Family said they caused Brewster man's death

After a Putnam County sheriff's deputy tackled George Taranto and his colleagues helped handcuff the Brewster resident outside his home on July 8, 2019, Sgt. William Quick and Investigator Daniel Hunsberger spoke to his wife, Karen.

While paramedics treated George Taranto, 75, Quick said, "Do you know that I almost killed your husband tonight?" according to Karen Taranto.

Karen Taranto and her son and daughter believe head trauma caused by George Taranto being driven to the ground led to his death two years later. But a federal judge disagreed on March 31, dismissing their $75 million wrongful-death lawsuit over an incident that began with a report of a transformer fire and ended in a standoff with George Taranto, who suffered from early dementia and had gone outside with a loaded handgun to investigate noises.

Judge Victoria Reznik of the U.S. District Court in White Plains dismissed all claims filed by Taranto's family against Hunsberger, Quick and three other deputies: Vincent Dalo, Ryan Diskin and Ronald Yeager. Claims against Putnam County and then-Sheriff Robert Langley Jr. were also dismissed.

Reznik found that Dalo did not use excessive force in tackling Taranto after deputies said they saw the gun in his right hand and mistook a holster in his left hand for a second weapon. Without a case for excessive force, the family's other claims, including for assault and battery and wrongful death, also had to be dismissed, said Reznik.

An investigation completed by the Sheriff's Office in July 2020 found that the officers "acted within the scope of their duties" and had not violated any state laws or agency regulations. "No reasonable jury could find that Deputy Sheriff Dalo's split-second decision to subdue Taranto by tackling him to the ground" was unreasonable, Reznik concluded.

The confrontation began shortly after Diskin responded to a report of a transformer explosion. He called for backup after spotting a vehicle with two males inside that was acting "suspiciously." Both males jumped from the car when Diskin followed it; one obeyed his order to drop to the ground and the other ran into the woods.

Yeager, who responded with Dalo, Hunsberger and Quick, testified that during the search for the second male, he saw Taranto standing at his back patio door and told him to stay inside. Hunsberger said he then saw Taranto standing behind a garage and also told him to return indoors.

Hunsberger said he began walking away but turned when he heard Taranto ask, "Who the fuck is out there?" Seeing a loaded Colt Mustang .380 pistol in Taranto's right hand, Hunsberger said he drew his weapon and alerted the other deputies. They took cover while Taranto shielded himself behind a parked car, according to court documents.

The family, whose lawyer did not respond to a request for comment, said Taranto's gun was pointed at the ground. They say he complied when deputies, with their weapons drawn, began screaming at him to drop the gun, raise his hands and walk toward them.

But the officers said Taranto, who they initially thought was drunk, initially did not obey their commands and continued to hide. When he put down his gun and walked toward the officers, Dalo feared that a holster in Taranto's left hand could be another weapon, according to court documents. He tackled the Brewster man from behind, causing his head to hit the ground.

At Putnam Hospital, Taranto suffered cardiac arrest and respiratory failure, as well as a pulmonary edema, according to his family, and was moved to Danbury Hospital in Connecticut. Deputies issued tickets for second-degree menacing, fourth-degree criminal possession of a weapon, resisting arrest and second-degree obstructing governmental administration, all misdemeanors.

Taranto was released but hospitalized again on Sept. 2, according to the lawsuit. A scan revealed bleeding in his brain, requiring surgery. His injuries led the family to sue for $50 million in ...