Intelligence Tradecraft - Sharpen your analytic edge

Intelligence Tradecraft - Sharpen your analytic edge

By Freddy MurreEducationCourses
Download on the App Store

Intelligence Tradecraft - Sharpen your analytic edge episodes

  • Critical Thinking in a Crisis: Separating Hype From Facts - Interview with Bart van den Berg S3E7

    What makes intelligence trustworthy enough to act on, and how easily is that trust lost? In this episode, host Freddy Murre sits down with Bart van den Berg, who leads the security unit at the Clingendael Institute in the Netherlands, to discuss critical thinking in a crisis, the tradecraft behind credible analysis, and where LLMs fit without eroding trust. 


    Bart’s path into intelligence runs from an economics and business degree with a master’s in the Chinese economy, through six years as an infantry officer and several as a trainer, to lead analyst at the Dutch National Cybersecurity Center. He describes the culture shock of leaving a rigid, procedure-driven military for open-ended civilian work, a shift also Freddy knows from his move from government intelligence into private sector finance.


    Cyber threat intelligence changes when it collides with geopolitics. The Log4j crisis and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine pushed Bart toward strategic questions from decision makers, while undersea cable incidents and DDoS claims triggered waves of reporting without a real rise in incidents. Drone sightings and the vague label of hybrid warfare showed how easily speculation fills the gap when facts are missing. 


    Trustworthy intelligence, Bart argues, comes down to tradecraft: rigor, speed, sourcing and tailoring to a decision maker. That separates intelligence from opinion, and he explains why he ranks attitude and skills above knowledge when training analysts. AI tests that standard: Bart recalls an LLM handing him fabricated quotes, explains why that threatens an analyst’s reputation. He also shares where LLMs help, from proofreading to challenging his own arguments, but argues that responsibility must stay with humans and that analysts have to prove their added value on top of AI. 


    Whether you are training analysts, briefing decision makers, or deciding how far to trust AI, Bart’s experience shows that credibility is built on rigor and sourcing and lost on one unchecked claim.



    RESOURCES

    Clingendael Institute - https://www.clingendael.org/

    NCSC-NL - https://www.ncsc.nl/en

    NCSC-UK - https://www.ncsc.gov.uk/information/log4j-vulnerability-what-everyone-needs-to-know

    NCSC-NL GitHub - https://github.com/NCSC-NL/log4shell

    Causes for undersea cable disruptions - https://joint-research-centre.ec.europa.eu/jrc-explains/subsea-cables-how-vulnerable-are-they-and-can-we-protect-them_en

    Sweden closes sabotage probe - https://www.sverigesradio.se/artikel/sweden-closes-sabotage-probe-into-damaged-baltic-sea-cable

    Drones at Copenhagen Airport in 2025 - https://www.reuters.com/world/danish-police-find-no-proof-drones-caused-copenhagen-airport-shutdown-2026-06-25/

    Freddy asks, When does something become intel - https://www.linkedin.com/posts/fmurre_in-your-opinion-when-does-something-go-from-share-7180879793012285441-NK8V/

    Grammarly - https://www.grammarly.com/



    CHAPTERS

    00:00 Career Journey Into Intelligence

    04:00 From Military To Think Tank

    07:26 Trainer Years And Russian Influence

    10:47 Cyber Intelligence Meets Geopolitics

    14:40 Incident Hype And Hybrid Warfare

    24:27 Separating Signal From Noise

    28:59 Leaving The NCC For Clingendael

    31:13 Military Training And Analytical Foundations

    36:04 Training And Skill Development

    47:06 Intelligence Inside Government

    52:21 Defining Good Versus Bad Intelligence

    58:44 AI Limits And Hallucinations

    1:08:09 Where AI Belongs In Analysis

    1:12:16 AI's Future And Human Responsibility

    1:20:08 Why Analysts Still Matter

    1 hr 26 min
  • Learning Tradecraft the Hard Way, Then Teaching It - Interview with Ondra Rojčík S3E6

    What separates good intelligence from noise, and why do so many organizations struggle to act on it? In this episode, host Freddy Murre sits down with Ondra Rojčík, an IBM security consultant with over 15 years in Czech government intelligence, to discuss tradecraft, stakeholders, and how AI fits into the intelligence cycle.


    Ondra explains why he stepped back from management to return to hands-on analysis, and reflects on what struck him about transitioning from a 250-person agency to a global tech giant. He also describes arriving at NATO and realizing how much basic tradecraft he lacked. That realization later inspired him to build a university course on intelligence analysis.


    Freddy and Ondra debate where information ends and intelligence begins. For Ondra, good intelligence answers the "so what" for a specific organization. Most public threat reports fail because they lack this tailoring. He walks through how his team built its own process for priority intelligence requirements, while being candid about executives unready to act, the public sector's superior training budgets, and the difficulty of measuring impact.


    They also weigh in on AI: LLMs excel at narrow tasks like summarization, but framework-mapping tests that looked promising on small samples fell apart at scale. Furthermore, stakeholders cannot simply rely on LLMs because they often do not know which questions to ask. Spotting unlisted threats remains the analyst's job. Meanwhile, adversaries use LLMs for speed and scale, raising the question: do more attempts mean more successful attacks?


    Whether you are maturing a CTI function, trying to influence leadership, or integrating LLMs, Ondra's experience proves that good tradecraft is only half the job; the other half is reaching people ready to act.



    RESOURCES

    IBM Acquisition of Red Hat - https://www.ibm.com/investor/news/ibm-completes-acquisition-of-red-hat Czech National Cyber Security Agency - https://nukib.gov.cz/en/ Pherson SAT Book - https://www.amazon.com/Structured-Analytic-Techniques-Intelligence-Analysis/dp/150636893X/ Intelligence training with Freddy - https://inteltradecraft.com/sat-certifications Pherson & Heuer SAT Book - https://www.amazon.com/Structured-Analytic-Techniques-Intelligence-Analysis/dp/150636893X/ Ondra's Medium profile - https://medium.com/@orojcik FIRST CTI 2026 - https://www.first.org/conference/firstcti26/ Ondra PIRs at SANS - https://www.sans.org/blog/bridging-gaps-cti-practical-guide-threat-informed-security-pirs



    CHAPTERS

    00:00 Ondra's Path Into Intelligence

    04:08 Leaving Government for Industry

    06:32 Government vs Private Sector Culture

    09:10 Learning Tradecraft the Hard Way

    12:58 Teaching and Practicing Tradecraft

    20:41 What Counts as Intelligence

    25:28 Sharing Knowledge and Building PIRs

    30:20 Intelligence Culture in Industry

    33:46 Maturing a CTI Team

    37:17 Training Budgets and Follow-Through

    42:00 Measuring the Value of Intelligence

    46:04 How Analysts Use AI Today

    49:13 AI's Future in CTI

    57:30 Adversaries, AI and Attack Success

    1:04:25 People Who Opened Doors

    1 hr 9 min
  • Building a CTI Team: Buy-In, Budgets, and Better Intelligence - Interview with Sherman Chu S3E5

    What does it take to build and run a cyber threat intelligence function, and how can you tell whether the intelligence you’re producing is any good? In this episode, host Freddy Murre sits down with Sherman Chu, who at the time of the interview worked at BlackRock, for a conversation about lessons learned on the job, tradecraft and AI.


    Sherman recounts his path from Army intelligence support through grad school and a vendor role at Flashpoint, then to end-user teams in financial services, building New York City’s CTI program from the ground up, and a stint at Deloitte. He explains what changes when you move from serving a broad customer base to serving specific stakeholders, and why end-user teams must also collect internally.


    Freddy and Sherman cover team-building: finding buy-in, keeping collection minimal, justifying budgets, evaluating vendors, and why training so often fails to change how a team works. Sherman shares the courses and books he considers foundational, including The Diamond Model of Intrusion Analysis and Heuer’s Psychology of Intelligence Analysis.


    A key question that comes up is what separates intelligence from data and information. Sherman offers his own definition, then breaks down what bad intelligence looks like, from marketing dressed up as analysis to context-free indicator sharing. He also explains how inconsistent terminology holds the field back.


    Over the last couple of years, Sherman’s view of AI has shifted from early skepticism to cautious adoption. He shares how he pairs deterministic code with LLMs to extract adversary procedures from reports, where models still hallucinate, and why analysis remains the hardest step to automate.

    Their advice for newcomers is to stay curious, build a pet project, and stay humble. If you lead a CTI team, want to join one, or are weighing where AI belongs in your workflow, this episode is well worth your time.



    RESOURCES

    Flashpoint - https://flashpoint.io/

    Columbia University MA program - https://www.sipa.columbia.edu/sipa-education/masters-programs/concentrations/international-security-and-diplomacy

    SANS FOR578 CTI -https://www.sans.org/cyber-security-courses/cyber-threat-intelligence

    Sergio's course "Diamond Model of Intrusion Analysis" -https://school.threatintel.academy/courses/diamond/

    Joe Slowik's Training - https://paralus.co/training/ Pherson's

    Structured Analytic Techniques (SAT) - https://www.amazon.com/Structured-Analytic-Techniques-Intelligence-Analysis/dp/150636893X/

    Richards J. Heuer, Jr. The Psychology of Intelligence Analysis -https://www.ialeia.org/docs/Psychology_of_Intelligence_Analysis.pdf

    Scott J. Roberts & Rebekah Brown's book "Intelligence-Driven Incident Response - https://www.amazon.com/Intelligence-Driven-Incident-Response-Outwitting-Adversary/dp/109812068X/

    VISMA and APT Attribution discussion - https://therecord.media/norway-says-chinese-group-apt31-is-behind-catastrophic-2018-government-hack



    CHAPTERS

    00:00 Introduction and Career Overview

    02:09 From Army Intelligence to Academia

    06:05 Vendor Versus End User Intelligence

    13:54 Building a Government CTI Program

    17:17 Training, Certifications, and Key Books

    25:14 Building a CTI Function

    37:46 Budgets, Tools, and Training Value

    47:28 What Counts as Intelligence

    52:49 What Makes Intelligence Bad

    01:00:06 Shared Language and Industry Maturity

    01:07:38 AI Across the Intel Cycle

    01:13:13 Hybrid LLM and Code Workflows

    01:16:22 AI Limits, Risks, and Democratization

    01:22:44 Traits for Aspiring Analysts

    01:25:01 Neurodivergence and Staying Humble

    1 hr 28 min
  • Bringing CTI to the Executive Table - Interview with Jan Henrik Schou Straumsheim S3E4

    Jan Henrik Schou Straumsheim, a partner in PwC's cyber advisory practice, sits down with host Freddy Murre to talk about the real work behind cyber threat intelligence. His interest in the field traces back to getting his hands on his father's old 386 computer and a book his mother gave him on the history of codes, and later took shape during years as a reserve infantry officer in Norway's armed forces, where he trained at the Defense Intelligence School and eventually became his unit's intelligence officer (S-2).


    From there, his career moved through a summer internship at Accenture, a part-time job in the security operations center at mnemonic, a pivot into consulting, and almost a decade now at PwC.


    The conversation explores what actually separates CTI from cybersecurity, and why so much of what gets sold as intelligence is really just unfiltered data dumps. Jan Henrik and Freddy debate how analysts should weigh sources, including the tricky question of trusting personas on dark web forums, then turn to how private-sector teams train and retain analytical skill, and why Nordic organizations still lag in treating CTI as more than a detection add-on. Jan Henrik shares a real client case, where a board commissioned a foresight report on AI risk, showing what it looks like when CTI actually reaches the boardroom.


    The conversation then shifts to AI's role in intelligence work: how Jan Henrik uses large language models every day, why he still insists on a human checking every output before his name goes on it, and where the line sits between AI as a sparring partner and AI replacing analytical judgment altogether. They close on a reminder that opportunity often comes from someone else opening a door, and why passing that on matters.


    This episode with Jan Henrik is a grounded, occasionally blunt conversation about what good intelligence work actually requires, well worth a listen for anyone trying to make CTI matter to the business it's meant to serve.



    RESOURCES

    simon singh the code book - https://www.amazon.com/dp/0385495323

    Mnemonic Internships - https://www.mnemonic.io/no/careers/internships/

    Hatlebrekke The Problem of Secret Intelligence - https://www.amazon.com/dp/0748691839

    Freddy's SANS CTI Summit presentationFrom Gut to Gold Standard: The Admiralty System in CTI - https://youtu.be/y-CSDxMMXb0?t=5

    Freddy's SANS posts on Admiralty Scale - https://www.sans.org/profiles/freddy-murstad#resources

    SANS Cybercrime Investigations - https://www.sans.org/cyber-security-courses/cybercrime-investigations

    Washington D.C. police gaming crime statistics - https://www.washingtonpost.com/dc-md-va/2026/05/08/dc-police-crime-statistics-internal-investigation-findings/

    Research article Non-Determinism of “Deterministic” LLM System Settings in Hosted Environments - https://aclanthology.org/2025.eval4nlp-1.12/

    Research article Cognitive offloading, critical thinking and attitudes towards artificial intelligence https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42377671/

    Freddy's LinkedIn Profile -https://www.linkedin.com/in/fmurre/



    CHAPTERS

    0:00 Early path into cybersecurity

    2:12 From mnemonic's SOC to PwC

    8:27 Building PwC's global CTI arm

    10:38 CTI versus cybersecurity defined

    11:45 Military intelligence background

    18:40 What actually counts as intelligence

    20:05 Separating good intel from bad

    26:19 Training and upskilling analysts

    32:57 CTI maturity across the Nordics

    41:20 Linking CTI to enterprise risk

    50:28 Building a successful CTI function

    56:30 Measuring CTI's real value

    1:03:12 AI's rapid rise in CTI

    1:14:51 AI risks and human oversight

    1:26:01 Career-defining opportunities and mentorship

    1 hr 31 min
  • Breaking In, Proving Value, and Staying Ahead in CTI - Interview with Rebecca Ford S3E3

    In this episode of Intelligence Tradecraft, host Freddy Murre sits down with Rebecca Ford, a cyber threat intelligence analyst who started out on the government side with Army Cyber and DISA, focused heavily on North Korea and the Asia-Pacific region. From there, she moved into the private sector, where she's spent the better part of a decade helping grow a CTI function from an early-stage team into something far more mature.


    Rebecca traces her path into the field: an overheard conversation about true-crime shows that led an Army analyst to recruit her, on-the-job training in an era before cyber threat intelligence even had a name, and the 2014 Sony hack as the moment the discipline truly landed on the map.


    She and Freddy explore what separates useful intelligence from what she calls being reduced to "news reporters with a microphone." The difference lies in handing stakeholders a raw threat feed versus giving them analysis that actually drives a decision. Rebecca shares her working definition of intelligence, built around an adversary's intent, opportunity, and capability. They also get into the two very different audiences an analyst serves, senior leadership and network defenders, and why treating report counts as a success metric misses the point entirely.


    The conversation covers building real relationships with stakeholders, the argument for "fusion centers" that merge cyber, physical, travel, and financial-crime intelligence, and the considerable value of community and mentorship in a field where, as Rebecca puts it, your next opportunity usually comes from someone who already knows you.


    A large part of the discussion is about AI: where it genuinely speeds up research and helps an analyst get started, why Rebecca still verifies everything by hand before it goes out, and why she believes human judgment should stay in charge of the final call.


    Rebecca ends with a reminder that showing up and investing in the community, whether at conferences, in focus groups, or at vendor events, is part of the job for anyone hoping to build a career in the field.


    RESOURCES


    Sony Hack - https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-30573040


    Gert Jan's Metrics - https://github.com/gertjanbruggink/metrics


    SANS CTI Summit 2026 Visual Summary - https://www.sans.org/blog/visual-summary-sans-cti-summit-2026


    Rebecca's LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/rebeccaford/


    Freddy's Intelligence Architecture Mind Map - https://github.com/Errum/IntelArchitectureMap


    Reuters IKEA bets on remote interior design as AI changes sales strategy - https://www.reuters.com/technology/ikea-bets-remote-interior-design-ai-changes-sales-strategy-2023-06-13/


    CHAPTERS


    00:00 Welcome & Rebecca's Background


    00:57 Breaking Into Cyber Threat Intel


    02:58 Learning Cyber Intel From Scratch


    04:30 The Sony Hack Turning Point


    06:53 From Army Cyber to DISA


    09:32 Adjusting to the Private Sector


    12:29 Defining Intelligence and Stakeholders


    15:16 Proving Value and Building Community


    23:14 Good Intelligence vs. Bad Intelligence


    26:20 Mentorship and Learning From Mistakes


    34:01 Team Diversity and Fusion Centers


    40:25 Misconceptions and Measuring Impact


    47:00 Communicating With Stakeholders


    55:07 Where AI Fits in Intel


    1:13:15 Mentors, Advice & Closing Thoughts

    1 hr 18 min
  • Intelligence Work Demands Honesty About Uncertainty - Interview with Rebekah Brown (S3E2)

    In this episode of Intelligence Tradecraft, host Freddy Murre talks with Rebekah Brown, senior researcher at the University of Toronto's Citizen Lab, about what it actually takes to do intelligence work well, in government and in the private sector. Rebekah's background spans the field: she started as a Marine Corps cryptologic linguist and NSA analyst, later led threat intelligence at Nike, and worked the vendor side at Rapid7. Today, she co-authors the SANS FOR578 course and has co-written an incident response book with Scott Roberts.

     

    The conversation traces how a clerical error sent her through Mandarin Chinese training instead of Korean, why private-sector CTI teams so often import government habits that don't fit the business they're protecting, and why translating between technical teams and leadership is often the real job description. 


    They spend real time on definitions: what separates intelligence from reporting, what makes intelligence good or bad, and why so much of what gets labeled cyber threat intelligence in the private sector is really just collected information without analysis behind it. 


    Rebekah and Freddy also trade stories about the growing pains of building a threat intelligence function inside a business that doesn't think in nation-state terms, and what it actually takes to make expensive training change how a team works day to day. 


    When it comes to AI, Rebekah explains where she believes LLMs can genuinely support brainstorming, coding, and research tasks, and where she draws a hard line at analysis itself. The two also debate how AI might reshape the size and shape of intelligence teams in the years ahead. 


    It's a grounded, experience-driven conversation for analysts, team leads, and anyone trying to prove the value of intelligence inside their organization. 


    RECOURCES 


    The Marine Corps Logo - https://www.war.gov/Multimedia/Photos/igphoto/2001789719/ Defense Language Institute 


    Foreign Language Center - https://www.dliflc.edu/ 


    University of Toronto Citizen Lab - https://citizenlab.ca/ 


    The Cuckoo's Egg - https://www.amazon.com/Cuckoos-Egg-Tracking-Computer-Espionage/dp/1668048167/ 


    Ghost Net Report - https://citizenlab.ca/research/tracking-ghostnet-investigating-a-cyber-espionage-network/ 


    Intelligence-Driven Incident Response - https://www.amazon.com/Intelligence-Driven-Incident-Response-Outwitting-Adversary/dp/109812068X/ 


    Scott Roberts LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/scottroberts/ 


    SANS FOR578 - https://www.sans.org/cyber-security-courses/cyber-threat-intelligence 


    Rob M Lee LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/robmichaellee/


    CHAPTERS


    00:00 Welcome and introductions 


    0:37 High school to the Marines 


    1:22 Becoming a Marine linguist 


    3:56 A lucky mix-up at NSA 


    5:45 Early training and mentors 


    9:44 What is intelligence? 


    14:17 Good intelligence versus bad 


    16:32 Leading and teaching Marines 


    20:37 Injury ends a military career 


    25:12 Standing up Nike's threat intel 


    31:28 Rapid7 and the CTI boom 


    38:19 Bridging techies and leadership 


    45:01 Writing the book and course 


    58:15 Measuring intelligence's real value 


    1:02:27 Where AI fits in intel

    1 hr 23 min
  • Good Intelligence vs Noise and the Skills AI Can't Replace - Interview with Josh D. MacLellan (S3E1)

    Staff Threat Intelligence Advisor Josh Darby MacLellan at Feedly kicks off season three by unpacking his path into CTI, what separates intelligence that gets used from intelligence that gets ignored, and why core skills like stakeholder communication may outlast technical specialties as AI reshapes the field. Josh started his career with childhood dreams of becoming a criminal lawyer, shifted through academic study of international relations and security, and unfolded into more than a decade of private-sector threat intelligence work across Canada, the US, and multiple specialties within CTI. Josh is blunt about where the field falls short. Good intelligence is connected to a decision and a decision-maker, versus reports written for other analysts that never get read. Josh and Freddy discuss team structure, and why CTI teams that skew small and heavily technical tend to miss the core skills of stakeholder conversation that keep a function relevant when budgets tighten. Josh argues communication is a trainable skill, the same way he trained himself to become a clearer public speaker despite two speech impediments and years of mumbling through bombed public talks.As for AI, Josh draws a clear line between what he'll delegate and what he won't. He uses LLMs for collection support, editing, and even as a stand-in second analyst to catch his own blind spots, but he won't hand over the analysis stage. Trusting an unreviewed AI process, he argues, is a bit like citing a source you've never actually read. Freddy pushes back with his own testing of LLMs on structured analytic techniques, and the two get into what's actually lost when a black box quietly decides what information matters.


    RESOURCES

    NATO Intelligence Cycle - https://ac.nato.int/resources/uploads/2284/picture2-intel-8Wgsa2.png

    Freddy's Intelligence Architecture Mind Map - https://github.com/Errum/IntelArchitectureMap/files/14615837/240315.-.Intelligence.Architecture.v0.7.42.pdf

    Gert Jan's Measuring value of CTI - https://github.com/gertjanbruggink/metrics

    Feedly - https://feedly.com/

    Intel471's CU-GIRH - https://github.com/intel471/CU-GIR

    Sherman Chu's Tyranny of Current Intelligence - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IETRHdMejaw

    Sherman's slides - https://www.sans.org/presentations/were-in-now-now-the-tyranny-of-current-intelligence-and-how-to-manage-it

    Intel Tradecraft Courses and Trainings - https://inteltradecraft.com/sat-certifications

    IRM Workshop - https://www.intel471.com/lp/building-an-intel-workshop

    SANS FOR578 CTI - https://www.sans.org/cyber-security-courses/cyber-threat-intelligence

    Josh Darby's SANS presentation "Can We Forecast Our Own Fate" - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B9TkeUbD1Mk

    Josh's slide deck - https://www.sans.org/presentations/can-we-forecast-our-own-fate-mapping-the-future-of-the-cti-industry-with-sats

    Feedly CTI Essentials - https://feedly.com/ti-essentials

    Webinar: What CTI practitioners recommend you focus on in 2026 - https://feedly.com/ti-essentials/posts/what-cti-practitioners-recommend-you-focus-on-in-2026

    Freddy and Josh Think smarter, not harder: Making SATs work in CTI - https://feedly.com/ti-essentials/posts/think-smarter-not-harder-making-sats-work-in-cti

    Feedly AI - https://feedly.com/ai

    MLitt in Terrorism Studies - https://www.st-andrews.ac.uk/subjects/international-relations/terrorism-mlitt/


    CHAPTERS

    0:00 Intro and Welcome

    1:01 Josh's Path Into CTI

    4:04 CTI Maturity Across Countries

    8:08 Pivot to Protective Intelligence

    12:12 Defining Intelligence and CTI

    13:13 Good vs Bad Intelligence

    16:16 The Intelligence Cycle

    23:23 Engaging Stakeholders Directly

    26:26 Core Skills and Job Security

    33:33 Training and Certifications

    40:40 Building Well-Rounded Teams

    43:43 Mentoring and Giving Back

    49:49 AI's Role in the Cycle

    58:58 How Josh Uses AI

    1:05:05 People Who Shaped His Career

    1 hr 13 min
  • The librarian who founded modern OSINT: Sources, tradecraft & AI - Interview with Arno Reuser (S2E8)

    If you've ever read a text or sat in a briefing and quietly wondered what actually separates this "intelligence" from someone's hot take on LinkedIn, a journalist with a deadline, an analyst with a search bar, or an AI, this episode is for you.


    The host, Freddy Murre, sits down with Arno Reuser, the man who founded the Dutch Defence Intelligence Service's open-source intelligence (OSINT) capability in the early 1990s, before most of Europe had a word for it. What follows is less an interview than a working argument about how OSINT should actually be done, and where the field has gone soft.


    Arno doesn't mince words. He'll tell you the "information explosion" everyone complains about is just proof you skipped your stakeholder and requirement analysis. That most of what gets sold as OSINT is the word "OSINT" stapled to “everything”, such as tools. That he has, by deliberate choice, never written an analytical judgment in his life, and why that line between collection and analysis matters more than people think. For anyone who's argued about what counts as OSINT versus PAI (Publicly Available Information), or where collection ends and all-source begins, this is the debate you want to engage with.


    Along the way: the librarian's discipline, he says, underpins all good intelligence work, the collection plan he calls "worth gold," the classroom trick thousands of students have failed, and a run of war stories from his teachings, such as a prison break by email to a deepfake that fooled cyber experts who personally know him.


    The back half takes on two problems every practitioner is living with right now. How do you put a value on intelligence when the same report is priceless to one decision-maker and useless to the next? And what is AI actually good for? Arno uses LLMs daily and is genuinely amazed by them, but only for things he can verify. He and Freddy get specific on hallucinations, sycophancy, model collapse, and the difference between a real summary and a machine that just shortens the text and deletes the one sentence that mattered.



    RESOURCES

    Maersk Website - https://investor.maersk.com/news-releases/news-release-details/cyber-attack-update

    Dutch Police Data Breach - https://www.politie.nl/nieuws/2024/oktober/2/update-over-datalek-politie.html

    When does something go from a Google answer to Intelligence - https://www.linkedin.com/posts/fmurre_in-your-opinion-when-does-something-go-from-activity-7181221399561203712-mV-m/

    LexisNexis Library - https://www.lexisnexis.com/en-us/products/digital-library.page

    Vague questions in OSINT - https://opensourceintelligence.biz/vague-osint-questions/

    Structured Analytic Techniques (SAT) Training - https://inteltradecraft.com/sat-certifications

    Pherson Structured Analytic Techniques for Intelligence Analysis - https://www.amazon.com/Structured-Analytic-Techniques-Intelligence-Analysis/dp/150636893X/

    Routledge Handbook of Terrorism Research - https://www.routledge.com/The-Routledge-Handbook-of-Terrorism-Research/Schmid/p/book/9780415520997

    AI Model Collapse - https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=AI+model+collapse&btnG=



    CHAPTERS

    00:00 From literature searcher to founding military OSINT

    04:00 Becoming a librarian: the Kampen archive moment

    08:00 Where OSINT stops and intelligence begins

    11:00 Why "cyber" keeps getting OSINT wrong

    15:00 What actually makes something "intelligence"?

    24:00 The information explosion myth

    32:00 The classroom trick: think before you type

    36:00 The collection plan that's "worth gold"

    42:00 The human factor cyber keeps ignoring

    45:00 War stories: validation and getting fooled

    51:00 Learning the craft: sources, sources, sources

    55:00 Customers ask for what they think you can do

    01:08:00 Can you measure the value of intelligence?

    01:11:00 AI and LLMs: amazed but skeptical

    01:32:00 Deepfakes, the NATO photo & "how likely is it?"

    1 hr 38 min
  • From Dutch Military Intelligence to Private Sector Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI) - Interview w/Martijn (S2E7)

    SUMMARY

    Former military intelligence analyst turned consultancy director Martijn Docters van Leeuwen joins Freddy Murre to unpack what cyber threat intelligence really is, and why so many teams "talk the talk" without "walking the walk", i.e. doing the work.


    Martijn Docters van Leeuwen has done the whole journey, infantry, military intelligence, stopping ATM skimming and gas attacks in the Netherlands, to building a bank's first CTI team, and now being a cybersecurity consultant.


    So when he talks about CTI being a tradecraft and not a report that magically lands in your inbox, he's not theorizing. He's been the only analyst in the room wearing all seven hats, the guy getting asked "why does this cost so much?", the one trying to prove value in the six quiet months when nothing's on fire.


    We get into the stuff analysts actually argue about: why most teams are great at talking the talk and bad at doing it, the trap of living in your own little football field while the business has no idea what you do, how people game their own metrics to manufacture a crisis, and where AI genuinely helps versus where it's just a confident liar with no fingers. Threat vs. risk, mirror imaging, incident-driven vs. intel-driven, and the brutal truth that training does nothing if you walk out the door and never apply it.


    If you do this work, or you're trying to convince someone it's worth doing, pour a coffee and settle in.



    RESOURCES

    Structured Analytic Techniques (SAT) Certification Training by Intel Tradecraft and Pherson - https://inteltradecraft.com/sat-certifications

    Intelligence Mind Map - https://github.com/Errum/IntelArchitectureMap

    When does something go from a Google answer to Intelligence - https://www.linkedin.com/posts/fmurre_in-your-opinion-when-does-something-go-from-activity-7181221399561203712-mV-m/

    Mitre Att@ck - https://attack.mitre.org/resources/attack-data-and-tools/

    Mark Arena - CTI: Comparing the incident-centric and actor-centric approaches - https://medium.com/@markarenaau/cyber-threat-intelligence-comparing-the-incident-centric-and-actor-centric-approaches-f20cfba2dea2

    ASML The world's supplier to the semiconductor industry - https://www.asml.com/en

    SANS FOR578 CTI - https://www.sans.org/cyber-security-courses/cyber-threat-intelligence

    TIBER European Central Bank - https://www.ecb.europa.eu/paym/cyber-resilience/tiber-eu/html/index.en.html

    Freddy's resources on SANS - https://www.sans.org/profiles/freddy-murstad#resources

    The intelligence cycle - https://github.com/Errum/IntelArchitectureMap

    Basic cyber-hygiene guidance from CISA - https://www.cisa.gov/topics/cybersecurity-best-practices

    NSM ICT Security Principles - https://nsm.no/advice-and-guidance/publications/nsm-ict-security-principles

    SANS FOR578 CTI - https://www.sans.org/cyber-security-courses/cyber-threat-intelligence

    Obsidian (note-linking/mind-mapping for research) - https://obsidian.md/

    CTI-CMM - https://cti-cmm.org/

    CREST - https://www.crest-approved.org/

    Google Notebook LM - https://notebooklm.google/

    Intelligence minor, Leiden University - https://www.universiteitleiden.nl/en/education/minors/minor/fgga-minor-intelligence-studies

    Heuer & Pherson Structured Analytic Techniques for Intelligence Analysis - https://www.amazon.com/Structured-Analytic-Techniques-Intelligence-Analysis/dp/150636893X/



    CHAPTERS

    00:00 Introduction & from military intel to CTI

    08:30 Building a bank's first CTI team

    15:00 What is intelligence — and what is CTI?

    26:00 Talking the talk vs. doing the work

    35:00 Incident-driven vs. intelligence-driven CTI

    46:00 Tradecraft, methodology & pricing CTI work

    53:00 Collection, analysis & tailoring reports

    01:04:00 Mirror imaging & understanding threat actors

    01:08:00 Measuring the value of a CTI program

    01:19:00 Threat vs. risk: capability, intent & opportunity

    01:24:00 Training intel skills & making it stick

    01:36:00 Can AI help us do intelligence better?

    1 hr 43 min
  • Lessons from a Former US Navy Collector - Joe Slowik on intelligence tradecraft and AI in CTI (S02E06)

    In this episode of Intelligence Tradecraft, host Freddy Murre sits down with Joe Slowik, a threat intelligence veteran whose career spans the US Navy, Los Alamos National Laboratory, MITRE, and the vendor world (Dragos, DomainTools, Gigamon, Huntress, and now DataMinr).


    In the conversation, Joe makes the case that intelligence is fundamentally about decision support, not raw data feeds or research written for other analysts. He and Freddy dig into what separates good reporting from bad, why stakeholder alignment and rigor (ICD 203, clear separation of fact vs. assessment) matter, and when a "flash report" beats a polished deep-dive.


    They also tackle the attribution debate — how-centric vs. who-centric attribution, the mess of overlapping naming schemas (APT10 vs. APT31, the Visma case), and why "trust us, we're Microsoft" isn't tradecraft. Joe explains the thinking behind his Applied Threat Intelligence training and the gap it was built to fill.


    The back half turns to AI: where LLMs genuinely help (research, scripting), where they're dangerous (cognitive offloading, model decay, drying up the junior-to-senior pipeline), who's accountable for AI-generated output, and how threat actors are using these tools, from better phishing to voice cloning.


    Joe's bottom line for newcomers: critical thinking, communication, and curiosity come before any prompt-engineering skill.



    Resources

    Joe Slowik's LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/joe-slowik/

    Joe Slowik's Blog and Courses - https://paralus.co/

    Freddy' Structured Analytic Techniques (SAT) Training - https://inteltradecraft.com/sat-certifications

    Los Alamos National Laboratory - https://www.lanl.gov/

    NIST Cyber Threat Intelligence definition - https://csrc.nist.gov/glossary/term/cyber_threat_intelligence

    CTI used in books (Google Search) - https://books.google.com

    APT 1 Report - https://services.google.com/fh/files/misc/mandiant-apt1-report.pdf

    Moonligh Maze on Wikipedia - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moonlight_Maze

    SANS FOR578 CTI - https://www.sans.org/cyber-security-courses/cyber-threat-intelligence

    ICD 203 - https://www.dni.gov/files/documents/ICD/ICD-203.pdf

    MLitt in Terrorism and Political Violence - https://cstpv.wp.st-andrews.ac.uk/masters-in-terrorism-and-political-violence/

    Routledge Handbook of Terrorism Research - https://www.routledge.com/The-Routledge-Handbook-of-Terrorism-Research/Schmid/p/book/9780415520997

    APT Groups and Operations Rosetta Stone (not mine) - https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1H9_xaxQHpWaa4O_Son4Gx0YOIzlcBWMsdvePFX68EKU/edit?pli=1&gid=1864660085#gid=1864660085

    Structured Analytic Techniques (SAT) Training - https://inteltradecraft.com/sat-certifications

    Tradecraft Primer: SATs - https://www.cia.gov/resources/csi/static/Tradecraft-Primer-apr09.pdf

    An Illustrated Book of Bad Arguments - https://bookofbadarguments.com/

    Weston's Rulebook for Arguments - https://hackettpublishing.com/philosophy/logic-mathematics/critical-thinking/a-rulebook-for-arguments-group

    Joe's Critique of Practical Threat Intelligence - https://pylos.co/2026/05/03/a-brief-critique-of-practical-threat-intelligence/

    Cognitive Offloading - https://sistemasi.ftik.unisi.ac.id/index.php/stmsi/article/view/6180

    OpenAI Research - https://openai.com/research/index/



    Chapters

    00:00 Intro and Joe's career path

    06:11 The Evolution of Cyber Threat Intelligence and intelligence

    15:05 Rigor, reporting, & attribution

    29:50 The Relevance of Intelligence in Incident Response and CTI

    47:09 Building & measuring a CTI function

    01:00:13 Training teams (and why it doesn't stick)

    01:07:37 Integrating LLMs in Intelligence Work

    01:19:50 Skills for the Future of CTI


    1 hr 31 min

About Intelligence Tradecraft - Sharpen your analytic edge

From the publisher's feed

Join us on “Intelligence Tradecraft”, where we explore the adoption of intelligence tradecraft in the private sector. Hosted by an intelligence and cyber threat intelligence professional, each episode…