Artificial Lure here with your Martha’s Vineyard fishing report for Friday, November 21, 2025. The cold snap’s rolled in and the saltwater bite has slowed, but for the stubborn few still on the hunt, there’s some reward if you know where to look.
Let’s get right to today’s tides for Oak Bluffs: low tide hit just before dawn at 4:44 AM, with a high at 12:01 PM. If you’re making a midday run, plan to fish that incoming tide through early afternoon. Sunrise was at 6:42, with sunset coming fast at 4:15, so daylight’s scarce—make the most of it and keep a headlamp handy. Temps are staying chilly all day, but the north wind has finally laid back; conditions are much more manageable than earlier this week, especially in the lee along the south shore and Buzzards Bay area. The forecast is holding dry but brisk—layers and fingerless gloves are a must, and keep your thermos close by, it’s the Vineyard after all.
Striped bass migration is just about done. On The Water Magazine says the last of the stripers are racing south, so the odds of hooking up with anything bigger than a resident schoolie are slim. A stray could shoot through the Sound or slip past Gay Head on that tide, but don’t bet the farm on it. The surf is empty, and bass action inside the harbors has been dead quiet, with no reports out of Edgartown or Menemsha in days.
If you’ve got tog fever, there’s still a respectable blackfish bite. Boats working the rock piles off West Chop and around Devil’s Bridge on the north side are finding tautog willing to chew, especially on green crabs—hard to find in the bait shops lately, so flip rocks for Asian shore crabs or bring your own supply if you can. Most guys are picking at their limits, with fish up to 6–7 pounds, and it looks like the bite might last right into early December if this weather holds. For the best results, drop your rigs tight to structure and don’t sleep on the slack tide—the bite can really turn on when things settle. Try a simple tog jig or double-hook rig with a chunk of crab, 2–4 ounces to hold bottom.
There’s also been a surprisingly fun run of mackerel and sea herring off the east end of the Cape Cod Canal, and by extension, Vineyard Sound—perfect for filling the freezer or grabbing fresh bait for the spring bite. Tie on a sabiki rig, bring a light spinning rod, and bucket up a mess of horse mackerel in the early morning. The daily limit is 20 per person. These also make top-notch chunk bait if you’re chasing tog or plan to store some for later.
Freshwater is where most islanders have turned this week. Upper Cape kettle ponds like Duarte’s, Seth’s, and Duarte out toward Aquinnah are seeing a steady pick of stocked rainbows and a few bruiser brown trout. Locals are catching on small spoons, bright spinners like Panther Martins, and live shiners. With water temps dropping, slow your retrieve and focus on the deeper holes—these trout are hungry but a little sluggish.
For bass and pickerel, stick to weedy, smaller ponds with deeper spots; use suspending jerkbaits, Ned rigs, and subtle jigs. A few fat largemouth have fallen for slow-rolled swimbaits or a classic shiner under a float, especially at first and last light.
If you’re chasing action, two island hot spots: try Great Pond in Edgartown for the best shot at both trout and pickerel, and Tisbury Great Pond (the Quansoo side) where the outflow’s drawing in fish on strong tides.
Top baits and lures today: green crab or Asian shore crab for tog, sabiki rigs for mackerel, and small gold spoons or shiners for trout and bass.
Thanks for tuning in to this Vineyard fishing update—don’t forget to subscribe for next week’s scoop. This has been a Quiet Please production, for more check out quietplease dot ai.
Great deals on fishing gear https://amzn.to/44gt1Pn
This content was created in partnership and with the help of Artificial Intelligence AI