Legends and Lore Podcast

On December 5, 1872, the British brig Dei Gratia came upon a ghostly sight—a ship drifting aimlessly in the Atlantic. It was The Mary Celeste, a merchant brigantine that had left New York just a month earlier, fully crewed and bound for Italy. But now, it was eerily empty. The lifeboat was missing, the cargo untouched, and there were no signs of struggle. The crew had simply vanished into thin air. For over 150 years, theories have ranged from natural disasters and piracy to paranormal forces and secret plots. What really happened to the Mary Celeste? Was it foul play, a tragic accident, or something even stranger? Join us as we set sail into one of history’s most enduring maritime mysteries.

In 1959, nine experienced hikers set off on a trek through the frozen Ural Mountains—only to vanish under bizarre and terrifying circumstances. When their bodies were found, investigators uncovered a scene so disturbing it defied explanation: tents ripped open from the inside, strange injuries, radiation traces, and no clear cause of death. Over the decades, theories have ranged from avalanches and military experiments to yetis and even something otherworldly. Was it natural disaster, human error, or a terrifying secret buried in the snow? Join us as we unravel the mystery of The Dyatlov Pass Incident.

In this episode of Legends & Lore, we spread our wings and dive deep into the chilling legend of Mothman. From the first eerie sightings in Point Pleasant, West Virginia, to the tragic Silver Bridge collapse, we unravel eyewitness accounts, government conspiracies, and the shadowy presence of the Men in Black. But Mothman’s story doesn’t stop there—his legacy stretches across the globe, appearing in strange sightings from the UK to Chicago. Is he a cryptid, an interdimensional being, or a harbinger of doom? Join us as we explore the theories, the cultural impact, and why this winged figure continues to haunt our collective imagination.

In this spine-chilling episode of Legends & Lore, host David Culpepper dives into the eerie and unsettling phenomenon of the Black Eyed Kids. Who are these pale, monotone children with jet-black eyes, and why do they insist on being let inside? From terrifying eyewitness encounters to theories about supernatural origins, alien hybrids, and modern mythology, we explore every dark corner of this modern urban legend. Are they real? And if they are, what do they want? Join us as we uncover the mystery of the Black Eyed Kids—just don’t answer the knock at your door tonight.

On March 13, 1997, thousands of people across the Southwest witnessed something extraordinary: a series of mysterious lights gliding silently across the night sky. In this episode of Legends & Lore, host David Culpepper dives into the Phoenix Lights, exploring eyewitness accounts, the leading theories, and the deeper questions this event raises about the unknown. Were the lights extraterrestrial visitors, secret military experiments, or something even stranger? Join us as we unravel one of the most compelling UFO mysteries in modern history.

In this chilling episode of Legends & Lore, host David Culpepper takes you deep into the sinister world of H.H. Holmes, America’s first documented serial killer. From his charming exterior to the horrors hidden within his infamous “Murder Castle,” Holmes’s story is one of deception, manipulation, and murder. Discover how he used the chaos of the 1893 Chicago World’s Fair as a hunting ground, the gruesome secrets investigators uncovered, and the myths and facts that surround his dark legacy. Was he a criminal mastermind or a conman turned killer? Join us as we unravel the terrifying tale of the Devil in Chicago.

In this chilling episode of Legends & Lore, host David Culpepper ventures into the dark woods of Elkhorn, Wisconsin, to unravel the legend of the Beast of Bray Road. For decades, locals have reported sightings of a wolf-like creature stalking this quiet stretch of road, leaving behind eerie encounters, strange tracks, and more questions than answers. Is it a cryptid? A shapeshifter? Or just a misunderstood creature of the wild? Join us as we explore the history, the eyewitness accounts, the wild theories, and the ongoing search for this mysterious beast. Get ready to question what’s lurking just beyond the headlights.

In this episode of Legends & Lore, host David Culpepper takes a deep dive into the disappearance of the Roanoke Colony, one of history’s most enduring mysteries. Join us as we explore the hopes, hardships, and haunting clues left behind by the settlers, uncover the latest discoveries, and examine the theories—both plausible and wild—that surround this legendary tale. What really happened to the Lost Colony? Tune in and decide for yourself.

What connects the mysterious disappearance of an experienced sailor, unexplained underwater lights documented by police, and ancient Native American legends? Welcome to Lake Champlain's Triangle - a mysterious zone between New York and Vermont where boats vanish, compasses spin wildly, and something large lurks beneath the surface. Join us as we dive deep into the dark waters of America's most enigmatic lake, featuring exclusive interviews with MIT researchers, local witnesses, and marine scientists who are still trying to explain what's really happening in this seemingly peaceful body of water.

On a quiet summer evening in 1955, two Kentucky families faced something that would challenge everything they thought they knew about reality. What started as a curious light in the sky escalated into a terrifying night-long siege by mysterious silver creatures that seemed immune to bullets. Eleven witnesses, including adults and children, barricaded themselves in a farmhouse, firing shotguns at entities that floated, flipped through the air, and kept coming back for more. The Kelly-Hopkinsville encounter remains one of the most well-documented and puzzling close encounter cases in UFO history. Join us as we explore this fascinating case, from the initial sighting to the police investigation, and discover why it continues to influence UFO research nearly 70 years later. What really happened that August night in Kentucky? Tune in to find out.