
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


In this solo show Bart shares his expanded understanding of the many kinds of symmetry all around us, how it was triggered by a simple photographic challenge, and how it led to his new-found appreciation of art of designing car wheels!
While this podcast is free for you to enjoy, it’s not free for Bart to create. Please consider supporting the show by becoming a patron on Patreon.
Reminder – you can submit questions for future Q & A shows at http://lets-talk.ie/photoq
I've mentioned it quite a few times now, but I continue to enjoy the heck out of the photographic community on Glass. Probably in no small part down to the fact that you have to pay to join, so only people who really want to share their work do, it has remained an island of sanity and positivity in these challenging times. My primary reason for continuing to invest so much of my creative energy in Glass is that sanctuary from invective, but secondarily, I also enjoy the fact that the site sets a monthly challenge to the community through a featured tag. Each month starts with a blog post by a member of the Glass team describing the month's featured tag, the tag then spends the month in gold at the front of the tag list as a gentle encouragement, and then a week or so after the month ends the Glass staff will post again with a list of their favourite images from the month's featured tag. I think these challenges are pitched perfectly in that they're not annoyingly in-your-face, but the little golden tag is always there, gently nudging you to think about the challenge.
The March 2025 featured tag is simply Symmetry, and it seems to have struck some kind of chord with me, because it's really got me looking at the world differently, and it's getting me to notice new things I'd not really been thinking about consciously before.
I’ve not share much of my work yet, but I’ve spent the past three weeks thinking about all the different types of symmetry there are in the world around us.
When I think back on my previous shots that were symmetric, the most obvious thing that jumped to my mind first were reflections, in my case, usually in still water. I figure I’d definitely keep an eye out for opportunities to see things reflected, but that didn’t strike me as particularly imaginative.
Watching what others tagged with featured tag I soon realised I’d missed something bloody obvious — sure, reflections mirror things top to bottom in our frames, but we humans love building things with parallel features, so standing in the middle of something parallel gives you lots of left-right symmetry. I started to see a lot of cool street scenes with parallel lines converging on some kind of interesting feature at or near a vanishing point.
Some of those street shots caught my eye much more than others, so I started to ask myself why, and that reminded me of something I dimly knew already, but had somewhat forgotten about.
What the more eye-catching shots of parallel features had in common was a slight imperfection. Something human or natural breaking the perfection of the built landscape. A rarer variation on that idea was a blemish or crack or some kind of decay affecting each side differently.
The next thing that caught my eye was shots that added an extra dimension to the parallel line to form grids of squares. These kinds of squares and grids also tend to be man-made, like the parallel, but it was nice to see some fun architectural shots in the mix of reflections and parallel lines.
One or two of the architectural shots make use of other geometric shapes for their symmetries like circles and triangles, but in the man-made world that seemed to be where the types of symmetry ended. (I was wrong about that, but that’s for later!)
The other geometric shapes were natural, and they were mostly hexagonal — nature doesn’t do parallel lines, perfect squares, ideal circles, but it does do hexagons! From bee hives to drying mud and even solidifying lava, hexagons are very stable shapes that really do occur naturally.
It was nature that finally opened my eyes to a whole other class of symmetry, and ultimately led me to a little project I’ve nearly completed and am nearly ready to share.
Nature may not do perfect circles much, but it does have lots of circular things made up of radial segments. Flowers are the most obvious, and looking at my own back catalogue they are actually the biggest source of symmetry in my previous work! Sure, I have quite a few fun reflections, a good number of parallel lines, and even the odd grid of boxes, but I’ve shot loads and loads of flowers!
The one shot that caught my eye was a top-down view of an Iris flower which is unusual in having three equally spaced petals rather than four or more. That set of lightning bolt of realisation in my brain — I’d only been thinking of folding symmetries, but this iris had a whole other type of symmetry on offer!
Reflections and parallel lines are symmetric along one fold — horizontally for reflections in water, and perhaps vertically for reflections in glass. Parallel lines like streets have one fold too, again, vertically. Rectangles and grids have two, unless they’re square, and then they get two more from the diagonals. Triangles are interesting because they only have one fold, unless they’re equilateral when they get 3. Hexagons have six, three along the mid-lines of the parallel sides, and three along a lines from every point to its opposite number. That was starting to bend my brain already, and then of course you have perfect circles, which have an infinity of possible folds.
The Iris flower had three folds since the petals were equally spaced and equal in size, but it had something else going on too — it could rotate over itself three ways — it had rotational symmetry around it’s center. That’s what makes ‘circular’ flowers cool! There are lots and lots of different arrangements of petals. The total number varies, but many add an extra level of complexity by alternating the colours, lengths, thicknesses, or shapes of some of their petals. But, they all have rotational symmetry.
Had it been summer my project would have been to find 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and maybe more petalled flowers and collect them into a collage. But it’s not summer yet, so what could I shoot in March in Ireland with radial symmetry?
As I was pondering this I was just finishing a walk, and as I walked up my driveway and past my beloved new Polestar 2, it struck me — alloy wheels!
Once I started to really pay attention to the allow wheels on the cars around me I started to notice that there's so much going on there!
I think one of the reasons they catch the eye is that the majority are based on five-pointed radial symmetry because most cars have five nuts holding the wheels on. Small cars like minis only have four, which means their wheels often look noticeably different because they have traditional folding symmetry as well as radial symmetry.
Because Irish license plates stay with the cars not the humans, and because they capture the year the car was first registered in their first two digits trends over time are easier to notice.
Older designs tend to be much simpler, and to traditional fold-based symmetry along each of five distinct 'spokes'. The oldest cars tend to have five simple spokes, maybe with some tapering along their lengths and some flaring where they meet the rim and the hub, but they're basically five-pointed stars. Some had spokes radiating from the nuts and the points half way between the nuts, so they had ten rather than five, but all ten would be the same.
Over time the ten-spoked designs started to differentiate every second spoke to add some interest, maybe there would be fix thick and five thin spokes, or every second one would be a slightly different shape. You still see that idea on the newest ICE cars, but now with the addition of colour of a sort with the use of black allow wheels with parts of the spokes ground back to the bare metal underneath to give an interesting effect. Often every second spoke is more black than the other, and the newer the car the more likely it is that the grinding will have some sort of cool pattern so there's more going on than just each spoke have one colour or the other.
Another trend I've noticed is that the designs that stick to just five big 'spokes' have started to add ever more flare to those five spokes by first etching a clear line down the middle, then splitting each spoke into a pair of parallel spokes, and then adding ever bigger shapes to one or both ends that they start to look ever less like single spokes and more like five-sided fancy flowers. Some really lean into the flower-like feel with very wide oval or even hexagonal shapes.
For a long time the designs retained their five-folded symmetry through each of the spokes, but more recent design have no fold symmetries left because they hook the spokes in some way, meaning all that remains is the rotational symmetry.
Finally, EVs have really shaken things up in recent years because of their strong focus on aero dynamics. While many even brand new ICE vehicles retain very open designs, EVs favour much more closed designs, getting ever closer to disks with a few holes in them than to five-pointed stars. With this move towards disks some really very unusual things are starting to happen. Some EVs are completely ignoring the nuts in the middle and reverting to four-sided designs, even more startlingly, some very avant-garde designs from the likes of Peugeot and Hyundai are using two-spoke designs, some with fold symmetry, and some without. These designs really catch the eye because they are so different to everything that has come before.
I've been very surprised by how much more there is to symmetry than I once thought, and I've really enjoyed looking out for all kinds of symmetries in the world around me. I hope I've inspired you to start looking at your world a little differently, and that maybe you too will enjoy noticing new kinds of symmetry in your neck of the woods!
The show starts with some quick followup on a few recently covered and long-running stories before diving into the regulatory and legal stories, and some highlights from Apple’s services and original content. The four main stories are Apple’s first full month under President Trump’s second tenure, the UK’s attempt to secretly back-door iCloud, loads of new and updated Apple devices, and a re-vamp of Apple’s child safety features. The show finishes with a rundown of a few other quick Apple-related stories that made the news in February.
You’ll find detailed show notes below the fold, and if you enjoy this free show, please consider clicking on the donate button at the top of the left side bar – the show is free for you to listen to, but not for Bart to Produce!
Quick updates to long-running stories the show continues to track, and to stories covered in recent shows.
Apple's attempts to delay the remedies phase of the US DOJ antitrust case against Google over search was denied shortly after the previous episode was recorded — appleinsider.com/…
Apple enables AirPods Pro 2 Hearing Aid feature in the UK — appleinsider.com/…
Apple continued their drive towards facilitating repairs by adding manuals for the new M4 Macs — appleinsider.com/…
Having previously made a mockery of itself by attempting to ban AirTags on luggage, Lufthansa has joined the growing number of airlines supporting Apple's new location sharing feature for FindMy items — appleinsider.com/…
The iOS 18.4 betas revealed the Apple Intelligence features that are on the way soon, and Apple formally announced more official rollouts for April (none of them new that I could see) — Apple PR
Notably absent from the betas were the Siri enhancements everyone is eagerly awaiting (App Intents & personal data model)
Related: Apple Intelligence for China comes a little closer: Apple will use Alibaba to power iPhone’s AI services in China — www.cultofmac.com/…
Two nice illustrations that regulatory scrutiny can make real-world differences:
The Digital Services Act has it's first really concrete effect on iOS app availability in the EU, with a porn app being successfully notarised and published on the AltStore — www.bleepingcomputer.com/…
Google Play Books now links out to website & avoids Apple's 30% cut — appleinsider.com/…
There finally seems to be light at the end of the tunnel for Apple in Indonesia, the company has reached a deal with the Indonesian government to get the iPhone 16 range certified in the country, including a 10x greater investment than first offered — www.macobserver.com/…
South Korea Fines Apple for Unauthorized Data Transfer of 40M Users — www.macobserver.com/…
Apple forcefully refutes UK's claims about mobile browsing — appleinsider.com/…
Apple Faces Antitrust Scrutiny in Germany Over App Tracking Transparency — www.macobserver.com/…
Brazil gives Apple 90 days to enable third-party app marketplaces on iOS — appleinsider.com/…
Apple TV+:
The Apple TV app is now available on Android — Apple PR
MLS kicks off 30th season with new ways to watch & exclusive perks on Apple TV — appleinsider.com/… ( Apple PR)
Apple TV+ show is bought by another streamer for the first time — appleinsider.com/… ( Suspicion bought by UK streamer ITVX)
MLB 'Friday Night Baseball' returns to Apple TV+ on March 28 — appleinsider.com/…
Recipes Are Coming to Apple's News+ Service — www.macstories.net/…
Apple Music 1's newest DJ is King Charles III on 'The King's Music Room' — appleinsider.com/…
Apple's first full month in the second Trump Era
Apple appears to be appeasing Trump
Despite it still being completely illegal, Apple (and Google) have returned TikTok to the app store — daringfireball.net/…
Apple & Google both comply with Trump's executive order to rename the Gulf of Mexico — www.macobserver.com/…
Apple & Tim Cook return to X
One notable counter-example offering a ray of hope: Apple shareholders reject proposal to scrap company’s diversity programs — apnews.com/… (97% voted against )
Trump's long threatened tariffs on China went into effect on March 4th – 20% (addition of another 10% on existing 10% from first Trump term) and no exemption for Apple — abcnews.go.com/… & www.nytimes.com/…
A Bank of America study highlights the obvious: Trump's tariffs could drive up iPhone prices by about 10% — appleinsider.com/…
Related: India prepares for Trump trade disruption by cutting import taxes for Apple & others — appleinsider.com/…
Related: China threatens App Store probe in retaliation for trade tensions — appleinsider.com/…
Related: Apple pledges record-breaking $500 billion investment in the US — www.cultofmac.com/…
Credible reports have emerged that the UK government has issued Apple with a secret order to break iCloud Advanced Protection globally to facilitate surveillance under it's controversial Investigatory Powers Act (IPA) — appleinsider.com/…
Lots of Apple hardware updates
iPhone 16e — Apple PR & Product Page
Apple announces “iPhone 16e” to replace iPhone SE, starts at $599 for 128GB — arstechnica.com/…
Apple C1 Is Here, Its First In-House Cellular Modem — www.macobserver.com/…
Everything Apple stripped out of iPhone 16 to make the iPhone 16e — www.cultofmac.com/…
No MagSafe
no wide angle or telephoto, just single lens with 2x modes
no camera control button
no dynamic island, older notch design instead
No UWB or thread radios, and no wifi 7 (just wifi 6)
Presumably binned version of A18 with one fewer GPU core (5 rather than 6) — www.macobserver.com/…
more basic display with 800nits max rather than 1,000 for the regular iPhone 16, and 2,000 for the pros, and an older less robust glass
No colour options — just black or white (but there are $39 colourful cases)
iPhone 16e teardown reveals surprisingly repairable design but can’t answer key question — www.cultofmac.com/… (7 out of 10 repairability score)
iPhone 16e vs iPhone SE 3: A quantum leap forward — appleinsider.com/…
iPhone 16e vs iPhone 16: A new Apple Intelligence-powered entry-level option — appleinsider.com/…
iPhone SE, iPhone 14, iPhone 14 Plus are all retired with iPhone 16e launch — appleinsider.com/…
Apple has officially killed off the Home Button — appleinsider.com/…
Opinion, analysis & reviews:
iPad & iPad Air Updates — Apple PR
Apple Speed Bumps iPads: iPad Air Goes M3, iPad Gets an A16 — tidbits.com/…
iPad 11 chip upgrade does not bring Apple Intelligence — www.cultofmac.com/…
Apple releases new Smart Folio alongside new iPad — appleinsider.com/…
Apple Reveals New Magic Keyboard for iPad Air — www.macstories.net/…
iPad Air and iPad Go Green With 100% Recycled Materials and Carbon Neutral Goals — www.macobserver.com/…
The iPad Air Officially Marks the End of Apple’s 64GB Era — www.macobserver.com/…
Analysis: Apple's new iPad updates are not dramatic, but don't need to be — appleinsider.com/…
Updated MacBook Air — Apple PR
Updated Mac Studio — Apple PR
Apple have released the M3 Ultra as an option with the Mac Studio — Apple PR
New Mac Studio spans the generations with M4 Max, M3 Ultra chips — sixcolors.com/…
Apple announces child protection improvements — www.cultofmac.com/… & appleinsider.com/…
Good Summary: Apple Aims to Boost Child Privacy with New Age-Related Controls — tidbits.com/…
Apple’s Updated Age Ratings Explained: What’s Changing and Why it Matters — www.macobserver.com/…
Related: Nice guide on Apple's current child protection features — www.macobserver.com/…
Apple released their spring lineup of iPhone & Apple Watch accessories:
Apple releases a new iOS app to help people host parties, Apple Invites — Apple PR
Key features:
How the new Apple Invites app works, and when you want to use it — appleinsider.com/…
How To Use Apple Invites (Complete Guide) — www.macobserver.com/…
Apple released a rare sneak-peak video of some robots they're experimenting with in their labs, and their big focus is giving their movements personality — sixcolors.com/…
Apple now lets you transfer purchases from one Apple Account to another — appleinsider.com/…
Apple has started a transition away from pre-paid AppleCare+ to a subscription mode – retail stores no longer offer pre-paid, but Apple's website still does — appleinsider.com/…
Apple Sports app adds Nascar support just in time for Daytona 500 — appleinsider.com/…
iOS Update Enables “Critical Messages” via SMS — www.macobserver.com/…
Beats Releases the Powerbeats Pro 2 with H2 Chip and Heart Rate Monitoring — www.macstories.net/…
Finally: Adobe Photoshop comes to iPhone — www.cultofmac.com/…
Note: When the textual description of a link is part of the link it is the title of the page being linked to, when the text describing a link is not part of the link it is a description written by Bart.
In this solo show Bart shares some recent experiences engaging with creative professionals, and how those experiences have helped clarify some of his thinking on whether or not AI bots can replace photographic creative professionals. As you might well deduce from the title, he doesn’t think so, but do you agree with his reasoning?
While this podcast is free for you to enjoy, it’s not free for Bart to create. Please consider supporting the show by becoming a patron on Patreon.
Reminder – you can submit questions for future Q & A shows at http://lets-talk.ie/photoq
A bunch of apparently unrelated things have me thinking a lot about the intersection creativity and AI recently, which of course means I've been thinking about AI and photography again. The more I think about it, the more I realise Microsoft’s Satya Nadella seems to have the right idea on all this, and that Microsoft’s Copilot branding for their AI agents is spot on. The AIs aren't going to replace creatives, they're going offer us a helping hand to do our thing even better.
For various reasons, I’ve found myself engaging with more creative professionals in the last half a year or so than I have in ages. As an IT professional I’m used to people engaging my creativity to solve their problems, and that has certainly given me a lot of experience in the art of translating from normie-speak to my particular jargon. Not to mention the art of engaging with customers to try understand what they’re really trying to achieve. I like to think I do that quite well, but in all my years I’ve rarely been the normie engaging someone else’s experience, creativity, and expertise, until recently! And, I’ve found it to be a rewarding and enlightening experience.
In the second half of last year I engaged a professional audio production agency for the first time. If you’ve listened to any of the recent shows you’ve heard the result of that engagement. Having spent many years on my wish-list, I now have a Bartificer Creations audio tag to sonically brand these shows, and a short little sonic icon to brand any and all audio work I do, on these shows and elsewhere. The tag is what you hear on the Let's Talk podcasts announcing that they're Bartificer Creations. I've chosen to include it as the very first thing you hear, even before the theme tune. And the sonic icon is the short little Intel-inside-like two-tone audio jingle you hear at the very end, after the closing theme. The sonic icon’s two tones invoke the sound of the words “let’s talk”.
I simply adore these, so I’m gonna give a big shout-out to the wonderful creative professionals responsible for these two pieces of custom sonic branding — they are by Defacto Sound, the company behind Twenty Thousand Hertz, the amazing podcast all about our sonic universe. They mentioned at the end of one of their shows that one of the ways you could support the podcast is to employ the company for some audio work. So I reached out to them last summer, and a long, enjoyable, and very fruitful creative collaboration began. It took months to get from my conceptual idea to the few seconds of audio they delivered around Christmas time. But they're just perfect. They're exactly what I really wanted, rather than what I thought I wanted. They're not something even the most impressive AI I can imagine could have done for me. Why? Because I could never have created a prompts to get to there from where I was at the start of the process. I needed the engagement with skilled, creative, experts to discover what I really wanted as opposed to why my inexpert brain thought I wanted!
The creative process kicked off with a broad-ranging conversation with two of Defacto Sound’s creatives. We talked about my podcasts, what I’m hoping to achieve with them. What my aspirations are for the shows. Why I do things the way I do, what I hoped people felt when listening, and so on. We talked about my brand in general — was I happy with my logos, the mic one and the bracketed one? I was, so why? What was it about them I liked? Did I like my current theme tunes? How were they created? What had I asked the composer for? Why did I like them?
BTW — a big shout-out to that composer, Brendan Finan, and old college friend, and an Irish music teacher, composer, and author. Bren produced the original single theme that both Let's Talk shows shared for many year, and the newer individual themes you've been enjoying for the past year or two.
We talked about my personality, how do I like people to think about me? How much or how little do I like leaning into my Irish identity? They'd done their research up front and had noted the greens all over my visual branding, and the use of the orange from the Irish tricolour as my accent colour.
Finally, we talked about my taste in music.
We decided to start with the longer tag, then, when that was figured out we’d find some aspect of the tag to key the shorter icon off.
The key concepts we settled on were that the feel needed to be friendly, approachable, a little modern, but traditional enough to feel un-intimidating. I preferred the idea of keying off real instruments, but was open to going a little more synthetic if the feel was right. Finally, I agreed it was OK to lean in a towards Irish themes, but not to let that dominate, and absolutely no Paddy-whackery (the kind of OTT stereotypes some in America love but I find offensive and obnoxious)!
Then they went off for a few weeks and worked up some ideas. They came back to me with six initial ideas accompanied by a slide deck explaining their thinking behind each one and relating them to different aspects of our conversations. The expectations were clear, this was a starting point, not a final menu. The idea was for my detailed feedback to fuel a second round of hopefully near-final options.
As expected, none of these first six concepts were close to perfect, but three in particular contained ideas that spoke to me. Those three little sparks fed into the second round which produced two near-perfect options. We'd focused down to the idea of a chaotic start cohering into a harmony to represent the shows' focus on bringing understanding and clarity to the audience, to the little two-tone that became the icon, and to a voice and phrasing I liked for the vocal track. And yes, the instrumentation of the two-tone is Apple-inspired
I neither know nor care whether or not the Defacto Sound team used AI to help them with their execution of the work. I just care about the quality of the final product!
Like I say, I have no idea whether or not they actually did use AI in late 2024, but I doubt they won’t be by using it in some form for similar work in 2029. But so what‽ That’s not what made them so valuable to me, the value came from the decidedly human interactions that helped me discover and express my deeper desires for the project. To get from what I thought I wanted to what I really wanted.
Way back when I first started to muse about starting my own shows on some of the other shows I was then appearing on, a listener who happened to be a graphic designer donated an engagement to develop a logo for the show to help get me going. That’s where the green mic logo still used today comes from! Thank you Gérard Moonen!
When I decided to start branding all my creative endeavours under the single Bartificer Creations brand I reached out to Gérard again (and despite trying desperately let me pay him for his work, he insisted on donating his services again — you rock Gérard ). The result of this engagement was the green and orange lower-case b wrapped in chevrons logo I still use today. I adore both of Gerard’s logos — they fit me perfectly
Presumably because I love the logo so much, I started to use the core part of the logo (the bit without the words) for other things that were not really related to Bartificer Creations — I was starting to dilute the brand and associate it with more and and more things. Late last year I decided it was time to stop doing that, and instead to expand the logo into a suite of related logos I could use in different contexts.
Specifically, I wanted to add three additional logos for:
Being graphics rather than audio I felt a little more on my home soil for this project, so what I figured that since what thought I wanted was probably a lot closer to what I really wanted this time, I didn't need to spend big money this time with a graphics agency en-par with Defacto Sound (my creative budget was running too low for that ). At the very least I knew I'd need much less translation from normie-speak to graphics jargon, so I went for a simpler option and engaged and old acquaintance who does graphics work on the side, and who I know has a good eye for graphics and is much more skilled than I am with graphics editing tools.
The brief this time was to keep the colours, the font, and the basic concept of letters wrapped in some kind of punctuation marks from the original logo, and develop three similar but different new logos. I was even pretty sure I knew which punctuation characters I wanted to use — curly braces for myself and Wing as a couple, square braces for the boring corporate identity, and round brackets for myself, the well rounded individual.
Again, the process started with a conversation that was all about the why and the desired feel of the logos. It was about communicating deeply human things between humans again.
In this case — a really good AI would have made things worse, because I was suffering a little from the infamous Dunning-Kruger effect — I had a little knowledge! I thought I knew exactly what I wanted, and I would have been able to express those requirement in prompts to an AI, and I could have gotten what I thought I wanted relatively easily. Thankfully I was self-aware enough not to try that!
As you might expect, by adding another human with more experience and expertise into the mix we ended up with better designs for all three logos. None are a million miles off my original idea, but all are noticeably better than what I had visualised in my own head at the start.
I'd assumed that with the exception of the corporate logo, I'd want to stick with lower-case letters, and I thought I'd play around with shared vertices — I would have reversed an upper-case Bs in BH and have it share one side of an upper-case H, and I'd have gone with two back-to-back lower-case bs, with the left one mirrored, for personal logo. Finally, I'd have stacked a lower-case b over a lower-case w for the couple's logo.
I wasn't totally wrong in my thinking though — I was correct to think square braces for a formal corporate identity, curly braces for a union of two humans, and round braces for me, the person. The final logos do indeed have that structure.
So, what did engaging with another, more experienced, human bring into the mix? Ultimately, three important tweaks that make the final logos dramatically better than my naïve original plans:
The end result — three superb logos to compliment the original!
Starting withe the corporate logo — much to my surprise, lower case letters proved to be much better, even in the rigid square braces. Even more to my surprise, varying the letter size and baseline was not just OK, it really brought the logo to life!
Moving on to the couple's logo, the addition of that ampersand really did elevate things to another level. This time, the letters are the same size, while the ampersand is smaller, and I love how that reflects our equality within our union.
Finally, the logo I was initially more sure about proved to be the last one to come together. The rounded braces left and right were just not working. The resulting logo was too rectangular to fit with the rest of the set, and it looked bland and un-interesting. Like a misspelled copyright logo!
This is where engaging someone with more expertise and experience really paid off. Because I trusted my acquaintance's taste, if gave them freer reign than I'd originally planned, and asked for any ideas, no matter how different from my original thoughts, and that was the key. They didn't stray far off the reservation, just far enough outside my initial brief to land on a perfect solution that still feels harmonious with the rest. They replaced the actual punctuation characters with idealised true circular segments, and rotated them 45 degrees to add a nice diagonal element to the design. Then, to add the needed little splash of whimsey, varied the size of the two letters. All of those conceptual leaps were beyond my limited imagination, I needed help to get there!
One last little detail I want to highlight — notice that the mix of upper and lower case is not random! For all four of the logos, Humans get upper-case letters, and corporate entities don't! That little touch of deeper meaning really unifies the whole set nicely for me, and not something I'd have ever brought to the table on my own.
The last piece of context is my recent inclusion of some AI agent assistance in my professional live — we were given the OK to use Microsoft’s various Copilot AI agents, so I adopted the one that fits my work best. I write a lot of PowerShell code these days, so I've enabled the GitHub Copilot AI agent in the VS Code IDE. I now have an ever-present helping hand while I get on with my coding tasks.
This closes the circle nicely, because here I'm the subject matter expert considering whether and how AI can help me do my work. The people consuming the outputs from my code neither know nor care where or not I used AI to get the job done — they just need the data or the functionality my code delivers for them!
I honestly didn't know what to expect when I enabled the AI agent. Now that I've been letting it help me for a few weeks, I can report that my initial thoughts on AI have been reinforced by the experience. Microsoft really did name this technology appropriately by describing it as a copilot — I am very much the pilot flying (to abuse some aviation jargon), and not in any way being railroaded by the AI. The AI following my lead, and if I don't lead, nothing happens!
Code assistants use a slightly different mechanism to prompt their pre-trained LLMz (Large Language Models) than the one used by regular AI chatbots. Regular bots project forward from a history which is a mix of pre-loaded context and your conversation with the bot to that point. It's very linear, past inputs projected forward. That's not what code suggestion bots do — they suggest next middle pieces to insert at your current cursor position. They don't just consider the code that's before the current cursor position, they consider your entire codebase, looking both forward and backwards in the current file, and at all the other files that make up your project. This means the copilot suggests additional code in the same style and using the same conventions as your existing code. Instead of offering generic suggestions, it offers suggestions that do things your way. This means it amplifies your existing skills rather than try to re-train you to do things differently. It also means that if you have no skills to bring to the party, there's not much happening. But, if you're really good at your job, you can get a lot more done with the same amount of time and effort!
The AI is not replacing skilled coders, it's making their skills even more valuable!
So, with all that context, I've been spending a lot of time musing about what AI might mean for the future of my beloved art and craft of photography.
It's far to early for strongly held beliefs about all this, but my opinions are starting to crystallise a little more.
First off, I'm becoming ever more secure in my belief that what ever problems we need to overcome as a society when it comes to adapting to the ever increasing prevalence and power of AI in our lives, this is not about copyright. Training on data is no more copying it than indexing it for a search engine is. The whole copyright palaver is distracting us from the real problems — the training is not at the root of the very real problems we're facing, it's abuses of the trained models that are at the root of our problems! Instead of fixating on the minutia of the training mechanism, we need to look at the harmful outcomes abuse of the models is producing.
Using AIs to rip off artists is not a copyright problem, it's a counterfeit problem! When someone sells fake Levi Jeans we don't fixate on the minutia of the imitation cloth gets made. We don't fixate on regulating the machines for weaving fabrics or creating blue dyes! Instead, we deal the problem of knock-off Levis flooding online market places as what it truly is — counterfeiting, and we tackle it right there in those market places, right at the point of sale! We need to do the same when people sell AI-generated knock-offs.
The other opinion I'm becoming ever more confident of is my view that AI is not going to replace human creativity and experience. Like the digital spreadsheet freed chartered accountants from the chore of manually performing calculations cell by cell, and freed them up to run more models to better inform and advise their customers, AI is going to amplify the skills humans bring to photography. The fear when spreadsheets were digitised was that it would result in the number of chartered accounts needed by society plumetting, throwing millions out of work. But no, that's not what happened, there are more chartered accountants now than ever before! Accountant's true value was not in their ability to crunch numbers, it was in their ability to extract useful insights from those numbers. Letting the computers do the tedious arithmetic didn't replace accountants, it empowered them!
The lesson I take from all this is that if you're bringing truly human skills to the table, you don't need to worry about being replaced by an AI. It's people who only do menial chores that need to up-skill before they go the way of the steam locomotive firemen, the gas lamp lighters, and the human computers of the past.
When I think about the kinds of people currently making their livings from photography, I don't see many people doing just menial chores. I see lots of people bringing truly human skills to the table. The one exception I can think of is people who shoot only generic stock images — those really can be replaced by AI image generators, but only those doing purely generic stock.
Even focusing in just on stock photography, the truly valuable banks of stock images are not generic, they're focused. I can see this first-hand in work. As a major Irish University, Maynooth University uses a lot of stock images all the time, but they're not coming from Getty or Shutterstock, they're coming from our internal stock photo library. They don't show generic university buildings, they show our buildings, they don't show generic lecturers and tutors, they show our wonderful academics do their thing, and they don't show generic students doing vaguely academic looking things, they show our students using our facilities, working in our labs, and excelling on our sports fields in our uniforms. That stock library has real value to our institution, and it was created by professional photographers who understand our university's brand and character in the same way the Defecto Sound team, Bren, and my graphic designing acquaintance took the time to learn about me and my brand before developing the creative assets I needed.
If you want to make a living in photography, lean in to your human skills, and use AI to amplify them — don't try to become a better machine that the machines, because eventually, the machines alway out-machine the humans! But, equally, the humans will always out-human the machines
The show starts with some quick followup on a few recently covered and long-running stories before diving into the regulatory and legal stories, a little HR news, and some highlights from Apple’s services and original content. The three main stories are President Trump’s impact on Apple, the latest OS point-releases, and Apple’s Q1 2025 earnings call. The show finishes with a rundown of a few other quick Apple-related stories that made the news in January.
You’ll find detailed show notes below the fold, and if you enjoy this free show, please consider clicking on the donate button at the top of the left side bar – the show is free for you to listen to, but not for Bart to Produce!
Quick updates to long-running stories the show continues to track, and to stories covered in recent shows.
Turns out Apple's Indonesia problems were not over after all. Last month I shared reports that the government were about to accept Apple's updated proposal, but it didn't work out like that:
Belgium has appointed a magistrate to investigate the allegations against Apple alleging it uses conflict minerals filed by the government of the Democratic Republic of the Congo, initiating the formal legal process — www.macobserver.com/…
Goldman Sachs long-running off-the-recored grumblings about Apple Card got on the record: Goldman Sachs CEO says Apple card partnership may end before 2030 — www.reuters.com/…
January 2025 was a mixed month for Apple's on-going supply-chain diversification efforts:
UK opens probe into Google’s and Apple’s mobile platforms — arstechnica.com/… (
More trouble for Apple in Brazil: Privacy nightmare FaceApp causes Apple & Google to be fined in Brazil — appleinsider.com/… (App was published to the local app stores without even a privacy policy in Portuguese!)
DOJ -v- Google: Apple becomes involved in the remedies phase of the trial (Google were found guilty of breaching the Sherman Act last year with their search engine)
UK trial over Apple's App Store fees seeks $1.83B fine — appleinsider.com/… (4 year old class action has been allowed to proceed)
Apple and Amazon get $600 million UK price fixing lawsuit dismissed — appleinsider.com/…
Apple have settled another class action suit, this time over swelling batteries in early Apple Watches (up to and including the series 3), and for just $20M — www.macobserver.com/… (affected US Apple Watch owners can claim their slicer of the pie at WatchSettlement.com)
M. Night Shyamalan beats $81 million plagiarism accusation over 'Servant' — appleinsider.com/…
Apple TV+
With the start of the 30th Major League Soccer season in the US, Apple roll out yet more soccer features — Apple PR & www.macobserver.com/…
More French-language programming coming to Apple TV+ in EU countries — appleinsider.com/… (deal signed with the French government)
Oscar nominations completely snub Apple TV+ — www.cultofmac.com/…
Apple Delays Next-Generation CarPlay Launch, Continues Development with Automakers — www.macobserver.com/…
Synchrony Pay Later coming soon to Apple Pay — appleinsider.com/…
Apple Arcade launches into 2025 with 10 new games, including PGA TOUR Pro Golf — Apple PR
Apple Wallet:
President Trump's Effect on Apple
In the lead up to the inauguration, and on inauguration day itself the CEOs of major tech firms were unusually prominent:
Tim Cook is donating $1 million to Trump’s inauguration […] — www.theverge.com/…
Tim Cook joins big tech leaders for Trump's inauguration — appleinsider.com/…
US senators question big tech, including Apple, on the reason behind inauguration donations — appleinsider.com/… (Concerns about quid-pro-quos in terms of regulatory changes etc.)
Editorial: My interpretation was that it was pandering to a notoriously transactional president with a history of feuding with CEOs that irked him
At a pre-inauguration rally President-elect Trump made an un-substantiated boast involving Apple: Trump claims Tim Cook has committed Apple to massive US investment — appleinsider.com/…
Despite a lot of campaign and transition time bluster, no Apple-affecting tariffs have materialised yet — appleinsider.com/…
Both Apple and President Trump are heavily involved in the bit-partisan TikTok divestment mandate signed into law by President Biden which came into effect the day before Trump's inauguration: Here’s Why You Still Cannot Download TikTok From App Store — www.macobserver.com/…
President Trump signed many executive orders in his first days in power, and those around re-naming geographic features have impacted on Apple and other map-publishers:
Apple released the next round of OS point updates in January, mostly continuing the rollout of Apple Intelligence — www.macstories.net/… & appleinsider.com/…
One notable common feature was a refinement of notification summaries triggered by high-profile failures to summarise notifications from news apps:
Unusually, Apple previewed the changes — arstechnica.com/…
The delivered changes over-delivered on the preview a little — sixcolors.com/…
Analysis: LLMs aren’t always bad at writing news headlines — sixcolors.com/… (Examples of other AIs performing much better than Apple Intelligence)
Opinion: Apple Intelligence summaries might get warning labels. That’s not enough. — sixcolors.com/…
Related Analysis & Opinion: When Are Summaries Valuable? — tidbits.com/…
Apple are now confident enough in their infrastructure and the maturity of the product to enable Apple Intelligence by default (users can still disable it globally, or by-feature) — tidbits.com/…
Macs get fun custom Genmoji with macOS Sequoia 15.3 — www.cultofmac.com/…
How Visual Intelligence gets more powerful on iPhone 16 in iOS 18.3 — appleinsider.com/…
Note that even as the next WWDC gets closer than the previous, we're still waiting for many promised features, including improved Siri and personal context — www.macobserver.com/…
Related: Apple joins AI hardware standards consortium to improve server performance — appleinsider.com/…
Q1 2025 Earnings Call — Apple PR
This is Tim (and Kevan!): Apple’s Q1 results call, transcribed — sixcolors.com/…
The earnings in graphs and context: Apple’s reports record revenue for Q1 2025 — sixcolors.com/…
Best summary: Despite iPhone Decline, Apple’s Q1 2025 Sets Revenue Records — tidbits.com/…
In Apple’s first-quarter earnings, the Mac leads the way in sales growth — arstechnica.com/…
Services buoy slumping iPhone sales in record-breaking holiday quarter earnings — appleinsider.com/…
Apple has more than 2.35 billion active devices, up 550 million since 2022 — appleinsider.com/…
Apple highlighted that their numbers show better iPhone 16 upgrade rates in countries that do have Apple Intelligence compared to those that don't — appleinsider.com/…
Analysis:
John Gruber — "Apple’s overall sales in China have been trending down for 3 years now. It looks to me like Apple has peaked there"
Mind-melting stats from Apple’s profitable earnings call — www.cultofmac.com/…
Related:
Apple introduces the 2025 Black Unity Collection — Apple PR
Apple moves to open-source, unify Swift component across platforms — appleinsider.com/…
American T-Mobile iPhone users can now join the carrier's beta service providing SMS over satellite via StarLink — www.macobserver.com/… (Previously Android-only)
Apple expands its India retail presence with Apple Store app — appleinsider.com/…
NVIDIA Announces GeForce NOW Cloud Gaming for Apple Vision Pro — www.macobserver.com/…
Game Porting Toolkit 2 exits beta to help developers move to macOS — appleinsider.com/…
Razer Launches PC Remote Play for Streaming PC Games to the iPhone, iPad, and Other Devices — www.macstories.net/…
Apple's 2025 annual shareholder meeting is on February 25 — appleinsider.com/…
Note: When the textual description of a link is part of the link it is the title of the page being linked to, when the text describing a link is not part of the link it is a description written by Bart.
In this solo show Bart shares his idea of setting himself “New Year’s Challenges” instead of stereotypical New Year’s resolutions, looks back on his 2024 challenge to try shoot more monochromes, and forward to his 2025 challenge to try find shots where the colours themselves are the primary subject.
While this podcast is free for you to enjoy, it’s not free for Bart to create. Please consider supporting the show by becoming a patron on Patreon.
Reminder – you can submit questions for future Q & A shows at http://lets-talk.ie/photoq
I gave up on the concept of new year's resolutions many years ago — the science is in, they don't work and they usually just make you feel worse! But, I didn't give up on the concept of using the changing year as an opportunity for change. Rather than resoling to meet some unrealistic goal and then beating myself up for inevitably failing, I flipped things around and set my self challenges instead. Not "do this thing" or "don't do this thing", but "try this new thing".
There's no failure or success, it's just an idea to keep in your head to help nudge you towards something you think will be positive. Simply keeping the challenge in your mind will inevitably affect what you do. Sometimes that effect will be big, and sometimes it will be small, but you're probably going to learn something useful regardless.
For 2024 my challenge was to try to improve my monochrome work. My instinctual photographic style is very colour-forward with sharp detail, lots of contrast, and punchy colours. The colours are not the subject in my instinctive style, but they are central to the look and feel of my shots of just just about everything — landscapes, macros, trains, you name it, punchy is my look! So, for 2024 my challenge was to slow down and consider the very opposite of my instinctual style, get rid of the colour completely! Could I capture the same subjects in a very different way? I was seeing some amazing monochrome work on Glass, and I realised that I might enjoy exploring that subset of photography.
I don't know if others think my 2024 challenge was fruitful, but I certainly do. The challenge kept new questions active in my mind all year. As I was shooting I was as shooting I was asking myself new questions like — is the colour helping or hindering? or is the colour optional here? That really helped me see things in new ways.
I didn't change my default look. I didn't want to! But I really enjoyed exploring new ideas and experimenting with new techniques. Looking back on my work from last year it seems clear to me that I've added a really useful new tool to my photographic toolbox!
Before producing this episode I compiled my successful monochromes from 2024 into a series on Glass, so you can judge for yourself how my challenge turned out
What I find interesting is that I started the year inspired by a handful of very different monochrome-first photographers who all had their own signature looks, and while those examples helped me see and think differently, my monochrome work hasn't ended up looking like any of theirs, it's still got something of my default style in it, even without the punchy colours.
I think punchy is probably still a good description for my monochrome shots. They tend to be even more contrasty than my colour shots, with even more emphasis on detail, even blacker blacks, and even whiter whites! I also remembered just how much I love using the colour channel mixer to turn blue skies black and add some super contrast with the clouds
This shot of a train along my beloved Royal Canal captures that look well:
https://glass.photo/bbusschots/KmX3spY9iuqz72Lc51TYe
I had hoped that focusing on monochrome would help me get better at recognising interesting shapes in the world around me, because without colour to add interest I expected to need to draw more heavily on shapes and lines to build interesting compositions. That certainly proved to be true, and as I hoped, I think it's just made me a better photographer in general, not just in monochrome.
I think this shot of rectangles within rectangles in the architecture of the newest student apartments in Maynooth University illustrates that best. I'd never have shot anything like that before this challenge.
https://glass.photo/bbusschots/Vkl0Lfz3tcQS7zHQPe8zZ
A nice unexpected discovery is how powerful monochromes can be at night. I think my single favourite image from 2024 has to be this night shot of a pair of students approaching the main entrance to the magnificent Revivalist Gothic St. Patrick's House in St. Patrick's College Maynooth:
https://glass.photo/bbusschots/7EQo6ehwamfzoP5OpFOENt
Speaking of the unexpected — a nice thing about challenges is that because they're open-ended and are just about keeping an idea in your mind for the year, they can bring all sorts of little bonus extras you could never have anticipated. I probably learned more about colour in 2024 than the entire previous decade. I certainly didn’t expect that from a challenge to myself to use it less! For years colour theory baffled me, and I just didn't get what HSL and hue and all those words really meant. By really digging in deep to how colour channel mixers work all that finally clicked for me!
So, on the whole, I'm considering my 2024 challenge a resounding success. Yay!
But it's 2025 now, can I repeat that success? Honestly, I have no idea, but I do have a new challenge so I can find out.
By learning to shoot without colour I got more attuned to the beauty in textures, and while colour obviously plays no role in monochrome shots of textures, it can play a big role in the beauty in textured scenes themselves.
What really helped this idea click in my head is discussions with my Dad who's also a photographer, and I think a listener (hi Dad ). While I'm factually Flemish, and do have a sense of connection to Flanders and a real love for the place, I'm also very Irish, probably more so in fact. My Dad on the other hand is Flemish to his very core and has the kind of deep connection to the Flemish landscape he grew up in that I do to the Irish landscape I grew up in. I should also mention that I definitely got my interest in photography from my Dad — the earliest shots of me are all monochromes developed in a home darkroom!
Like I try to capture the beauty I see in the Irish landscape, he tries to do the same in the Flemish landscape, but they are very different landscapes. Especially in autumn and winter the Flemish landscape's beauty is very subtle iIn fact, the beauty is more in its textures than anything else. The comforting earthy tones speckled with bits of reassuring green and accented with flashes of white from the birch bark all around are something special, and not at all easy to capture. Sure, there are also lots of interesting shapes with meandering rivers and dykes, and stunning tall lines of Poplar trees, they play second fiddle to the textures.
Those of us in the family into photography have a little private chat group where we share our work and comment on it. While enjoying Dad's best shots of the Flemish landscapes something he said about what he was trying to capture hit me like a revelation — the distinctive warm earthy colour pallet is the primary subject! It's not one specific colour, or one nice curving river bank, it's the broader colour pallet of the scene as a whole that's really the most important subject in his best shots.
Looking back through my own archive of Flemish landscapes I think this one from a frosty winter many years ago captures the feel of the Flemish countryside best for me:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/bbusschots/5426456218/in/photolist-2puETMY-2pwVrai-jzSonY-2puLm6D-2pxegBp-jDLGmy-nuvq44-2pukfZn-iWYTfr-joZSaq-jB3CYr-jbA1pj-iNU2ER-oaZgP3-7TnrtC-j1UXdc-jhiDK1-j9pYwn-iR8Gvk-iUzPWS-j53GB4-j1VvRs-jnKbfE-jyiMFx-iUuB1F-jdfLKF-j6eRon-iSFftZ-juUyy7-j3HFGn-gAhzUH-js6a2x-jthav9-jgenuB-5MFtz4-7RHVik-7RHvbB-jeXLSP-7S26DW-iZsAkt-7RXRwx-jtewcr-jqq4wY-9gw1wh-7SLhDy-7SKSY9-6pcQU1-9gw1nY-8HaFtn-7TLCVe
A little bit less dramatic, I found another shot of the same pond in more mundane light:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/bbusschots/11909631513/in/photolist-2puETMY-2pwVrai-jzSonY-2puLm6D-2pxegBp-jDLGmy-nuvq44-2pukfZn-iWYTfr-joZSaq-jB3CYr-jbA1pj-iNU2ER-oaZgP3-7TnrtC-j1UXdc-jhiDK1-j9pYwn-iR8Gvk-iUzPWS-j53GB4-j1VvRs-jnKbfE-jyiMFx-iUuB1F-jdfLKF-j6eRon-iSFftZ-juUyy7-j3HFGn-gAhzUH-js6a2x-jthav9-jgenuB-5MFtz4-7RHVik-7RHvbB-jeXLSP-7S26DW-iZsAkt-7RXRwx-jtewcr-jqq4wY-9gw1wh-7SLhDy-7SKSY9-6pcQU1-9gw1nY-8HaFtn-7TLCVe
Like I said, The beauty in this landscape really is subtle. It's not one specific thing, but the overall texture and feel of the place, and, like I keep saying, the colour pallet.
So, my challenge for 2025 is to find more scenes where the colours themselves are the primary subject. I'm only getting started, but I'm already having fun. This shot of the differently coloured bare winter vegetation in Carton House Estate worked out very nicely, and without having the challenge in my head I'm certain I'd never have noticed it, let alone captured it:
https://glass.photo/bbusschots/4zZswIk6QLyGQleyIWSieh
I don't know if New Year's Challenges will work for everyone, but they've worked for me, and I hope I've inspired you to think about a way in which you'd like to challenge yourself to shoot differently in 2025.
Happy New Year!
The show starts with some quick followup on a few recently covered and long-running stories before diving into the regulatory and legal stories, a little HR news, and some highlights from Apple’s services and original content. The three main stories are conflict mineral complaints filed against Apple, the latest OS point-releases, and the continued rollout of Apple Intelligence. The show finishes with a rundown of a few other quick Apple-related stories that made the news in December.
You’ll find detailed show notes below the fold, and if you enjoy this free show, please consider clicking on the donate button at the top of the left side bar – the show is free for you to listen to, but not for Bart to Produce!
Quick updates to long-running stories the show continues to track, and to stories covered in recent shows.
Apple's Indonesia iPhone 16 ban drama will probably end with $1 billion investment — appleinsider.com/…
Airlines actually started rolling out support for AirTags to help locate lost luggage in time for the holiday travel chaos: United Airlines and Air Canada first to offer official support for AirTag link sharing — appleinsider.com/…
Apple Vision Pro global rollout continues with Taiwan on December 17 — appleinsider.com/…
EU regulators continued to focus in Apple in December:
Regulatory scrutiny and enforcement may be slow and plodding, but it does cause real changes eventually:
USB-C gets a bit more universal as the EU’s mandate goes into effect — arstechnica.com/…
Norway gets world's first Apple Pay alternative for iPhone — appleinsider.com/… (thanks to EU regulations forcing Apple to open up access to the NFC chip)
The Delta emulator for iOS becomes the first app in the US Apple App Store to make use of the new External Purchase Link Entitlement, allowing users click on a link within the app to support the development of the app on Patreon — www.macstories.net/…
Apple agrees to $95M settlement to end privacy lawsuit over Siri recordings — appleinsider.com/… ($20 per-user-per-device, over incorrect 'hey Siri' triggers and human review of random sample of Siri interactions)
Apple hit with $1.2Bn lawsuit after killing controversial CSAM-detecting tool — arstechnica.com/… (Class action by abuse survivors)
Brazil antitrust ruling against Apple overturned by Federal Justice — appleinsider.com/… (mandated 3rd-party App Store Payments)
The US 9th circuit court of appeals has rejected an appeal to overturn the dismissal of a class action case that claimed Apple was tricking users into having to upgrade to paid iCloud plans, most probably killing the case — appleinsider.com/… (The argument was that it's impossible to live on the 5GB base plan, so the free iCloud is a lie, unfortunately, many of the actual plaintiffs were successfully using the free plan, making the whole case look as dumb as I think it was )
The DOJ -v- Google anti-trust case over the company's search monopoly moved forward with Google filing a remedies proposal it doesn't believe it should implement simply to allow its appeal of the actual original ruling to proceed — appleinsider.com/…
Suggested Reading: Apple’s Year in Court: A Recap of 2024’s Most Notable Lawsuits — www.macobserver.com/…
Apple Sued for Having Power to Spy on Employees’ Personal Lives — www.macobserver.com/…
CA state suit filed by Apple employees
Claim is that Apple effectively force staff to simultaneously:
As of January 1st 2025, it's Official, after many years sterling service, Luca Maestri is no longer Apple's CFO, as Kevan Parekh officially assumed the role — www.macobserver.com/…
Apple's look back at 2024 continued in December:
Apple Music Radio taps big talent for three new stations — appleinsider.com/… ( Apple PR)
Apple TV+:
Health:
Apple continues to rapidly expand support for receiving payments on iPhones via Tap-to-Pay:
Puerto Rico joins U.S. states that let driver’s licenses go in Apple Wallet — www.cultofmac.com/…
Apple Delays HomeKit Support for Robot Vacuums to 2025 — www.macobserver.com/…
Apple accused of covering up war crimes by willfully using Congo conflict minerals — appleinsider.com/…
Apple issued another round of important minor-version OS updates including significant improvements beyond the Apple Intelligence Rollout (next story):
iOS 18.2 — www.cultofmac.com/…, www.macobserver.com/… & www.macstories.net/…
New centralised page for setting all default apps (Settings → Apps → Default Apps)
EU citizens now have the ability to delete more stock apps (Photos, Safari, Messages, Camera & App Store)
The promised AirTag location sharing
The rather marmite new email categorisation feature
Some asked-for improvements for the new Camera Control feature on iPhones 16 Pro
Daily Sudoku Puzzles in Apple News+
Layered Voice Memos on iPhones 16 Pro — appleinsider.com/…
Snoopy screensavers arrive on Apple TV with tvOS 18.2 — appleinsider.com/…
New visionOS 2.2 brings widescreen Mac to Apple Vision Pro — appleinsider.com/…
Apple Intelligence continues to roll out — Apple PR
New English language regional dialects released for Australia, Canada, New Zealand, South Africa & the UK
Initial limited rollout in EU (if you change your language to English UK )
Apple exec launches Apple Intelligence in Australia — appleinsider.com/…
New features for existing users — appleinsider.com/…
Image Playground (macOS & iOS) — appleinsider.com/…
Genmoji (macOS & iOS)
Magic wand tool in Apple Notes generates images based on existing note content (text and images)
Writing Tools enhancement: Re-write tool now accepts arbitary prompts instead of offering just three pre-defined style options
ChatGPT integration (iOS & macOS) — www.macobserver.com/…
Visual Intelligence on iPhones 16
Review: iOS 18.2/macOS 15.2 Review: Picture not so perfect? — sixcolors.com/…
Numbers, Pages, and Keynote gain Apple Intelligence smarts — appleinsider.com/…
Summaries prove to be a poor fit for news apps!
Related: Apple-Nvidia collaboration triples speed of AI model production — appleinsider.com/…
Related: Apple says it uses Amazon's custom AI chips — www.cnbc.com/…
Note: When the textual description of a link is part of the link it is the title of the page being linked to, when the text describing a link is not part of the link it is a description written by Bart.
In this solo show Bart tries to explain the difference between a channel mixer for monochrome conversion, and the very similar looking selective colour adjustment, and to do so, he starts by describing the HSL representation of colour our photo editors use internally.
While this podcast is free for you to enjoy, it’s not free for Bart to create. Please consider supporting the show by becoming a patron on Patreon.
Reminder – you can submit questions for future Q & A shows at http://lets-talk.ie/photoq
In LTP 131 I shared my recent adventures in monochrome photography, and one of the things I mentioned was the power of the Channel Mixer for making more creative conversions. This led to an interesting discussion with friend of the show and frequent guest Allison Sheridan about the difference between two almost identical looking controls but don't do the same thing at all, the channel mixer for monochrome conversions, and selective colour adjustments. The app Allison was trying to use had a set of sliders that looked like what I described in LTP 131, but they just didn't seem to be doing anything like what I described they would, what was going on? Allison was using the Photos app on a Mac, and it doesn't have a channel mixer, but it does have selective colour adjustments, and those controls look like a channel mixer.
Initially I struggled to explain the difference, and I didn't do very well, and then I confused things even more by trying to explain that you can actually emulate a less effective channel mixer with a selective colour adjustment, but that did the opposite of help! We switched focus to finding Allison a true channel mixer she could use without spending money on software that wasn't free or that she didn't already own, and got her up and running with Affinity Photo 2.
OK, so that solved Allison's most immediate problem, but it still left me feeling like unfulfilled — I'd tried to explain something I actually do understand, and utterly failed. It's been niggling away at me for the last few weeks, and just in time to record this show, the penny finally dropped, I was trying to explain what these sliders do without starting with how our photo editors model colour. We usually think computers model colours as Red, Green, and Blue values, so-called RGB, but that's literally only half of the story, it's how we store, transmit, and display images, but it's not how we edit them! When we load an image into an editor it gets transformed from an RGB representation into a more useful alternative representation, Hue, Saturation, and Lightness, or HSL. To understand both the channel mixer and it's close cousin the selective colour adjustment, we need to understand how both understand colour, in other words, we need to understand the HSL colour space.
As we all probably learned in science class when our teachers explained how televisions work, you can create any colour of light by adding more or less red, green, and blue light together. This means we can represent the colour of any pixel in an image with three numbers — a red brightness, a green brightness, and a blue brightness.
In this representation the total value of a pixel’s red, green, and blue brightness values will determine the apparent brightness of the pixel, and the ratios between the three brightness values will determine the pixel’s colour.
A pixel that’s 100% blue, 50% green and 50% red has a total brightness of 60% (200 out of a possible 300), and so does a pixel with 50% blue, 100% green, and 50% red, and indeed one with 50% blue, 50% green, and 100% red. The difference between these three pixels will not be their brightness, but their colour.
RGB is an efficient representation for storage and transmission, and it's how the physical pixels in our displays work, but it's a terrible representation for editing because of it's coupling of brightness and colour. To change a pixel's colour without affecting it's brightness you have to change at least two RGB brightness values, and the same is true of you want to change a pixel's brightness without changing it's colour.
HSL exists because RGB is an inefficient way of representing pixels when the problem to be solved is editing rather than storing or physically displaying.
When you load an image for editing in an image editor each pixel's RGB values get translated into HSL values and the editor manipulates those values rather than the RGBs. It's when you save the file that the reverse transformation happens, and obviously, the graphics code that's used to render the image on screen is doing the same translation in real-time. The math to go between the two representations is trivial for a computer.
So, what is this HSL pixel representation? Each pixel still gets three numbers, but this time the numbers represent it's Hue, Saturation, and Lightness.
To understand a pixel's hue you need to imagine the rainbow as a line that runs from red on one end to violet on the other that you then close as a circle. When you do that you'll be surprised to find that it looks like a continuum. You probably thought there's be a clear break somewhere in the line, but there isn't, red and violet are actually as similar as red and orange! We can describe any colour by an angular position along this circle, and by convention we label red as being at zero degrees, with orange at thirty, yellow at sixty and so on.
The pixel's saturation is simply the intensity of its colour, with pure white being zero, light pastels being the low numbers, and the pure version of the colour in the rainbow being one.
The final value then is the pixel's lightness, this is simply how bright or dark it is, with black being zero and white being one.
Now, we can change colours without affecting brightness, and brightness without affecting colour. Changing the hue change the shade of the colour, and changing the saturation changes its intensity.
Now that we know how our editors internally represent colour, let's re-visit the channel mixer which I mentioned in LTP 131 when describing my monochrome adventures.
This is a tool for converting colour images into black and white images with more artistic control than we get by simply desaturating them.
Just like our photo editors can represent a colour image in HSL, they can represent black at white images as simply brightness values, one for each pixel. What the channel mixer does is convert individual hue, saturation, and lightness values for each input pixel into just a single lightness value for each output pixel. For each pixel, three inputs get converted to one output.
The naïve approach is to simply ignore the colour information in the input image and just copy the lightness values across un-changed. This is what happens when you convert and image by simply sliding the saturation to zero.
What the channel mixer lets us do is group the pixels into multiple sets based on their hue, and apply a different adjust me to each set. We have 360 degrees of hue to work with, so what most editors do is divide that imaginary circle into eight 45 degree segments, giving you eight sliders which map to:
In effect, every pixel gets connected to one of the eight sliders based on its original hue.
So what do the sliders do? They apply a gain to that pixel's lightness value, letting your darken or lighten the resulting output value by some amount. Note that you're not adding or subtracting a set amount of lightness from each affected pixel, but multiplying the input value by a given factor. This is why the sliders all start in the centre of the slider labeled, which corresponds to multiplying the input value by 1 to get the output value, in other words, leaving the pixels lightness un-changed.
When you slide the slider to the right you are multiplying by 1.x, so 1.1, then 1.2, then 1.3 etc., making the pixels controlled by that slider a little brighter, more brighter, a lot brighter, etc.. When you slide the slider the other way you're multiplying by 0.x, 0.9, then 0.8, then 0.7 etc., making the controlled pixels a little darker, more darker, a lot darker, etc..
This is very powerful, because a lot of colour photographs have large areas with a similar colour, like blue skies, green grass, and so on. The channel mixer lets us nudge each region in a different direction to give us much more control over the resulting monochrome image.
Now that we understand the colour mixer, let's examine it's close cousin, the selective colour adjustment.
The fundamental difference here is that this time both the input and output images are in colour, so we don't have three values for each pixel becoming one value for each pixel, but three input values for each pixel being translated to three output values for each pixel.
Again, we're working HSL, so each pixel has an original hue, saturation, and lightness, and and output hue, saturation, and lightness.
We're presented with an extremely similar interface, because we're doing the same trick of grouping all pixels into one of 8 segments based on their hue, the difference is that we now have three sliders for each colour segment, a hue slider, a saturation slider, and a lightness slider.
We can use the hue slider in each segment to nudge the shade of each matching pixel clockwise or anti-clockwise around our colour circle. This lets us do things like make blue pixels a little pinker or greener, yellow pixels a little more orange or green, etc..
We can use the saturation slider to make the colour of each matching pixel a little more or less vibrant. Maybe we have a sunset where the sky has a lovely orange hue we want to emphasise, while the shadows have a blue hue we want to reduce, we can push the orange saturation up, and the blue saturation down, giving us the warm feel we want while simultaneously de-emphasising the cooler colours we don't.
Finally, we can use the lightness slider to brighten or dark the matching pixels.
What we're doing here is applying colour shifts in a fine-grained way rather than applying them to every pixel.
So, the final piece of the puzzle, can you get some of the power of the channel mixer in an editor that doesn't have one, but does have both a selective colour adjustment and a saturation slider?
Maybe. It depends entirely on the order in which the editor chooses to apply those two controls. If the editor does the desaturation first, then the selective colour adjustment has nothing to work with, but if the editor applies the selective colour first, then you can alter the different colour regions of the image separately before the colour information is thrown away.
So, the first caveat is obvious — if the ordering is wrong, you're SOL (straight out of luck, or similar ). There is also a second caveat — in my experience many editors only let you nudge the brightness for each colour segment a little bit, so you'll never get your blue skies to go as inky black as you could with a true channel mixer.
While my hook for this episode was disambiguating two confusingly similar sliders, the knowledge I'm most keen to share is actually an understanding of the HSL colour space. As a computer scientist and physicist I've been conditioned to think of colours in RGB for decades, which held back my understanding of powerful image editors like Photoshop and Lightroom for many years. It was the first time the HSL penny dropped that these tools finally started to make sense to me. The names of adjustments and sliders suddenly made a lot more sense, and their effects suddenly became a lot more intuitive to me.
Those of you from a fine arts background probably grey up with an HSL mindset from the very beginning, so you probably knew all this already. I hope you found the first-principles explanation useful thought. But my big hope is that my fellow STEM people have joined me in understanding colour in a new way.
The show starts with some quick followup on a few recently covered and long-running stories before diving into a big serving of regulatory stories, a handful legal story, just one piece of HR news, and some highlights from Apple’s services and original content. The three main stories are a new security feature that appeared unannounced in iOS 18.1, 3rd-party sharing for Find My, and some updates to Apple’s Pro apps. The show finishes with a rundown of a few other quick Apple-related stories that made the news in November.
You’ll find detailed show notes below the fold, and if you enjoy this free show, please consider clicking on the donate button at the top of the left side bar – the show is free for you to listen to, but not for Bart to Produce!
Quick updates to long-running stories the show continues to track, and to stories covered in recent shows.
AirPods Pro 2 hearing tests and protection features come to France, though not the hearing aid functionality, at last not yet — appleinsider.com/…
Apple Intelligence developments:
The Matter standard continues to evolve, V1.4 released — appleinsider.com/… (New devices types include home battery & EV-charging devices, heat pumps, water heaters, and in-wall controllers for lights, fans, etc.)
Apple's RCS support gets a little better with emoji reactions from Android devices now being displayed just like those from iOS devices — www.macobserver.com/…
Apple continues to diversity away from China and develop production in India:
Apple's attempts to re-gain access to the Indonesian market for the iPhone 16 have not gone well:
India Rejects Apple’s Request to Suspend Antitrust Investigation Report — www.macobserver.com/… (Apple had previously succeeded in suspending the report over claims it leaked proprietary information)
The European Commission continues it's focus on Apple:
Apple have released their first Digital Markets Act (DMA) Compliance Report that includes iPadOS, and the European Commission released a statement saying they are carefully evaluating it and emphasising the possible penalties if Apple are found wanting:
Following an investigation by national authorities in Ireland, Belgium & Germany the Commission has notified Apple that the geo-blocking within Apple Media Services (App Store, Apple Arcade, Music, iTunes Store, Books and Podcasts) breach EU anti-geo-blocking laws — European Commission PR
Related: Apple suppliers are also in the cross-hairs: Corning faces antitrust actions for its Gorilla Glass dominance — arstechnica.com/…
EU drops four-year Apple audiobook probe after complaint is withdrawn — appleinsider.com/…
Apple's browser rules deemed anticompetitive, says UK competition body — appleinsider.com/…
The US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) have announced that they will start supervising large digital wallet providers, and Apple Pay is very likely to come under scrutiny — appleinsider.com/… & www.macobserver.com/…
Brazilian Antitrust Regulator Orders Apple to Lift App Store Payment Restrictions — www.macobserver.com/…
A judge in an existing class action suite against Apple over the App Store has approved an expansion of the class to cover more customers over more years — www.macobserver.com/…
The well known consumer advocacy group Which! is suing Apple for £3Bn over the alleged anti-competitive nature of iCloud — appleinsider.com/…
The argument is that "iOS has a monopoly" and that Apple has used that "dominance to gain an unfair advantage in related markets, like the cloud storage market." Specifically, Apple is accused of making it difficult to use alternative suppliers.
Apple prompts Molly Anderson from Head of Industrial Design to VP of Industrial Design — www.macobserver.com/…
It's awards & rankings time!
Apple reveals 45 app and game finalists for the 2024 App Store Awards — Apple PR
Top Apple Podcast charts for 2024 show what everyone's been listening to — appleinsider.com/…
Apple Music Classical is now available in CarPlay — appleinsider.com/…
Have happier holidays with 15 new Apple Arcade games — www.cultofmac.com/… ( Apple PR)
Apple Pay:
iOS 18.1 brought a new security feature to iPhones: Inactivity Reboot — www.bleepingcomputer.com/…
Apple’s Find My enables users to share the location of lost items with third parties — Apple PR
Apple updates it's Pro Apps
Final Cut Pro 11 begins a new chapter for video editing on Mac — Apple PR
Apple also updated Logic Pro, adding Quantec Room Simulation — appleinsider.com/…
Apple slashes MacBook Pro speaker repair costs — appleinsider.com/…
The campaign group Toxic-Free Future has released their 2024 Retailer Report Card, and Apple tops the rankings — appleinsider.com/…
The report's aims:
"The 2024 Retailer Report Card grades the largest retailers in the U.S. and Canada on their actions to eliminate highly hazardous chemicals and plastics and replace them with safer solutions."
Apple was the only company to get an A grade with a score of 84%, the next closest retailers are Sephora & Walmart with 69% & 65%
Apple have extended their return periods again, from 8 November items can be returned until January 8th (usual policy is 2 weeks) — www.cultofmac.com/…
Note: When the textual description of a link is part of the link it is the title of the page being linked to, when the text describing a link is not part of the link it is a description written by Bart.
From the publisher's feed