In December 2013, the untimely and mysterious death of Christy Appleby raised eyebrows and sparked speculation. Fast forward to January 2017, when Colin Arey vanished without a trace, leaving behind a cloud of uncertainty. The following year, in June 2017, Robin Davis also met a suspicious fate, further deepening the intrigue surrounding these events. Just six months later, in December 2017, Kirk Davis similarly succumbed to an enigmatic demise. All these incidents unfolded in the small town of Bucksport, Maine, and they share a chilling connection: each individual was last seen in the company of David Appleby, a figure now shrouded in suspicion.

Tonight we are joined by Jacqui Fulton an investigative journalist who has worked to bring justice for the Bucksport four, and private investigator Jen Dorman who has took on the fight to help bring forth enough evidence to finally make David Appleby answer for his involvement in each case.