This week, the Creeps celebrate once again by making holiday sweets. Here's what we made:

Kelsey tested a fun spin on her usual Christmas cookie: She made peanut butter cookies and they're grape jelly thumbprints!

You'll want to make plenty of these, they were a huge hit with the whole fam.

Then, Kelsey tells this year's classic ghost story, while Matt shares the history of this Christmas tradition.

Our story on this Christmas Eve special is The Phantom Hag, Author is unknown