Hey there, fellow anglers! Artificial Lure here with your Martha's Vineyard fishing report for this fine Friday, May 2nd, 2025.
The Vineyard waters are starting to heat up, folks! We're seeing that first real push of migratory stripers making their way around the island. Those early scouts that hit the south side of the Vineyard a couple weeks ago have now filtered up into Buzzards Bay and surrounding waters[3][5]. While it's been a slower spring than normal, things are finally picking up steam.
Water temps have been climbing from the chilly mid-40s we had just a week ago, which is bringing more life to our fishery[3]. The holdover stripers in the rivers and salt ponds are getting more active but still a bit finicky[1]. If you're targeting these bass, focus on river mouths where bunker and herring are congregating - these big, oily baitfish are like candy to hungry stripers[1].
Big news - the squid have arrived in force! They've been thick under dock lights around Falmouth, Mashpee, and Cotuit[1]. If you can jig up some fresh squid, they make fantastic bait or a mighty fine dinner.
Tautog fishing is excellent right now, especially in Buzzards Bay where anglers are finding limits without much trouble[1]. For tog, work the rock piles outside river mouths during falling tide when warmer water is washing out crabs and other crustaceans. Small green crabs with trimmed legs have been the ticket to keeper-size fish[1].
Scup season just opened yesterday, and black sea bass season opens in about two weeks, so we've got plenty to look forward to[1].
For hot spots, try Woods Hole - while water was still a bit cool last week at 44.8 degrees, the sunshine we've had should have pushed that up nicely[3]. Also, don't overlook the Maritime Academy docks where tautog have been steady[3].
As for bait and lures, seaworms are absolutely crushing it for stripers - they might not look like river herring, but both resident and migrant bass can't resist 'em[2]. If you're jigging for tautog, bring both jigs and conventional rigs to see what's working best that day[1].
Bluefish should start showing up mid to late May according to the usual pattern, so get ready for some choppers soon[4].
Remember that nighttime fishing becomes more productive as we move into the warmer months, especially for bass as we get into summer[4].
The early bird gets the worm, so hit those spots at first light or evening tide changes for your best shot at success! Tight lines, folks, and I'll see you on the water!