Intro: Why You Don’t Need a Massive Crowd to Make a Big Decision

Let’s set the stage: You’ve got a genius product idea (hello, brilliance!), but there’s that nagging feeling—will people actually want it? Before going big, what if you could get answers without having to shout from the rooftops?

Think of it this way: Testing product-market fit with a small audience is like cooking for a few friends before hosting a Thanksgiving dinner. You get to try out the recipe, add a little more spice if it’s too bland, and toss in extra marshmallows if your “friends” (a.k.a. early users) tell you they’re key.

So, let’s dive into how you can serve up that product and get some honest feedback from a tiny, highly-targeted audience before risking a big launch!

1. Hand-Pick Your Small Audience Like a Chef Chooses Ingredients

A small, handpicked group of early adopters is your first stop. Forget throwing the product out there for anyone and everyone—reach out to people who truly need what you’re offering. These are the folks who, when they see your product, should think, “This is exactly what I needed!”

Imagine you’re on a road trip. If you know where you’re headed, you’re more likely to get there without taking endless detours. The same goes for your product: a well-defined destination (aka target audience) means your test journey is more likely to reach real insights.

Tip: Identify a specific, small group that desperately needs the solution your product provides. They’re not just users; they’re the ones who can’t wait for your product to exist.

2. Find Your Superfans: Small Groups, Big Feedback

You don’t need a crowd; you need some superfans. Think of them like the biggest fans at a rock concert. They’re the ones in the front row, knowing every lyric by heart and ready to scream if you add a killer guitar riff. These are the people who will genuinely use and talk about your product.

To get them engaged, make it exclusive. An invite-only beta can make people feel like they’re getting backstage passes. Exclusive access boosts engagement because they feel like they’re part of something special.

Tip: A Facebook Group, Slack channel, or Discord server can become a small, interactive hub where these superfans can connect with you, offer feedback, and even help you spread the word when the time’s right.

3. Keep Feedback Loops Fast and Furious

Picture this: You’re at a comedy show, and the comedian tests out a joke. If the audience laughs, they know it’s good. If not, they tweak it for the next set. Testing product-market fit should be the same—feedback is instant, and the tweaks are quick.

Set up a simple, structured way to capture feedback, whether through quick surveys, one-on-one calls, or feedback forms. The key here is to avoid making the feedback loop feel like homework for your users. Make it fun, make it quick, and don’t bombard them with questions. They’ll give you gold if you make it easy for them!

Tip: Consider sending out a super-short survey after each milestone or product update, but add a little humor. Ask, “On a scale of ‘meh’ to ‘OMG where have you been all my life,’ how would you rate the new feature?”

4. Run Tiny Experiments with a Big Punch

Imagine you’re throwing out popcorn at a movie theater. You don’t throw a whole bucket at the audience to see if they like it; you toss a piece here, a piece there, and watch who grabs for more. Testing product-market fit with a small audience works the same way.

Run a small experiment on one feature at a time. This helps you figure out what they love and what they couldn’t care less about, without risking everything. Try offering an MVP (Minimum Viable Product) version and ask users if it solves their pain points. Remember, the goal isn’t perfection here—it’s to see if you’re close to something that could be huge.

Tip: Start with a basic version, roll it out, and measure responses to see if they find it valuable. Experiment with different marketing angles too—sometimes, it’s how you present it that clicks.

5. Analyze Reactions Like a Detective

Let’s say your product gets a “meh” from your small audience. Don’t freak out—consider it a clue! Sherlock Holmes wouldn’t call off a case after one dead end, so don’t be discouraged by initial feedback. Dig into what users actually say versus what they do.

Did they enjoy using the product? Did they tell a friend about it? Analyze behavior as much as feedback—sometimes, people’s actions speak louder than their words. And if you find a detail they keep mentioning, good or bad, take note. These are your clues to refining the product for the larger audience later.

Tip: Use tools like Google Analytics, Hotjar, or Crazy Egg to understand user behavior. Watch where they click, how much time they spend, and where they drop off.

6. Make It Feel Like a Club, Not a Classroom

In the end, your small audience wants to feel like they’re a part of something, not just another cog in a test machine. People want to feel like insiders, especially if they’re helping shape a product they care about. So, treat them like VIPs!

Keep them updated on how their feedback has shaped the product. When they see their suggestions in action, it gives them a sense of ownership. Plus, who doesn’t love a little spotlight? They’re much more likely to share your product with others if they feel they’ve had a hand in building it.

Tip: Send out occasional updates with phrases like, “You asked, we listened!” and show the features or tweaks based on their feedback.

Building something from the ground up isn’t easy, but remember—it’s the small steps that help you reach the top of the mountain. Testing your product-market fit with a small group doesn’t just give you valuable insights; it gives you the confidence to go big when the time’s right!

With each new insight, you’re one step closer to product-market fit and, hopefully, avoiding the dreaded “meh” reaction from a larger audience.

Register here for my FREE course

P.S.:Consider this your friendly reminder: A small audience can be mighty if you approach them the right way. Treat them like your startup sherpas—they’ll help you scale the mountain, one insight at a time.

This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit manojthomas.substack.com