Power Structuralism in Ancient Ontologies

Marcus Aurelius' Meditations: How Stoic are They?


Listen Later

Christopher Gill (Exeter) gives a talk on Marcus Aurelius' Meditations and asks How Stoic are They? Abstract: In this paper I address the longstanding question whether the Meditations present orthodox Stoic philosophy or a personal or eclectic selection of themes. In approaching this question I stress the importance of taking into account what seems to be Marcus’ core project in the Meditations (namely, promoting his own ethical self-development) and also of taking full note of the themes which recur most commonly in the work before focusing on the more exceptional and puzzling features. I suggest that Marcus’ core project in the work and many specific points made in the Meditations reflect key standard ideas in Stoic ethics, especially the distinctive account of development as oikeiōsis (Marcus, like us, seems especially familiar with Cicero’s presentations of this in de Finibus 3.17-22, 62-8). As in many other Stoic writings, the significance of the interface of ethics with logic/dialectic or physics is stressed by Marcus; standard themes that are evoked repeatedly include the ideal of wisdom as ‘dialectical virtue’ (D.L. 7.46-8 = LS 31 B) and the definition of the goal of life as bringing your daimōn into line with the rational direction of the whole (D.L. 7.88 = LS 63C(3-4)). Within this interface area, certainly, there are some unexpected motifs, including rather Platonic-looking mind-body dualism and (at least in a few cases) seemingly inappropriate use of the ‘providence or atoms’ disjunction. However, the best explanation for these features is, I think, premature or over-hasty moralisation within a fundamentally Stoic framework, rather than philosophical amateurishness or eclecticism.
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Power Structuralism in Ancient OntologiesBy Oxford University

  • 3.1
  • 3.1
  • 3.1
  • 3.1
  • 3.1

3.1

7 ratings


More shows like Power Structuralism in Ancient Ontologies

View all
Philosophy for Beginners by Oxford University

Philosophy for Beginners

328 Listeners

Approaching Shakespeare by Oxford University

Approaching Shakespeare

330 Listeners

General Philosophy by Oxford University

General Philosophy

73 Listeners

Aesthetics and Philosophy of Art lectures by Oxford University

Aesthetics and Philosophy of Art lectures

75 Listeners

Theoretical Physics - From Outer Space to Plasma by Oxford University

Theoretical Physics - From Outer Space to Plasma

56 Listeners

Critical Reasoning: A Romp Through the Foothills of Logic by Oxford University

Critical Reasoning: A Romp Through the Foothills of Logic

38 Listeners

The Secrets of Mathematics by Oxford University

The Secrets of Mathematics

42 Listeners

Critical Reasoning for Beginners by Oxford University

Critical Reasoning for Beginners

30 Listeners

CortexCast - A Neuroscience Podcast by Oxford University

CortexCast - A Neuroscience Podcast

4 Listeners

Poetry with Alice Oswald by Oxford University

Poetry with Alice Oswald

25 Listeners