For this episode, we made homemade cookies to try. Kelsey made her family's favorites and Britt made hers and Matt's.

Here's what we tried: Cream cheese candy, peanut butter cookies, chocolate no-bakes, 1939 chocolate chip cookies.

In this holiday special, Matt tells a ghost story for Christmas. Gather around the fire, toast with some holiday cheer, and tune in to hear this year's tale, one of a game of hide and seek, titled Smee, written by A. M. Burrage.