The legal issue in Felthouse v Bindley centers around the formation of a valid contract, specifically whether silence or a failure to reject an offer can be considered acceptance.

Here's a breakdown of the issue:

• Offer: Paul Felthouse offered to buy a horse from his nephew. He stated in his offer, "If I hear no more about him, I consider the horse mine..." This created a condition where the nephew's silence would be deemed as acceptance.
• Silence as Acceptance: The nephew did not explicitly accept his uncle's offer but intended to sell the horse to him. He told the auctioneer, Bindley, not to sell the horse. However, Bindley mistakenly sold the horse.
• Dispute: Felthouse sued Bindley for conversion (a tort that deals with interfering with someone else's property). To succeed, Felthouse needed to prove that the horse was his property, which depended on whether a valid contract existed between him and his nephew.
• Court Decision: The court held that there was no contract because the nephew had not communicated his acceptance of the offer. Silence did not constitute acceptance. An offeror cannot impose an obligation on the offeree to reject an offer.

Why this case is important:

• Principle of Acceptance: Felthouse v Bindley established a key principle in contract law: acceptance must be clearly communicated. An offeror cannot force a contract on someone by saying "if I don't hear from you, I assume you agree."
• Protecting the Offeree: This case protects the offeree from being bound to a contract they did not explicitly agree to. It prevents people from being forced into agreements through inaction or silence.

Modern Implications:

While the general principle of Felthouse v Bindley still holds true, there are some exceptions and nuances in modern contract law:

• Conduct as Acceptance: In some cases, conduct can imply acceptance even without explicit communication. For example, if the nephew had delivered the horse to his uncle, that action might have been considered acceptance.
• Prior Dealings: If parties have a history of dealing with each other in a certain way, silence might be considered acceptance based on their established practices.
• Unilateral Contracts: In unilateral contracts (where one party makes a promise in exchange for an action), acceptance is often through performance of the requested action, rather than explicit communication.

Need Classes?

Legal English innovation has several classes weekly, focusing on commercial law and other areas to help you communicate better with your clients.

+57 320-315-4781

Follow us on Instagram!

Friends on Facebook?

Like us on Linked In?

Vocabulary Breakdown

• A Different Ball Game: A situation that is completely new or different, requiring a new approach or strategy.
• Legally Binding: An agreement or promise that is enforceable by law.
• Hold Up a Bargain: To fulfill one's part of an agreement.
• To Be Entitled: To have the right to something, often a benefit or privilege.
• Safe and Sound: Free from harm or danger.
• Exercise a Right: To put a right or privilege into action; to use it.
• An Animal Shelter: A place where stray or abandoned animals are cared for.
• A Take Away: A key point or lesson to be learned from a situation.
• The Fine Print: The details of an agreement, often in small print and containing important conditions or limitations.

Scenario

Imagine you volunteer at an animal shelter. You find a lost dog with a collar but no identification. You put up "Found Dog" posters, hoping the owner will see them. Someone calls, claiming to be the owner. They say, "I'll give you a reward, that's a legally binding offer!" But when they arrive, they seem hesitant about the dog.

You remember a story about someone who almost gave their pet to the wrong person. You decide this is a different ball game. You say, "Before we hold up that bargain, I need to see proof of ownership – vet records, photos, anything." The person gets angry. You stand your ground, exercising your right to be cautious. Finally, they show you photos of the dog. Relieved, you hand over the dog, who is now safe and sound with its real owner.

The Take Away: Always be careful, even in seemingly simple situations. Pay attention to the fine print, trust your gut, and don't be afraid to exercise your rights.

Need Classes?

Legal English innovation has several classes weekly, focusing on commercial law and other areas to help you communicate better with your clients.

+57 320-315-4781

Follow us on Instagram!

Friends on Facebook?

Like us on Linked In?

Imagine a landmark case about council house allocation. The case hinges on a seemingly small word in the housing act, and the judge's decision could have high stakes for many people. One side presents a bombshell piece of evidence. Lawyers use fancy jargon to argue their points, and the judge has to ponder the implications of the quirk in the law. Finally, the judge makes a decision, wrapping up the case and leaving the door open for possible appeals.

Vocabulary List

• Binding (adj.): Creating a legal obligation
• Bombshell (n.): A surprising and impactful event
• Council House (n.): Public housing provided by local authorities
• High Stakes (adj.): Involving significant risk or potential consequences
• Jargon (n.): Specialized language, often difficult for others to understand
• Landmark (adj.): Historically important and influential
• Open (adj.): Allowing for future possibilities
• Ponder (v.): To think carefully about something
• Quirk (n.): A peculiar aspect
• Seemingly (adv.): Appearing to be something, possibly deceptively
• Wrap Up (v.): To conclude or finalize something

Need Classes?

Legal English innovation has several classes weekly, focusing on commercial law and other areas to help you communicate better with your clients.

+57 320-315-4781

Follow us on Instagram!

Friends on Facebook?

Like us on Linked In?

Legal Concepts & Practices 

• Prior dealings: Past interactions or transactions between parties.
• A long-standing agreement: An agreement that has been in place for a considerable amount of time.
• Course of dealings: A pattern of conduct between parties in previous transactions.
• A precedent: A legal decision or case that serves as an example or authority for deciding similar cases in the future.
• To hold up: To remain valid or effective, especially under scrutiny or challenge.
• To be murky: To be unclear, vague, or ambiguous.
• Unspoken rules: Informal or implicit understandings that govern behavior.
• Informed consent: Agreement to something after being fully informed of the risks, benefits, and alternatives.
• Bounty hunter: A person who captures fugitives or criminals for a reward.
• Last but not least: An expression used to emphasize the importance of the final item in a list.
• Legally sound: Compliant with the law; valid and enforceable.
• No ambiguity: Clear and precise language.
• At the forefront: In a leading or prominent position.
• To be a wrap: To be finished or concluded.

Need Classes?

Legal English innovation has several classes weekly, focusing on commercial law and other areas to help you communicate better with your clients.

+57 320-315-4781

Follow us on Instagram!

Friends on Facebook?

Like us on Linked In?

Vocabulary Builder

• To tackle: To confront or deal with a challenge or problem. (e.g., "The lawyers decided to tackle the issue of liability head-on.")
• Consideration: Something of value exchanged between parties to make a contract binding. (e.g., "The consideration for the lease was the monthly rent payment.")
• To enter into: To formally become involved in an agreement or contract. (e.g., "The parties entered into a binding arbitration agreement.")
• To unpack something: To analyze or explain something in detail. (e.g., "The judge carefully unpacked the complex legal arguments.")
• A bargain: An agreement between parties, often involving the exchange of goods or services. (e.g., "The plea bargain allowed the defendant to avoid a lengthy trial.")
• Cold hard cash: Money in the form of physical currency, emphasizing its immediate and tangible nature. (e.g., "The contract required payment in cold hard cash.")
• To be all ears: To listen attentively. (e.g., "The mediator was all ears as the parties explained their positions.")
• To give up something: To relinquish a right, claim, or possession. (e.g., "The defendant gave up their right to a jury trial.")
• To trim hedges: To reduce or limit something, often to avoid risk or exposure. (e.g., "The company trimmed its legal liabilities by implementing a new safety protocol.")
• Forbearance: The act of refraining from enforcing a right or debt. (e.g., "The bank granted the homeowner forbearance on their mortgage payments.")
• The backbone of something: The essential part of something that provides support. (e.g., "Contract law is the backbone of commercial transactions.")
• To spot something: To identify or notice something, often that is difficult to find. (e.g., "The lawyer spotted a loophole in the contract.")
• To wrap up: To conclude or finish something. (e.g., "The parties hoped to wrap up negotiations by the end of the week.")
• Likewise: Similarly; in the same way. (e.g., "The plaintiff breached the contract; likewise, the defendant failed to fulfill their obligations.")

Need Classes?

Legal English innovation has several classes weekly, focusing on commercial law and other areas to help you communicate better with your clients.

+57 320-315-4781

Follow us on Instagram!

Friends on Facebook?

Like us on Linked In?

Basic Contract Terms

• To tackle: To begin to deal with a difficult task or problem. In a legal context, this could mean taking on a complex case or legal issue.
• To enter into: To formally agree to something, like a contract or agreement.
• To be legally bound: To be obligated to do something because of a law or contract.
• To take to court: To initiate legal proceedings against someone.
• To throw out of court: When a judge dismisses a case, often due to lack of evidence or merit.
• Consideration: Something of value exchanged between parties to a contract that makes it legally binding (e.g., money, goods, services, or a promise to do or not do something).
• Illusory promise: A promise that appears real but is so vague or conditional that it does not actually create a binding obligation.
• Hot air: Empty talk; promises or claims that are not genuine or sincere.
• An offer: A proposal to enter into a contract, including definite terms.
• Acceptance: An agreement to the terms of an offer, creating a binding contract.
• Back out on a whim: To withdraw from an agreement without a valid reason.
• Right to revoke: The ability to withdraw an offer before it is accepted.
• Option contract: An agreement where one party pays for the right to keep an offer open for a specific time.
• Reject outright: To completely refuse an offer.
• Counteroffer: A response to an offer that changes the terms, effectively rejecting the original offer and creating a new one.
• Scratch the surface: To only begin to deal with a problem or issue; to address something superficially.

Need Classes?

Legal English innovation has several classes weekly, focusing on commercial law and other areas to help you communicate better with your clients.

+57 320-315-4781

Follow us on Instagram!

Friends on Facebook?

Like us on Linked In?

Greenmail is a controversial corporate takeover defense where a company buys back its shares from a hostile bidder at a premium to prevent a takeover.

This practice, considered by some to be corporate blackmail, raises ethical concerns because it rewards aggressive behavior, dilutes shareholder value, and protects management. 

While not illegal, greenmail's legality can be challenged if it unjustly benefits management or harms shareholders. Ultimately, it presents a complex issue regarding fairness and transparency in corporate governance.

Need Classes?

Legal English innovation has several classes weekly, focusing on commercial law and other areas to help you communicate better with your clients.

+57 320-315-4781

Follow us on Instagram!

Friends on Facebook?

Like us on Linked In?

This tactic, triggered when an acquirer surpasses a specified ownership threshold, allows existing shareholders (excluding the acquirer) to buy shares in the merged company at a discounted price.

A key element is the conversion price, offering a significant reduction compared to the market value. The text uses a hypothetical example involving "Hostile Inc." and "Woke Inc." to illustrate how the strategy could dilute the acquirer's ownership and potentially deter a hostile takeover. The duration of the shareholder's right to purchase shares at the discounted price is also a critical component.

Need Classes?

Legal English innovation has several classes weekly, focusing on commercial law and other areas to help you communicate better with your clients.

+57 320-315-4781

Follow us on Instagram!

Friends on Facebook?

Like us on Linked In?

A flip-in poison pill is triggered when an acquirer reaches a predetermined ownership threshold, allowing existing shareholders (excluding the acquirer) to purchase additional shares at a discounted price.

This dilutes the acquirer's stake, making the takeover more expensive and less attractive. The explanation uses the example of Woke Inc. facing a hostile takeover by Hostile Inc. to illustrate how a flip-in poison pill functions. 

Need Classes?

Legal English innovation has several classes weekly, focusing on commercial law and other areas to help you communicate better with your clients.

+57 320-315-4781

Follow us on Instagram!

Friends on Facebook?

Like us on Linked In?

Poison pills dilute the acquiring company's ownership stake, making the takeover more expensive and challenging.

Two main types are detailed: flip-in pills, which allow existing shareholders to buy discounted shares, and flip-over pills, granting post-merger discounted share purchases. These tactics significantly hinder hostile takeover attempts.

The overall goal is to deter unwanted acquisitions by increasing their cost and complexity.

Need Classes?

Legal English innovation has several classes weekly, focusing on commercial law and other areas to help you communicate better with your clients.

+57 320-315-4781

Follow us on Instagram!

Friends on Facebook?

Like us on Linked In?