On the 25th anniversary of 9/11, Stephen reflects on the fear, anger, and profound vulnerability exposed by that terrible day—and on what 25 years of rebuilding can teach us now. From the collapse of our illusions of power and invulnerability to the remarkable renewal of New York City, this reflection asks where our truest strength is found. The past does not have to dictate our future. Even from the rubble, life can emerge—and life and love will have the day, if we choose them.
9/11
The 25th anniversary of “9/11” triggers the terrible memory of a beautiful, cloudless Tuesday morning turned ugly by billowing stacks of smoke erupting from the tip of my island home. Within hours a silent, soot-besmeared remnant from lower Manhattan slowly walked north on avenues eerily bereft of cars, and then, nothing. Silence—the city was silent -- except for low streaking fighter jets searching for unknown enemies. It was as though we Manhattanites had collectively stepped through the scrim of a post-apocalyptic film for real.
With the distance of 25 years, we’ve gained at least a little clarity on how the initial all-for-one, one-for all communal bonding, gave way to unbridled anger and disorientation that shaped our civic life into a hugely mistaken forever-war. In the meantime, I’ve been aware that a profound spiritual truth exposed on that day strains to remain in our conscious awareness. This truth is revealed in the targets themselves: two of the then mightiest symbols of power and wealth in the world were brought crashing down to their foundations.
In the world’s financial capital no amount of money made any difference at all as the towers fell. None. No accomplishment, no fame or notoriety, no amount of preplanned security, no level of striving for comfort, no access to power—none of this made the slightest bit of difference when the towers came down in the wealthiest city in the wealthiest country in the world. The most impressive and powerful works of humanity mattered nothing at all, which deeply unnerved those who thought our power and might had made us invulnerable. And that loss of control and veneer of invulnerability fed our collective anger, to our moldering detriment, since we’re now chewing our democracy to bits in amplified waves of anger, resentment and tribalism.
The spiritual truth that’s still available to us remembering that terrible day is the recognition that our truest strength is, and always has been, located somewhere else. Humanity’s originating heresy has always been idolatry, and its modern companion, narcissism. As David Foster Wallace famously and wisely observed with graduating collegiates some years ago: “Everybody worships. The only choice we get is what to worship.”
But here’s another truth. In the 25 years since, Manhattan’s entire Westside from the George Washington Bridge to the World Trade Center site has been transformed. Cranes and development everywhere. Housing and neighborhoods sprouting where only rotting docks and shipyards and derelict buildings had defined the riverside. The austere and lifeless canyons once known as the financial district have been entirely remade into residential communities with grocery stores and playgrounds. It is pricey real estate to be sure--there’s a whole lot of work to be done on that economic front. But still, out the rubble, life erupted.
Newcomers and GenZers will take this for granted. Old-timers can only marvel at the signs of life renewed. Here’s the lesson: There is always, always, tomorrow, and then the day after that, which, for the spiritually alert also points to the location of our truest strength, to the author of life and love and energizing hope as antidote to our crippling narcissism.
Here’s the takeaway: Life and love will have the day, if we choose it. That they’re woven into the fabric of creation--even in you and me--is what I believe. Despite current conditions, we have been given agency to participate in framing our future. The past does not dictate how we’ll choose to live in the present moment. Look about and everywhere there’s opportunity to participate in reweaving the fabric of our human community. Right where each one of us lives. Right there.
Get full access to Living in the Meantime at livinginthemeantime.substack.com/subscribe