Evan and Tessa matched on Tinder. They had a good connection and kicked it off, but Tessa ended up ghosting Evan after their first date. He admits that he may have been excessively using his cell phone at the date, but Tessa gives us the scoop on what exactly went wrong.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Marcus thought his date with Danielle checked all the boxes: easy chemistry, and a smooth night from start to finish. But one small moment at the end of dinner completely changed everything, and Danielle made up her mind on the spot. Now Marcus is left confused, while Danielle says that moment told her everything she needed to know. Find out everything on Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Erika thought her date with Gunner was one of those easy, natural connections, great conversation, lots of laughs, and clear chemistry. But near the end of the night, Gunner suddenly started feeling off and cut things short… then completely disappeared. When we finally hear his side, it turns out something from that night stuck with him in a way Erika never expected.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Trevor thought his date with Nadia was full of laughs and playful chemistry, even bonding over a strange, recurring smell at the restaurant. But while Trevor brushed it off as a funny coincidence, Nadia had a very different theory about what was really going on. By the end of the night, something he didn’t think was a big deal became a dealbreaker she couldn’t ignore.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Jordan and Alyssa went out after meeting the good ol’ millenial way, on a dating app. He thought everything went smoothly, they really connected over their shared love of travel… but now Alyssa has left him behind wondering what happened. But after the date, Alyssa did a little digging online and found something that made her completely rethink everything. Now Jordan’s left confused, and Alyssa says the truth she uncovered was too much to ignore.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Ethan and Marissa met at a networking event and hit it off enough to grab drinks afterward. He thought their first date was going perfectly, laughs, good conversation, even walking her home like a gentleman. But Marissa never called him back. What did Marissa see after their date that had her confident she didn't want to call Ethan back? Find out on Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Ava thought she had one of those rare, instant-chemistry first dates with Brent, great conversation, future talk, and even a kiss to seal it. But after the date, Brent quietly disappeared, leaving her completely confused. When the truth comes out, it turns out something he saw after the date sent his mind spiraling in a way Ava never could’ve expected

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

After a great dinner together, Mikey was shocked when Annie suddenly went from talking about extending the night to completely ghosting him. When we finally get Annie on the phone, she reveals that one habit of Mikey's was simply too much for her to handle.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Kim thought she had found a genuinely thoughtful guy when she met Jeffrey on Hinge. He seemed to remember every detail, asked all the right questions, and somehow knew things about her that made it feel like they had known each other for years. But after the date, Jeffrey disappeared, and when the truth comes out, Kim learns there was a reason he seemed unusually informed.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Jennifer thought her date with Raymond was a success, but afterward he completely ghosted her, leaving her confused about what went wrong. When we get him on the phone, Raymond admits she “had it going on”… except for one detail that instantly turned him off and made him question everything. Jennifer fires back, and what starts as a simple explanation quickly turns into a heated clash over judgment and first impressions. Find out what happened on Second Date Update!

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.