How many of you genuinely enjoy the process of buying a car?
If there are any car salespeople reading this, forgive me—but you know the game. You don’t walk in, point to a car, accept the first offer, and drive away smiling. No, you sit down. You listen. You nod. You hesitate. You stand up to leave.
“Well, wait a minute…”
The deal sweetens. You start toward the door again.
“Wait, wait—what if we add this?”
Behind the performance is not some grand villain twirling a mustache. It’s just a person trying to make a living. There’s a certain quiet desperation in the whole thing.
Oddly enough, that image is closer to the Catholic imagination of the devil than the dramatic, trident-bearing monster we often picture.
Culturally, many of us have inherited a somewhat Protestant imagination about Satan. Think of John Milton’s Paradise Lost. Milton’s Satan is charismatic, articulate, almost heroic in his defiance. So compelling, in fact, that in some places the book has been controversial because the devil begins to look admirable.
But that is not the Catholic vision. For that, we turn to Dante.
In The Divine Comedy, Dante descends through the nine circles of hell, guided by the poet Virgil. Each level corresponds to distorted love—what we call the deadly sins. In the circle of lust, souls are blown endlessly about by violent winds, never at rest, driven from one desire to another without ever being satisfied.
But when Dante finally reaches the very pit of hell, he does not find fire.
He finds ice.
Satan is not enthroned in flames. He is frozen waist-deep in a lake of ice. He flaps his wings desperately, trying to escape, but the flapping only makes the air colder. The ice thickens with every attempt at self-liberation.
He is not magnificent. He is pitiful. Dante describes him as grotesque, sobbing, trapped in darkness and cold. The deeper reality of hell is not fiery spectacle but total privation: the absence of warmth, the absence of light, the absence of love.
For the medieval mind shaped by Aristotle and St. Thomas Aquinas, cold is not a “thing.” It is merely the absence of heat. Darkness is not a “thing”. It is merely the absence of light.
Hell is not a kingdom of alternative glory. It is what remains when light and love are removed.
The word Satan itself means “accuser.” In a courtroom, the accuser stands opposite the advocate. And the Church calls the Holy Spirit our Advocate—our defender.
Yet how often do we listen to the accuser?
How often do we internalize the voice that whispers: You are your worst moment. You are your failure. You are disqualified.
The second reading we heard reminds us: the gift is not like the transgression. The fall is real, but grace is greater. Through the disobedience of one, sin entered the world. Through the obedience of One, life is restored. And not only eternal life someday, somewhere…but abundant life even now.
Which brings us back to the garden.
The story of Adam and Eve is so familiar that we sometimes miss its subtleties. Eve is called “the mother of all the living.” Adam is given the task to “shamar”, to guard and till the garden. To keep watch.
And yet, when the serpent speaks, Adam is “with her.” Standing there. Silent. Watching.
Both depart from their vocation. Both step outside trust. And the fracture begins.
But what happens immediately after the fall is one of the most revealing moments in all of Scripture.
“They heard the sound of the Lord God walking in the garden in the cool of the day.”
What an extraordinary image.
God is not storming through the garden with fury. He is not wielding a machete, hacking through branches in rage. He is walking—calmly, gently—“in the cool of the day.”
He calls out, “Where are you?”
Not because He lacks information. But because He invites relationship.
Adam responds, “I was afraid.”
Afraid of what? God had given no cause for fear. Not in His generosity. Not in His provision. Not in His love.
And yet fear enters when trust collapses.
Justice must follow the fall. There are consequences. The ground will be harder to till. Childbirth will be painful. Life will be more arduous. Mercy does not eliminate justice—but it transforms how justice is lived.
And before sending them out, God does something extraordinary.
He clothes them.
Leaves would never survive the wilderness. So He makes garments of skin and fur. He equips them for the exile. He blocks the path back to the tree—not out of cruelty, but to prevent them from grasping immortality in a fallen state.
Even in judgment, there is protection. Even in exile, there is accompaniment.
This is the Catholic imagination of the spiritual battle.
The devil is not glamorous. He is not powerful in the way we imagine power. He has no authority over you unless you give it to him. He offers the illusion of freedom but delivers isolation. He promises autonomy but produces cold.
God, by contrast, walks toward you in the cool of the day.
He does not delight in your shame. He does not savor your fear. He calls your name.
Dante describes heaven as the opposite of hell in every possible way: light instead of darkness, warmth instead of cold, music instead of silence, the joyful presence of those who walked in faith before us.
Hell is constriction.Heaven is expansion.Hell is absence.Heaven is fullness.
Lent, like all of life, places us in moments of wilderness. Temptations come. Accusations echo. We stumble. But the goal is not despair. The goal is clarity.
To see the accuser for what he is: desperate, diminished, frozen.
And to see God for who He has always been: walking toward us, calling gently, clothing us in mercy, and leading us toward life.
The choice is not between two equally compelling kingdoms.
It is between ice and light.Between isolation and communion.Between accusation and advocacy.
And the One who calls you does so calmly…in the cool of the day.
Pilgrim's Prologue is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Get full access to Pilgrim's Prologue at pilgrimsprologue.substack.com/subscribe
