Librarians Spill the Tea Podcast

Librarians Spill the Tea Podcast

By Mary Elizabeth Schiavone & Tristan M.K. DraperSociety & CultureEducation
Download on the App Store

Librarians Spill the Tea Podcast episodes

  • Season 2, Bonus Episode: Giving a Professional Talk

    Welcome to Librarians Spill the Tea, where we explore the context around scholarly drama and librarianship. For each episode, you’ll find an Episode Description, Timestamps, full Transcript (on Substack only), followed by our Show Notes, which contain any works and other links mentioned—you can find any images on our Substack.

    Thanks for listening to Librarians Spill the Tea! Subscribe for free to receive new posts, episodes, and updates.

    Episode Description

    Tristan and Mary go through the process of creating, submitting, preparing, and giving a professional talk, using their talk for the Association of College and Research Libraries (ACRL) College Library Section (CLS)’s Open Meeting.

    We’re trying a new way of sharing full episode transcripts! This episode’s transcript is available as a PDF:

    Mentioned in this Episode

    * ACRL CLS: https://www.ala.org/acrl/aboutacrl/directoryofleadership/sections/cls/clswebsite/clshomepage

    * The slides from our presentation:

    * Recording of the presentation:

    The music in our intro/outro is “Old Friends from Manhattan” by White_Music on Pixabay.

    Thank you to CELEB for letting us use their amazing podcasting studio: https://www.beloit.edu/celeb/

    Stay in touch!

    Subscribe on Substack.

    Subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

    Subscribe on Spotify.

    Follow us on Instagram: @lsttpod

    Follow us on BlueSky: @lsttpod.bsky.social

    Share your research tea with us at [email protected]

    xoxo,

    your librarians



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit librariansspillthetea.substack.com
    45 min
  • Season 2, Episode 5: Pseudoscience-isode! with Lincoln Draper

    Welcome to Librarians Spill the Tea, where we explore the context around scholarly drama and librarianship. For each episode, you’ll find an Episode Description, Timestamps, full Transcript (on Substack only), followed by our Show Notes, which contain any works and other links mentioned—you can find any images on our Substack.

    Thanks for listening to Librarians Spill the Tea! Subscribe for free to receive new posts, episodes, and updates.

    Episode Description

    Join your librarians, Tristan and Mary, and physicist, Lincoln, as we explore astrophysics research, pseudoscience, conspiracy theories, and science communication.

    Timestamps

    00:00 Intro

    00:52 International Cosmic Ray Conference

    01:40 Ice Cube

    03:38 Pin Check

    05:18 Topic Intro: Pseudoscience

    07:33 Defining Pseudoscience

    11:08 Pseudoscience Examples

    12:51 Conspiracy Theories

    15:11 Scientific Communication

    17:37 Citizen Science

    24:02 Library Favs

    For a full transcript of this episode and any pictures, visit our Substack at https://librariansspillthetea.substack.com/.

    Mentioned in this Episode

    * International Cosmic Ray Conference: https://indico.cern.ch/event/1258933/

    * Investigation of Electromagnetic and Muonic Air-Shower Components using IceTop Simulations (Lincoln’s Presentation): https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.08478

    * Overcooked: https://store.steampowered.com/app/448510/Overcooked/

    * IceCube Neutrino Observatory:

    https://icecube.wisc.edu/

    * Critical Role:

    https://critrole.com/

    * Busy Beaver Button Co:

    https://www.busybeaver.net/

    * Button Museum: https://www.busybeaver.net/button-museum/?srsltid=AfmBOooeG8syQWUOu_WGbJZkz1yx1FuyE-FD7sRTF2EQwjPiLXKaBfc_

    * American Physical Society General Meeting: https://www.aps.org/events

    * Enrico Fermi Nobel Prize: https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/1938/summary/

    * Red String Meme

    * IceCube’s first citizen science project a success: https://icecube.wisc.edu/news/research/2024/01/icecubes-first-citizen-science-project-a-success/

    * Civil War ship log transcription project: https://www.zooniverse.org/projects/bluejackets/civil-war-bluejackets

    * BatAMP - Bat Acoustic Monitoring Portal: https://batmanagement.com/pages/batamp-bat-acoustic-monitoring-portal?srsltid=AfmBOopgBNfP0nxMcpEOR-Jb9uZrsWUNOOTuZmllxz8Cdy1jI7HcVkFR

    * Library of Congress Virtual Volunteering:

    https://crowd.loc.gov/

    * Fish Gate: https://visdeurbel.nl/en/

    * Whale FM: https://www.scientificamerican.com/blog/observations/sounds-of-the-deep-scientific-american-launches-citizen-science-project-to-id-whale-calls/

    * Philosophiae Naturalis Principia Mathematica: https://lib.utah.edu/collections/rarebooks/database/science/principia.php

    * 3rd floor carpet

    Pin Check

    * Certified Loud Librarian Pin:

    * Green Dragon Pin: Unfortunately, we couldn’t find the exact pin, but it came in a set like this: https://gamesofberkeley.com/products/mystery-dice-set-7-metal-tiny-treasures-10mm-w-pin?srsltid=AfmBOophZ2Qo2pl2Il8nrAUHytyRcmhS_N5PI4k_4jDmnATJa9MSCe7c

    * Knowledge is Power Pin: Tristan lost this button, but here’s a similar pin: https://www.ebay.com/itm/256384862224

    The music in our intro/outro is “Old Friends from Manhattan” by White_Music on Pixabay.

    Thank you to CELEB for letting us use their amazing podcasting studio: https://www.beloit.edu/celeb/

    Stay in touch!

    Subscribe on Substack.

    Subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

    Subscribe on Spotify.

    Follow us on Instagram: @lsttpod

    Follow us on BlueSky: @lsttpod.bsky.social

    Share your research tea with us at [email protected]

    xoxo,

    your librarians (and physicist)



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit librariansspillthetea.substack.com
    28 min
  • Season 2, Episode 4: Brewing Tea - Citations (Vendors Behaving Badly, part 2)

    Welcome to Librarians Spill the Tea, where we explore the context around scholarly drama and librarianship. For each episode, you’ll find an Episode Description, Timestamps, full Transcript (on Substack only), followed by our Show Notes, which contain any works and other links mentioned—you can find any images on our Substack.

    Thanks for listening to Librarians Spill the Tea! Subscribe for free to receive new posts, episodes, and updates.

    Episode Description

    Join your librarians as Tristan and Mary explore different kinds of citations and spill tea on citation manipulation, journal impact scores, and self-citation.

    Timestamps

    Intro - 0.00

    Pin Check - 2:15

    Citations - 3:23

    What is a citation? - 3:49

    Citation styles - 8:21

    Citation tools - 21:09

    Citation tea - 26:43

    Journal Impact Factor - 26:59

    Tea - 30:24

    Citation Manipulation - 31:07

    Citation cartels - 32:11

    Self-citation - 41:03

    Clarivate tea - 49:23

    Library favs - 1:02:24

    For a full transcript of this episode and any pictures, visit our Substack at https://librariansspillthetea.substack.com/.

    Mentioned in this Episode

    * Ripped Bodice - State of Romance Report: https://www.therippedbodice.com/state-racial-diversity-romance-publishing-report

    * MLA Containers Explainer: https://style.mla.org/works-cited/works-cited-a-quick-guide/

    * Chicago Color Coded Citations Example:

    Image credit: https://edubirdie.com/citation/chicago/

    * Chicago Style Citations: https://www.chicagomanualofstyle.org/home.html

    * Chicago Style History: https://www.chicagomanualofstyle.org/help-tools/about.html

    * MLA (Modern Language Association) Style Citations:

    https://style.mla.org/

    * APA (American Psychological Association) Style Citations:

    https://apastyle.apa.org/

    * APA Style History: https://apastyle.apa.org/about-apa-style

    * ACS (American Chemical Society) Style Citations: https://pubs.acs.org/doi/full/10.1021/acsguide.40303

    * AMS (American Mathematical Society) Style Citations: https://www.ams.org/arc/styleguide/AMSstyleguide.pdf

    * IEEE (Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers) Style Citations: https://journals.ieeeauthorcenter.ieee.org/create-your-ieee-journal-article/create-the-text-of-your-article/ieee-editorial-style-manual/

    * IEEE drama: https://www.science.org/content/article/update-reversal-science-publisher-ieee-drops-ban-using-huawei-scientists-reviewers

    * IEEE Preventing Citation Manipulation During Peer Reviews: https://ieeephotonics.org/news/preventing-citation-manipulation-during-peer-reviews/

    * The rocks Tristan found:

    * Ebling Library (University of Wisconsin-Madison) Journal Impact Metrics Guide: https://researchguides.library.wisc.edu/c.php?g=1226768&p=8979284

    * University of Calgary Academic Publishing Demystified Guide: https://libguides.ucalgary.ca/publishing/impact_factor

    * Citation Manipulation Article: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-025-88709-7

    * COPE article on citation manipulation: https://publicationethics.org/topic-discussions/citation-manipulation#:~:text=Citation%20manipulation%20involves%20editors%20or,manipulation%20that%20undermines%20academic%20integrity

    * “The Emergence of a Citation Cartel” article: https://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2012/04/10/emergence-of-a-citation-cartel/

    * “Visualizing Citation Cartels” article: https://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2016/09/26/visualizing-citation-cartels/

    * “Hundreds of extreme self-citing scientists revealed in new database” article: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02479-7

    * “Journal hit by citation scandal named among top in field”: https://retractionwatch.com/2017/06/19/journal-hit-citation-scandal-named-among-top-field/

    * Evaluation toolkits:

    Example 1:

    Example 2:

    * “Men Set Their Own Cites High: Gender and Self-Citation Across Fields and Over Time” paper: https://sociology.stanford.edu/publications/men-set-their-own-cites-high-gender-and-self-citation-across-fields-and-over-time

    * University of British Columbia Guide on Citation Justice: https://guides.library.ubc.ca/citationjustice#s-lg-box-16597673

    * #CiteBlackWomen:

    http://www.citeblackwomencollective.org/

    * Cite Black Women on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/citeblackwomen/

    Pin Check

    Pride library check out card pin

    Read queer books pin

    Brooklyn Ripped Bodice pin (only in Brooklyn store)

    The music in our intro/outro is “Old Friends from Manhattan” by White_Music on Pixabay.

    Thank you to CELEB for letting us use their amazing podcasting studio: https://www.beloit.edu/celeb/

    Stay in touch!

    Subscribe on Substack.

    Subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

    Subscribe on Spotify.

    Follow us on Instagram: @lsttpod

    Follow us on BlueSky: @lsttpod.bsky.social

    Share your research tea with us at librarianspillthateapodcast [at] gmail.com

    xoxo,

    Your librarians



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit librariansspillthetea.substack.com
    1 hr 6 min
  • Season 2, Episode 3: Replication Crisis - Feeling the Future and Scholars Being Messy on Main

    Join us to learn about the experiment credited with launching the replication crisis in social psychology.

    Welcome to Librarians Spill the Tea, where we explore the context around scholarly drama and librarianship. For each episode, you’ll find an Episode Description, Timestamps, full Transcript (on Substack only), followed by our Show Notes, which contain any works and other links mentioned—you can find any images on our Substack. For a full transcript of this episode, visit our Substack at https://librariansspillthetea.substack.com/.

    Timestamps

    0.00 - Intro

    0:59 - Pin Check

    2:16 - Topic

    3:34 - What is the replication crisis?

    4:16 - Other Definitions

    8:15 - Spilling the Tea

    8:35 - Bem and his study

    12:21 - Bem’s article

    24:55 - Responses to Bem’s article

    29:53 - Replication worries before Bem

    42:46 - Why is this happening?

    51:55 - Library Favs

    Mentioned in this Episode

    National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. 2019. Reproducibility and Replicability in Science. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/25303.

    P-value: https://wmed.edu/sites/default/files/P-VALUES%20SIMPLIFIED.pdf 

    Slate article: https://slate.com/health-and-science/2017/06/daryl-bem-proved-esp-is-real-showed-science-is-broken.html 

    Bem’s Feeling the Future article: Bem DJ. Feeling the future: experimental evidence for anomalous retroactive influences on cognition and affect. J Pers Soc Psychol. 2011 Mar;100(3):407-25. doi: 10.1037/a0021524. PMID: 21280961. 

    Chuck Honorton: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Honorton  

    Cornell Chronicle post: https://news.cornell.edu/stories/2010/12/study-looks-brains-ability-see-future 

    James Alcock critique: “Back from the Future: Parapsychology and the Bem Affair”: https://skepticalinquirer.org/exclusive/back-from-the-future/ 

    Bem’s response to Alcock: https://skepticalinquirer.org/exclusive/response-to-alcocks-back-from-the-future-comments-on-bem/ 

    Nature article: https://www.nature.com/articles/485298a

    Andrew Gelman posts: 

    https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2013/08/25/a-new-bem-theory/

    https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2011/02/15/with_a_bit_of_p/ 

    Why Most Published Research Findings are False by John P.A. Ioannidis: https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.0020124 

    Ulrich (Uli) Schimmack’s Replication Index: https://replicationindex.com/ 

    Psych with Paul Bloom and David Pizarro podcast episode: https://psych.fireside.fm/10 

    WEIRD study - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20550733/ 

    Pin Check

    Possum pin

    The Newberry pin 

    The music in our intro/outro is “Old Friends from Manhattan” by White_Music on Pixabay.

    Thank you to CELEB for letting us use their amazing podcasting studio: https://www.beloit.edu/celeb/ 

    Stay in touch!

    Subscribe on Substack. 

    Subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

    Subscribe on Spotify.

    Follow us on Instagram: @lsttpod 

    Follow us on BlueSky: @lsttpod.bsky.social

    Share your research tea with us at librarianspillthateapodcast [at] gmail.com

    xoxo,

    Your librarians



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit librariansspillthetea.substack.com
    55 min
  • Season 2, Episode 2: Brewing Tea - We Were Peer Reviewers!

    Join us as we discuss our experience serving as peer reviewers for an academic journal. We’ll explore our approaches to peer review and lessons learned.

    Timestamps

    00:00 - Intro

    1:09 - How we were invited 

    6:46 - Tristan’s peer review experience

    8:31 - Mary’s peer review experience

    10:30 - Time peer review took

    10:56 - Tristan’s process

    14:17 - Mary’s process

    20:56 - The hardest part 

    29:18 - Results

    Transcript - available on Substack

    Mentioned in this Episode:

    Tristan’s peer review research resources: 

    Elsevier Modules in Becoming a Peer Reviewer: https://researcheracademy.elsevier.com/navigating-peer-review/becoming-peer-reviewer

    “How to be a Great Peer Reviewer” by Tomoki Sempokuya, Nicholas McDonald, Mohammad Bilal: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9820852/

    Wiley Author Services How to Peer Review Guide: https://authorservices.wiley.com/Reviewers/journal-reviewers/how-to-perform-a-peer-review/step-by-step-guide-to-reviewing-a-manuscript.html

    Cambridge University Press & Assessment Guide to Peer Reviewing Journal Articles: https://share.google/6Fxp5tnn1S22pKIj6

    The Uncanny Mouse episode: https://librariansspillthetea.substack.com/p/episode-4-the-uncanny-mouse 

    --

    The music in our intro/outro is “Old Friends from Manhattan” by White_Music on Pixabay.

    Thank you to CELEB for letting us use their amazing podcasting studio: https://www.beloit.edu/celeb/ 

    Stay in touch!

    Subscribe on Substack. 

    Subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

    Subscribe on Spotify.

    Follow us on Instagram: @lsttpod 

    Follow us on BlueSky: @lsttpod.bsky.social  

    Share your research tea with us at librarianspillthateapodcast [at] gmail.com

    xoxo,

    Your librarians



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit librariansspillthetea.substack.com
    31 min
  • Season 2, Episode 1: Non-Traditional Research Outputs

    Welcome to Librarians Spill the Tea, where we explore the context around scholarly drama and librarianship. For each episode, you’ll find an Episode Description, Timestamps, full Transcript (on Substack only), followed by our Show Notes, which contain any works and other links mentioned—you can find any images on our Substack.

    Thanks for reading Librarians Spill the Tea! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support our work.

    Episode Description

    In today’s episode, we introduce a new type of episode called sipping tea, where we discuss interesting things that we find in our research! Sip some tea with us as we chat about non-traditional research outputs and comics in peer-reviewed journals. We’ll discuss “Stories About Repatriations: Journeys to Complete the Work,” a full comic featured in the journal American Anthropologist, and our own experiences creating and using non-traditional research outputs.

    Timestamps

    00:00

    Intro

    00:37

    Sipping Tea Episode Introduction

    00:55

    Exploring Non-Traditional Research Outputs

    01:10

    Pin Check

    02:06

    Defining Non-Traditional Research Outputs and Gray Literature

    04:12

    Traditional vs Non-Traditional Research Outputs

    05:37

    Examples of Non-Traditional Outputs

    07:21

    Discovering Comics in an Academic Journal

    08:49

    Understanding Repatriation and Cultural Patrimony

    09:07

    Stories About Repatriations: Journeys to Complete the Work

    13:29

    Undergraduate Research and Non-Traditional Research Outputs

    14:51

    Sharing Research and Scholarly Communication

    15:51

    Determining the right research format?

    17:13

    Evaluating Non-Traditional Research Outputs

    18:25

    The Role of Peer Review in Creative Formats

    21:04

    Will this conversation impact our work going forward?

    24:07

    Navigating Publishing Non-Traditional Research

    26:39

    Library Favs

    27:55

    Outro

    For a full transcript of this episode, visit our Substack at https://librariansspillthetea.substack.com/.

    Mentioned in this Episode

    Non-traditional research outputs (University of Melbourne): https://research.unimelb.edu.au/strengths/updates/news/explainer-what-are-non-traditional-research-outputs,-and-why-do-they-matter

    Gray literature: https://guides.library.illinois.edu/c.php?g=1310347&p=9630537

    Ologies: https://www.alieward.com/ologies

    “Two Archaeologists Unscientifically Argue That Ethical Practice Is Anti-Science” by Emma Louise Backe: https://thegeekanthropologist.com/2021/04/27/two-archaeologists-unscientifically-argue-that-ethical-practice-is-anti-science/

    Dr. Sonya Atalay: https://anthropology.mit.edu/people/faculty/sonya-atalay

    Dr. Jen Shannon: https://www.colorado.edu/anthropology/jen-shannon

    National Park Service Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act website: https://www.nps.gov/subjects/nagpra/index.htm

    “NAGPRA Comics featured in peer-reviewed journal, American Anthropologist”: https://nagpracomics.weebly.com/project-updates/nagpra-comics-featured-in-peer-reviewed-journal-american-anthropologist

    “Stories About Repatriations: Journeys to Complete the Work” by Sonya Atalay, Jen Shannon, and John G. Swogger: https://drive.google.com/file/d/18QQYDDi9bjbpvSA9sNV9tHp_SSsHL--o/view

    Abstract: NAGPRA Comics, Vol. 1: Journeys to Complete the Work: Stories about Repatriations and Changing the Way We Bring Native American Ancestors Home (2017) is a coauthored comic book by archaeologist Sonya Atalay (Anishinabe-Ojibwe), museum anthropologist Jen Shannon, and archaeologist and comic artist John Swogger in collaboration with the Ziibiwing Center of Anishinabe Culture & Lifeways. This comic book—the first in the NAGPRA Comics series—is based on our research, scholarly commitments, and practical experience implementing the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act of 1990 (NAGPRA). As an applied comic, Journeys to Complete the Work is both a scholarly resource and a call to action. It aims to empower Native communities by informing them about their rights under NAGPRA and to educate Native and non-Native communities about the law—its benefits and its shortfalls (Swogger 2017).

    Graphic narratives are a vernacular and popular form, which allows us to use a direct vocabulary and avoid sanitized legal language for concepts relating to the unsettling history and reality of burials, bones, and digging up graves. In 2012, it was estimated that there were 300,000 to 600,000 Native American bodies in US university, museum, and laboratory collections that were subject to NAGPRA (McKeown 2013, 10). While we may slip into using NAGPRA legal terms like “culturally unidentifiable individuals” and “associated funerary objects,” we are talking about Native ancestors—bodies that were dug up from burials, burials that reflect spiritual care for individuals and the items buried with them that were intended for traveling with the ancestors on their journey. Repatriation is a part of completing this interrupted journey.

    Ethno/Graphic Storytelling: Communicating Research and Exploring Pedagogical Approaches through Graphic Narratives, Drawings, and Zines by: Sonya Atalay, Letizia Bonanno, Sally Campbell Galman, Sarah Jacqz, Ryan Rybka, Jen Shannon, Cary Speck, John Swogger, Erica Wolencheck: https://anthrosource.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/aman.13293

    “Completing the Journey: A Graphic Narrative about NAGPRA and Repatriation” by Sonya Atalay and Jen Shannon: https://www.americananthropologist.org/ethnographic-storytelling/atalay-shannon-completing-journey

    Pictures of our window decorations (only on Substack)

    In the Library with the Lead Pipe: https://www.inthelibrarywiththeleadpipe.org/

    Tristan’s lightning talk slides (only on Substack)

    Other Resources Reviewed in the Prep for this Episode

    University of Wollongong - Australia Library services for researchers - Strategic Publishing Guide: https://uow.libguides.com/strategic-publishing/NTRO

    Pin Check

    There is no planet B*: https://shop.amnh.org/there-is-no-planet-b-enamel-pin

    * It was later discovered that this pin actually belonged to Tristan’s student worker :)

    & JULIET X FOLX Transgender Awareness Pin: https://www.broadwaymerchandiseshop.com/products/juliet-transgender-awareness-pin?srsltid=AfmBOoqP-j6ZdykLAhJEQYmd2x4f4v2xNHTx7AWtx909grZXSI65AbaL

    The Lab Coat of Library Science:

    https://www.etsy.com/listing/1229899968/lab-coat-of-library-science-cardigan

    The music in our intro/outro is “Old Friends from Manhattan” by White_Music on Pixabay.

    Thank you to CELEB for letting us use their amazing podcasting studio: https://www.beloit.edu/celeb/

    Stay in touch!

    Subscribe on Substack.

    Subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

    Subscribe on Spotify.

    Follow our Instagram (@LSTTPod) and BlueSky (@@lsttpod.bsky.social)!



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit librariansspillthetea.substack.com
    29 min
  • Bonus Episode: ACRL, part 2

    Welcome to Librarians Spill the Tea, where we explore the context around scholarly drama and librarianship. For each episode, you’ll find an Episode Description, Timestamps, full Transcript (on Substack only), followed by our Show Notes, which contain any works and other links mentioned—you can find any images on our Substack.

    Thanks for listening to Librarians Spill the Tea! Subscribe for free to receive new posts, episodes, and updates.

    Episode Description

    This episode is a compilation clips from amazing library professionals that we met at the conference and asked them questions about what it was like being at a professional conference, how they prepare for a conference, how they network other things like that. A huge thank you to our guests for their fabulous insight and willingness to share it!

    Show Notes (pictures on Substack only)

    Mentioned in this Episode

    * Shine in a Good Way Shop (mentioned by Cassy Leeport): https://shineinagoodway.com/

    * TLAM course at UW Madison (mentioned by Cassy Leeport): https://researchguides.library.wisc.edu/c.php?g=1293565&p=9584934

    * Evidence Synthesis Institute (mentioned by Melissa Ernst): https://www.lib.umn.edu/about/evidence-synthesis-institute

    * Library Trends (mentioned by Melissa Wong): https://www.press.jhu.edu/journals/library-trends

    * Owamni Restaurant (mentioned by Patrick Leeport): https://owamni.com/

    * Easton’s book: forthcoming!

    * Ruha Benjamin (opening keynote): https://www.ruhabenjamin.com/

    * Saeed Jones (closing keynote): https://www.readsaeedjones.com/

    The music in our intro/outro is “Old Friends from Manhattan” by White_Music on Pixabay.

    Thank you to CELEB for letting us use their amazing podcasting studio: https://www.beloit.edu/celeb/

    Stay in touch!

    Subscribe on Substack.

    Subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

    Subscribe on Spotify.

    Follow our Library’s Instagram and TikTok: @beloitLITS



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit librariansspillthetea.substack.com
    36 min
  • Bonus Episode: ACRL, part 1

    Welcome to Librarians Spill the Tea, where we explore the context around scholarly drama. For each episode, you’ll find an Episode Description, full Transcript (on Substack only), followed by our Show Notes, which contain any works and other links mentioned—you can find any images on our Substack.

    Thanks for listening to Librarians Spill the Tea! Subscribe for free to receive new posts, episodes, and updates.

    Episode Description

    Tristan and Mary talk through their experiences at the Association of College and Research Libraries Conference. Join us to learn more abotu what it’s like to be at a large professional conference.

    Mentioned in this Episode

    * Ruha Benjamin (opening keynote): https://www.ruhabenjamin.com/

    * Saeed Jones (closing keynote): https://www.readsaeedjones.com/

    The music in our intro/outro is “Old Friends from Manhattan” by White_Music on Pixabay.

    Thank you to CELEB for letting us use their amazing podcasting studio: https://www.beloit.edu/celeb/

    Stay in touch!

    Subscribe on Substack.

    Subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

    Subscribe on Spotify.

    Follow our Library’s Instagram and TikTok: @beloitLITS



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit librariansspillthetea.substack.com
    35 min
  • Episode 4: The Uncanny Mouse - AI in Scientific Publishing & Art

    Welcome to Librarians Spill the Tea, where we explore the context around scholarly drama. For each episode, you’ll find an Episode Description, Timestamps, full Transcript, followed by our Show Notes, which contain any works and other links mentioned.

    Thanks for listening to Librarians Spill the Tea! Subscribe for free to receive new posts, episodes, and updates.

    Description

    Today we’ll be talking about an article that was published and retracted from Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology in February 2024 due to its use of inaccurate, AI-generated figures. We’ll be discussing AI-generated art and images, publisher disclaimers, Midjourney, and public response to the article in question.

    Timestamps

    00:00 - Intro

    00:55 - Pin Check!

    2:28 - Exploring the retracted article

    3:29 - Looking at the images

    6:10 - Initial thoughts on the images

    6:39 - The Vice article

    10:10 - The Frontiers disclaimer

    13:53 - LinkedIn post discussion

    15:49 - The article’s retraction

    23:17 - Midjourney

    41:20 - Responses to the retracted article

    44:13 - Anti-AI tools

    55:04 - Library Favs segment

    Transcript

    For a full transcript of this episode, visit our Substack at https://librariansspillthetea.substack.com/.

    Mentioned in this Episode

    The article in question: “Cellular functions of spermatogonial stem cells in relation to JAK/STAT signaling pathway”

    The AI-generated mouse image from the article:

    Vice article: Scientific Journal Publishes AI-Generated Rat with Gigantic Penis In Worrying Incident

    Frontiers peer review process:

    LinkedIn post by Tullio Rossi, PhD

    Retraction notice from Frontiers

    Statement about the retraction from Frontiers

    Nature AI policy

    Dress up simulators (non-AI):

    * https://www.dolldivine.com/classic-games/hobbit-and-lotr-dress-up-game

    * https://www.dolldivine.com/fairytale-duet-ff

    * https://www.dolldivine.com/space-princess

    Midjourney site: https://www.midjourney.com/home

    Midjourney Wikipedia article

    Midjourney top of the week screenshots (at time of recording):

    Midjourney The Economist Cover: How a computer designed this week’s cover

    Artists suing Midjourney and others:

    Article about the Midjourney image winning competition:

    An A.I.-Generated Picture Won an Art Prize. Artists Aren’t Happy.

    Fawkes, Glaze, and Nightshade: The Great AI Art Heist

    Artist who uses Midjourney: Dr. Nettrice Gaskins

    Creating Scientific Images Guidelines: https://lupinestudios.com/scientific-visualization-checklist/

    Other Resources Reviewed in the Prep for this Episode

    Pin Check

    Libraries are for everyone pin

    Belle da Costa Greene pin

    More about Belle da Costa Greene

    Librarians, saving your ass since 300CE pin

    The music in our intro/outro is “Old Friends from Manhattan” by White_Music on Pixabay.

    Thank you to CELEB for letting us use their amazing podcasting studio: https://www.beloit.edu/celeb/

    Stay in touch!

    Subscribe on Substack.

    Subscribe on Apple Podcasts.

    Subscribe on Spotify.

    Follow our Library’s Instagram and TikTok: @beloitLITS



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit librariansspillthetea.substack.com
    58 min
  • Episode 3: Brewing Tea - Literature Reviews

    Welcome to Librarians Spill the Tea, where we explore the context around scholarly drama. For each episode, you’ll find an Episode Description, Timestamps, full Transcript, followed by our Show Notes, which contain any works and other links mentioned.

    Thanks for listening to Librarians Spill the Tea! Subscribe for free to receive new posts, episodes, and updates.

    Description

    In our first “Brewing Tea” episode, we focus less on the drama, and more on the nuts and bolts of the research process. We cover what a literature review is, what a literature review is not, how to write one, how to use one, and why we should even care about literature reviews.

    Timestamps

    00:00 - Intro

    00:39 - Pin Check!

    2:51 - What is a lit review?

    3:24 - Lit review vs. Annotated Bibliography

    4:19 - Are lit reviews different across disciplines?

    8:01 - Defining related terms

    8:34 - What is synthesis?

    9:49 - Synthesis vs. description vs. interpretation

    11:09 - Lit vs. scoping vs. systematic reviews

    13:21 - Why care about a lit review?

    23:29 - Making a lit review/where to start

    31:57 - Organizing a lit review

    32:07 - LibGuides

    40:39 - Lit reviews are narrative

    43:02 - How do you use a lit review?

    48:21 - Library Favs segment

    Transcript

    Mary

    (with music) Ready for some scholarly drama? Join your librarians as we spill the tea.

    (music)

    Welcome to Librarians Spill the Tea. I'm Mary.

    Tristan

    I'm Tristan.

    Mary

    We're going to be doing a Brewing Tea episode, which is where we talk about some of the nuts and bolts of research, and maybe what different terms mean things you should be thinking about, all that good stuff. So today we are going to be talking about literature reviews.

    OK, Tristan, what pins are you wearing today?

    Tristan

    I am wearing an enamel pin that looks like an award ribbon, but it's made out of books and it says “library enthusiast.”

    Mary

    Mhmm.

    Tristan

    And then I'm also wearing a pin that Mary made. That has a turtle? Tortoise? Turtle on it?

    Mary

    I searched turtle to get that picture, so we're gonna go with turtle.

    Tristan

    OK saying “I read banned books.” It's very cute.

    Mary

    We have a lot of pins related to banned books. Mostly because I was really into making buttons at that point in my career, when it was banned books week.

    Tristan

    Amazing. Good work.

    Mary

    Thank you so much.

    Tristan

    What about you, Mary? What are you wearing?

    Mary

    OK, so I am wearing also a button that I made, and this one says, “tomorrow needs you” and it's a yellow background with blue text. It has like a little sun on there and then “call/text 988,” and that's one I made for Suicide Prevention Month, but it's like always on my backpack, and I'm just wearing it today.

    Tristan

    Yeah, that's a good one.

    Mary

    Also, I feel like for folks that are at Beloit, if you ever want one of the buttons we've made-- I'll link like at least the images for these maybe. Just DM us on Instagram and I will do my best to get you one. ‘cause we can always make a couple more.

    Tristan

    Yes, should we also highlight that celeb has button making materials and devices?

    Mary

    Oh, we should. Mm-hmm. So where we record our podcast, aside from when I hide in my little tiny walk in closet to fill in gaps, is the awesome CELEB podcasting studio, which has a great setup. So Beloiters, if you're listening to this, definitely come check it out if you want to start your own recordings, and come use the button makers, they have multiple.

    Tristan

    Multiple button makers, multiple sizes. They have sewing machines, 3D printers. I think they make stickers and do printing.

    Mary

    Mm-hmm. They have the T-shirt maker thing. Yeah. Definitely reach out to celeb if you're interested in trying out some making stuff.

    So we're going to start today by--Tristan, could you please explain, what is a lit review?

    Tristan

    Alright, so a lit review is generally an overview of published literature on a specific topic or theme or idea question that analyzes and might summarize different writings, different works that are related to your research or whatever you're interested in.

    How was that?

    Mary

    OK, that was great. That was really good.

    What is then the difference between a literature review and an annotated bibliography?

    Tristan

    Oh, great question. So an annotated bibliography generally does not have as much synthesis or evaluation. It's more on the summary side of things, so it'll typically be a list of citations and then, depending maybe on your faculty or your instructor, you might be asked to also summarize the source. You might be asked to say a sentence or two on how you would use it, but typically it will be formatted very differently than a literature review. So typically a literature review is formatted more as a paper with kind of an introduction, a middle and end.

    Mary

    Mhmm.

    Tristan

    Whereas an annotated bibliography typically is a list.

    Mary

    OK. Yeah. I like that. Are there differences in literature reviews across different fields and which ones do you know about being a little different?

    Tristan

    Yes, there are definitely differences between disciplines and how we approach light reviews, how how we do them, maybe even when and why we do them. So I think, for the humanities, I'll speak mostly to the humanities. That's what my background is in. That's where most of my liaison departments are. For the humanities, for lit reviews, we tend to focus more on theory, I would say, and I'm going to actually borrow something from one of our faculty here, Dr. Johnson, who teaches in the Critical Identity Studies department and the religious studies department.

    So one time I visited one of her classes to talk about citations, and as part of that conversation, she brought up the idea of “research genealogy,” which I just love as a concept. I've been obsessed with it ever, ever since she brought it up. But it's basically the idea that, in the humanities especially, when you are doing your research, although I think this definitely applies to other fields as well, you are building an understanding and a discussion between the sources that have come before you. So you're building a genealogy by looking back and putting different sources together in context.

    Mary

    I like that way of explaining it.

    Tristan

    Right. And so I think that's what a lot of humanities literature reviews aim to do. You're putting together resources, you are talking about how they relate, how they are conversing with each other, but then also how they are related to the work that you yourself are doing. But what about in STEM, Mary?

    Mary

    Ohh my goodness, I'm so glad you asked. No. So I did talk to one of our chemistry professors and then I also talked to my sister, who is a physics professor at another small school. Just because I had some thoughts, right? But really the most of the questions we get literature reviews are tied to students that would be categorized at least somewhere between humanities and STEM, kind of like in the poli-sci, history, literature, other fields.

    Tristan

    Right. So and we are a liberal arts school, so it makes sense that there's a lot of crossover.

    Mary

    Yes, yes, but in a lot of sciences, lit reviews are less often assigned in classes for especially undergraduate level students, and they might make more of an appearance in, if you're looking for a full lit review, professionals would publish that in an academic journal to kind of provide almost like a snapshot of the state of the field at the time of writing.

    Now, just because a full lit review is not generally assigned in a class doesn't mean that they're not using some of those tenants. So that might appear instead, in part of an introduction to a paper, it might appear just in a little bit of a different format than we're used to seeing in a full review like us as humanities kids would envision. Another kind of explanation for how these lit review things happen--What a weird way to say that it's okay--Or why maybe you would look at a lit review in these fields. Someone's making a claim that I either want to make or refute, and so I'm looking into if the way that they're saying it is how I wanna say it, and…



    This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit librariansspillthetea.substack.com
    52 min

About Librarians Spill the Tea Podcast

From the publisher's feed

Join us in exploring the messiness of the scholarly world!