In this episode, the Main Creeps finally get to try Zagnuts, because Matt found a Zagnut, and Kelsey now gets to try a Zagnut. We promise you can go to a store and buy Zagnuts, we didn't make this up. This is part one of a series where Matt finds old people candy that Kelsey didn't think was real.

Matt tells a story of unsolved murders in the 1960s, from what locals called the Mad Butcher of Fayette County, West Virginia.