Investing Odyssey

Investing Odyssey

Download on the App Store

Investing Odyssey episodes

  • Stahl, From the Start (Revised), Episode 2: A bad manager can beat the market

    Three Horizon writings on holding versus trading, across fourteen years.

    From Can a Bad Portfolio Manager Beat the S&P 500? (Contrarian Views and Ideas, August 1997): a manager whose picks average 8.8% a year, simply holding, overtakes a 10% market by year nine, and by year twenty compounds at 12.33%. “Patience is a remedy for many things, including poor stock selection.”

    From the 3Q 2010 Market Commentary (Horizon Asset Management, September 2010): missing five days in September cost a year’s return; the worst ten years of the Depression returned 9.9% after inflation, against negative 30.2% for 2000 to 2009; and why Horizon favored owner-operated, information-advantaged companies.

    From Buy-and-Hold vs. Market Timing: The Consequences of Portfolio Turnover (Horizon Asset Management, Market Commentary, February 2011): a perfect market timer earning 20% a year for 50 years, turning over yearly and paying a 28% tax, ends 87% behind a buy-and-holder. Frequent traders “create for themselves a higher requirement for success.”

    Part of Stahl, From the Start (Revised), short explanations of Murray Stahl’s and Horizon’s writings, joined by theme. This is our explanation, with short quoted lines; it is not a reading of the originals and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security.



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit investingodyssey.substack.com
    11 min
  • Stahl, From the Start (Revised), Episode 1: If you knew the future

    Three Horizon writings on forecasting, and on whether knowing the events in advance would tell you the returns.

    From Time Travel, Socialism, and Equity Market Returns (Contrarian Views and Ideas, April 1997): a London advisor of 1925, shown the General Strike, the Depression, the war and the end of Empire, could not have predicted that over a 70 year period British stocks would return virtually the same as American stocks. "In investing, as in life, the race is not necessarily to the swift."

    From A Solution to an Unfair Question (The Skeptic's Almanac, June 1998): a fictional General Ivankov seizes Moscow, Russia booms on resource concessions and mineral certificates, gold falls to $224 and oil to $9.72, and the Dow reaches 17,353. "Every policy, if pursued consistently, has unintended consequences."

    From Reflections on the European Debt Crisis: Predicting the Past (Horizon Asset Management, Market Commentary, May 2010): Greek debt at 113.4% of GDP, Italy at 115.2%, and France's thirty glorious years, when French equities returned 16.5% a year after inflation in the 1950s despite a falling franc. "When the market expects a grievous event, it may be right, but that event may already be reflected in the price."

    Part of Stahl, From the Start (Revised), short explanations of Murray Stahl's and Horizon's writings, joined by theme. This is our explanation, with short quoted lines; it is not a reading of the originals and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security.



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit investingodyssey.substack.com
    11 min
  • Murray Stahl Episode 41: A holding company, a scorekeeper, a miner

    This episode is from the original version of Stahl, From the Start. The series has been rebuilt as Stahl, From the Start (Revised), with longer episodes that combine related writings by theme. Start here: https://investingodyssey.substack.com/p/stahl-from-the-start-revised-episode

    A June 2010 Contrarian compendium predicts a gold bubble and features four very different companies.

    From Contrarian Research Report Compendium, June 2010 (Horizon Research Group): in Murray’s Musings, Stahl predicts a gold bubble, because the gold market is tiny next to household wealth. A 2% weight would require $1.37 trillion of gold, more than 15 times annual production, and world production had declined since 2001 despite rising prices. The report’s history of the California Gold Rush, from John Sutter to Levi Strauss and Buffalo Bill, argues that bubbles can bear useful fruit.

    The featured companies: U.S. Gold, run by Rob McEwen; Wesco Financial, at a discount to its marketable securities; Fair Isaac, with a large buyback; and Loews, whose public stakes exceeded its market value. Reader questions cover CME, AutoNation, Afghanistan and the VIX.

    Part of Stahl, From the Start, short explanations of Murray Stahl’s early writings.



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit investingodyssey.substack.com
    6 min
  • Murray Stahl Episode 40: Inflation, now and then

    This episode is from the original version of Stahl, From the Start. The series has been rebuilt as Stahl, From the Start (Revised), with longer episodes that combine related writings by theme. Start here: https://investingodyssey.substack.com/p/stahl-from-the-start-revised-episode

    A May 2010 Horizon commentary explains how it handles inflation risk without trying to predict it.

    From Inflation Now and Then (Horizon Asset Management, Market Commentary): investors grossly oversimplify inflation, which affects different parts of the economy differently. Knowing in 1970 that the decade would be inflationary, you might have bought Newmont Mining, but its 35 times multiple contracted, while Archer Daniels Midland, a grain processor with a fixed percentage margin, did far better: $100 grew to $678, against $149.

    Horizon's approach is to own businesses that don't need inflation to pay off but would benefit from it: royalty companies such as Franco Nevada and Royal Gold, spread-based businesses such as MasterCard, and real estate companies with strong balance sheets such as Vornado and Forest City.

    Part of Stahl, From the Start, short explanations of Murray Stahl's early writings.



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit investingodyssey.substack.com
    5 min
  • Murray Stahl Episode 39: Predicting the past

    This episode is from the original version of Stahl, From the Start. The series has been rebuilt as Stahl, From the Start (Revised), with longer episodes that combine related writings by theme. Start here: https://investingodyssey.substack.com/p/stahl-from-the-start-revised-episode

    A May 2010 Horizon commentary on the European debt crisis turns to France in the 1950s.

    From Reflections on the European Debt Crisis: Predicting the Past (Horizon Asset Management, Market Commentary): American debt is nearly 83% of GDP once Social Security borrowing is included, Spain’s deficit was 11.4% of GDP, and Ireland’s 14.7%. Yet France after the war saw its franc collapse, lost in Indochina, fought in Algeria and survived coup attempts, while real growth averaged 5% a year and French equities returned 16.5% a year after inflation in the 1950s.

    The lesson the commentary draws: events are easy to see, but slow-moving conditions matter as much, and economic progress happens in spite of problems. When the market expects a grievous event, the event may already be in the price.

    Part of Stahl, From the Start, short explanations of Murray Stahl’s early writings.



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit investingodyssey.substack.com
    3 min
  • Murray Stahl Episode 38: Four companies outside the usual index

    This episode is from the original version of Stahl, From the Start. The series has been rebuilt as Stahl, From the Start (Revised), with longer episodes that combine related writings by theme. Start here: https://investingodyssey.substack.com/p/stahl-from-the-start-revised-episode

    An April 2010 Global Contrarian compendium questions quantitative forecasting, then features four companies.

    From The Global Contrarian Research Report Compendium, April 2010, Part I (Horizon Research Group): in Murray’s Musings, Stahl uses Research in Motion’s consensus forecast to show the danger of extrapolating past trends, and praises economists who write in plain terms, from Gary Becker to the Marshall Jevons mystery novels. The report then looks at Chinese television’s untapped advertising market, the long-standing gap between tax rates on income and on capital gains, and Benjamin Graham’s income from Graham-Newman. Its argument is that great investors first secured a livelihood and mobilized other people’s capital.

    The featured companies: Vivendi, whose parts might be worth more separately; Television Broadcasts of Hong Kong; Areva, described as a call option on nuclear power rather than a value stock; and Phoenix Satellite Television.

    Part of Stahl, From the Start, short explanations of Murray Stahl’s early writings.



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit investingodyssey.substack.com
    6 min
  • Murray Stahl Episode 37: More thoughts on China

    This episode is from the original version of Stahl, From the Start. The series has been rebuilt as Stahl, From the Start (Revised), with longer episodes that combine related writings by theme. Start here: https://investingodyssey.substack.com/p/stahl-from-the-start-revised-episode

    A March 2010 Horizon commentary on how, and why, it invested in China.

    From More Thoughts on China (Horizon Asset Management, Monthly Commentary): the note gives the data first. Real GDP had grown about 9.7% a year since 1977, yet GDP per person was $3,565, under one-eleventh of the U.S. level. Purchasing power parity studies suggested the renminbi might be as much as 50% undervalued, and the most widely used international benchmark, MSCI EAFE, held no China at all.

    Then the reason, which it calls an extraordinary statement: one cannot diversify a portfolio with China, because China already reaches every portfolio through trade, commodities, inflation and interest rates. Its two rules are domestic revenues (a company selling overseas is Chinese in name only) and, where possible, the government as a significant shareholder, as with China Life and CNOOC. The caveat is patience: six Hang Seng drawdowns averaging about 56% in three decades, yet 11.5% a year over thirty years against 8.1% for the S&P 500.

    Part of Stahl, From the Start, short explanations of Murray Stahl's early writings.



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit investingodyssey.substack.com
    5 min
  • Murray Stahl Episode 36: Is China in a bubble?

    This episode is from the original version of Stahl, From the Start. The series has been rebuilt as Stahl, From the Start (Revised), with longer episodes that combine related writings by theme. Start here: https://investingodyssey.substack.com/p/stahl-from-the-start-revised-episode

    A February 11, 2010 Horizon commentary takes apart the claim that China was in a bubble.

    From Is China in a Bubble? (Horizon Asset Management, Interim Market Commentary): the note argues that the word itself carries an emotion that makes dispassionate analysis difficult. Taking a December 2009 Forbes article as its specimen, it points out that the Hang Seng went from 20,106 to 20,122 between January 2007 and January 2010 while China's real GDP kept growing, that the article's debt comparison with the United States was not a bona fide one, and that the popular "$7 of credit per $1 of GDP" statistic sets nominal debt against real GDP.

    Its test case, Evergrande Real Estate, was priced at about $15.77 per square foot of undeveloped land, against raw-land sales of roughly $81 and over $145. The valuation might prove high or low, but the note did not find it preposterous. Its conclusion: no bubble, but expect extreme interim volatility.

    Part of Stahl, From the Start, short explanations of Murray Stahl's early writings.



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit investingodyssey.substack.com
    4 min
  • Murray Stahl Episode 35: Less talk, more figures

    An August 2009 Horizon note checks the exchange thesis against the figures.

    From Exchanges: Less Talk, More Figures (Horizon Asset Management, Commentary): the draconian margin compression people expected didn’t appear. CME Group’s operating margin was 42.5% and Hong Kong’s 78.5%. Competition had actually shrunk: 76% of a list of independent North American exchanges had been acquired by five companies. And losing market share hadn’t meant losing volume. The NYSE’s share of its own listed volume fell from over 80% to under 45%, yet its volume grew nearly 15% a year. The CBOE lost 67% of its options share since 1973 while its volume grew about 36% a year from 2000 to 2008.

    The note suggests a securities exchange version of Moore’s law, and says exchanges are at the doorstep of a golden age.

    Part of Stahl, From the Start, short explanations of Murray Stahl’s early writings.



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit investingodyssey.substack.com
    3 min
  • Murray Stahl Episode 34: A fund that promises three times today

    This episode is from the original version of Stahl, From the Start. The series has been rebuilt as Stahl, From the Start (Revised), with longer episodes that combine related writings by theme. Start here: https://investingodyssey.substack.com/p/stahl-from-the-start-revised-episode

    A July 2009 Devil’s Advocate compendium moves from negative bubbles to shorting triple-leveraged ETFs.

    From The Devil’s Advocate Report Compendium, July 2009 (Horizon Research Group): in Murray’s Musings, Stahl argues that negative bubbles, excessive confidence in a bad outcome, cost more than positive ones, because their losses are opportunity costs that leave no documents. He cites a revival in offerings, including record May issuance of $49 billion, as a sign the capital market was working again. The report treats ETF companies as an industry and as true croupiers, then explains a June 2009 FINRA notice: leveraged and inverse ETFs need not track their index over long periods, because of constant-dollar shorting and daily swap resets.

    The trades: short triple-leveraged bull funds against their index funds, three dollars long for each dollar short, and short the VIX, which the report projects back to 10 to 12. It also warns about crowding, through the fallacy of composition.

    Part of Stahl, From the Start, short explanations of Murray Stahl’s early writings.



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit investingodyssey.substack.com
    6 min

About Investing Odyssey

From the publisher's feed

New perspectives on investment opportunities

investingodyssey.substack.com