
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


This week, I think the Creeps have it together. They might lose it, because we're drinking sweet mead from Nine Hives Meadery of Howe Sweet It Is, which we've had on the show before. You can find them at 1116 Cambria Rd. in Lumberport, WV and also at the Bridgeport Farmers Market - and when the mead is this good you can't blame us for having a lot...
Then, Matt has a story that starts with bagels? A pint sized thief, a bite sized bagel bandit, broke into Bagel Dock Express bagel shop in Southport, North Carolina, where the scaly fellow startled the employees. We're sure you've seen by now, a three food alligator wandered in to the store, looking for who knows what, perhaps a nice bagel? Note-the gator was removed safely and alive.
The Creeps also talk about levels of exhaustion, adding more alcohol, the farmers market, getting less snobby, tiny feet noises, bloody barrel rolls, and breakfast plans.
This week, we ate dinner for 12 at a five-person party, as Kelsey made the best spread for a Halloween party you've ever seen. We tried Frankenstein guac, mummy pigs in mummy wraps, cheesy spiders, two charcuteries, her classic go-to olive tapenade, stuffed pepper jack o'lanterns, pumpkin shaped smoked salmon cheese ball, popcorn balls, all with dips, veg, and sauces galore.
Then, Matt serves up a Thanksgiving kickoff true crime. In 1991, Omaima Nelson, who endured a very abusive childhood, is serving life in prison for killing Bill Nelson. She stabbed him while he was tied up, she beat him with a clothes iron, then dismembered him over a 12 hour period. She supposedly flushed him down her garbage disposal along with leftover turkey, and ate his ribs with barbecue sauce.
Also, we're feeling blue but not at all sad, as the blue wave sweeps the country. The sun is shining, the birds are singing, the trash is taking itself out. Also, Kelsey's never been invited to a party? both Main Creeps are looking for Paypigs? and we're doing Oop's All Soups! for Friendsgiving.
This week, Kelsey grabbed some of Dave's Sweet Tooth Toffee, and we're trying their Coffee Toffee and milk chocolate varieties - and we definitely bought this because of their FDT "Fresh Delicious Toffee" ads, because we love fresh delicious toffee... This stuff is crisp and doesn't break your teeth.
Matt shares yet another quid pro quo from the White House. This time it involves former ambassador to Greece, Kimberly Guilfoyle, and when she asked Trump donor Eric Deters in October 2026 to wire her $100,000 to cover her own Amex credit card debt. The qpq comes into it where Deters alleges that she offered access to the Trump administration's officials in exchange for this deal. Since this story has to do with the Trump elites who are close to the orange overlord, we're sure this story in no way has anything extra shady going on.
The Creeps also talk about never ever getting political, all the fun seasonal flavors that Dave's has, needing some credit card sugar in the future, and more crazy hair.
We're trying Momofuku's incredible instant noodles in no-spicy Soy & Scallion, and nicely-spicy Tingly Chili. If you can find both, get both, as they don't disappoint.
Then, a very Matt-tastic (his words) cult episode! He covers Gwen Shamblin Lara, the giant-coiffed lady as seen in the doc The Way Down, who was a church leader known for her Weigh Down Workshop of extreme Christian themed dieting. This episode mentions abuse of children, discretion advised.
Holiday season is coming back in a big way, so we swear we're here. We were quite busy this season but not too busy to talk your ear off. We also talk about the gross-Tommy takedown, hotness? noodle size, noodle price, noodle obsession. Noods.
This week, we jump right into trying Oreo's yet again. One is standard, Red White and Blue Firecracker Pop! Blueberry, Lemon, cherry cream on a blonde Oreo. Go find those if you still can. They taste like PIE!!! We dang'in F with 'em. Matt also tells his story about the effect Asian sodas had on him.
Kelsey talks about the internet! She's covering the feminist 4B movement from Korea, and it's migration to women in the US after 2024's orange political upheaval, because I guess women also want rights. The 4B's are no marriage, no childbirth, no dating, no sex. This movement started in 2019 after the murder of a woman in Gangnam Station caused social upheaval and national outrage. She's maybe also covering the "traditional wife aesthetic" honeytrapping of some ice and other agents.
The Creeps also talk about Joe Bob's 3 B's, the gas nightmare because of the orange nightmare, Matt lying, the texture of the cookie part of the Oreo, the Flavor over Sugar ratio of imports, and the story of a girl.
This week, Kelsey's got a big box of imported Oreo's for us. She got the Oreo Flavor of Asia Variety pack, quite a large box of: Original, Blueberry & Raspberry Split, Crystal Grape & Peach Split, Ice Cream Matcha, and White Peach Oolong Tea.
Then, Kelsey talks to Matt about Malik Chandler of Grove City, Ohio, his use of TikTok to attempt a Chris Hansen, and the shooting of an alleged pervert and pos that occurred after.
The Creeps also talk about Kit-Kat's, accurate flavors gone wrong, and being tired.
This week, a great lineup of sugar sits before our Creeps. We're trying Little Bites mystery flavored mini muffins, Little Debbie Cosmic Brownie themed mini muffins, and we're washing it down with the bold jolt of Alani Witches Brew - one of the best ones they make.
Then, Matt shares the worst college football crime in years with Kelsey, someone who usually does not sport. We're talking about the now infamous Michigan loss that was egregiously turned into a win by referee intervention, the addition of an extra second, and an undeserved extra hail mary attempt for Michigan. Matt also shares the Western Michigan University paper's reporting of a robbery, because it for sure was.
The Creeps also talk about doing what we want, kicking Spooky Season into high gear, what makes the best cereal milk, and Matt's love of football when it's done fairly.
This week, the Creeps talk about Matt's birthday party, where we tried Kelsey's best ever Italian Cream Cake. Then, Matt's uncle Kenny brought up a chocolate cake, donuts, and Bismarck's from Nu Era Bakery, located at 120 Stratton St. in Logan, WV. Open Tue-Fri 7 AM-5 PM, Sat 7-3, closed Sun-Mon. None of this cake lasted, we ate all of it.
Then, Matt gets into some winter squatch, and then I guess some summer squatch? We're talking about abominable snowmen. But not just any old kind, nope we've gone weirder than ever, bringing you the Underwater Abominable Snowman of the Bahamas, found by whacked out divers in the late 70s. Somehow.
They also talk about birthday parties, twists, cake fiends during cake season, hot dog shapes, the Buttercream Gang, and the history of yeti legends large and small.
This week, Kelsey travelled home with at least a bakers dozen of Pokémon styled goodies from Krispy Kreme! She also had to grab some seasonals because we are forever known for our love of Autumn snacks. They're already here and we gotta eat 'em all.
Here's what we tried: Pokéball, cookie butter, maple cheesecakes, mocha, pumpkin cake, Charmander (chocolate toasted marshmallow filled, orange caramel icing), Bulbasaur (vanilla), Squirtle (cotton candy buttercreme, Jigglypuff (strawberry), Pikachu (lemon filled), very gold donut holes that cover your hand in gold
Then, Matt tells a tale of tales gone missing. In Arizona, a couple steal thousands of dollars worth of books from their local library in an attempt to resell them to Half Price Books, for an amount we can only assume is like twenty bucks...
The Creeps also talk about their favorite starter pokemon, opting for the seasonals and specialties, expensive hotel breakfast, library overdues, and the literacy crisis. If you would like to honor the memory of Dolly Parton and dishonor the memory of the Arizona book bandits, you can donate to the Imagination Library at Donate.imaginationlibrary.com/
This week, CODE ORANGE! The Creeps are still getting spooky and it's gonna stay that way! We're trying more Bones coffee, first the Army of Dark Chocolate variety, as Kelsey cold brews it with cold foam and chocolate drizzle because we're awesomely bougie and it only gets more fancy from there. They try S'morey Time, Holy Cannoli with all sorts of accoutrement.
Then, Matt takes Kelsey on a trip to 1800's New England (all of New England, just all of it) for the insanity of several stories on the panicked belief that friends and family were vampires from beyond the grave. That those vampires were making the living sick instead of it being (Tuberculosis) consumption. And that the bodies needed to be exhumed, examined to determine vampirism, in which they were then cut apart and re-buried or even burned in (often failed) attempts to spare the ones left sick above ground.
They also talk about the candy and pumpkin spice flowing, coffee roasts, needing caffeine for night recording, fall trips on the east coast, Colin Robinson, Val Kilmer in Tombstone, and Matt's pocket knife. Trigger warning: this episode contains Updog.
From the publisher's feed