how we actually take those non-dual teachings
and practices and then go on the street with the average Joe who is so far
removed from this stuff. It makes a lot of sense to me and brings a lot of peace and inner calm and puts me in a really
great mind state and heart state with these teachings and really contemplating and feeling into them and using them.
But then when I go into the everyday world, you just it’s just like I’m not to the point where I can just pretend
that Joemo that’s not the right way to put it. But okay, h how do I then take this wisdom of non-dual teachings and
then use it for mutual benefit with the just the man on the street, you know,
that’s completely asleep, you know, in either good ways or bad ways. So that’s well
the non the nondual nonduality has is put it in really plain terms not would
say almost non-technical or nonjargon or just plain really plain is that
realizing what is usually commonly called what you put in you get realizing
an form of interdependence of everything of your body speech and mind It’s really
literally the ball you throw comes back at you in that way. So it’s seeing you
say you don’t have certain things happening but it’s because you perceive
them also differently. So it’s it’s what we is also called understanding how different level of consciousness are
operating. There is a very popular thing if you have a golf ball consciousness
you just have a very narrow perception of the world is really to keep it plain
is like that is to to to to realize that the the actual natural state of things
that seems to be moving around or being permanent and stable but actually you we
just are passing by you know Bangkok will be here probably in 50 years but I
won’t be watching this building the same way because I might not be here. Nonduality is it really is having a
clear understanding of the interdependence of everything that occurs within body, speech and mind and
interactions with other people interactioning. So the other person, the
other people around there are a reflection of what you’re calling. Does
it make sense? No, it doesn’t make sense in it doesn’t make sense. But no, what I meant by what I meant by
to me those are interavana teachings, you know, that’s dependent origination. That’s the interconnectivity of
dependent origination. That’s kind of a trained mind um with with with samadei,
you know, and this is an kind of an expanded consciousness. But I guess in the some of the non-dual teaching and I
don’t want to get in the weeds here, but I’ll just say this. What what I meant by non-dual teachings is is stuff like there is no there is no observer and
there’s no observed, right? Everything is one kind of this when they’re presented in certain ways, they can be
like this watered down new age thing that’s not helpful. But actually what you said there is very helpful and all
those teachings are in in Terravada too, you know. But I I get this this self and other. I think that’s where it’s really
Dissolving Boundaries: Self and Other
helpful in a sense like how hard is there a self and how hard is there an other?
Exactly. Dissolving those boundaries that they tried and it’s really helpful dissolving those boundaries in some
sense but then dep mentioned comma too cause and effect intentionality. So, it it does help
dissolve these boundaries a little bit, but then um uh I guess I don’t know what it’s depended on, but then it seems
flimsy, you know, that’s that’s what I meant by that because it’s using kind of a mind trick to be helpful to dissolve
these boundaries that really aren’t there to begin with, but it’s almost like I’ve seen some people kind of
spaced out and not being able to take some of what they’ve realized or are seen or think they understand and then
they get when they take that to the quote unquote real world. I don’t know. It doesn’t doesn’t seem to translate
well or I don’t know what I’m trying to say here. But that’s you’re trying to you’re trying to see that if you apply if you don’t if you
don’t have a proper understanding or if you if your understanding is too much on
the intellectual level then when you step out it’s not going to work because
there is no other opening like the heart opening consciousness opening. you
haven’t developed what is called in the tavada tradition the parameies you you know to you know to loosen up this self
of this sense of identity the other day I completed a book which is written by
patch riush he’s a a young girl from the the lineage of tuluian riush so it’s a
karmakaju but he’s wrote this book basically around the concept of dignity and why am
I speaking about dignity and non-duality is because it comes into the sense to
dissolving the boundaries that you might have between I am these
are but at the same time understanding that you also have a form of integrity.
So other teachers call would call this having compassion and having to help.
Okay, this person is suffering a lot. I need to help. Can I actually help? Do I
actually have the skills to help that person? And how can I help? And does that person want to be helped? So it
goes that boundary can become very loosened and not understood probably
correctly deeply and that becomes what is called idiot compassion. Some other teacher call that the idiot compassion
like Chongyam was calling that idio compassion which means I have to help because I need to be compassionate. I
love to be comp I love to give. I’m a giver. So I need to give. But then you
lose your own dignity because you can’t sleep anymore. Maybe you haven’t eaten. It comes at the detriment. It it it
actually depletes your own capacities. And the Buddha also said that you know we do have this experience of having
this human life. This human body is given to us. It’s very rare because there are a lot more ants than there are
human beings. So it’s very rare to obtain this human. And if you have the chance to hear the dharma or to you know
understand a bit about your mind just have that dignity to sometimes say okay you can have compassion but it doesn’t
The Dangers of Idiot Compassion
mean don’t go too much out of your way and sometimes that fact that nonp
perceiving the actual understanding of non-duality means I have to help you know this you
and me is the same we are one no no we are not one because we don’t have the same karma. We come from diff at the
subatomic level we are one. We have we are made of the same flesh and bones but
we are not one because our intentionality before we were born and
during this no I I am a very very strong on that but you know I keep it for
myself because it goes against the summer but that no non-duality can easily become okay we are one we one
love no love is very important but maintain the dignity of your practice
maintain the dignity of your of your sense that you are not that so much important eventually.
So you’re you’re very right. So you’re very right when you speak about the self identity because it actually touches the
very important point across all the schools of Buddhism about non-self. So what we seeing today
is a lot proliferation of teachings coming in all direction including Buddhist teachings and and a lack of
understanding of that Buddhism is not neihilism
neihilism that you know there’s nothing exists so I don’t have a self so no matter what I do you are like me no it’s
the grasping attachment and the grasping is not so much about the assets it’s
about the sticky in mind. How do you stick to the stories you tell yourself? If you losen that, you start really
realizing nonduality. Yes, the other person is suffering more than me. That doesn’t mean that I have
to help every single person I meet on the road, but it means that I can be kind to that person.
Yeah. There’s so you know we enter another we enter another path
where this nonduality becomes you know it it’s it’s not like a concept you have
to it’s not like glasses you have to put in and remove it’s just your world
becomes a completely different world. So when you see things happening in the reality like wararm mongering and this
and this you realize why they are doing this because the unh wholesome roots and sorry for them
but I can’t change them so I have to only I can only rely on the my own inner
peace and I’m really coming back to that it’s really and I I was actually thinking and what
we were going to this to come to to converse about our conversation today and I thought you know I come up with
What is inner peace is love in action. Love for yourself first. But it doesn’t
mean you have to become so selfish that you don’t love. It means you even you
love your heart. You can go inside the body. You love the stomach. your love,
your start there and then everything starts softening up because
because eventually you can’t battle so much outside and by
developing that love in option for yourself you’re developing it for others
and then you can step into other parameies and then you can you know you start understanding on
I don’t know these are also the basics of healing you know there’s there’s a lot of there’s There’s a lot of healing
in understanding uh and practicing Buddhism as you want to put it just globally like this.
Exactly. So I don’t know great points here. So the self- loveve I
want to get on in just a second but I wanted to to address some of this what what um Soka mentioned here there’s a
lot of paradoxes you know and I found that a lot of the spiritual path is being comfortable with these paradoxes
because when it’s pres there’ll be one thing presented one way another thing presented another way and some things
are just paradoxical and that doesn’t mean that they’re they invalidate each other it’s just when we talk about
teachings like this and views. They’re just they’re they’re so subtle and so profound that a lot of times we don’t
Embracing Paradoxes in Spirituality
have normal worldly reference points for this. So the what needs to be pointed
back to again and again is an experiential level. So we’re just trying to put words to things that we kind of
see and know in our experience. And even though conceptually it it’s it’s really
challenging to put it uh put a lot of these things in non-p paradoxical language sometimes because they are they
are paradoxical. It doesn’t make them in invalid or not helpful. So I can I can totally see how people say you know I
can’t resolve this paradox. Yeah. A lot of them uh can’t be resolved. So I just have to be comfortable holding paradox.
And just a quick aside, I I found cuz there’s so much cognitive dissonance right in our world too. Like one thing
will say one thing and then somebody says the other thing and they’re at odds but I see the value of both of these and
that can cause inner conf or it seems to promote inner conflict too. But actually if we take these two things that are
causing cognitive dissonance and and we can hold them lightly and sit with them
then I’ve found yes it may be unpleasant but then these things start resolving
themselves and working out and being okay with holding these two seemingly
conflicting things. And then what I found is a lot of the distortions will
start to fall away and more understanding and wisdom will start arising and then be able to kind of see
through both and come to how it should be kind of held and responded to and
addressed it. I know that’s kind of a lot of fancy language. I’d like to give a real solid example, but just think
about two just take two opposing things and how there seems to be some uneasiness and if we can just hold both
of those at the same time in our awareness and sit with the unpleasantness that’s uh um involved
with that or comes along with that and see how they can kind of resolve each other and things can kind of fall away
and there can be some peace uh with being able to be with those. Yeah,
it’s also I think the other thing sure it’s also an understanding in doing these things there’s a very big
understanding that comes to or realization about how certain things
work in the mind is where do these thoughts all come where do they come from so there’s a lot of imagery you
know in Zen you say it’s clouds passing by so people who have a tendency to
visualize very easily they going understand why in the clouds but that doesn’t mean that it’s it’s just imagery
if you actually understand who and what and where are this thought coming from
and going and why am I sticking to it so I’m coming back to the dignity was saying the issue is not so much
having or not having is really the sticky mind and the storytelling attached to the
sticky mind where is it coming from this very strong sense of self that I am a
solid sense I’m a solid yes I am a solid person in in in flesh and bones but the
story I’m telling is basically my label my inputting my constant inputting that
I also I am more important than the other I am this and I am that and usually I’m coming in the elevator I
don’t want anyone else in the elevator and all this expanding expanding constantly and become so solid that that
becomes your reality But that’s not the reality imag. So that’s where there are issues.
So whether you come from Teravada or you go to Vajayana, you pass all the Miamika schools, Zen, Mahayana, everything,
everybody everything touches back on that point. So how you develop inner
peace, loosen up the grasping on that sense of self.
Clinging is the problem. Clinging like you’re saying the stickiness. I like that word sticky because that people can
relate to but clingy people know what it’s like for someone to be clingy. Clingy, right? So that’s where all the
trouble I mean that one is pretty much everyone can relate to, you know, and how when we can loosen our grasp and not
Understanding Compassion and Boundaries
cling so much how much peace and ease that we can feel in our own experience, not a theoretical thing but a real
energetic reality. And it is yeah just a few words about um you know the boundaries in compassion it’s really
important I find too that just because well for me my compassion practice is
first acknowledgement right so just acknowledging to begin with some people don’t want to acknowledge anything but
that’s like the first step then comes care and this is before we even do anything and for me that’s a really
challenging one because I have doubts about my own authenticity of care or if I’m caring enough, right? Or if I’m
caring in the right way at the right time. So, it’s a little bit different, I think, maybe with males and females
sometimes about that. So, males kind of show care in a different way than in general, not because we all have these
feminine and masculine qualities, too. But then it’s like this wanting for this pain to be resolved, you know, wanting
for the pain to release and then to know peace. Now, sometimes the most compassionate thing I can do is say,
“Okay, I need a boundary here. I need to get as far away as possible and then I can do this from a distance because what
I’m doing now is entangling with someone or something and I’m causing more problems than than I’m helping with. So
for me at times like that the I have to do compassion from afar because there’s
just too much conflict or entanglement. uh can always come back maybe but that distance and boundary is needed for
compassion you know and how do we have compassion for ourselves when we we don’t have compassion so we can have
compassion for the fact that we can’t have compassion right now too and as far as the the self-love goes to me a huge
part of this is honesty right because when I first started doing these I love you to my heart I’ve talked about this
before just didn’t feel honest you know it felt sappy and goopy you know and
just not helpful. But that honesty itself is a form of self-love, right?
Being honest with ourselves. So hopefully most people that are watching this have have already addressed this
this self honesty. But there’s plenty of people we interact with that haven’t got there yet. And it’s a huge form of
self-love just to be almost brutally honest sometimes if some of those people some people haven’t looked at themselves
honestly and they’re constantly kind of lying to each other uh themselves or are glossing things over. So I won’t
discount that as love either. And one of the ways that Ajan Jeff uses that I like for meta is just you know a really
practical thing that it doesn’t have to be an overt lovingness. It’s just may
you real not you Ahsoka but like someone that I have hard finding loving kindness
to or meta towards is may you soon realize the heirs of your ways for your
own b and change your change your actions for your own benefit and for those around you. you know, it’s a very
practical, real, direct kind of nononsense uh care for someone to
acknowledge no, they they’ve done something unskillful and harmful even. But so my well-wishing to them is that
they change their they see the errors of their ways and change not from a judgmental point, but for a from a a
place of care for wanting their well-being to to to come about. And to
me, the ground level is just an absence of ill will. You know, it’s not even a
an absence of ill will because that is so detrimental, you know, for me to
harbor that I want to hurt something, you know, even if it’s just a thought that I’m not going to act on, it is so
painful for the heart and has consequences and can start wars even with this with ill will. So I think
that’s some of the things I wanted to address around interestingly there you know I I was
involved in the global peace event in Bhutan so it was enormous major there were a
few days we got about 100,000 people it had different section I mean different
section different events in a one event but it all it all involved chanting
mantra or chanting aspirations, prayer, you know, like some of the parita sutas,
some of what you would call parita suta, some of the, you know, some of the very
cardinal chants also. So there was basically two weeks, 10 days full on
that. And what was interesting is being on the conventional level, I was really
literally involved in doing a lot of logistics and moving around. So I haven’t had a chance to sit down and
enjoy like most of them. But on the unconventional level when I was asked
and I had feedback with the prime minister said did you attend did you
were you able I said no it’s very difficult to be when you are the host to
also en you know enjoy the party usually you are the one however on the
nonconventional level the energies were there. So got this look meaning huh? So
it doesn’t have that you you but you get the energy of it. So that’s also a way of explaining non-duality in the sense
that sometimes we are removing ourselves from some places that we don’t feel this
is going to be maybe wholesome and sometimes we are in places where oh we gather we get the benefits of having
been there and it’s because at the unconventional level we have attracted that but what I wanted to say also
connected with that is that some people were saying yeah okay you chain You chanting chanting chanting
aspiration mantras. How does that help for peace? Or like you know the monastics now have been walking home.
How does that help for peace? You know having peace means sitting conventionally at a negotiation table.
Well no not necessarily and in part because we we you have to realize how
much leverage you might have to do certain things. So the if I expand what you’re saying about having compassion
for the self and having compassion for others but understanding
the interplay where we have an leverage or not you
start to realize how you can have compassion for some of these political figures that we see constantly on TV cuz
the idiocy of which on what they base their action is just so blatant you can only have
compassion for individuals like that and they are not just one there are many but
Compassion in Politics and Society
when you understand when I said that to some people they were how can you actually have compassion for such an individual I said just look further dig
further the ignorance at the basis of I mean the unh wholesomeness of of of even
their intention it’s not a matter of judgment it’s just it’s it’s a it’s just
a matter of acts. It’s separating the person from the defilement too. It’s their defilements
that are acting. Yes. Yes. Yeah. And they don’t know they are doing this. That’s where the compassion comes.
Come on fellow. You know, really I feel really sorry for you. The problem is that when you sneeze, everybody else has
a cold. That’s the thing. But this is also where I think it’s very what I am a
little concerned with, if I may step into a follow-up topic. What I’m a
little concerned is that and you know I we I can only live with it and that’s
where I really like to stick to
wherever are the lineages and the teachers and the traditions where still
what is called the perfect dharma is available. I like to stick to that. It’s
called in other languages it’s called the perfect dharma the true dharma and not the deluded versions which can lead
to what you spoke earlier the spiritual bypassing how come this non-dual thing
if you extract it from the you know you become become very secular it doesn’t I
go outside and it doesn’t work people are attacking me okay because maybe there’s something that is missing so
what I am concerned with and it’s been discussed a lot with a number of scholars as well is the world we are
entering where AI becomes a major agent. How can we contribute to I mean seeing
already online you know a number of delusion and Buddhism says this and the
Buddha said no the Buddha didn’t say anything of that how do we maintain
the uh how can I say the the thread the path is I think something that I’ve
learned a lot during the this year by connecting more and more with Vajayana
schools really check the lineages of the teachers you connect with. If the
person who’s giving you a teaching or the you know source on internet on chat
GPT double check your facts your sources your information but ask where is that
source comes from where what’s the lineage and that teacher can that
teacher give me the names of his own or her own teachers and it has to go up a
line of something then it has a sense if it’s just blah blah then everyone can
create blah blah you know that’s a little bit of a concern and I think all
of us who have been diving delving into Buddhism in a way or another whether it
is from meditation whether it is you know from many entry points I think we have a responsibility there
to somehow for me at least for me it’s really my my sincere aspiration to to
contribute ute to keeping tracks of what are the factors where somehow I
appreciate some of even any of the teachers who say okay eventually the Buddha said that it’s in the suta number
one in this book because at the moment it can go in any other in any direction
yes very important for me it’s very important just a few a few words on that this is
one of the whole reasons I was drawn to what’s called Buddhism is there’s not very many doctrines, but the one of them
it’s been called the doctrine of open inquiry. And so I was always getting in trouble in school. I would partly take
responsibility cuz there’s there’s a type of unhelpful doubt, right, where you’re doubting something because I’m
right, I know it, and I want to show that you’re wrong, right? That’s not the kind of doubt that I’m I mean that
The Importance of Authentic Teachings
that’s not a helpful doubt, right? But open inquiry is a sincere wish to to
find the truth and and and a truth that’s helpful in Buddha where um the Buddha said you know a poso come and see
for yourself you know you need to check this out and has to be seen and known for each wise one for themselves. So,
and how do I learn a lot of things as I ask questions? But it’s it’s it’s it’s it’s questions in order to get at the
real true meaning and an understanding and one that will benefit me and those around me and especially in the long
term. So, that’s why I’m just I love uh that it’s encouraged to ask questions
because some people take questions as oh you’re not respecting my authority, you’re doubting me, you know, no, no,
no, no. This is about getting to truth and holding holding things to and taking on the accountability. So I don’t
recommend everyone do this, but I say again and again in my stuff, you know, please if I’ve made any mistakes or you
can add something to it or give a little bit of a different understanding or teaching that will help me understand,
will help other people understand, please do so. if I’ve got something wrong, please reach out because I know
um you know that this is really important to me and um and like you said
the references and I don’t I get lazy about that too, but I’m I’m totally into that. This is what we have to work with
even to the point where I get a little bit nerdy on the original text. I would love love love to for like the Poly Tech
Society to list more in detail where they get the source text from and then
try to go trace it back to the most the oldest original text sources that we
have and then preserve those in images. I know there’s a lot of preservation in in different schools going on which is
great taking the images cuz some of them can be really you know flimsy palm leaves and things but we I mean these
are just as a scholarly pursuit so it’s not for everybody but I think the more documentation and the more details and
but I don’t know how we would do it for sorry and I just wrap this up because this gets into a little bit more
specifics than we want but you know some of these texts might be hidden or well protected too so I don’t know exactly
how to do that. You know, some of them might be interned and interred in a stupa or something protective somewhere
or maybe kept away from the general knowledge in order to preserve it more. So, I don’t know exactly how to deal
with that, but I feel you know since in terabad at least there’s no secret teachings that we can um trace trace as
far back as we can to the original text and have a cataloging system and a reference system to to preserve because
this is what we have to work with. Right now, we can go into a whole another talk of did the Buddha actually say this or
not. That’s another thing. But we we to to to have well organized and documented
what we do have to work with. It’s really important you know. Yeah.
That that as well. But you know that there’s been several councils because initially it was it it was a tradition.
So we have to rely we have to rely but the the the Mahabhi society in Bangalore
and the Pali society in also in Sri Lanka has I mean there’s the Palanon and
the Pali society they they Sri Lanka is actually a a good
repository of of the original the original um original text or whatever original
quotes or original teachings of the manuscript too. I’m not talking about the physical manuscripts like the palm
leaf manuscripts and the Gandahar fragments and all these things. I even went to the British library and and
talked to one of the librarians about a little bit of this. But yeah, and there’s huge digitalization efforts
underway too. So I think these are all really cool things and there’s so many text. Yeah. Apparently, they also
uncovered thanks to AI and thanks to um GPS
and GP GP. No, no, GIS GIS and GPS. So, the the JO
the Jol location and J the localization but of how the Earth and the movements.
Oh, GPS global positioning satellite. Yes. Yeah. GIS and they’re the one that
actually GPS is more like the map but it doesn’t give you the actual
location that you know the actual layers of the territory. So apparently they found some old Buddhist societies under
some guts in India. So things that have yeah that were
covered over the years. So they found also yeah I show you I will show you.
Yeah. No no I have the there’s a book in search of the Buddha. So it was a, you know, they literally unearthed so many
things like some of the Ahsoka pillars even, you know, and so many things that were literally buried in India. It was
some old white guys, European white guys that unearthed a lot of this stuff in
India in what the late in the 17 1800s. So yeah, quite incredible.
Yes. And they also now the state of Odisha which is a southern eastern state. It’s
in between west Bengal and Tamiladu somewhere in that area towards
it’s between Chennai and Kolkata somewhere over there the state of Odisha actually has also has unearthed a number
of places therei alagiri there’s a number of places there so there are now festivals starting
chanting tipitaka and guruba sambaba festivals being organized over there I
can also send you si san yes Yeah. So, there’s a lot happening, but okay. How does that help
The Significance of Pilgrimage Sites
with inner peace? Well, that’s right. So, that’s a good thing. We talked a little bit about
things that inspire, you know, we have these, you know, some people get overly involved in physical things or physical
locations, but I think if they can inspire faith and then draw people to the practice, then it can be very
helpful. And it’s it’s it’s interesting to hold this too when it’s even prophesized that you know this sassa
this Buddha’s dispensation will eventually come to an end you know it won’t last forever within permanence. So
holding this another paradox of okay, how do we best preserve and represent
the what teachings we have and then at the same time knowing they will eventually come to an end, you know, and
and die out and and holding these two and being okay with that and doing what we can to to
skillfully act with with these paradoxical things here. Yeah. Yes. So on Monday I’m traveling and I’m
Preserving Teachings Amidst Impermanence
starting a three months journey again being on the road but I’m starting with
a month in Bgaya and I I was recently uh hearing so I’ve met
Lu Poasano in December who he pass from the Tai for one elder of the tri forest
tradition here in Bangkok passing by he had he was on his he had just come back
from Bulgaya Then I met last week Abot the Abjaniko
who is the abot of Abayagiri monastery in the redwood valley and he had spent a
month on the pilgrimage on the holy places in sat. So we were also talking about Bodgaya and now I’m going again
and somehow this is to say that we came to the same conclusion or at least the
same observation going there repeatedly for different
different actual purposes but same purpose somehow it is that regardless of
the tradition you practice regardless of your entry point into the dharma you are in the
dharma. So your practice might defer from mine. Your sitting posture might
defer it from you know from your neighbor. Somehow that place of Bodga
Gaya is a center where and and it was really interesting
to hear an elder of the tri forest tradition which is you know one of the aesthetic branches of Theravada Buddhist
Unity in Diversity: Bodhgaya’s Role
in Thailand speak and observe Tibetan devotees chanting Omani. Some having the
women with the the prayer wheel and others with the mala and and saying eventually what how is my practice
better than that and how is their practice different from mine but it has the same. So the container might be
different but the I mean sorry the content might be different but the actual container and expression remain
different but the same. It’s it’s just a different it’s a so
bulgaya has become really a conversion of these it’s not that it has become but
over the centuries over the millennium where the Buddha originally sat down on
that body tree it has become a congre a a gathering of people of all
walks you can see everything there everything and that’s just that’s where I think
it’s resourcing for me It’s it’s always and then for everyone who goes to Bgaya it’s always oh my it’s complicated
bodgaya is complicated because it’s the poorest state and you’re talking about compassion is the poorest state of India
so you say well if there wasn’t any bgaya how can you develop compassion it’s really complic it’s a complicated
place but somehow everything dissolves when you’re there because this is a magnetic power to go so what I wanted to
say is that it doesn’t really matter the practice that you have what matters is that you have a chance to hear the
dharma. You have a chance to hear the dharma. That’s already an enormous merit because it’s not just because it’s it’s
rare, but because it’s a chance for you to plant the seed that can basically
help you. So, if somebody askked you what Josh, I’m asking you, what is salvation for you? What does salvation
mean? How do you relate to salvation? Probably saving myself for myself. And I
also have taints of okay that’s a that’s a Christian baggage that I have with salvation. Uh I I’d have to contemplate
that a little bit more than than getting on the spot. But I would say end of end of uh end of suffering, you know, that
that it’s possible and that the the path is there and nobody’s going to do it for me. You know, I have help and friends
Defining Salvation and Inner Peace
along the way. Yes. Exactly. But nobody’s doing it for me. And that’s where the inner peace comes
in. you I I cannot force you to have or at least it’s not something that you can
force someone to have in there. You can only say like listen I am I’m encouraging you to find that inner peace
and you have a super active mind but you can find inner peace because somehow you
have the true you know your true nature is a beautiful nature and this is not
just Buddhism who said that there were a French philosopher 300 years ago they were saying the same thing that I mean
French or other phil I mean you know or Greek philosophers as well they say stoics your your nature Yeah, your
nature is is basically pure and everything else that you build on is
just about defilements. So in that defilements you clear the bush. You keep
what is important for you to function in a way that is socially acceptable and
wholesome and then develop that inner peace and that inner peace will will
help you out no matter what because once you discover how it works you want more
of it and it leads to wisdom and wisdom yes wisdom can overcome everything. There
was someone someone asked or I mean I mean I’m in a number of groups and I
often see people saying okay but but in the Tavada tradition or the Ty forest tradition in particular it’s all about
restrictions and restrain and restrain okay that’s their practice right but
then you hear the elder in this case in my case it was ROM from Tara Monastery
in when I was in in Ontario he was And yes, it’s true. It can be perceived like
there’s a lot and it’s true eventually that you cannot you don’t eat after the sun. I you know this the highest point
of the sun and you have to wake up early somehow you somehow there has to be some
discipline of communal life. Yes, you can see it as so much restraining but think about the other side too. That’s
where the non-duality comes in. Think about the non-conventional thing. Instead of seeing it as restriction, see
all the freedom and the liberation you have from everything. By not having certain things, your life
is simplifying. It’s freedom from that’s usually like in America we think about a freedom to do
this, freedom to do that. But a freedom from it’s a freedom from crappiness,
you know, stuff. Freedom from stress, freedom from all these negative things.
Yeah, exactly. And I personally just to make a a point towards me because to come back
to the introduction you gave about me because it’s something I’ve been pondering a lot.
Freedom from Distractions
People ask me how can you still you’re not living in a monastery anymore. So you’re officially not an upasa anymore.
You’re not a long-term resident in a Thai tradition. Why do you keep your hair shaved? Well, because for me it’s
it’s a challenging restrictions. It’s it’s one for me for instance it’s been one of the greatest obstacle as a
woman I guess I had very long hair so there’s a lot so and recently there is a
friend of mine who has shaved her head and took a temporary sana ordination and
did the the pilgrimage on the maha maha pajapati this was a pilgrimage of
Buddhist of bukunis from bgaya to the birthplace of the Buddha and we had this
conversation about shaving head you know how for women it it’s completely different. It’s something a man can’t
talk about. Even if you’ve had you short hair, it’s complicated. So why do I have
that? But it’s not just so much that is that why don’t you just have more and I
realize I still live as though I’m actually a nun. I’m actually still in a
monastery. And it’s not a life of restriction that I give myself. I I just
I realize I go and I yesterday I accompanied someone doing some shopping
and I said the freedom of not needing anything. I don’t it’s not that before it was bad. Before
I was in a different realm and I had a child and so I had to buy certain things you had to afford. Now it’s like I see
certain things do I actually need? No. So I still operate with my bowl and I still operate although I have a full
cool full kitchen just for myself. Why do I choose this? because it’s freedom from
Yes. Yeah. It’s it’s really important and and I I I want to change my not freedom
from negativity because we’re still going to experience that. But yeah, it’s a reorientation to not what can I do,
but what can I be free from? And I implore people to, you know, you you can hear a little bit about these things,
but you have to have to take it on for practice for yourself and see how it lands in your heart. because maybe it’s
not for everybody, but maybe once you give it a real honest shot, then you can
Navigating Modern Challenges with Mindfulness
kind of feel some of the the peace and and freedom that comes from these practices as well. So, it’s all about
what we can let go of, what we can orient, what can we be content with. So, if we can be content with very little,
then if you view people that have to have everything a certain way, right, and they can’t tolerate this and they
can’t tolerate that, I’ve got news for everybody. There’s going to be a lot of times in our lives where we we don’t
have choices. We won’t be able to have the option to do what we want to do. Right? So then how are we how are we
when things don’t go our way? That’s a very important spiritual question. So once I’ve trained to be content with
very little, then that none of that’s a big deal where it can be a huge deal for a lot of people, but then it’s oh, I’ve
already trained and practiced this. I can be happy and content with with very little. And so it’s just a beautiful
strategy and training in in just so many situations in life, you know, and it’s it’s it’s it’s kind of fundamental and
foundational too, you know. It’s very much so. And I was going to say, you know, before you earlier on in
the conversation, you mentioned how how to navigate dual non-dual world and how
some some people find it really challenging to navigate that. I say when I’m practicing then I go outside it’s
completely different but while you have those foundations those ethical
foundation not just understanding okay it doesn’t mean that I not buying a new
cushion if I really need because the cushion has not yet fully disintegrated that doesn’t want what it mean or that I
I but more is not better and that the basic requirements are really always
taken care if you if your basic requirements are always taken taken care of. Basically, you have a very good
platform to go outside and start seeing how just look at also look at other
every other other human being. Just look at them just not walking with this phone
like this constantly in the head. And that is one of the closing remark I want to make regarding
Luan Poasano. So the elder from the t Thai forest tradition he often speaks of
mind one of the aspects of mindfulness is about maintaining
spatial awareness being constantly aware of spatial awareness so special awareness being
aware of your surroundings it’s something that we use in yoga since I I’ve you know I’ve been teaching yoga
for 15 years so special awareness doesn’t mean copying the other person or or necessarily having to talk to
everyone one, but having a spatial awareness who is around, how to move in a crowd, how to move on the road, and
that’s mindfulness. It can save you from an accident because you’re going to see the car coming in. That’s also something
very important. But also, it’s teaching you to actually maintain that kind of
steadiness. You can see a danger coming in, but you can also see, you know, the
beauty the beauty of the sky. Because if you kind of walk like this like people
do a lot these days. I’m really sorry but you’re going the more you do that the more the more complicated it’s going
to be for you to understand nonduality. You know it’s a it’s be and it’s also called situational awareness too right?
Situational awareness. Even just this practice with the space because this cup that you’ve seen me drink from if you’re watching this what
what’s around this cup? We don’t we we’re focused on objects too but what about the space that’s around it too and
another really interesting practice is peripheral vision. So just if we just with our physical eyes just expand to
where we can look at the periphery now how it just kind of brings one into the
present moment as well and it kind of expands the mind state really temporarily. Yeah. It’s um it’s a really
important practice because we’re so focused on objects and I will just say with the phone and this is not an excuse
but because I’ve heard there’s these apps now that will turn your experience transparent. It will have the camera on
and whatever you’re doing on your screen. You can see what’s down below as you’re walking. So it’s it’s ridiculous
what we’ve come to now that we’ll have to have an app to do that so we don’t so we can continue looking at our phone and
still see the ground below us. So yeah, I don’t it it is really something, you know. I mean, we talked about this a
little bit before. I mean, the pros and cons of this, but it this is really important to get a handle on this now
because I find I have challenges with it, you know. Yeah, I think it’s a generational it’s a
generational thing as well. You can listen to any talks about AI and you
know social even you can go from political to health to Buddhism to tech
to finances. They’re all going to say the same thing. This is going you know that there are
certain things that I cannot do for the bank on the website. I have to do them here. I cannot do it simply because
there’s no facial recognition on the computer. So this it’s not something that is is some actually this is
something that we have to deal with but generationally we come from a time where we are we are
accustomed to do without and therefore for us
we are using it as a tool as a simple tool for connecting but for
some in the new generation this is the nonduality as you see as you say this the app can
make you so you can look at the screen and to actually look at the screen and at the same time you can see what’s happening so that’s going to be the
duality and and we cannot get away it’s going to be like this but how do you manage I think you just keep going you
keep going the way because it’s their issue eventually we cannot we cannot we
cannot we can make we are going to come to I was listening to some several actually podcasts in the
past few is with considering the samsara is not going to get any better. Having
mindfulness, anxiety prevention and resilience building, but not the same
kind of resilience as something that you have to add on is really something that you have to build cuz there are people
who are extremely empathic for the damages to the environment and they cannot get away with the fact that the
environment is being damaged. And I said, okay, fine. But empathy is the problem of empathy is that it stops
Building Resilience Through Inner Peace
there. It makes you very it can drain you. If you step in and understand and
having compassion maybe you can start doing something at your own from and and and the that
that’s one aspect. The second is that there are lots of people who are oh my
gosh this person has passed away. Oh my god this is person. Yeah we’re all going to pass away. So don’t get too much
attached to this actually physicality and how everything is changing and it’s
very difficult because things are going much faster than in our generation and
or past generations. I mean the pre pre200 whichever age you are it’s extremely
difficult to um now to say to stop things it’s just accelerating. So
you can you can only even more than before you can be you need to build your own resources
that inner I’m coming back to this inner peace because it’s really going to be your asset is going to be your asset
because very few people realize how everything can disappear from your life in just one instant.
Yep. Exactly. Loss. Yeah. You cannot grasp because if it has to go
it has to go. And as you know I know I know I know quite a quite a great deal of that. So but what does it teach? It
teaches you that that inner peace is your strength. Yes. Exactly. Because people look at
peace sometimes and they think it’s weak but no actually invulnerability can be a strength you know because it it does
it does allow this well vulnerability allows openness and connection and inner
peace allows stability, groundedness, collectedness and a place of where we
can come from wise action and wise response instead of reactivity and destruction to so yeah and I will I will
challenge people though to do a slight digital detox. I mean, we were talking about Ahsoka’s retreat before here and
how she just limited it to Bare Essentials online. I did a a month-long Zen retreat in Korea where I turned in
my devices. And let me tell you, that was some of just that alone was so challenging. And my whole I didn’t even
realize how much reference point for reality and my sanity actually is tied now to digital devices and digital
interactions. But no matter what we want to do or how we want to digital detox, I think we need to do some degree of that.
But at the same time, I’m not a lite either where we throw it all away and just live in some kind of caveman world
or something. So it it’s about balance and we can never have enough mindfulness. That’s for sure. So I I
welcome people to to help me interact with my devices more uh mindfully. I know it’s way easier for me when I’m not
constantly interacting with a device to be more mindful like this. just talking and communicating then I can realize I’m
talking to a a computer screen in front of me and not actually a SOA but when that mindfulness is there it’s just like
I’m not even aware but so yeah these are important things and we we still have a
one last thing we still have a reference point our generation for what life was like before the internet kids today they
don’t have that reference point they don’t know a world without internet no and there are already two generations
who don’t know about that Because there’s an earlier one that
Yeah, that’s right. Millennials. Yeah, there’s a just the the I mean they just the ‘9s, the one from the ‘9s.
That’s right. But anyway, what I wanted to remind ourself that the Buddha spoke always
about the middle way, the middle way in everything. So do not engage in extreme
of everything. So it’s it requires you know mindfulness is is is maybe has
become the Macdonald of Buddhism as uh Melvin Mlehood was talking about it.
Actually we invited the lion’s roar to Bhutan but he has retired so someone else came in and however what he spoke
about this in a very good way in the sense that it was was symbolizing expressing the fact that it’s
mindfulness for eating and mindfulness for walking and mindfulness for educating the kids and mindfulness for
The Middle Way in Practice
my yoga and mindfulness for my cosmetic routine or whatever it is that’s not what mindfulness is is mindfulness is
the basis of everything but to having Having said that, he reminded also the
middle way. So the middle way is always being able to catch back where it is
because we go, we human, right? So we tend to go to extreme. I can’t say yesterday I didn’t buy anything cuz I
was really free from any desire of having or purchasing or whatever. But I can’t say that I didn’t say, “Oh, this
is nice. It was nice. What I had in my hand is really nice.” But then I look at it and
I say, “Wait, it’s nice.” And I put it back, you know? So you come back to the middle way. Do I actually need this? Is
it useful? And that’s a mindful effort because also the Buddha taught that if
dharma is easy to you, then it’s not real dharma. So you need to put a little bit of effort, a little bit of training
here. Come on. Just not let go too much of it. And as you said also I think being honest about the fact that there’s
going to be my tendency is to sleep late. Okay. If my tendency to sleep late
in the morning okay then I shift something and I’m mindful mindfulness my
meditation in the evening or I do it later in the morning. It’s okay. It doesn’t mean that every one of us has to
become a monk or a monaste and go into wrist train. It just means what is the middle way that works for you
and the relationship what is your and yes and how can you navigate yourself your own little middle
way and that already is going to be an enormous training for your mind and then
absolutely something else I have come back to is the buddo for in my case it’s been the
budo so it’s been really checking the breath and checking the breath either with the buddo which works but also
stopping the breath here the focus of the breath here which is something that has been done in zana as well but you
stop so you’re not concentrating too much on breathing in and breathing out
and it’s going you just it just stops here and then after that last breath
there is a moment where nothing happens and that’s where you start really
realizing what it means to rest in awareness rest in the natural awareness
Wow. And you can stay there and if you start doing a little bit pieces by pieces, eventually one day you might end
up staying one hour and that’s where something is one day is going to switch.
So that’s what I recommend to I recommend to people to really and that’s that’s that’s really the seed of inner
peace. That is something nobody can take away from you whether you are in a hospital where you are tending to rush
in the in the in the airport whether you know, you need to wait in the hot
sun to cross the road, whatever. It stays with with you. You know, we had a
big earthquake here. So, and I mean, that’s already almost a year ago, but
that moment you realize how it’s very easy to be shaken.
Yeah. So, that inner peace seeds by seeds, it goes and grows and then you
find your middle way. Well, that that’s beautiful, Ahsoka. I think we’ll we’ll leave it there. And
yeah, may may everybody’s mindfulness practice be um become optimal for their
own well-being and for everyone else’s. And yeah, may may we may we all come to
know optimal peace and how we relate in skillful ways to ourselves and to
everyone around us and everything around us u for our own well-being and that of everyone else’s. So may all beings
everywhere realize awakening and be free. Thank you all
listening.
Integrating Presence is made with Jetpack Podcast. Full show notes and every episode at https://integratingpresence.com/