Misunderstanding from Familiarity and Foreignness
"Ears to hear!" It was characteristic of Jesus' teaching/parables that many "heard" but did not really hear or grasp what he was saying. Matthew has led us through many episodes, but wants us to engage the challenge, because it continued, then and now. Mt chooses this point to recount two episodes that are like little parables of misunderstanding and danger.
"Familiarity breeds contempt" it's a cliche. It also blinds people. We already "know" him. Jesus just taught people to be nice to each other. He was a great businessman, small group leader, revolutionary, popular philosopher, religious mystic, apocalyptic visionary, positive thinker.
Jesus was too long ago and far away. He's too divisive and dangerous. He can't speak to us. ۬We want a spirituality all can share without changing, not a Lord who calls to discipleship. ۬We're in a different world with different issues. We can't admit Jesus' power in our world.
At Home among those who "knew" Him
We've never been there, but we can recognize the hometown scene. People who've known him since childhood, as a carpenter's apprentice with his father, etc. We learn something of Jesus' family: four brothers all with good biblical names, like Jesus/Joshua. At least three sisters. Mary is known, but Joseph seems gone. At least 8 children left. Our people.
When they hear Jesus now, they're astonished, but don't understand. They see Jesus not in terms of an in-breaking kingdom of God, not in terms of embodying God's actions for his people. ۬How could they? He trying to be a Sage, a Wise man, a Wonder-worker. Where did he get this? It's not us, not from us. The real Sages of the Law oppose him; are after him. Etc.
Jesus is not surprised. He keeps a low profile. But note, this isn't the end of the story. Jesus' own brothers didn't believe in him now, but his crucifixion and resurrection brought faith.
Notable Enough for the Powerful to Notice
For Herod Antipas, ruler of Galilee, it was as if Jesus just now appeared on the scene. He had recently executed John the Baptist, and he can imagine that Jesus is John resuscitated. ۬He just popped up on the radar. No history. Suddenly famous. What to make of him?
John is the best pigeonhole they have for Jesus. And it's a dangerous analogy for Jesus. But Jesus must fit into some category. "Powers?" sounds like a prophet. John is haunting me.
Herod Antipas and Herodias and the Death of John
The story of Herod imprisoning/killing John was well known, recounted in Mt, Mk, and Lk, and in the Jewish historian Josephus with varying details that reflect the complex motivations and guesses at motivations. Herod Antipas had publically divorced a princess and married his niece, Herodias, who had divorced her husband. John condemned the marriage. ۬Jesus noted John's role as Elijah.restorer of the people, forerunner of the Messiah.۬As Elijah was hated by Ahab and Jezebel so John had Antipas and Herodias.
But there was more. Josephus recounts how popular/powerful John was becoming and Herod's fear that he might lead a rebellion, and thus imprisoned him in Macherus fortress. Herod's mindless promise to his dancing step-daughter was just the irrational excuse to kill him.
In the meantime, the divorced princess's father Aretas attacked Herod and destroyed his army. Josephus says that many thought this defeat was God's punishment for killing John.
Then Herod learns about Jesus. He's haunted by John. Is Jesus John revived? Matthew wants us to see the amoral irrationality and danger of such a 'king.' The opposite of God's kingdom.
For Jesus, all the various oppositions simply showed the vast human brokenness and need for the very life, forgiveness, healing, and new Lordship, that God was bringing in through him.