Send us a text

In this episode, we plunge into the murky waters of the Lizzie Borden murder case, dissecting the chaos and confusion that followed the brutal slayings of Andrew and Abby Borden on that fateful August day in 1892. With original witness statements from the time, we aim to sift through the historical noise and uncover the contradictions that have kept this case alive for over a century. 

We scrutinize the accounts of key witnesses, from the first responders, Officer George W. Allen and Dr. Bowen, whose premature conclusions raise serious questions, to Lizzie’s own contradictory statements that leave us guessing. What was she really doing in the barn? And why did she resist a search of her room? 

Bridget Sullivan, the maid, provides a crucial timeline that clashes with Lizzie’s narrative, while the mysterious club found under Alice Russell's bed and the suspicious behavior of those involved hint at deeper secrets. We delve into the ethical quagmire of the investigation, exploring allegations of bribery and witness tampering that cast a shadow over the entire legal process. 

As we navigate through the testimonies, it becomes clear that the human element—fear, bias, and self-preservation—plays a pivotal role in this tragic saga. Join us as we unravel the threads of this infamous case, still shrouded in mystery and intrigue, leaving us to ponder: what really happened in that house on Second Street?

Send us a text

A new experimental podcast where I try out a new format with no background music or host to educate you as two Lizzie Borden Trial experts analyze Moody's compelling two-hour opening statement in 56 minutes, commercial-free. This was Moody's first murder trial at the age of 40. Mrs. Churchill's Inquest is coming soon. Subscribe so you don't miss it! 

TIMECODES:
00:00    INTRO - MOODYS DEMONSTRATES THE TIMELINE of AUGUST 4, 1892 
00:56    The Horror of the Crime
01:26    Classic Opening
02:00    The Difficulty of Acquiring the Transcripts Going Back to Author Ed Pearson in the 1920s 
02:21    A Roadmap of the Prosecution's theory
03:12    Their First Shot of Persuasion
04:37    Old Common Law Language of the Jury's Duty 
05:10    Moody Describes the Crime as Unthinkable
06:45    Moody Tells the Jury to Focus on the Facts & Not Her Character
07:39    Moody Begins to Describe the Family starting with Andrew Borden
09:02     Describes the Layout of the House on a Busy Street in Broad Daylight
10:10     Describes the 3 Exterior Doors of the House
10:40     Moody Describes the Tension & Unkindly Feeling in The House
10:45     He Prepares the Jury for Circumstantial Evidence
11:10     Moody describes the benefaction of property given by Andrew to a relative of Mrs. Borden
11:30     This caused a giant shift in the house between the sisters and Mrs. Borden 
17:55     Who Was In The House the Day Before the Murders?
18:30     Sudden violent illness in the house
18:59     Moody connects illness to Lizzie's attempt to buy Poison the Day Before the illness
20:00     Lizzie Visits Best Friend Alice Russell Evening Before the Murders predicting Doom
21:00     The Day of The Murders 
22:00     Moody Emphasizes the Locked Doors of the House
22:50     Moody Walks Through the Timeline of the Murders 
23:45     Bridget Vomits Breakfast in Back Yard   
24:04     Mrs. Borden Tells Bridget to Wash the Windows While She Goes Upstairs and  tends to                 Pillowcases in the Spare Bedroom that Uncle John Morse Had Slept In during the night
26:56     Moody ascertains that Andrew Borden Arrived at 10:40 am in Contrast to Neighbor who swore she saw Andrew attempting to Unlock His Own Front Door with a Key at 10:32 am
28:55     Lizzie Begins Ironing Handkerchiefs according to herself
30:40     The General Alarm of the Murders Came at 11:15 am to the FRPD Station
34:30     Impossible to Believe Lizzie Eating Pears in the Upstairs Loft of the Barn looking for lead- No footprints in Dust - While Andrew Borden Was Being Murdered according to Officer Medley
35:19     Lizzie suddenly insists she heard Mrs. Borden Come In after asserting All Morning She Was Out to See a Sick Friend  - then Why Was She Sending Bridget Out on Errands To Look For Her?
36:40     Lizzie Changed Clothes While Upstairs into a Prink Wrapper while alone in her room
37:30     Establishing the Order of Deaths - Abby first -cold & clotted - Andrew warm & dripping blood
38:25     Moody Describes the Stomach Contents of Andrew Borden Indicative of Time of Death
39:00     Abby Borden's Stomach Contents Suggest Prior Death by 60+minutes 
40:10     Lizzie disclosed that she turned her clothing over to the police several days after the murders
40:22     Professor Wood descr

Send us a text

Enigmatic Nellie McHenry arrived in Fall River alongside her husband, Detective Edwin McHenry, shortly after the brutal murders of Andrew and Abby Borden. Dubbed the "mysterious lady in black" by local newspapers, Nellie would provide important clues about the household by disguising herself as a relative of the late Mrs. Borden and skillfully gained the trust of Bridget Sullivan, the Borden family’s maid to extract confidential details about the household.

Bridget spoke candidly, revealing key insights that she never disclosed during her preliminary or superior court testimony. However, the world remained unaware of Nellie McHenry’s undercover work until 1989, when the grandson of Prosecutor Hosea Knowlton donated his grandfather's legal files to the Fall River Historical Society—documents that were later published in 1994.

Among Bridget’s revelations was the denial of Lizzie’s claim that a messenger boy delivered a note summoning Mrs. Borden to visit a sick friend. For one, the front door was still double-locked, forcing Mr. Borden to be let in by Bridget upon his return. Additionally, Mrs. Borden never left the house without informing Bridget, even for something as simple as a yeast cake.

Bridget had attempted to leave her position three times, but each time, Mrs. Borden persuaded her to stay by increasing her wages. Though reluctant to share specifics, Bridget admitted that living and working in a household devoid of love was too difficult for her. 

Nellie McHenry is played by Tanya Montoya.

VoiceOver Narrator: Mike Paine

Interview by Borden Experts created with Google Notebook LLM.

Trial testimony provided by the website of LizzieAndrewBorden.com with permission from Stefani Koorey. 

Royalty-free music: Unstoppable and Adrenaline by Jon Wright 

Other sources: The Knowlton Papers by FRHS 

The Case Against Lizzie Borden by William Spencer.

Directed & Produced by Kate Lavender

Visit Lizzie Borden Audio on my YouTube channel and leave a comment! 

https://www.youtube.com/@lizziebordenaudio

Send us a text

This episode contains new information of Lizzie refusing a search and barring the officers from looking inside her room or bureau. Later this information would be disputed as tho it never happened. Read it for yourself in the book "The Jennings Journals, 1892" by the Fall River Historical Society. What was she hiding? Please leave a comment if you know.

Alice said she knew "it was cold blooded murder" implying it was Lizzie by the way that her Uncle, John V. Morse, looked directly into Lizzie's eyes and cried out, "How in the name of God does something like this happen, Lizzie?" when he became emotionally distraught upon hearing that the Bordens had been brutally slain in the few hours since they had all dined together at breakfast.

On further reflection I believe that John Morse was the one person that truly grieved over the loss of Andrew and Abby Borden as he found in Andrew a brotherly, best friend that he could confide in financially and share a sense of belonging as brother-in-laws, his Fall River family for over 42 years when his sister Sarah married Andrew. They were very much alike and shared many secrets which Emma would pry out of him by her letter writing.

The information of John Morse is known to me bc I have recorded the inquest of Charles Sawyer which also goes into more detail about the anguish that John Morse exhibited that day. Unlike Lizzie who was busy swooning.

Included is the expert testimony of Dr. Ed Wood, Professor of Chemistry at Harvard Medical School and his autopsy results of the stomach contents of Andrew and Abby Borden for prussic acid. Unfortunately, he says he would need at least a full two weeks to test for other poisons.

The Flat Iron Theory as a murder weapon is discussed in a letter written to the District Attorney in a letter.

Alice hints that she changed after she found a big ugly stick that scared her under the bed she slept in suggesting that Lizzie may have planted it there. But the FRPD did another thorough search during the funeral and they are the ones that put it back under the bed that made her take notice. I think she changed because of something else she saw or heard regarding Lizzie's behavior - was it because of the dress burning? Was it because she never saw Lizzie cry but only swoon?

Alice Russell played by Shaily Rae Smith
D.A. Hosea Knowlton played by Tim Dennis
HK006 - What Became of the Piece of Lead? by Brenda McGinnis
Irish Cop and Narration by DJ/Radio Star Jack Cone
Lizzie Barrs the Officers: Tanya Montoya as Lizzie Borden
Tim Dennis as Officer Harrington
Dr. Ed Wood played by David Loftus
John V. Morse & Flat Iron Theory by Jack Dabdoub
Lizzie's Axe by David Loftus

FATAL CHOICE opening music by eBunny
CANDY FACTORY by Roman Cano (Alice's theme)
SPOOKY WALTZ by Elena Naumova (Lizzie's new Axe)
SHIMMERING WATERS by Jon Wright (Flat Iron Theory)
HAPPY HALLOWEEN by Ahoami (Closing theme)

Trial transcripts provided with permission by Stefani Koorey
and the website LizzieAndrewBorden.com

Produced by Kate Lavender

Please leave a 5-Star Review on Apple Podcasts. Thank you!

Podcast Superstar and mentor Courtney Kocak has a new podcast called "THE BLEEDERS" for writers that want to get published. Courtney interviews the top people in the industry, authors, agents and marketers on how to write and sell your book!
She’s got you covered with a podcast, a Substack AND a Youtube video!! 

We can’t get enough of Courtney and NEITHER WILL YOU! That’s “The Bleeeeeeeders” a show for writers that want to learn all the secret hacks that attract eyeballs to your writing… follow Courtney Kocak on X for the deals and steals that helped her get her show to Number 1 on Apple Podcasts! And thanks for

Send us a text

Dr. Bowen was summoned shortly after Lizzie Borden discovered the body of her father, Andrew Borden, dead in the sitting room with his head smashed open by a hatchet.  Shortly after Doc Bowen arrived he encountered several witnesses and gave his timeline of events and sadly, described how Mrs. Borden visited his office early Wednesday morning stating that someone was trying to poison her the day before the murders.

Bowen made acute observations on Lizzie and Bridget's behavior including what they were wearing, their composure, and whether or not Lizzie was fainting or crying as the papers said she "was having fainting fits." 

District Attorney Hosea Knowlton: Tim Dennis
Dr. Seabury W. Bowen: David Loftus
Fainting Lizzie: Rina Sklar
Music: The Gargoyles of Notre Dame by Alex Grey
Voiceover Narration: Don Sharp @Sharpvoiceovers on Fiverr
Trial transcripts provided with permission by Stefani Koorey
and www.LizzieAndrewBorden.com

HK 130 and HK 332 were selected from "The Knowlton Papers" by the Fall River Historical Society.
Performed by CrankyPants T.D. Dennis 

"Jonsey" on KBOO.fm.org for some of the most interesting people in the world of books, podcasts, radio theater, music & humor. Guaranteed to entertain & enlighten. And thanks for the review, Jonsey! Jonsey @KBOO.fm.org

Courtney Kocak's "PODCAST BESTIE" is a best friend to podcasters trying to grow & monetize their shows with the top marketing professionals in podcasting with a ton of DIY tips and tricks.  And thanks for the shoutouts, Bestie! 

Visit www.HighDesertSpores.com for the home mushroom grower. 

Send us a text

On August 4, 1892, Dr. John Coughlin, the Mayor of Fall River, arrived at the residence of Andrew and Abby Borden only forty minutes after their brutal murders. Despite the passage of time, his meticulous notes and observations remain relevant today. 

Coughlin's observations include a haunting insight into the nature of the crime: the same person who killed Mr. Borden was responsible for Mrs. Borden's death. He was baffled by the lack of blood at the crime scene and the absence of any evidence that could identify the perpetrator. There were no blood drops leaving the crime scene from Mrs. Borden to Andrew Borden and no bloody footprints leaving the building.

The person committing the deed cleaned up all traces of their work. John Morse who was in town visiting relatives was still wearing the same clothes he arrived in the day before and was seen by several witnesses eliminating him as the first suspect. 

"The same deliberate hand that inflicted death upon the man guided the weapon that cut off Mrs. Borden's life. I cannot satisfy myself how a person could have done such a deed with so little blood around and leave no mark of his presence left behind." 

Dentist M.M. Park played by David Loftus 
Special Appearance by Jack Cone
Mayor Dr. John Couglin played by David Loftus
All other voices played by David Loftus

Music in order of appearance: 
Gloria in Excelsis by Raffaele De Leonardo
Disturbed Anxiety by eBunny 
Cute Puzzle Box by Roman Cano

Produced by Kate Lavender

All information contained in this podcast was selected from the scholarly work of the Fall River Historical Society with "The Knowlton Papers" and "The Jennings Journals 1892." You can order these books online. 

Outro voiceover by Don Sharp of Sharp VoiceOvers

Send us a text

John Morse was the first person that gave his inquest to District Attorney Hosea Knowlton after the suspicious murders of Andrew & Abby Borden on August 4, 1892, just a few hours after he left the house to pursue his errands after spending the night in the same room that Abby's body was found brutally hacked about the head the same way as her husband with no bloody footprints leaving the crime scene. 

D.A. Knowlton grilled him with questions attempting to piece together a plan with Emma or Lizzie to kill their father and stepmother. Many people believe that Uncle John had something to do with the murders but Morse, a lifelong bachelor, showed he had a deep fondness for the extended family he'd known for over 30 years and was invited back for the noonday meal when he came upon the crowds at the house and a guard at the door. 

Music provided by:
eBunny for "Enchanted Violin" from AudioJungle/Envato in the Intro
Spring is Coming by Jack White played at the Outro

David Loftus as John Vinnicum Morse and psychopath Philip Gordon Reed from "The Knowlton Papers" published by the Fall River Historical Society.

Dennis Alexander: Announcer
Tanya Montoya as Lizzie Borden and Tim Dennis as Fall River Police Officer during a room search of Lizzie Borden's bedroom taken from "The Jennings Journals 1892." 

Guest appearance by radio star Jack Cone. "Everywhere that I looked not a trace of crimson could be found." Thanks, Jack, you're a class act! 

Cameo appearance by Arielle Nissenblatt @arithisandthat as Lizzie Borden at the pharmacy the day b4 the murders. "Ten cents of prussic acid, please." You rule! 

Jack White's music can be purchased from Amazon and Apple Music and everywhere music is sold. His royalty-free music is available at MelodyLoops.com

Produced by Kate Lavender

Transcriptions of trial testimony provided with permission by Stefani Koorey and the website of LizzieAndrewBorden.com

Send us a text

Emma Borden, the older spinster sister to Lizzie Borden gave her inquest testimony to District Attorney Hosea Knowlton sometime during August 9-11, 1892 less than a week after the murders of her father and stepmother. 

The testimony takes on new meaning now that we know Emma was present with Lizzie in Fairhaven while she was asking for chloroform at Hypolyte Martel's Apothecary two weeks before the murders which can be verified with the latest book from the prestigious Fall River Historical Society's "The Jennings Journals 1892." 

Includes a short interlude from "one who reads but only a woman" written anonymously to D.A. Knowlton to not forget "the burnt dress" from "The Knowlton Papers" by the Fall River Historical Society.

Emma Borden: Brenda McGinnis
District Attorney Knowlton: Tim Dennis
One Who Reads But Only a Woman: Brenda McGinnis
Last Dance: by eBunny
Spring is Coming: by Jack White
Narrator: Don Sharp 
Produced by Kate Lavender

Trial transcripts provided with permission by Stefani Koorey, Ph.D. and the website of LizzieAndrewBorden.com

Send us a text

Listen while reading the transcript.  Emma Borden and Alice Russell discuss the burning of the Bedford Cord Dress after the murders.

Brenda McGinnis as Emma Borden, Mrs. Cyrus W. Tripp, Mrs. Jane Gray & Gossipy Church Lady.
Rina Sklar as Alice Russell.
David Loftus as Eli Bence, Dr. Albert E. Chase, Officer Harrington & others.
S.W. Conser as Eli Bence, Officer Medley, Reads the "Love Letter to Lizzie" and lawyer, Andrew Jennings & others.
S.W. Conser as spectral voices in Greek Chorus. Host of "Words & Pictures" @KBOO Radio.
Ken Jones as Officers Doherty & Harrington.
Larry Andrews as Officer Harrington.
Christie Quinn reads 2 passages from Parallel Lives from the Fall River Historical Society.
Rolf Semprebon as Officers Doherty & Harrington. Host of "Sounds Unsound" @KBOO Radio.
James Krzmarzick as D.A. Willaim A.Moody's Opening Statement at the Superior Court Trial.
Jody McCoy as Mrs. Churchill.
Kati Dery as Bridget Sullivan with PSHAW!Ha! Ha! Ha!
Martin Dodge as Outro.
Samantha an ominous child voice.
Scary male voice: Jack Dabdoub.
Lady Blue: Lyrics & Melody by Kate Lavender, Vocals by Christine Rotondo.
Music by AudioJungle and MelodyLoops.com.
Both songs were titled: Mysterious Clocks.
RoyaltyFree Music by MelodyLoops.com
Ominous Orchestra by Elena Naumova
Sadness Inside by Erick McNerney
Sadness Through the Window by Audioblyca
Irish Pub by Alexander Lisenkov
Funny Bassoon by Eitan Epstein Music
https://www.lizziebordenaudio.com
https://www.lizziebordenaudio.substack.com
Transcriptions of Lizzie's witness statements provided with permission by Stefani Koorey and LizzieAndrewBorden.com 

Send us a text

Defense Lawyer Ex-Governor George Robinson discusses "that one blue dress with the theory there were 2 bloody dresses to burn" and the prosecution's pursuit of "the Bedford Cord dress" played by Dennis Alexander.
Next door neighbor Mrs. Churchill testifies her discovery of Abby Borden's body upstairs in the guest room after Lizzie's urging played by Jody McCoy.
Officer Medley, Assist. Marshall John Fleet, Charles Cook, business manager, and Reverend  Jubb was played by David Loftus.
Bridget Sullivan played by Kati Dery
James "Chocolate" Dixon played Constable F.L. Edson and Dr. Albert C. Dedrick notices a bowl of bloody water in the guestroom after he placed his fingers in Abby Borden's wounds.
Tanya Montoya as Lizzie Borden.
Gwyn LaRee as Mrs. Bowen and Mrs. Perry Gifford, Seamstress.
Assist. Marshall Fleet, Officers Doherty & Harrington played by Tim Dennis.
Dennis Fitzpatrick as Hiram C. Harrington, Andrew Borden's brother-in-law.  Music by MelodyLoops.com Theme song: Golden Age of Modern Empires.
Recorded at KBOO Radio in Portland, Oregon
https://www.lizziebordenaudio.com
Transcriptions of Lizzie's witness statements provided with permission by Stefani Koorey and LizzieAndrewBorden.com