Let Me Sum Up

Let Me Sum Up

By Luke Menzel, Tennant Reed, Frankie MuskovicNewsScienceGovernmentPolitics
Download on the App Store

All Let Me Sum Up episodes

  • LMSU Holiday Special 2022: Don’t Sum Up

    In this EXTRA SPECIAL HOLIDAY SPECTACULAR your intrepid hosts eschew the normal dissection of climate and energy reports and instead, in an exercise of regrettable democratic process, critique a climate movie of YOUR choice, dear Summerupperers.

    But before we do that, we kick off with the inaugural awarding of our favourite climate and energy paper of 2022. This award, which most-definitely-will-not-be-named-the-Papies, was awarded to… DRUMROLL pleeeeease…..

    'Empirically grounded technology forecasts and the energy transition’ from Rupert Way, Matthew C. Ives, Penny Mealy and J. Doyne Farmer from Oxford University. AKA the learning rates paper! A very worthy recipient of Let Me Sum Up’s inaugural NON-Papie! Honourable mentions for our runners up go to Infrastructure Victoria’s ‘Towards 2050: Gas Infrastructure in a Net Zero Emissions Economy’ and the Commonwealth’s ‘Safeguard Mechanism Reforms consultation paper’. And of course you could do a lot worse than hit the back catalogue to hear us discuss these three papers on Episode 11, Episode 5 and Episode 7 respectively!

    Grabbing the popcorn and maybe some rotten tomatoes, your intrepid hosts settled in to critique the climate movie of your choice for 2022, the satirical comedy ‘Don’t Look Up’ in which two astronomers go on a media tour to warn humankind of a planet-killing comet hurtling toward Earth. The response from a distracted world: Meh. The response from your intrepid hosts? We’re not going to make it that easy for you Summerupperers! We watched so you can listen ;-)

    Frankie's One More Thing is Noel Pearson’s Boyer Lecture for 2022, available as a podcast or on ABC iView, where he discusses constitutional recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, contending this is not a project of identity politics, but one of justice, unity and inclusion.

    Tennant's One More Thing is a retro fantastic re-reading of a favourite science fiction book by William Gibson, Neuromancer, published in 1984. Go check it out!

    Luke's One More Thing is a summer movie whodunnit, Glass Onion starring Daniel Craig as Benoit Blanc, a charming PI with a southern drawl. Reminiscent of Agatha Christie and also skewering the rich and powerful, this is currently filling Menzel’s void of Rian Johnson’s missing Star Wars trilogy so give it a watch peeps!

    We are taking a break in January but will be back with ever more reports to read in Feb 2023. In the meantime, happy holidays to all our wonderful Summerupperers. Please keep tweeting your thoughts to us at @LukeMenzel, @TennantReed and @FrankieMuskovic and if you would like to weave some golden threads through our back catalogue, give us your feelpinions or suggest papers to read we are always here for that - hit us up at [email protected].

    1 hr 7 min
  • UN expert group targets zero net zero target flimflam!

    Perhaps for the final time in 2022 your intrepid hosts reconvene ENERGY CRISIS CORNER. Why you might ask? Only: the spectacular recall of the Federal Parliament to pass legislation on a price cap for wholesale gas for the next year, $3bn in bill relief for vulnerable Australians to be jointly paid by the Commonwealth and the states, price caps on coal to be enacted by the states AND somewhere in there a significant commitment to fund energy efficiency and electrification for households and businesses, $TBA. So y’know. #fairbiton

    This week we discuss one of the bagillion reports launched at COP27, this one from the UN High-Level Expert Group on the Net Zero Commitments of Non-State Entities, ‘Integrity Matters: Net Zero Commitments by Businesses, Financial Institutions, Cities and Regions’. AKA the Greenwashing Report!

    Frankie's One More Thing is the recent announcement from Treasurer Jim Chalmers that the Government will develop a comprehensive sustainable finance strategy, including mandatory climate risk reporting, a sustainable finance taxonomy and a crackdown on corporate greenwashing. It’s allllll coming together folks.

    Tennant's One More Thing is a hot-off-the-press update from European Trilogues in which an agreement was reached on a host of measures, but of most interest to our resident CBAM enthusiast, was the green light on implementation for the European CBAM which will come into force in 2026 after a 3-year transition. Enough time for other jurisdictions to implement their own CBAMs? OUI! says Tennant.

    Luke's One More Thing is a cracking podcast for the politically inclined, etymology curious subset of Summeruperers (ALL OF YOU RIGHT?). Origin Story sees hosts Ian Dunt and Dorian Lynskey dive into the histories behind words and concepts that are commonly misunderstood and get thrown around willy nilly. McCarthyism? Woke? Centrism? This pod has got you covered.

    HOLIDAY SPECIAL: Summerupperers, to a collective ‘meh’ from your intrepid hosts at the result of our poll, we will indeed dutifully go and watch Don’t Look Up and bring you what could potentially be the last remaining hot spicy vindaloo takes on this analysed-up-the-wazooo climate movie. Frankie is happy it’s not Naked Gun 2.5 (also wasn’t an option) and Tennant is about as happy as the gas industry is right now (did you catch his openly self interested and partisan campaign for Soylent Green on Twitter?). The Good News? Don't Look Up is streaming now (and likely until the End Times) on Netflix, so you can watch along at home! Go on!

    And that’s all from us this week Summerupperers! We shall see you next time and until then, please keep tweeting your thoughts to us at @LukeMenzel, @TennantReed and @FrankieMuskovic and if you would like to weave some golden threads through our back catalogue, give us your feelpinions or suggest papers to read we are always here for that - hit us up at [email protected].

    1 hr 13 min
  • One climate statement to rule them all (and in the Hansard bind them)

    Recovered from epic Egyptian adventures your intrepid hosts begin by revisiting the final outcomes of the formal negotiations at COP27. That’s not the only thing we revisited though! This video of Tennant’s Beat Saber antics in the ruins of the Australia pavilion as he and Luke waited until the bitter end of COP is well worth a watch. You’re welcome ;-)

    This week we unpack the Albanese Government’s first Annual Climate Change Statement, tabled by Climate Change and Energy Minister Chris Bowen in the Parliament last week, as required under the recently passed Climate Change Act. This One-Climate-Statement-to-Rule-Them-All wasn’t the only present under the climate christmas tree though! We also had a look at the Climate Change Authority’s First Annual Progress Report, Australia’s Emissions Projections for 2022 and the latest National Greenhouse Gas Inventory quarterly update, all released with the statement. A veritable feast of climate delights Summerupperers!

    Aaand, if you enjoyed this week’s Numbers Talk with Frankie, is it because it recalled fond memories of the BBC’s Shipping Forecast? Shout out via the socials!

    Frankie's One More Thing is a just released report from the Australian Sustainable Built Environment Council (ASBEC), ‘Unlocking the pathway: why electrification is the key to net zero buildings’ which finds electrification is the lowest cost, fastest emissions reduction pathway for building operations and would save $49 billion out to 2050 compared to BAU. Boom!

    Tennant's One More Thing is a movie he’s crushing on in which Michelle Yeoh and her fists of fury go on a rollicking adventure through the multiverses exploring lives she could have led. If you need an escape from the heavy heaviness of climate policy land for a bit go check out Everything Everywhere All at Once!

    Luke's One More Thing is Katharine Murphy’s excellent new Quarterly Essay, ‘Lone Wolf: the making of Anthony Albanese’, an account of his formative years, rise to the Labor leadership and the journey through the 2022 Federal election to victory, including the internal machinations over what Labor’s climate policy should be. A fascinating read for climate policy nerds!

    VERY IMPORTANT PODCAST MATTERS: Summerupperers, we need your vote on what climate-related movie we should watch and discuss for our very first holiday special and last episode of the year before the xmas break. Should it be Soylent Green, The Day After Tomorrow or Don’t Look Up? Make your vote count RIGHT HERE.

    And that’s all from us this week Summerupperers! We shall see you next time and until then, please keep tweeting your thoughts to us at @LukeMenzel, @TennantReed and @FrankieMuskovic and if you would like to weave some golden threads through our back catalogue, give us your feelpinions or suggest papers to read we are always here for that - hit us up at [email protected].

    1 hr 16 min
  • COP27? Let Me Sharm Up

    Recorded on the ground in Sharm El-Sheikh as negotiations got to the pointy end of things at COP27, your intrepid hosts ditch the usual format in this very special episode of Let Me Sum Up.

    Listen in as we dive into all things COP27: the hot button issues in the negotiations, the vibe on the ground and around the pavilions, Team Australia’s presence at this COP (coffee diplomacy included) as well as our personal highlights across an incredibly packed couple of weeks full of speeches, events and launches of papers! So many papers! Don’t worry Summer-upperers, we’ve got material to keep this pod going in perpetuity.

    Frankie's One More Thing was a look ahead at future COPs! COP28 next year will be in Dubai, UAE, and early insights from the presidency have energy transition, finance for adaptation and inclusivity from a gender and youth lens are key thematics. Following Dubai we are looking at Eastern Europe in 2024 (Prague anyone?) and Brazil in 2025 before a potential Australian COP31 in 2026!

    Tennant's One More Thing was to promote a new avenue of Let Me Sum Up *cough* propaganda *cough* CONTENT! If you were following along on our socials the last couple of weeks you will have seen us slaving away to bring you content and daily video reports on the goings on. These are now all available on our shiny new Youtube channel where you can binge watch them all over again and see cameos from legends like Anna Freeman, Matt Kean, Jojo Rouse, Richie Merzian, Darren Miller and Krista Singleton-Cambage.

    Luke's One More Thing is to ask all of YOU, dear Summer-upperers, for your vote on what climate-related movie we should watch and discuss for our very first holiday special and last episode of the year before the X-mas break. Should it be Soylent Green, The Day After Tomorrow or Don’t Look Up? Make your vote count RIGHT HERE.

    And that’s a wrap on COP27 from us in Sharm El-Sheikh Summer-Upperers! We shall see you next time and until then, please keep tweeting your thoughts to us at @LukeMenzel, @TennantReed and @FrankieMuskovic and if you would like to weave some golden threads through our back catalogue, give us your feelpinions or suggest papers to read we are always here for that - hit us up at [email protected].

    1 hr 11 min
  • Bonus: Live from the Bedouin Tent at COP27

    In this short bonus episode your intrepid hosts are joined by CEO of the Australian Renewable Energy Agency, Darren Miller to unpack the latest from COP27 in Egypt. You will learn of Darren's heroics in the Australia Pavilion, why there is 'no way' negotiations will be done by Friday, and hear our hosts react to the unexpected appearance of a certain US Climate Envoy in the Bedouin Tent.

    There is a video version of this episode! To see John Kerry crash a recording of Let Me Sum Up with your own eyes click here.

    13 min
  • Measure twice, cut nunce? Tackling methane from Aussie coal mines

    In a tantalising pre-COP27 gathering your intrepid hosts start by dissecting the implications of the Australian Government's commitment to sign up to the Global Methane Pledge. An initiative spear-headed by the EU and US ahead of COP26, the pledge requires signatories to commit to cutting methane emissions 30% on 2020 levels by 2030. More seaweed coming to a trough near your friendly neighbourhood cows? Most certainly, but as always, there are sectors that present more quick wins (read on!) and others that will be slower to mooove.

    The locus of our focus this week is a paper by UK-based think tank Ember, 'Tackling Australia's Coal Mine Methane Problem' by Dr Sabina Assan. The paper picks up on the recent revisions by the IEA to Australia's estimated fugitive methane emissions from coal mines based on new-fangled satellite imagery and suggests measures to improve measurement, reporting, mitigation and ultimately, avoidance of coal mine methane emissions. A topical choice ahead of COP27 to be sure. What did we make of it you may ask? Listen on for spicy vindaloo and yogurt antimatter takes!

    Frankie's One More Thing starts us off at the bleak end of the climate action spectrum with UNEP's Emissions Gap Report 2022. TLDR: there is currently no credible pathway to 1.5C and current policies have us on track to 2.8C of warming by the end of the century. Your intrepid hosts, ever the optimists, like to picture the window into a clean energy future Utopia is just that bit further ajar with comfort taken in recent commitments from the US and the conservative nature of models representing the uptake of renewable energy (see episode 11!).

    Tennants's One More Thing had him scandalously plugging another podcast! Quelle horreur! Michael Liebreich, we salute your fantastic pod Cleaning Up and in particular, your recent episode with former Greek finance minister Yanis Varoufakis on the structure of energy markets. A cracking and timely conversation about the role of Government in driving more structural energy market governance reform. If you felt so inclined to return the favour to your friendly neighbour pod here at Let Me Sum Up we'd love to have you on to talk all things energy transition and dare I say it, explore demand side action with fellow efficiency acolytes. Slide on in to our DMs ;-)

    Luke's One More Thing brings us home by christening YOU our dear listeners with a well deserved moniker "Summer-upperers". With more syllables than the title of the pod we feel this is incredibly ON BRAND for your fortnightly one-hour, 45-min podcast on all things climate and energy. Massive thanks to listener Cynan for the inspo in coining the collective noun for this burgeoning pod community!

    The next time you hear from us dear Summer-upperers will be from COP27 in Sharm El-Sheikh, Egypt! We look forward to dissecting and reporting the goings on over the next two weeks. Make sure you follow us on Twitter at @LukeMenzel, @TennantReed and @FrankieMuskovic and in the meantime please send us your spicy vindaloo takes and suggestions for papers at [email protected].

    1 hr 5 min
  • Bonus: We're going to COP27

    In this short bonus episode, your intrepid hosts reveal they are all going to COP27 in Sharm El Sheikh. They also speculate on the possibility of Let Me Sum Up Live from Sharm – an event which is in no way organised, but if you will it dude, it is no dream...

    5 min
  • Ka-ching! Act now for huge learning rate savings!

    This week your intrepid hosts recapped some BIG news out of Victoria with the announcement of new emissions reduction targets - 75% to 80% (on 2005 levels) by 2035, net zero by 2045 and a renewable electricity target of 95% by 2035. Wowser! The first government in Australia to formalise a 2035 target which has significant implications for the decarbonisation of fossil gas during that timeframe deserves a special shout out! Your resident Victorian co-hosts lamented the overhyped media focus on the revival of state-owned power company SEC with a measly $1Bn in funding - even if they do have a fab retro logo.

    A big shout out to friend of the pod Allison Reeve for the recommendation for this week’s paper. As we’re leaning into our (initially) accidental and now somewhat intentional pile-on regarding IAMs, we’ve decided to drive another nail into the coffin of these woefully inadequate-but-still-wildy-influential models and talk technology learning rates. Specifically, a look at 'Empirically grounded technology forecasts and the energy transition’ from Rupert Way, Matthew C. Ives, Penny Mealy and J. Doyne Farmer from Oxford University. This paper has caused quite a stir in IAM-land. Were your intrepid hosts shaken, stirred, dirty or taken with a twist? Only one way to find out.

    Frankie’s One More Thing is some encouraging progress on the circular economy from a recent meeting of Environment Ministers in which Commonwealth and state and territory governments committed to a product stewardship scheme for solar panels and household electronics, regulation of packaging and further work on phasing out single use plastics.

    Tennant’s One More Thing is a computer game called The Case of the Golden Idol in which the intrepid player explores crime scenes frozen in fantasy 18th Century England to solve a bunch of grizzly murders. What’s it got to do with climate and energy? Absolutely nothing! Loads of fun for our analytically minded listenership? You betcha.

    Luke’s One More Thing is a 2019 paper he stumbled on and got distracted by, ‘Recalibrating climate prospects’ which includes Amory Lovins, a grandfather of the energy efficiency movement, as a lead author and sets out the case for stronger focus on demand management and energy efficiency paired with renewables in IAMs. Yep, it’s those pesky IAMs undervaluing energy efficiency again.

    That’s all folks, see you next time! Please keep tweeting your thoughts to us at @LukeMenzel, @TennantReed and @FrankieMuskovic and if you would like to weave some golden threads through our back catalogue, give us your feelpinions or suggest papers to read we are always here for that - hit us up at [email protected].

    1 hr 8 min
  • Horsemen 4, Humans 0? Apocalyptic climate scenarios

    This week in our tenth episode (woot!) your intrepid hosts reconvene ENERGY CRISIS CORNER and oh boy there was no shortage of fodder for us to traverse. From the UK where gas reserves are low but the hubris is high and they’ll be capping energy bills and paying people to use less at peak times, to our French friends who’ve coined the best moniker for their efforts in La Sobriete Energetique (Energy Sobriety) campaign with voluntary measures to save 10% energy use. The debate is also running hot in the EU about how they will pay for Fit for 55, maybe CBAM proceeds! And how are things looking at home in Oz? Not much better we’re afraid. This week there was much discussion on just how bad energy prices are likely to get in the next little while. Yikes.

    At this point we’d normally cast about for a silver lining but instead we spiralled into apocalyptic catastrophe and with a paper appropriately titled ‘Climate Endgame: Exploring catastrophic climate change scenarios’ brought to us by four horsemen Luke Kemp, Chi Xu, Joanna Depledge and Timothy Lenton and published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA (PNAS). These guys contend that facing a future of accelerating climate change while blind to worst-case scenarios is naive risk management at best and fatally foolish at worst. What did we make of it? Listen on!

    Tennant’s One More Thing is a piece of 70s futurism called The High Frontier: Human Colonies in Space by Gerard K. O’Neill, a Princeton professor who suggested the answer to the world’s industrial challenges was GIANT SPACE COLONIES that would build orbital solar power stations and beam energy back to Earth via microwaves. Jeff Bezos is a disciple, could you be one too? Well worth a look!

    Frankie’s One More Thing was to celebrate the successful 2022 Energy Efficiency Summit. Your intrepid hosts worked on this in their day jobs and were excited to have Assistant Minister for Climate Change and Energy Jenny McAllister there to announce a National Energy Performance Strategy, veritable music to our ears. Failed to gatecrash the sesh? Never fear, you can watch it all here. You can also read the communique from hosting orgs and the Minister’s media release and speech. Special shout out to the crew at EEC for making the magic happen!

    Luke’s One More Thing is a super article in the Economist, ‘The energy transition will be expensive, but not catastrophically so’. It draws an interesting analogy to the current energy transition from fossil gas to heat pumps that we could all take heart from in the transition the UK made from town gas to fossil gas. It can be done! We’ve done it before! Now where do I get my heat pump installer ticket.

    That’s all folks, see you next time! Please keep tweeting your thoughts to us at @LukeMenzel, @TennantReed and @FrankieMuskovic and if you would like to weave some red thread through our back catalogue, give us your feelpinions or suggest papers to read we are always here for that - hit us up at [email protected].

    1 hr
  • Fix homes, help hospitals: The Victorian Healthy Homes Program

    This week your intrepid hosts recap some listener mail from friend of the pod, Dylan McConnell, who boldly contends that some of our critiques on IAMs could be appropriately directed closer to home at the ISP. Also Dylan earns mega bonus points by renaming the ISP as our very own energy system HEGELIAN DIALECTIC. If we called it that we might get even less focus on the process because shiny hegelian dialectic people. Hell Yes!

    The paper we explored this time represents perhaps peak wonk in the just released Victorian Healthy Homes Program research findings. The program was designed to measure the impact of an energy efficiency and thermal comfort home upgrade on temperature, energy use, health and quality of life. A thousand homes of low-income and vulnerable Victorians were chosen for the study that demonstrated some compelling findings, including… LISTEN TO THE POD.

    Tennant’s One More Thing was to spruik the 2022 Energy Efficiency Summit at which the many the opportunities for energy efficiency to accelerate our journey to net zero emissions will be discussed. Sound awesome? It will be! Want to come? You can! You can register to join online. Regretfully, the full version of Frankie’s incitement for you to storm the venue was edited out, not that that should be taken as a challenge to our dear listeners…;-)

    Frankie’s One More Thing was to say a big HAPPY BIRTHDAY to the Green Building Council of Australia who turn 20 this year. So many talented and passionate people have passed through the GBCA over the years, creating a community of alumni whose influence on building a more sustainable built environment goes from strength to strength.

    Frankie’s sneaky twofer was to remind us all that King Charles cares a bunch about climate change and even wrote a book about it. This book!

    Luke’s One More Thing dangerously broke the mold of our pod and departed from climate I KNOW HOW OUTRAGEOUS to flag a particularly brilliant piece of pop culture in the new David Bowie documentary Moonage Daydream. Hard recommend from Mr. Menzel!

    That’s all folks, see you next time! Please keep tweeting your thoughts to us at @LukeMenzel, @TennantReed and @FrankieMuskovic and if you would like to weave some red twine through our back catalogue, give us your feelpinions or suggest papers to read we are always here for that - hit us up at [email protected].

    1 hr 2 min