From the right angle, with the right wig... This week, Tyler and Johnny are covering the kidnapping of Charley Ross (part two). Plus: a piece of Blair Witch trivia that could've changed everything, All Stars 11 brings back the rapping roast, and a rogue peanut butter smearer seems to be on the loose.

Join the Secret Society That Doesn't Suck for exclusive weekly mini episodes, livestreams, and a whole lot more! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check out our new and improved apparel store with tons of new designs! thatsspooky.com/store

Check out our website for show notes, photos, and more at thatsspooky.com

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and all the memes @thatsspookypod

We're on Twitter! Follow us at @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to [email protected]

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.