
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


This episode continues the laws of squeezing (Sechitah) on Shabbos, focusing on practical and nuanced cases. We clarify the difference between passive melting (like placing ice into a drink, which is permitted) and actively causing melting or squeezing, which may be prohibited.
Key topics include:
Urinating on snow: Some authorities permit it since it resembles trampling snow, while others are stringent because the melting is inevitable and directly caused.
Spreading cloth over a barrel: Prohibited if it may become wet and lead to squeezing (a form of laundering). If the cloth is designated for that purpose, it may be permitted.
Stuffing material into a flask opening: Forbidden due to inevitable squeezing, which can involve either laundering or extracting liquid (similar to threshing).
Using a sponge: Not allowed unless it has a handle, reducing direct squeezing.
Plugging a barrel hole with cloth: Debate over whether an inevitable but undesired squeezing (Psik Reisha d’lo nicha lei) is permitted. Some allow it when no benefit is gained; others prohibit it rabbinically.
The shiur highlights a central principle: when an outcome is inevitable but unwanted, it may still be rabbinically prohibited on Shabbos—even without direct benefit.
By Moshe ZeidmanThis episode continues the laws of squeezing (Sechitah) on Shabbos, focusing on practical and nuanced cases. We clarify the difference between passive melting (like placing ice into a drink, which is permitted) and actively causing melting or squeezing, which may be prohibited.
Key topics include:
Urinating on snow: Some authorities permit it since it resembles trampling snow, while others are stringent because the melting is inevitable and directly caused.
Spreading cloth over a barrel: Prohibited if it may become wet and lead to squeezing (a form of laundering). If the cloth is designated for that purpose, it may be permitted.
Stuffing material into a flask opening: Forbidden due to inevitable squeezing, which can involve either laundering or extracting liquid (similar to threshing).
Using a sponge: Not allowed unless it has a handle, reducing direct squeezing.
Plugging a barrel hole with cloth: Debate over whether an inevitable but undesired squeezing (Psik Reisha d’lo nicha lei) is permitted. Some allow it when no benefit is gained; others prohibit it rabbinically.
The shiur highlights a central principle: when an outcome is inevitable but unwanted, it may still be rabbinically prohibited on Shabbos—even without direct benefit.